10 FANTASTIC Video Games (You Should Never Play)

Missed the golden age of these heavy hitters? Your game time is better spent elsewhere.

grand theft auto online
Rockstar

Nothing exists in a bubble.

The reason why any open-world game with swords and sorcery is inevitably compared to Skyrim and the concept of difficulty has somehow become a subgenre itself synonymous with Dark Souls is precisely because inspiration (and borderline plagiarism, if you ask Nintendo) naturally leads to association. 

Are the comparisons always fair? Not a cat in hell's chance. It's also not the case for every entrant on this list that they were once considered the apex of their respective genres and subsequently fell out of favour when something superior came along and put it to shame.

Great games can just as easily be casualties of their communities or, just as we meatbags are, age. Genuine British institutions like RuneScape 3 haven't been sidelined by a more modern take on the sandbox MMO as much as failing to give any fresh-faced newcomer a reason to even bother investing time in understanding its archaic systems. 

Self-sabotage is a recurring theme this time around and it's a testament to the power of nostalgia that many of these titles are still considered to be some of the best money can buy, even despite their flaws.

10. Destiny 2

destiny 2
Bungie

The masterminds behind Halo had already departed Bungie by the time Destiny 2 rolled around. Still, the knowledge of how to forge best-in-class shmup mechanics is clearly something that runs deep in the studio's blood, as the latter feels like an evolution of Master Chief's golden years in almost every respect. 

That being the case, there are precisely zero negatives to give Destiny 2's core gameplay. If only the same could be said for the surrounding baggage that drags it down to the depths of Titan's impossible ocean.

For every individual component of Destiny 2 that stands head and shoulders above its contemporaries (think raids, intimidatingly deep lore, and a power fantasy like no other), so too, do counterpoints so grievous exist that they can't be waived as ignorable irritants.

As old as it is, Destiny 2 has become a case study of why the live service model isn't sustainable. Chiefly in how its otherwise fantastic story has become a piecemeal, time-gated experience for existing players and a nonsensical mishmash of nonlinear events for newbies. Pile on some horrifying microtransactions, neglected PvP, and cookie-cutter seasonal content and you're left with naught but an adventure that's long since turned its back on attracting new blood and exists only to keep existing Guardians running the treadmil in its aging ecosystem.


9. League Of Legends

dr mundo league of legends
Riot Games

Credit where it's due, Riot Games has made a concerted effort to remedy League of Legends's longest-running problem, despite it being, bluntly, unsolvable. 

Any MOBA's greatest strength and weakness is its player base. League isn't alone in harboring some of the absolute worst outwardly aggressive socially inept cretins but as the most successful of its contemporaries, exposure to such unsavory types is naturally going to be more prevalent.

An incredibly frustrating reality, considering League's bread and butter 5v5 mode can devour hours of free time under the right parameters. Venture into Summonor's Rift with a pre-made group of friends and/or acquaintances and you're going to have a blast indulging in a strategic tug of war.

Risk your sanity and queue up solo, however, and you run the risk of being chewed out for the slightest misstep. Any League regular will have developed a thick skin towards griefing and verbal abuse by now but for anyone stepping into Runeterra for the first time, only pain and suffering await.

In a perfect world, fresh-faced competitors would be provided a haven in which to learn, practice, and develop the skills expected of anyone queuing up as a lone wolf. But smurfing (the act of veteran players creating new accounts to play newbies), rife as it is, makes breaking onto the scene all but impossible.


8. Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Metal Gear Solid V
Konami

Hideo Kojima, bless him, was finally let loose from Konami's clutches following the release of Metal Gear's fifth installment, but the soured relationship between the two parties had an indelible effect on The Phantom Pain. The first half of Venom Snake's romp across Afghanistan during the Soviet-Afghan War represents pinnacle Metal Gear in every sense. Open-ended stealth that awards the player agency to tackle objectives as they see fit in an open world culminates in a formula nurtured and perfected over decades.

Snake and his retinue of Diamond Dogs' pursuit of Skull Face hit the ground running and maintained a frantic pace for the first few dozen hours. Had quality persisted into Phantom Pain's second half, release review scores would have been wholly justified.

Then the second act comes along and upends everything. The constant momentum building toward Skull Face's demise gives way to a dull, repetitive plodding that sees Snake sent back out into the field to grind out a laundry list of missions the player already completed hours previously, just with added difficulty.

To add salt to the wound, Konami would follow-up the dross of Phantom Pain's second act in 2018 with Metal Gear Survive. An asset flip in all but name.


7. RuneScape 3

Runescape Botany Bay
Jagex

Any game, MMO or otherwise, that maintains an active player base for more than two decades, has done something right to stay relevant. To be fair, Jagex's accomplishments shouldn't be reduced to one singular reason for success, but the heart of its flagship title has long since been corrupted by an overabundance of mismanagement and aggressive monetization.

The quintessentially British humor and folklore that inspire the world of Gielinor still persist, and the sandbox nature of RuneScape truly gives players an open-ended approach to how they progress, but these established pillars of gameplay have long since been diminished by complacency and diversion from a unique vision that slowly slipped out of sight when creators Andrew and Paul Gower sold up and departed Jagex.

What remains isn't so much a shell of a game but one that feels as though it has fallen into maintenance mode in favor of its sister title, Old School RuneScape. Exacerbating the existing issues; 20 years of continued content updates have all but eliminated any ability for a newcomer to make head or tail of how any of its often archaic systems work.

There are so many reasons to experience everything RuneScape has to offer, but the barrier to entry is simply far too vast to surmount for any but the most hardcore of MMO fans.


6. Dragon's Dogma

dragons dogma
Capcom

The 2010s were a dark age for Capcom but there were a few diamonds in the rough released by the studio worth shouting about. Nobody expected Dragon's Dogma to take off the way it did. On paper, it masqueraded as a generic-looking action RPG with quirks in the form of scalable monsters and Pawn systems.

The result, a somewhat haphazard smashing together of The Elder Scrolls and Dark Souls, yielded something that, to quote Todd Howard, "Just works". Capcom managed to stitch together bottomless build diversity, meaningful exploration and a surprisingly memorable story in its first major attempt at an open-world RPG but even in 2012, the cracks and obtuse nature of several design decisions were obvious.

Limited fast travel, a mind-melting quest system in conflict with itself and a laughably awful UI have resulted in Dragon's Dogma becoming a victim of its age and a low budget.

With a sequel finally on the way this year, one can only assume what makes Dragon's Dogma a mild nightmare to play today will be remedied with its successor.


5. Mass Effect 3

Mass Effect 3 Shepard
BioWare

Bioware fell into the trap that all interactive storytellers need to be wary of with Mass Effect 3 - championing choice.

Commander Shepard's third and final outing delivered on the promise of a bigger and better sequel, boasting a more expansive galaxy, further meaningful interpersonal relationships for mankind's champion and a perfected approach to combat. On its merits, Mass Effect 3 outshines the series' middle child at every avenue, bringing satisfying closure to numerous ongoing storylines. All except the central war against the Reapers.

Distilling what had been progressively built up as an adventure where no one ending to Shepard's story would be identical even after hundreds or thousands of completions ended up falling at the critical last hurdle with an arbitrary choice between three outcomes. It's not often that a single aspect of an otherwise tremendous experience can be credited for souring everything that came before, but this ticks all of the boxes.

Do yourself a favor and consider Mass Effect's original run to be a duology. Headcanon and account for the loose ends.


4. Lost Ark

Lost Ark game art
Amazon Game Studios/Smilegate

Smilegate's MMO finally reached Western shores in 2022, almost overnight becoming one of Steam's biggest-ever launches.

Were the five-digit login queues on release worth soldiering through? That depends on who you ask, but anyone who stuck with Lost Ark through its wobbly first few weeks swiftly discovered why Arkesia's population in its native Korea spanned hundreds of thousands of visitors. Sublime combat, intricately designed endgame encounters, and more build diversity than a capital city proved Lost Ark's staying power. It's as much of a joy to play today as it was two years ago, in fact, but experiencing the best of what the game has to offer is another matter entirely.

Similar to other KMMOs, vertical gear progression is locked behind substantial RNG, with its horizontal counterpart less so, but requiring hours upon hours of grinding to make your character 'presentable' to other endgame players. If you lack any of the necessary upgrades, items, or titles to prove your worth, as it were, you're liable to be gatekept from even using the in-built party finder to join a group.

You'll encounter this same issue in other MMOs, of course, but it's much more pronounced here. To catch up with others who have been playing for years, you'll need to still go through the very same content veterans did but without the experience, leading to a vicious, neverending cycle of applying and being denied from actually engaging with the best of what Lost Ark has to offer.


3. Grand Theft Auto Online

Grand Theft Auto Online
Rockstar Games

Don't listen to law-abiding citizens. Crime does pay - you've just got to be good enough not to get caught.

That's Grand Theft Auto Online's mantra, at least, and considering the number of multi-millionaires you'll see zooming around Los Santos in public lobbies, career criminals are a dime a dozen. It's to be expected, then, considering the whole crux of what makes GTAO so addictive, that your fellow players aren't going to think twice about wasting you at a moment's notice, and it's one of many decisions made by Rockstar that's proven to be a double-edged sword ever since the service went live.

Yes, you can kill whoever you want whenever you want, and while there are built-in systems to reward this type of behavior (stealing another player's illicit goods so you can sell them instead, for example), that same freedom also serves as a griefer's paradise.

There are ways to tackle this behavior but they all cost money, and that's something you'll be short on when taking those tentative first steps into GTAO's lawless frontier. To make any meaningful dough, you'll need to engage with the various activities spread out around the city in its public lobbies, but these make you an easy target. Instanced content exists, but the pay is offensively bad and discourages repeated play.

Likewise, private lobbies exist, but if you find yourself resorting to that, you're better off just playing the single-player campaign.


2. Final Fantasy XV

Final Fantasy XV
Square Enix

In a world where Final Fantasy VII Remake exists, taking a retrospective look at Final Fantasy XV delivers a far less favorable view of the troubled fifteenth installment years after release. While comparing the two wholesale isn't entirely fair, it's fair to assert that XV's combat system, stylish as it was, exists more so as a prototype for what would eventually become VII Remake's lauded modernization of the Final Fantasy formula.

XV isn't a one-trick pony; Eos and its inhabitants are as gorgeous as ever and, until Rebirth comes along at least, the kingdom of Lucis still represents Square Enix's most accomplished open world to date.

Frustratingly though, a deeply disjointed narrative (a result of repeated development restarts) is still the biggest blemish on Final Fantasy XV. The tragedy of it all is that Noctis' road trip of self-discovery with buddies in tow against the backdrop of a continent on the precipice of war and in-fighting is still top-tier storytelling told in the worst possible manner.

If you need a two-hour animated movie to add much-needed context to an existing work, that's sign enough that problems were present from the very beginning.


1. The Mainline Pokémon Franchise

Pokemon Scarlet Violet Arven
Nintendo

Just play Palworld instead.

Mostly a jest, but The Pokémon Company and Nintendo could stand to learn a thing or two from a game that makes no secret of what globally popular franchise it's aping. Pokémon doesn't need guns, base building or, well, any of the trappings of a survival game - that's not what it wants to be, nor should it. What TPC (and, by extension, Game Freak) should do, though, is not be so stubbornly opposed to innovation or change.

The reluctance is understandable to a degree. Why bother with reinventing the wheel when the core formula, largely unchanged since the '90s, still generates nine-figure sums with every new generation? Scarlet and Violet, despite the outroar over its offensive performance issues, are proof enough that forgiveness is in good supply for Game Freak when its competitors would be spat out like used gum if it dared to ship anything so glaringly unfinished.

Despite all of this, the central loop of catch, train, battle, and repeat is still oh-so-alluring to multiple generations of gamers. Every Pokémon game, as a standalone experience, is worth playing but if you've dipped your toes in the franchise even as far back as Black and White, there's nothing Gen 9 can offer that you won't have seen before just presented in a slightly prettier manner.


Watch Next


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Joe is a freelance games journalist who, while not spending every waking minute selling himself to websites around the world, spends his free time writing. Most of it makes no sense, but when it does, he treats each article as if it were his Magnum Opus - with varying results.