10 Gaming Mechanics That Developers Should Have Fixed Years Ago

It's 2017 and we're still putting up with these simple design issues.

Skyrim Invisible Wall
Bethesda

Video games have come a long way over the past 30+ years. From 2D side scrollers to multi-choice, open world RPGs, gaming has advanced thanks to the hard work and dedication of developers, who have constantly pushed the boundaries of technology and have always looked to innovate in their work.

Despite all this hard work, certain outdated gaming mechanics from the bygone years have become immutable. Everyone knows that red barrels explode when you shoot them, water can never be trusted, and that the biggest weapon is usually the most powerful. It's time for a change.

As the technology has improved, certain mechanics that were once need are now outdated, and others that could only do so much now have the potential to do even more. Sadly, these improvements have been overlooked by many developers, resulting in modern games that are being held back by technological limitations from the '90s.

Here are 10 video game mechanics that developers really should have sorted by now.

10. Invincible/Useless AI Companions

Natalya goldeneye
Eon Productions

Having a computer-controlled companion alongside you has become the norm in many games, so it’s a shame that the majority of them can fall into one of two categories: completely invincible or absolutely useless.

One of these is clearly preferable to the other, but having a companion who can’t die can get distracting after a while. The Call of Duty games are known for this; you’ll be in cover trying to recover from the two bullets that have put you close to death whilst your team-mate will be absorbing gunfire like a magnet. This gets particularly annoying when that team-mate later dies in a cutscene – all the drama gets removed from their death when you’ve just seen them take a D-Day style assault directly to their chest.

On the flip side, having a companion who is useless is even more frustrating. Either they die at merely the hint of danger, causing you to replay the level again, or they just wander around and won’t actually contribute to the battle, leaving you to kill everyone yourself.

Getting the balance of a companion who is vulnerable to death but won’t die at the drop of a hat, and who will help with the mission without doing it for you, is challenging, but it’s something developers need to master


9. NPC Dialogue That Ignores Story Developments

Skyrim Dialogue
Bethesda

NPCs have come a long way from the early days of gaming, from silent background characters to helpful townsfolk to fully-fledged companions who gauge an emotional response from the player. One major advancement in NPCs is the way they change as the story develops. As the narrative progresses, characters will stop doubting you and will start respecting and praising you when you interact with them.

Unfortunately, not all games have improved their NPC dialogue in this way. Fallout 4 fans will be familiar with Marcy Long, who will constantly threaten you in Sanctuary by saying, "You better not tell anyone about this place". This was irritating to start with but hearing this again after hours of gameplay that have seen you take on thousands of enemies, was absolutely infuriating.

Many games that involve leading/working for a large group (e.g. resistance fighters) also mess up their NPC dialogue. In Homefront: The Revolution, you’ll still get other Resistance members belittling and talking down to you, despite the fact that you’ve single-handedly taken back the city.

This is probably the easiest issue on this list for developers to fix. All they have to do is make at least two different dialogue strands: one for before an event and one for after, meaning that NPCs will treat you appropriately depending on what you’ve done. Many games already do this, so the rest just need to keep up and stop being lazy.


8. Pausing Cutscenes

Far Cry 3
UbiSoft

Everybody’s been there: you’ve gotten to a pivotal cutscene in a game, where the major plot twists are revealed and key characters show their true colours… and someone walks in. In any other part of the game, you would simply press pause, but for some reason cutscenes don’t always work like the rest of the game.

For many games, pressing pause during a cutscene either doesn’t do anything, meaning it can’t be stopped, or it actually skips the scene all together, meaning you’ve either got to reload the level to trigger the scene again or resort to watch what you skipped via YouTube. What other entertainment medium does this? Imagine having a film that you couldn't pause in certain places.

Developers have managed to agree amongst themselves that the ‘Start’ button on the controllers for major consoles is the best button to use for pausing the game, so surely they can also agree that every game they make from now on will give you the ability to pause a cutscene? Many games now give onscreen prompts for what button to press to skip a scene, so why not a prompt for how to pause it?


7. Over-Confident Enemies

fallout 4
Bethesda

Getting the balance of difficulty right with enemy AI is tricky, but most developers have managed it, with enemies taking cover when shot at and using projectiles at the right moments. However, many games still seem to struggle with getting the AI to change tactics when they are losing.

The Batman: Arkham games got this right with their Predator situations, as enemies initially strolled around casually before the section began, but after their numbers started to drop they would become visibly nervous and scared, shooting blindly around corners as Batman carried on his assault. Sadly, not all games include Batman, and many developers can’t seem to replicate this type of advance enemy AI.

Quite often, after reducing a group of enemies from 20 to just 1 with a heavy weapon, that last guy will still run directly at you wielding a rusty knife in the exact same way his friends just did before you wiped them out. As fun as it is to destroy that last guy, it would be more of a challenge if he tried to change tactics and flank you instead of simply running into your bullets.


6. Broken Online Matchmaking

battlefield 1 scoreboard
EA

Online gaming has become mainstream in recent years, with many major titles like Call of Duty developed around online game modes and others like Battlefront and Overwatch doing away with offline single player completely.

With the difficulty of online matches limited only by the skill of the player, making sure all the varying difficulty levels are factored in is vital to making the online experience as fair as possible. Developers claim this is done by their matchmaking systems, claim being the operative word, as it’s clear that these systems just don’t work.

Too often new players end up in a match with higher level veterans who completely dominate them over and over, leading to the new player giving up. Surely it’s not that hard to match players together based on their level? (e.g. players under a certain level can only play against each other until they level up and are then put in the next matchmaking group – like getting promoted in football). Developers say this is how it works but it's been obvious for years it's not working.


5. Multi-Stage Levels That Stop Backtracking

Doom 4
Bethesda Softworks

As technology has improved, levels in video games have become more detailed and advanced, meaning many have multiple stages and sections to give the system time to load everything. This is understandable, and given that you’ve probably done everything you need to in previous areas, not being able to walk back to the very start of the stage isn’t always a problem.

The problem is with games that have stage-specific items to collect. Collecting certain secret items often comes with additional perks and character improvements, so you want to make sure you get them all. Unfortunately, the way many developers lay out their levels makes getting these items strenuous. Quite often you’ll come across a fork in the level’s path with two different directions to go in. In many games, if you go down the one that doesn’t lead to the collectible, you’ll trigger a scene that automatically leads you into the next stage of the level, with no way of going back to get the item you missed (as this scene will usually trigger an auto-save).

Players like exploring levels to find hidden items, but having to gamble on which direction to go just in case you trigger the next part of the stage adds an unfair challenge to the game. You shouldn’t be playing a game worried about accidentally completing a level because you went down the wrong path.


4. Already Empty Containers When Looting

Dishonored 2
Arkane Studios

With any game that involves health, ammo, and in-game stores (which is pretty much every game nowadays), there will be looting. Players have been conditioned to try and open every single box, container, or drawer in any given area to look for loot.

However, a lot of games include lootable boxes that are already empty. This isn’t that new, as franchises like the Zelda series don’t have items in every pot you smash, but at least it’s quite fun to cut grass and break vases while you’re looking. Pressing X in every box in a room to come up with nothing is boring, but if you want to find potential vital items, you have to do it.

Once the design of the container is made, it’s easy for developers to just paste them around the level to fill it out a bit, but players would much rather have fewer interactive boxes with guaranteed loot than have to look through the dozens of empty ones.


3. Lazily-Designed Invisible Barriers

Skyrim Invisible Wall
Bethesda

Levels in games can’t go on forever, so there has to be some kind of barrier stopping you from trying to go off into the distance that doesn’t exist, or from taking the easy route in a level. However, a lot of developers have gotten lazy with how they present these ‘invisible walls’ to players.

Nothing breaks your immersion in a game more than seeing your hero unable to climb over the knee-high wall between them and the rest of the city, or when they can break walls with their bare hands but can’t move the cardboard box that’s blocking the stairs in a building, or open the broken door that’s holding onto its frame by a splinter.

Obviously there have to be limits to how you can interact to the gaming environment, but there needs to be a bit of realism to it. Having a literal invisible wall stop you from going somewhere is like seeing a film character take a long detour when they could just go down one empty road – it’s just stupid.

Simply make sure every barrier is realistically explained and it’ll be fine. Large walls, barbed wire fences, an NPC physically stopping you: yes. Small fences, rubbish bags, thin air: no.


2. Hypocritical Cutscenes

tomb raider lara croft sad
Crystal Dynamics

Trying to craft a deep, compelling narrative in a game about a character who truly feels the weight of every person he kills can be difficult when that game is Grand Theft Auto. Many games are finding it hard to present a character who struggles with their moral choices whilst also presenting the player with a fun game to play. This attempt at balance usually ends up with cutscenes that show a character barely holding it together when faced with a moment where they have to kill, yet gameplay that shows a homicidal maniac massacring everyone in sight.

In the Tomb Raider reboot, Lara Croft struggled with killing in all the cutscenes, but the gameplay encouraged you to shoot flaming arrows at enemies and take them out as brutally as possible. In Grand Theft Auto IV, Niko spent every cutscene trying to make up for his past mistakes and rebuild his life in Liberty City, but seconds later he could be shooting down a helicopter from a tank that’s driving over pedestrians in a busy park.

Games that show how characters respond to difficult moral choices are great and should be encouraged more, but there needs to be a better method of getting this narrative across than the abrupt personality changes that currently occur in the moments between cutscene and gameplay.


1. Confusing Auto-Save

Pokemon Save
Game Freak

Pretty much replacing the check-point system, the auto-save feature seen in many games today does exactly what it says; it saves your game automatically so you can turn it off and pick up where you left off without having to worry.

Or at least that’s how it should work. With games that have auto-save only, it can become quite a task just making sure your game has actually saved, thanks to the way developers implement the system. In many open world games, completing a task usually causes the game to save. However, what counts as a task worthy of auto-save differs from game to game; some games save only after completing missions, meaning if you’ve gone collectible-hunting you have to start a mission just to make sure they’ve been saved, whereas others save your game every time you so much as open your inventory, which can lead to the game saving mid-battle when you're nearly dead.

This confusion with knowing what makes your game save means you often have to run around doing extra things just to double-check that your progress has indeed been counted. Surely developers can just add a manual save to their games alongside auto-save? Pressing pause and saving was perfected with the PS1: this is an example of one mechanic which has got worse with improved technology.

-

Agree with this list? What mechanics in games do you find annoying and outdated? Let us know in the comments below.


In this post: 
Skyrim GTAIV
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Been gaming since the Megadrive. Loves Batman, Futurama and Blackburn Rovers. Mild obsession with collecting steelbooks.