10 Gaming Moments That Led To Massive Lawsuits

Do you smell that? That, my friend, is the smell of money - I mean, um - justice.

Dk Vs Gozilla
Nintendo Universal

The second a new industry begins to make money, there will be two reactions.

Other industries will see the potential amount of money they're leaving on the table. They'll quickly staff a new subsidiary and race to catch up to the industry's originators as quickly, and as cheaply, as possible.

Or, someone will see that same amount of money on that same table, and just try and take it. Enter the civil lawsuit.

Of course, suing someone isn't always a cynical cash grab. People and companies have every right to protect and profit off of their own creations, and if someone is infringing on that right, then they're left with little choice but to sue. In some cases, this could even establish legal precedent that didn't previously exist, influencing the industry forever.

However, this is not always the case. And as video games grow in popularity, so too grows the controversy surrounding them. And where there's controversy around a popular form of entertainment, you can bet the lawyers will not be far behind.

These are ten video game lawsuits that will always live in infamy, either for the amount of money involved, legal importance, or just plain insanity.

10. Manuel Noriega Vs. Activision

Call Of Duty Black Ops Ii Manuel Noriega
Activision

No, you don't have something crazy in your eyes. In 2014 Manuel Noriega - yes, THAT Manuel Noriega - sued Call of Duty publisher Activision for using his name and likeness in Call Of Duty: Black Ops II.

For those who don't know, Manuel Noriega was the dictator of Panama from 1983 - 1989 and a willing CIA asset. He quickly turned to drug trafficking and other crimes to further consolidate his power, until he lost U.S. support and was captured, tried and convicted.

He appears briefly in Black Ops II as a temporary ally to the player.

Noriega sued Activision for violating his Right of Publicity, a law that prevents using someone else's name or likeness for commercial purposes. Noriega sought an undisclosed amount of damages in the form of lost profit from the game's sales.

The suit was dismissed, as depicting real people in fiction is protected under the First Amendment. It would be different if Activision had prominently featured him in the advertising of the game, as that would be in the express interest of generating profit from his notoriety.

And that's the story of one of the world's most infamous dictators suing a video game in civil court.


9. Silicon Knights Vs. Epic Games

too human
Silicon Knights

The chain of events that led to the closure of development studio Silicon Knights can only be described as a perfect storm of horribleness and hilarity (if you buy into that whole tragedy plus time thing.)

It all started with Too Human, an action RPG being developed by SK as a PlayStation exclusive in 1999, then a GameCube exclusive in 2000, and then as an Xbox 360 exclusive in 2005. It finally arrived in 2008.

On top of the promises of exclusivity to every major platform manufacturer, Silicon Knights also entered a contract with Epic Games to use the Unreal Engine for all future titles.

In 2007 SK sued Epic for breach of contract, claiming that the engine was unfinished. Epic then counter-sued, claiming, essentially, that SK knew what they were getting into in regards to the state of the engine. In one of the most hilarious turns of karma, it was discovered during the trial that SK had plagiarized a ton of copyrighted Epic code.

Epic not only defeated SK's suit, but won their counter-suit and were entitled to several million dollars from SK. SK appealed the verdict to a higher court, where Epic won again, entitling them to double the original amount awarded.

You gotta know when to fold 'em.


8. NCAA Athletes Vs. Electronic Arts And The NCAA

NCAA Football
EA Sports

We're including this case on the list not just because of the amount of money involved - but because of the amount of JUSTICE involved.

Once again we're dealing with the right of publicity, but in a much more reasonable sense. In 2009, former NCAA athlete Ed O'Bannon filed an anti-trust class-action lawsuit against the NCAA, its licensing company and Electronic Arts, publishers of NCAA Football and NCAA Basketball.

Student athletes had previously been barred from receiving royalties for the use of their likenesses under the pretense that the NCAA was not allowed to profit off of its student athletes... even though that's exactly what they were doing with EA.

EA even attempted the first-amendment defense that the players in the game were fictional representations in a fictional story. However, since the NCAA video games featured each player's actual likeness and precise statistics, including height and weight, combined with the fact that - y'now - college football and basketball games don't have stories, the parties chose to settle the matter out of court, awarding the athletes a total of $40 million.

And then EA promptly put an end to their NCAA games so they would never have to pay them again.

In the end, justice prevailed! Sort of, I guess...


7. Universal Studios Vs. Nintendo

donkey kong original
Nintendo

Everyone was trying to break into the suddenly burgeoning video game market in the early 1980s, including Universal Studios. So they set about taking a look at this up-and-coming little Japanese company that had only recently made its American debut called Nintendo. They could, hopefully, learn from their success, and make a fortune making video games based off of their various properties.

Or they could say screw all that work and just make a fortune by suing them.

Universal alleged that they were owed damages for any confusion distinguishing the character King Kong from the character Donkey Kong, and that Nintendo either had to license the name Donkey Kong from them, or pull the game from the market outright. Too bad Universal apparently doesn't keep very good records.

Less than a decade prior, Universal had sued RKO Pictures, makers of the original film, for the rights to make a new King Kong film under the basis that the character - originally conceived in the 1920s - had entered into the public domain.

Naturally, Universal lost the suit, largely due to the very precedent they themselves set in their own battle to freely use the character.


6. Hot Coffee Controversey - Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas

GTA Hot Coffee
Rockstar Games

Throughout the 1990s and early 2000s, video game controversies were practically daily news. Ever since Mortal Kombat, politicians and broadcasters were placing blame squarely on video games for turning children into degenerate hoodlums through their depictions of violence and sex. One such incident was the circus surrounding the Hot Coffee Mod for Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas.

At one point during development, developer Rockstar had planned to include a sex mini-game as a climax (nailed it) for the dating sim elements that were new to the series. After a successful date, your date would invite you back to her house for "coffee." Likely out of an interest to avoid this kind of controversy, the sex mini game was eventually cut, but it was left unfinished, buried somewhere in the game's code, to be forgotten.

Until it was exhumed as a user-made PC mod and all hell broke loose. Take Two patched the content out of the game entirely and removed it from all future retail versions of the game, but not before suffering a cavalcade of lawsuits.

Angry parents and government officials saw a gold mine. Take-Two eventually settled for $1-2 million. Of course, that's not that much money when divided among a lot of people and their lawyers.


5. Atari Vs. Philips

Copycat games are as old as gaming itself. But sometimes, the similarity is so glaringly obvious that you wonder if they just copied and pasted the original's code. And that has maybe never been more flagrantly obvious than in the case of Atari vs. North American Philips Electronics.

Pac-Man was one of the first products to really put video games on the map. The game was addictive as hell, gobbled quarters by the fist-full. Even the disastrous Atari 2600 home release sold record-breaking numbers. Everyone wanted in on the action.

Enter K.C. Munchkin for Philip's own Magnavox Odyssey, a game where you control a hungry circle eating dots and running from ghosts. If that doesn't convince you that it's a blatant rip-off, then just watch the video - it's the exact same game.

This case set the precedent for copyright law as it pertains to video games. While the idea of Pac-Man could not be protected, the total concept and "feel" of the game could be. In Philips's case, it was a mistake to copy not just the idea of the game, but even the art and character designs. Munchkin was ultimately pulled from the market.

Munchkin, did, however, include a level editor. So... that was pretty cool, I guess.


4. Dave Mirra Vs. Acclaim Entertainment

BMX XXX
Acclaim Entertainment

We went nuts for "xtreme sports" during the early 2000s. Once Tony Hawk's Pro Skater hit it big, every unconventional sport was getting its due, often with official endorsements from professionals, for multi-game franchises. One such franchise was Dave Mirra Freestyle BMX - Acclaim's answer to Activisions Pro Skater - and its spinoff, BMX XXX.

XXX was in every way a Dave Mirra game, but without the basis in reality, and with a lot of naked women. Instead of being rewarded with video clips from the actual sport - a common unlockable in the genre - players would unlock videos of women stripping. Dave Mirra was, understandably, not happy.

Mirra not only refused to endorse the game, but sued Acclaim for damages to his reputation and brand in the amount of $20 million. The suit was eventually settled with no money changing hands, but with a new, official Dave Mirra game in the works.

XXX, predictably, sold abysmally. Acclaim didn't last much longer, filing for Chapter 7 bankruptcy in 2004.


3. Immersion Vs. Sony

PS3 controller dualshock 3
Sony

Remember when the PlayStation 3 was announced and Sony revealed that they were removing the rumble feature from their iconic DualShock controllers? They claimed that motion-sensing technology was the future, and that nobody cared about rumble feedback anymore. And then everyone who bought a PS3 stood up and declared, "We hate this."

There was a real reason for that debacle and it wasn't just Sony being weird.

In 2002, Sony and Microsoft were sued by haptic technology developer Immersion. Immersion argued that Sony and Microsoft had infringed on their patents with their rumble controllers. And they had pretty good evidence to back up their claim. Microsoft, smartly, settled out of court. But not Sony. Sony fought...

... And Sony lost. Not only the initial suit, but two subsequent appeals. By the time it was over, it was decided that Sony owed Immersion over $97 million, plus future royalty payments on sales of their DualShock controllers.

Sony couldn't continue to infringe on the patent during legal proceedings, and so came up with an excuse that was the equivalent of "the dog ate my homework."


2. Andrej Sapkowski Vs. CD Projekt Red

Witcher Characters
CD Projekt RED

What possible beef could the creator of The Witcher have with the video game company that turned his creation into a pop culture behemoth? Why, money, of course! It's always money!

During CD Projekt Red's pursuit to acquire the license, they offered Sapkowski a percentage share in the game's sales. The author, believing the game would be a colossal failure, instead demanded a one-time payment of, well, substantially less than it would eventually be worth.

Needless to say, Sapkowski would eventually come to regret this decision, and go on to sue CDPR in 2018 for more than $16 million in lost royalties, arguing that their initial deal was only valid for the first game in the series. CDPR objected to the suit, but proved willing to renegotiate Sapkowski's deal.

The two parties ultimately reached an agreement, renegotiating royalties for Witcher games and other merchandise. We may never know what the final deal was, as it is protected by an NDA that prevents either party from disclosing the details of their new relationship.

Let's just be glad that this one ended amicably. Otherwise, we may never have gotten more of The Witcher.


1. Jack Thompson Vs. Everybody

Jack Thompson Gta Vice City
Rockstar Games

Oh God why? I really believed I would never have to see this guy's face again. But the past just won't stay buried.

Anyone who was even moderately engaged in the game industry during the early 2000s probably remembers Jack Thompson, a Florida-based attorney who made it his mission in life to exploit video game controversy in the media for his own prof - I mean - to protect the children. Think of the children.

Thompson's misadventures are far too numerous to count, but of note were his frequent battles with Take-Two Interactive, controversial publisher of games like Grand Theft Auto and Bully, often seeking outrageous damages in the hundreds of millions of dollars. These cases were often dismissed.

Anytime a violent tragedy involving a minor was concerned, you could count on Jack Thompson following closely behind, always returning just when you thought he was gone, not unlike Dracula's Curse. Where there was a grieving family looking for anything to make sense of the tragedy they experienced, there was Jack Thompson, all too eager to take their money under the guise of public service.

Eventually, Thompson's aggressive and exploitative tactics would earn him permanent disbarment and a $43,000 fine for his antics.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Donkey Kong
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

At 34 years of age, I am both older and wiser than Splinter.