10 Games That Prove Developers Are Getting Lazy

Even great games can be sloppy and half-baked...

The games industry is made up of the cream of passionate gamers, who lather their creamy goodness on such unfashionable attributes as hard work, diligence, study, self-denial and sacrifice, and have collectively elevated the humble origins of Pong and Space Invaders to give us the critically embraced and worthy art form we know and love today. Can such dedicated professionals stand accused of laziness? Let us agree first that, in the main, games developers love their art and perform it to the best of their abilities within the many internal and external pressures on their industry. This needs to be acknowledged, but these creative geniuses are human and as such are as open as any to human frailty, especially when their collective genius is distilled through the reason distorting filter of 'Design by Committee'. Let us also clarify and define what is meant by 'lazy': in this context, as the Oxford Online Dictionary definition of lacking in care. The criticism of (some of) the following games should not be taken as a de facto stance of negativity. It is possible to love a game yet still be mindful of its flaws, to spot the cut 'n' paste short-cuts from previous games, to pine for discarded features while admiring the new, to see amongst the modern gaming landscape of milk and honey the one bad apple that the grounds-keeper thought he could kick under the bush. Indeed sometimes the whiter the briefs, the more prominent becomes the stain. Two cardinal sins almost seem to be endemic, even amongst games of greatness: inane gathering of nonsensical items, and the devaluing of achievements and trophies.

10. Crackdown

Crackdown isn't necessarily the worst offender, but it pretty much started the ball rolling, which quickly became an immense source of pain. How many times have gamers been distracted from an involving storyline/quest/free-roam to collect the most immersion breaking objects imaginable? Making us collect shiny coins with Sonic is fine, but making us hunt down feathers with an assassin is not. Meaningless orbs, film reels, coffee flasks, pigeons, shards, tapes, flowers, skins, trinkets, diaries, notes, briefcases, bobbleheads... every single one distracts from the story, tears the gamer out of their willing suspension of disbelief and shouts 'YOU'RE PLAYING A GAME!' 'Ah but they give us trophies!' the defenders of this lazy alternative to game design will cry, gleefully they unlocking art and playing the newly formed puzzles. And while it's true that done well, collectables can enhance a game - such as when they're worked into the story, with is a rationale, and there is some motivation for the character - but more often than not it doesn't answer a need from gamers, it answers the need for developers to put in trophies and achievements.

9. Sly Cooper And The Thievius Raccoonus

'Win' a trophy by putting the disc in the console. Seriously. How cheap and meaningless can an 'achievement' be? A trophy for booting a game up, for getting to each chapter, for following the most basic instructions that we need to do to even get going in the game. Give us a trophy for making a character, for naming the character, for guiding our character through the first doorway, for standing still, for pausing the game, because what us gamers want is to feel special. We long for our metaphorical mummy and daddy to preen 'Well done!' when we take our first faltering steps. We're all approval junkies crying out for the next 'Ooooh you found a flower!' And yet... and yet, there is it seems an argument that suggests that this is in fact what gamers want; after all, how many websites or youtube videos are devoted to getting an 'achievement'? How many gamers will play some half-baked, lazily thrown together pile of junk because it has easy trophies and will boost their gamer score? How many gamers will use a gun they dislike, play a gameplay mechanic they find torturous until the pigeon-feed drops outta the hole and they say with relief 'Phew!l I can stop that now thank god, I've got the achievement.' Fellow gamers, far be it from anyone to point the finger of blame, but it's you. You're the ones to blame.

8. The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct

The Walking Dead Comic won the Eisner Award for Best Continuing Series in 2010. The Walking Dead TV Series has received countless award nominations including Best Television Series Drama at the 68th Golden Globe Awards. The Walking Dead: A Telltale Games Series won numerous Game of the Year Awards from the most respected individuals and companies in the industry. In a bold move, The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct seems to have decided to buck this trend. Maybe it's the Artificial Intelligence, confounding everyone€™s understanding that it would be impossible to make zombies have dumber AI than 'Walk towards player moaning or mumbling 'braaaaains'. Maybe it was the alternative approach to characterisation: instead of giving us fully rounded believable characters we bond with and care about, Terminal Reality decided to throw in a bunch of flat, empty, dead-eyed soulless 'who cares' mannequins whose only role was to scavenge. Maybe - just maybe - it was the magical 'from thin air' spawning zombies, the over-repeated and low quality art assets, the flat insipid lighting, the uninspired fetch quests, or maybe it's the weird decision to make a game out of fundamentally unlikable protagonists. Or maybe The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct never attracted the acclaim so rightly awarded its brethren because every single element of this travesty is lazy.

7. Thief

The original Eidos Interactive Thief was just that: original. Achieving Metacritic Universal Acclaim for both Critic and User scores, this breakaway from gaming norms saw the charismatic protagonist relying on silent and surreptitious movement over gung-ho gun-play and introduced a new genre, the Sneak-'em-up. The concept remains strong; having to think, analyse surroundings for shadows, be mindful of where your footsteps may give you away, having to skirt danger rather than meet it head on, should all make for a tense, immersive, heart palpating adventure. Except it doesn't. Combat upgrades will make the player treat stealth as a matter of choice rather than necessity, immersion is shattered by endlessly repeated dialogue, the virtually empty city streets are populated by even emptier NPCs with endlessly repeated dialogue. (See how annoying it is?) Garrett has developed a Jackdaw Mentality, his furtive manoeuvring through locked windows and clever disentangling of traps to steal a frikkin spoon will make this game feel more of a Chav-Sim than playing a master thief. All that's missing is the ability to spray 'Gaz Woz Here' on the walls and leave a smelly parcel on the living room carpet.

6. FarCry 3

The single player of FarCry 3 stunned the critics and fans alike, but then the multiplayer element equally stunned the fans into silence. Not in a Ohmygodthisisamazing silence, but an enforced silence through the chat headset, which - on a good day - might allow players to hear a garbled mess of unintelligible white noise. Now, us gamers may actually be used to hearing an unintelligible garbled mess from our team-mates, but the thing is; the ramblings and banality are ours. The in-game banter may have nothing to do with strategy or tactics, and may only consist of drunken laughing at each others ineptitude, but that is what keeps us playing, and with a shamefully unaddressed VOIP failure the online component of FarCry 3 had the longevity of a cliff-perched lemming with Monday morning blues opening his tax bill. Have a glance at your friends list and see how many people are currently playing this what should have been amazing online experience, but instead became a ghost-town, where only the dedicated map-makers remain, wandering forlornly, unable to get their many hours of creativity seen, evaluated and played by their fellow FarCry fans. The (excellent) protagonist/antagonist Vaas had some of the most insightful and well written dialogue in any game to date, including:
" Did I ever tell you what the definition of insanity is? Insanity is doing the exact... same f*cking thing... over and over again, expecting... sh*t to change. That... is crazy; but the first time somebody told me that...I dunno, I thought they were bullsh*tting me, so boom - I shot him. The thing is, okay... He was right. And then I started seeing: everywhere I looked, everywhere I looked, all these f*cking pr*cks, everywhere I looked, doing the exact same f*cking thing... over and over and over and over again thinking: "This time, it's gonna be different; no, no, no, no, no, please... This time it's gonna be different."
When FarCry 4 is released, how many gamers will bear that in mind?

5. Battlefield 4

Where to begin? Let's ignore the Day One crashes and server problems, the many bugs, the many patches seemingly designed to introduce yet more bugs, and let us instead look at what was left out from previous versions, discarding the maxim 'If it ain't broke don't fix it' Dice instead went with 'If it ain't broke let's kick it until it squeals on the floor while its dog-tags are heartlessly flung in the furnace of wanton abandonment'. In Battlefield 3 players could squad up before joining each other online. a useful feature that (mostly) ensured players would join a game on the same team, and often in the same squad. Preferring zero form over functionality, Dice discarded this popular feature in favour of... Nothing. And then there's Co-op: Battlefield had a 3 player co-op campaign. Previous iterations had a (purchasable) Onslaught mode, but once again these have been discarded, the developers resources of time and talent instead directed to ensuring a completely immersive, satisfying and trouble-free online experience. (If you don't laugh you cry, right?) Some of this could have been forgiven if the game worked, but fans and investors alike were left feeling they'd been conned. time (and the courts) will decide if this is true on the investors behalf, but looking once again at metacritic we can see that although critics initial reactions were favourable, once the game was released into the great wide open, players felt disillusioned and wondering if they'd just bought an expensive and lazy beta.

4. Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag

Once again it should be made clear, the Assassins Creed Series has rightfully gained a massive fan-base in love with the franchise. (This reviewer being one of them). Free roam Piracy? Yes please, more of that, we love that stuff. Raiding ships and convoys, sneaking around the Caribbean landscape picking fights when we want to, stealth-kills when desired or all guns blazing, combining the varied tools and swordplay, with each fight finishing with some brutally satisfying and devastating combos on the remaining guards. Brutal combos obviously cut 'n pasted from Assassins Creed 3. Which then introduced the problem that the weapons had changed, and now some of the combos looked, well 'strange' and unfinished. Two possible solutions: re-work the previous animations to better sync with the new weaponry, or reduce how often the double-kill animations would appear. Guess which direction the developers took... For those of you haven't played this game, (and really, despite its flaws you should play this game) they chose the latter route; what is depressingly becoming The Road More Travelled. Players who completed (and spent countless hours on side missions) this game saw two or three double-kills sequences before it was discovered they could be forced. Yup, the double-kill animations are in this game, and the more you watch them the more you realise they are badly copied directly from the previous iteration. For Shame Ubisoft, for shame. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g_6Oyx3Z1oc

3. Gotham City Impostors

Gotham City Impostors was seriously, seriously, loved by its fans, who were happy to spend countless hours either kickin' butt or getting theirs handed to them on a plate only to leap back in for second helpings. And rightly so, because it was a massively under-rated and under-played new IP in a world where nine out of ten games proudly sport a numerical. The plus points are numerous: home-brew weapons and equipment, imaginative tools for map traversal including glider-rigs, zip-lines, spring boots... too many to list; player customisation beyond compare to any online shooter before or since. and well-balanced maps that played differently depending on which body-type/transport tools were chosen. But in the end, all were spoilt due to a lack of attention to the details, to the finishing touches, the final layer of polish that lifts a game into greatness. A refusal to engage with the community to tweak or balance, the sloppiness of constant server instability, a crude hotchpotch of a party system. Despite the love the fans showed Monolith, it soon became apparent that this was to be a one-sided infatuation: Monolith regarded this as a finished product and headed off to the bar to celebrate while the adoring community pleaded 'Stay with us Monolith, this game could have been simply epic.'

2. Grand Theft Auto V

It might be shocking, and controversial to say it, but with GTA V, RockStar screwed up. That is not to say that GTA V is not a work of art: it boasts an astonishing single player experience - a sandpit of opportunity rarely offered to gamers and testament to the astonishing man-years of dedicated work that pushed the boundaries of modern gaming in its storytelling, its graphical splendour, its voice-acting, scripting, music... So what the hell possessed RockStar to make them decide to cheapen the online experience with the ability to buy in-game currency with real-world cash? Leaving aside the flawed decision to delay the online component thereby ensuring that everyone who played GTAV was going to log in the same time, everyone having completed the Single Player experience and thus crashing the servers for days. We'll allow that the grandiose scale of Rockstars dreams led to server overload and the loss of characters. Let's jump into the one decision that soured the heart of every honest, scrupulous fair-minded gamer out there. Selling in-game cash is wrong; it is lazy, and it makes a mockery of any pretensions to police the online world of money cheats due to their 'breaking the in-game economy.' Plus, it sells the developers' souls for a mess of pottage. The GTA Online community were crying out for fixes to character and progress loss, for the much needed promised additional content, yet Rockstar seemed locked in a war with hackers and glitchers whose main aim was to get as much in-game currency as possible, and further, to splash that money around to every player they'd meet, an ultimate money shot in protest at players being able to buy their way to success. Successive updates saw in-game cash rewards being dropped significantly, rewards that already seemed designed by disparate committees, vying to outdo each other with nonsensical formulae of rewards bearing no relation to difficulty or time invested. How many players lost faith or trust in RockStar once they decided to prostitute their art? How many gamers had genuine achievements in the game devalued as other players saw not someone who'd been rewarded for their in-game efforts, but had been rewarded for pushing credit card numbers into the store, or was seen as one of the glitchers and hackers made endemic by the bean-counting ethos of the developers? Oscar Wilde famously said a cynic knows the price of everything and the value of nothing. Rockstar, you could have satisfied the ever-increasing need for extra-curricular earning in so many ways. On the store you could have sold clothing, vehicles, apartments, all carefully designed so as not to disturb game balance, all beautifully crafted to make players want to strut like cocaine addled peacocks. Instead you cynically and lazily saw monetary gain in selling in-game rewards, and lost sight of their value.

1. Aliens: Colonial Marines

It was all looking so good, pre-release, Gearbox employees were regaling us with how much they revered the Aliens franchise and we all fell about in excitement. How proud they were to be able to produce not just a game, but a game that was to be considered canon; how excited they were to be able to lavish their loving care and attention to lead us into the iconic settings of the Sulaco and LV-426. It is beyond the scope of this article to go into the seemingly terminal and unending delays and development hitches, nor is it the place to speculate on claims that Gearbox knowingly mislead SEGA with false information about development and progress. However, the evidence seems indisputable that the reverence, love, pride and excitement was farmed out to different development studios. It seems that Gearbox were so lazy they had others do their lazy for them. This farming out meant that the buying public were misled at best, and lied to at worst: trailers showing scenes that never made it into the game were used as advertisements even past the release date; adverts showed graphics that were subsequently reduced in quality and realism in the final release, Gearbox only truculently admitted other studios were carrying out the bulk of the work after whistle-blowers released the information. The popularity of the series benefited Gearbox way out of proportion to what they delivered, with A:CM achieving healthy global sales and entering the UK charts at number one, yet garnered universally bad reviews from critics and gamers alike. The stance taken by Gearbox before, during, and after this games release remains a shameful indictment of dishonest practice and one that once again brings to mind the aforementioned definition of insanity from our good friend Vaas. So what does the future hold? Once again gamers find themselves at the dawn of a New Generation, and once again are faced with a dearth of shiny that lives up to the hype. Will there be rush-released games seeking to find the wallets of players desperate for the killer game to lessen their post-buying angst? Will gamers continue fanboi wars furiously displaying their post-decisional rationalization in the form of arguments about DPI and FPS? Developers and publishers must be held to account when lazy decisions spoil potential greatness, when cut 'n' paste coding is released as a new full-priced game instead of a map-pack, when branding replaces innovation and evolution, and it is ultimately the gamers who need to shout out 'No more! enough with the lazy!' Are there any other games that deserve to be on this list? Share your own picks below.

Contributor
Contributor

When not overthrowing governments MuddledMuppet can be found on youtube making mockery of life with slightly better than average gameplay. https://www.youtube.com/user/muddledmuppet