10 Gaming Boss Fight Tropes That Need To Die

Punch him three times in the weak spot, we know...

Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order Ninth Sister Boss Fight
EA

The humble Boss Fight is as intrinsic to gaming as the 'jump' button (and blowing on cartridges).

From the early, formative years of Atari and Intellivision, through to the heyday of Nintendo, Sega and beyond, gamers have always tested their skills and claimed playground bragging rights by defeating bosses, usually at the end of a level or stage.

The structure is as familiar to players as the buttons beneath their thumbs: get to the end of a level, defeat a boss, rinse and repeat until the darkness has been lifted and/or the princess saved. The actual fights themselves are similarly predictable, and are usually heralded by a door slamming shut behind a player and the music changing.

While the gaming landscape has evolved exponentially with each new console generation, with the likes of Sony, Microsoft and - yes - even Nintendo putting more power than ever before in the palm of players' hands, boss fights have, sadly, failed to follow suit in the innovation stakes, sticking instead to tried and tested formula for thirty years or more.

Whilst this familiarity can often be a good thing, there are certain boss fight tropes which simply need to die.

10. Insta-Death

World of Final Fantasy cactuar tonberry moogle
Square-Enix

Games like Dark Souls and Bloodborne have conditioned modern day players to expect a challenge. There is a certain school of thought among players that believes if a game is not as hard as all hell, it's either (a) not worth playing, or (b) a Nintendo game.

That said, even the most masochistic player out there will tell you that bosses who can kill you in literally one hit simply have to go.

Take Final Fantasy VII's Tonberry, for example.

Here you have an enemy who, whilst small in stature and arguably pretty adorable to behold, can decimate your entire party with as much effort as casually swatting away a pesky fly. He is truly a nightmare, and could definitely be said to be somewhat unfair, despite the fact that he can - rather obviously - be beaten in the end.

There is, however, a subtle yet crucial difference between one-hit-kill bosses, and enemies in RPGs such as the Xenoblade series, who can kill you easily since they are of a much higher level and are not meant to be tackled early in the game.

These are the exception though, and the truly unfair, insta-death bosses can - quite frankly - do one.


9. Waist-Up Bad Guys

Galactus Lego Marvel Superheroes
Traveller's Tales

Okay, admittedly, there aren't that many other ways which spring to mind to represent scale on screen, but showing bosses from the waist-up is undoubtedly a tiresome cliche, at this point.

Every gamer can no doubt pull from memory at least three or four examples of encountering a boss - usually on the roof of a tall building, let's be honest here - who is so huge that they can only be seen from the waist up.

The Galactus fight in the Lego Marvel Superheroes game is a great example of this (as well as a great many other) boss fight trope. Appearing from the waist up, the destroyer of worlds torments and assaults the Avengers and friends on a rooftop, with audible "Nom Nom Noms" as he fills his other-wordly stomach.

The Darksiders series also leans into waist-up baddies, as do so many other titles it would be impossible to list them all, but one thing we as gamers can say for certain is that we are tired of this cliched set piece, and hope that developers can find new and interesting ways to represent massive bosses going forward.


8. Not Really The Big Boss After All

Zant Zelda
Nintendo

Turns out he wasn't really the big boss after all!

Oh, you tricked us you little scamp, you... Joke's on us, to which the egg on our chagrined faces will undoubtedly attest.

Taking The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess' Zant as one example from a vast pool of potentials, gamers have arguably been conditioned to expect these big, M.Night Shyamalan-style twists, completely robbing away the shock factor the developers were so obviously going for.

Of course Zant was only a servant of Ganondorf, in much the same way that Scarecrow was obviously working for Ra's Al-Ghul in Batman Begins (bit of a weird comparison, but there you go).

No genre is safe from this bait-and-switch, either, as a gamer could easily select a random game from their shelf (one would assume gamers have shelves) and they would likely encounter the old bluff.

Kuja in Final Fantasy IX is a good example, as is Orochi in the beautiful Okami, not to mention Edward Kelley in Nioh; gaming is saturated with "I'm not actually the real boss, mwuhaha!"

Could you imagine if the new Star Wars trilogy focused entirely on Kylo Ren and Snoke, then randomly whipped Emperor Palpatine out from nowhere for the last act?!

Madness...


7. Temporary Invincibility

marvel Ultimate Alliance 3
Marvel

Much of what I'm discussing here relates to patterns - patterns of movement, phases, or the repetition of cycles, and one which comes up time and time again, is temporary invincibility.

To explain further, each and every gamer on the planet will, at some point or other, entered into single combat with a boss, dodged for a bit, then dealt some damage, only for the boss to - somehow - render itself invincible for ten to twenty seconds (at which point minions usually spawn in an attempt to overwhelm the player).

The latest Marvel Ultimate alliance title - The Black Order - is a prime example of this, though it is by no means alone. There, armed to the teeth and ready to roll are 'Cap, Tony, Ghost Rider and Deadpool, trading fire and punches to the face with Loki, M.O.D.O.K, Mysterio, or whoever, when they suddenly retreat from the player and render themselves temporarily invincible.

Why not just do that for the whole fight?

It is a trick as old as gaming itself, and modern players are savvy enough to see through the facade and recognise it for what it is: a cheap tactic designed to prolong repetitive combat.

It has to go.


6. Boss Healing

Pokemon Sword Shield
Nintendo

It is perhaps a safe assumption that few things infuriate gamers more than bosses healing mid-battle.

Bosses, by their very nature, tend to possess more hit points than the regular grunts by orders of magnitude, and many a player has woken in a cold sweat at the thought of one boss or other with hundreds of thousands of HP that they just could not defeat.

Imagine, then, the white-hot fury which cascades over the player when the boss they have been chipping away at for what seems like hours (it probably was), finally getting their HP down to manageable levels at the expense of every potion and tincture in their inventory, suddenly pops a magic juice and heals back up to full (or near full) health.

Examples of this treachery are everywhere, from the Dark Jedi in Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic, the dreaded Haderax in Borderlands 2, to every trainer and their Mothers throwing healing potions into the mix during a climactic Pokemon battle.

The thing with boss healing, though, is that it isn't strictly unfair - if the player has healing spells or potions to use during combat, then shouldn't the boss, too?

No. No, they shouldn't.


5. Deflecting Projectiles

Jedi Power Battles
LucasArts

How many boss fights have you played in which your basic goal was to deflect or repel an enemy's projectiles back at them?

Yeah, thought so.

To pluck an example out of the air, the fight against the Trade Federation Vulture droid in Star Wars: Jedi Power Battles for PlayStation and Dreamcast perhaps sums this up best. Playing as one of many Jedi Knights and Masters (invariably choosing Obi-Wan, obviously), the player has, by this point, dispatched battle droids and droidekas with reckless abandon, deploying Force powers in conjunction with the trusty lightsaber.

Encountering the Vulture droid boss, all of the aforementioned finesse is unceremoniously cast aside as the player runs left and right avoiding bombs dropped by said ship, which then switches its pattern (see?) and instead fires a steady volley of blaster shots at our Jedi hero.

Do we rip it out of the air with the Force? Throw our lightsaber at its engines? Leap atop the moving vehicle and slice off its cannons?

Of course not, we just deflect the blasts back at it.

This trope is definitely not limited to Star Wars games though with everything from 3D Mario titles to Ori and the Will of the Wisps getting in on the action.


4. 3-Hit Formula

Super Mario 3D World
Nintendo

Okay, so it's mainly Nintendo who are guilty of this one, but they're not alone by any means.

Think back to your favourite - or least favourite, for that matter - Mario, Zelda, Kirby, or Yoshi game, and you'll no doubt recall a boss or five who require you to hit them three times in order to defeat them and continue on your merry way.

The first hit can usually be dealt quite easily, as the boss is still moving relatively slowly at this point, and has not yet evolved into a new form (more on that later...), nor have they amended their - yep - patterns.

After this first blow has landed, the boss is a bit annoyed. At this stage, the boss usually speeds up their movement, making it more difficult to land that second hit, and may even throw a few minions at you in the meantime.

Land the second hit, however, and the boss is now well and truly furious, and will speed up further and may even sprout some spikes or something equally nefarious, the better to swat the dastardly hero.

Manage to successfully land a third hit on the boss and he's toast.

We know... Please stop.


3. Hand/Weapon Stuck In The Environment

Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order Ninth Sister Boss Fight
EA

This one is perhaps the most ubiquitous example on the entire list, and can be found in countless action/adventure games from the last twenty years.

The player has hacked and slashed their way through hordes of monsters and minions, lackeys and lizards, and are now face to face with the boss (assuming it really is the boss, of course). The bold baddie goes through their repertoire of moves and attacks, forcing the player to dodge and defend for their life.

All of a sudden, the boss takes a huge swing, and plants their sword/axe/claw/fist into a tree/wall/pillar/floor, locking them in place while they struggle to free said implement.

There's the player's window! Attacking the stricken boss for a few precious seconds while they wiggle their tool loose (stop it...), is surely the path to victory.

Again, this is something we know without even knowing we know, you know?

It is so commonplace, in fact, that players could be forgiven for scanning the combat arena for trees, walls, pillars and the like immediately upon beginning a boss fight, or at very least straying close to said environmental feature just to see if the boss hits one and subsequently gets stuck.

Spoiler Alert: they probably will.


2. Quick Time Events

Star Wars The Force Unleashed 2
LucasArts

Admittedly, this one is not as prevalent today as it once was, but it still refuses to go away.

Quick-time events, it seems, are the gift that keeps on giving.

Back in the mid-to-late 2000s though, players couldn't so much as go to the bathroom without having to hit Square, Square, Triangle, Square at exactly the right moment.

Failing the QTE in this example doesn't bear thinking about.

Games of all genres were 'quick' to leap aboard the QTE train (via a button combination, obviously) when the idea was first popularised, with titles like Resident Evil 4 and the Force Unleashed games best showcasing the QTE.

In the former, it was commonplace to see hero Cop Leon Kennedy running away from environmental hazards, shaking off persistent enemies, or - most importantly - finishing off bosses, via a sequence of button presses or convoluted movements of the Wii remote.

The latter was much the same sort of fare, albeit more limited to the all-important boss fights than general gameplay. QTEs were used in the Force Unleashed games to pick up and crush AT-STs, defeat rogue Jedi, and even face off against Vader and the Emperor.

QTEs had their time in the spotlight, but now they really need to go.


1. Obvious/Glowing Weak Points

Ocarina Of Time Gohma
Nintendo

This entry - somewhat ironically - should have been obvious.

Whether you are an avid Xboxer, a PS-person (I may have just made that up), a Nintendo nut, or you haven't played a game since the Sega Mega Drive, you will have encountered this phenomenon.

Again, the player has fought off the hordes of hell and made their circuitous way to a large, ominous chamber. The door immediately slams shut behind them and the music changes.

Out steps the entity we can only assume is the real boss, shown either in full or from the waist-up. How can the poor, lowly gamer possibly hope to defeat such a creature?

By deflecting its projectiles back at it? Probably. By hitting it three times? maybe.

"But where to hit it?" the player wonders....

Oh, I don't know... How about that massive, glowing, super-obvious weak spot?

We're looking at you, Metroid Prime, Star Fox, Dead Space, Lost Planet, Gradius, Shadow of the Colossus, R-Type, most of the 3D Mario games and virtually every Legend of Zelda title... The list goes on.

For decades we've been spoon-fed and signposted to victory by bosses literally wiggling, peacock-like, their massive glowing bits at us, and it's long since time this trope was banished forever.


Watch Next


The Legend Of Zelda Quiz: How Well Do You Know Princess Zelda?

princess zelda breath of the wild
Nintendo

1. Princess Zelda's Name Was Inspired By Who?

Contributor
Contributor

Jedi Knight, last son of Krypton, backwards-compatible gaming nerd, Dark Knight of Teesside...