10 Failed Xbox 360 Games That Became Cult Classics

They may be classics now, but not at the time...

Brutal Legend
Electronic Arts

Microsoft may be a tech giant, but no one knew how things would turn out when the billion-dollar company shifted gears, and threw their hat into the gaming world. (I mean, look at Apple's Pippin.) Fortunately, things worked out, since their debut console, the Xbox, was a triumph.

Just to emphasis Microsoft's success wasn't a fluke, the follow-up proved to be among the best gaming systems ever. Not only did the Xbox 360 sell over 80 million units, it gave birth to some of the most influential titles, including Saints Row, Forza, Fable II, and the Halo sequels. Left 4 Dead, Gears of War, Dead Rising, and Mass Effect were only available on the Xbox 360 originally, but were quickly ported to other systems, since they were too frickin' good to remain exclusives.

Although some Xbox 360 titles are renowned as classics, things were very different at first. Certain games didn't have enough promotions to get our attention. Others were let down by piracy. Some gems tanked, purely because they came out at the wrong time. Because these Xbox 360 games are so beloved, it's a damn shame they initially failed.

10. The Saboteur

The Saboteur
Electronic Arts

Pandemic Games have been behind lots of greats, including Destroy All Humans!, Mercenaries, and Star Wars Battlefront (not that one).

But after seeing the success of Ubisoft's open-world action titles, Pandemic decided to give it a go, creating The Saboteur. The game follows an Irish racer-turned-spy during World War II, who's tasked with quashing Hitler's regime in Paris.

The Saboteur takes the best elements from Grand Theft Auto and Assassin's Creed, blending stealth, parkour, driving, and shooting with astounding effectiveness. But if there's any factor that stands out, it's the art design. Throughout your playthrough, you'll see German-controlled regions layered in black, white, and red, while liberated areas are slathered in vibrant colours. This inventive aesthetic constantly reminds the player which areas have yet to be freed, giving you more incentive to explore and kick some Nazi ass.

When a solid game doesn't do well, there's usually some underlying reason, like it came out at an inconvenient time or it wasn't advertised enough.

Sadly, there's no definitive explanation why The Saboteur wasn't a hit, save for the fact gamers just didn't gravitate towards it. This is a shame, since Pandemic Games closed up shop shortly after, making their swan song's failure all the more heartbreaking.


9. Alice: Madness Returns

The Dollmaker Alice: Madness Returns
Spicy Horse

American McGee worked as tech support for many iconic games, including Wolfenstein, Doom, and Quake. Despite his success, McGee hoped a day would come where he could oversee his own project.

He got his wish many years later, when he directed Alice - a dark reimagining of Lewis Carroll's Alice's Adventures in Wonderland. Because Alice did well critically and financially, McGee got to work on the sequel, Alice: Madness Returns.

It may have fallen short of expectations, but Madness Returns has plenty to offer. This time around, the twisted elements that defined the previous entry were cranked up to eleven (especially The Dollmaker). The simplest components are breathtaking, whether it's the exquisite environments or the physics of our heroine's hair.

Despite these positives, Madness Returns had enough issues for gamers to write it off completely. Although it's become popular in recent years, it's a colossal shame this sequel didn't stick the landing on its initial release. American McGee had so many other ideas for the IP, including two sequels, a series of short films, and a feature.

But after Madness Returns didn't work out, it encouraged the talented gaming director to retire from the industry for good.


8. Brutal Legend

Brutal Legend
Double Fine

When a game isn't promoted well, it's usually because the advertisements don't make the product look interesting.

However, a good promo can be just as damaging if it misrepresents the IP. Dead Island's teaser was nothing like the finished product. Trailers for the Kinect gave the impression the peripheral actually worked.

And few games encapsulate this problem better than Brütal Legend. All the promotions sold this head-banging rock fest as "God of War with guitars". In reality, the gameplay was a hybrid of action-adventure and real-time strategy. Once it became common knowledge how misleading the commercials were, sales dried up real fast.

Although heavy metal fans were initially disappointed, Brütal Legend is a blast if you judge it on its own merits, rather than what was falsely promised. It boasts a phenomenal voice cast, including Jack Black, Tim Curry, Lemmy Kilmister, Lita Ford, and a surprisingly coherent Ozzy Osbourne. There are a hundred songs, which is enough to satiate any music fan. The dialogue is hilarious, the gameplay is creative, and the Stage Battles suitably rock.

Even if you're not fanatical about this kind of music, Brtal Legend is a ton of fun.


7. Alan Wake

Alan Wake Ocean
Remedy

When you break down the numbers, there's no question Alan Wake was a success. On the Xbox 360 alone, this detective thriller sold two million units.

So, why is it on this list? Although Alan Wake's success is incontestable, it deserved SO much better. You see, Remedy Entertainment had the misfortune of releasing this project just before Red Dead Redemption. In two weeks, Red Dead made 1.5 million sales. In that same time frame, Alan Wake didn't manage one-tenth that amount.

But it wasn't all bad news. Through word-of-mouth, Alan Wake gained a lot of traction over the following months, giving sales a boost.

Sadly, this created another problem. Alan Wake wasn't just good. It was... too good. Consumers were so desperate to get their hands on the game, it was pirated like crazy. In fact, it was the most pirated Xbox 360 game of the year, save for Call of Duty: Black Ops.

Because of this, the developers believe they potentially lost over a million sales. Alan Wake sold decently, but it could've doubled its profits, if it had a better release date and wasn't illegally downloaded.


6. Shadows Of The Damned

Shadows Of The Damned
EA

In Shadows of the Damned, badass demon hunter Garcia, and his wisecracking sidekick Johnson (who's also his gun and motorcycle), venture to hell to rescue Garcia's lover.

Based on the promos, Shadows of the Damned looks like it tries way too hard to be edgy. Even Dante from Devil May Cry would tell Garcia to rein it in a little.

It may be schlocky as hell (literally), but Shadows of the Damned is fantastic. It successfully blends the cool and campy parts of Evil Dead and Resident Evil, while still feeling fresh. Due to innovative gameplay, astounding sound design, and fantastic boss battles, it looked like Shadows to the Damned was a franchise in the making.

Although new IP always have an uphill battle, this project should've generated a lot of hype, purely because of the talent behind it. It was developed by Grasshopper Productions immediately after the success of No More Heroes II. It was scored by Silent Hill composer Akira Yamaoka. Most importantly, it was produced by Resident Evil 4 director Shinji Mikami. With this dream team, how could it not be a hit?

Sadly, it didn't pan out. In its first month, Shadows of the Damned only sold 24,000 copies in the US. (That's including PS3 copies as well.) Now, nobody is going to pretend Shadows of the Damned is perfect. But the demon-blasting adventure title has so many great qualities, it should've performed far better.


5. Spec Ops: The Line

Spec Ops The Line Walker
2K Games

Spec Ops has been around since 1998 and yet, it's never been the moneymaker it should've been. However, Yager Studios recognised the tactical shooter's potential, and decided to go all in for the tenth instalment, Spec Ops: The Line.

The game was praised for its narrative, vibrant art, and focus on character development. It had the epic set-pieces which gamers come to expect, but it focused more on the psychological struggle that soldiers endure, especially when faced with moral dilemmas.

Unfortunately, The Line couldn't contend with bigger military shooters, like Battlefield and Call of Duty (especially since Black Ops II was released the same year). Spec Ops: The Line was anything but a COD clone, but that didn't stop it getting lost in the shuffle.

Because Spec Ops had been dormant for a decade, Yager Studios hoped The Line would revitalise the IP. Instead The Line was the final nail in the coffin. It sold so abysmally in its first week, it was beaten by Lego Batman 2. (That's just embarrassing.) Although The Line is now hailed as a cult-classic, it's directly responsible for killing the Spec Ops series.


4. NieR

Nier Gestalt
Cavia

NieR is a spin-off of the Drakengard franchise, and centres around the fifth ending of the original game. If you didn't understand that sentence, you're probably not shocked to learn the game flopped big-time.

It didn't help NieR went by different titles, based on location and the system it was on. The PS3 version was called NieR Replicant in Japan, while the Xbox 360 port was NieR Gestalt. The whole situation is so unnecessarily confusing, the studio behind it shouldn't have been surprised when NieR didn't get NieR its sales quota. (See what I did there?)

But NieR made juuuuuuust enough to warrant a sequel. And thank the gaming gods it did, since NieR Automata is a frickin' masterpiece. Not only did the follow-up spawn DLCs and crossovers, it encouraged gamers to check out its predecessor

As such, gamers have a newfound respect for the series as a whole, since they can appreciate the original's story, characters, and music. NieR developed such a resurgence, it recieved a remaster (although it was based on the PS3 version, not the Xbox 360 port).

Normally, it's frustrating when a great game doesn't get the praise it deserves. Fortunately, everything worked out for NieR in the long-run.


3. Lost Odyssey

lost odyssey
Microsoft

On paper Lost Odyssey sounded like a guaranteed hit. This turn-based IP was written by Final Fantasy creator Hironobu Sakaguchi and scored by visionary composer Nobuo Uematsu. Based on that information alone, how could any JRPG fan not throw their hard-earned money at it?

Apart from the loading times, nearly every aspect of Lost Odyssey was praised, especially the skill system, the combat, and the visual novel flashback sequences. Since Lost Odyssey was literally the biggest game on the Xbox 360, (it came on four discs), players were guaranteed to get their money's worth.

And yet, Lost Odyssey tanked spectacularly for one simple reason - brand recognition. It may have had Final Fantasy's creator at the helm, but it didn't have the name. When FFXIII launched two years later, it was ripped apart by critics. And yet, it sold 11 million copies, over 20 times what Lost Odyssey managed.

Lost Odyssey's failure is more frustrating in hindsight, since it's only gotten better with age. Unlike the recent Final Fantasy instalments, Lost Odyssey isn't bogged down by unnecessary twists, non-sensical plots, and convoluted mechanics. It never loses sight of the fundamental elements, allowing the player to enjoy the experience from beginning to end.


2. Darksiders II

darksiders 2
THQ

Darksiders II follows up directly from the events of the original, with the Horseman of the Apocalypse, Death, trying to clear the name of his brother, War, who's accused of ending humanity.

Darksiders II looks like more of the same on the surface, but the gameplay and mechanics have been fine-tuned to perfection. Although dungeon-crawling can be a slog, the arenas here are so well designed, navigating through them never feels like a chore. No matter how many times you hack-and-slash enemies, it always feels satisfying.

So, because Darksiders II is brilliant, it should've done well. And to the untrained eye, it seems like it brought in the mega-bucks. Darksiders II sold 1.5 million copies, and was the best selling game in the month it was debuted.

Unfortunately, Darksiders II didn't come close to earning a profit, since its budgetw was $59 million, making it one of the most expensive video games ever. Lars Wingefors, who currently owns the IP, admitted the game's cost was ridiculous, stating, "We can produce a product of the same quality, but for a lower cost." The fact its publisher, THQ, went into liquidation shortly after cemented Darksider II's reputation as a failure even further.


1. Enslaved: Odyssey To The West

Enslaved odyssey to the west
Team Ninja

What happens when Team Ninja put together an action-adventure title, based on China's most influential story, with a script penned by Oscar-nominated writer, Alex Garland, and Andy Serkis playing the lead? You get Enslaved: Odyssey to the West - one of the best games on the Xbox 360.

Because of the superb voice cast, flawless gameplay, beautiful cut-scenes, immersive soundtrack, and magnificent story, Enslaved felt like it was born to become a lucrative, multi-entry franchise.

According to Namco Bandai, that was the idea. If it sold over a million copies, Enslaved was sure to become one of their hottest IPs.

But after a month, the game only sold 800,000 copies. If you think that sounds disappointing, Namco discovered three months later that their data was incorrect, and they had sold less than half a million in total. After a year, Enslaved only generated 730,000 sales, convincing the studio to abandon plans to turn it into a series.

Much like Lost Odyssey, Enslaved suffered due to its branding. The game's central inspiration, Journey to the West, has been a pivotal part of Chinese culture for the last five centuries. Unfortunately, the beautifully crafted saga has never really taken hold in the Western world.

Enslaved: Odyssey to the West is a treasure, but its lack of recognition may have doomed it from the very beginning.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Alan Wake
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows