10 Gaming Sequels We Wish Didn’t Exist
There are three constants in both the film and gaming industries and that is quality, lack of quality and sequels. Anything will acquire a sequel so long as it shifts enough unit/tickets the first time around irrespective of quality. Whether these things deserve sequels or not is entirely subjective, but they'll likely get one anyway if someone feels there are a couple of dollars to be made. There are plenty of films and games that justify revisiting in sequel form and then more than a few which just change a detail here or a control option there, repackage themselves and shout about how awesome they are. But possibly the most annoying combination in the world comes when a great game or film gets a lousy sequel. There is nothing more unsatisfying than seeing one of your favourite titles being torn apart by a half-baked, ill conceived monstrosity of a sequel that has little love or compassion for what came before it. Games and films, which instead of proudly bearing the hallmarks of quality, merely serve to shamelessly plunder some cash from our expectant wallets. The following is a run down of ten such games. Games which the world would have been better off without. 10. Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic 2 - The Sith Lords
Although to some level we could add the Star Wars: The Old Republic MMORPG to this as well, at least that didn't feel like a half-finished scrap book rip off of a game, which is more than we can say for KOTOR2. Where Knights of the Old Republic put the RPG back on the gaming landscape to a large extent, Knights 2 was a cheap reworking of the same maps and ideas, offering nothing new. It looked like there had been absolutely no work done upon the character modelling or textures of environments and the campaign was about six minutes long from start to boring finish. The so-called story line was massively disappointing and offered nothing we hadn't seen in the last game. The only redeeming feature of this title is that by virtue of being exactly the same as the previous title, we still got to play with our Lightsabers.
9. Tomb Raider: Underworld
An embarrassment of glitches and errors, Tomb Raider: Underworld almost murdered its franchise into reboot mode, no wait; it did murder it to reboot mode. As the last game of its lineage and a sequel to the excellent Tomb Raider: Legend, which brought back all the feel of the Tomb Raider series, epic graphics and interesting set pieces, Underworld was a rotting corpse-leech pretending to be a game. The storyline was moderately appalling and the whole game felt rushed. This was not aided by the ludicrous amount of glitches which could render entire game saves unplayable if a player accidentally and unknowingly tripped said glitch. Underworld looked pretty enough and had some of the splendour Legend introduced but lacked anything of its own and the pay-off was absolutely non-existent. A poor title, which with a significantly longer dev time could possibly have been a much better game.
8. Duke Nukem Forever
What is there to say about this embarrassing turd of a game? Well, it's an embarrassing turd of a game for a start. Probably one of the longest running sagas and most hotly anticipated titles in gaming history, Duke Nukem Forever felt like a mass of rushed out garbage. We weren't expecting a masterpiece after previous titles, but by God we were expecting more than this. With a focus on ludicrous minutiae - like throwing excrement around while Duke says "ugh, gross" - nothing actually seems to happen in this game. We spend so long trying to force ourselves to like it, that by the time we realise that it's terrible, we have almost finished this piece of crap. Cheap toilet humour gags fall flat and there's a ridiculously linear feel to the whole thing - forget exploration, that was for old games (like Duke Nukem 3D). Even the core mechanic - shooting things to death - is somehow robbed of any element of pleasure by how abhorrent the whole game is. Franchise killed.
7. Silent Hill Homecoming
Fundamentally not a bad game, so, why is on the list? Because, although it might be a good game mechanically, is it a good Silent Hill game? No, it is not. With controls that feel too clever, the game loses a lot of its core trickery - namely that weapons are supposed to be unwieldy and most of the characters who find themselves in the fog of Silent Hill are not trained marksmen or even particularly good fighters; the challenge is that you can't fight easily or effectively. Survival horror is the term. The main character of this game was of course a soldier, but if you can shoot anything to death and over power any enemy with relative ease, where is the suspense? Where is the fear? As a result of the smooth combat, this just doesn't feel like a Silent Hill game at all. The story telling was lacking and borrowed heavily from the movie, which as we all know wasn't a great idea either. Not an awful game, but not a good Silent Hill game at all.
6. Shadow The Hedgehog
Sega made a brave(?) attempt to emulate the success of Nintendo's Wario concept, that is taking a bad/not-quite-good guy and giving them a title of their own. Although Shadow doesn't default to evil due to the player's "ability" to switch to whichever allegiance they choose, this is a definite attempt to have a more edgy character in this ridiculously colourful world. A neat idea maybe, but incredibly difficult to implement due to the ludicrous speeds at which Sonic games are played and the over the top nature of the series. The graphics for this Gamecube/Xbox/PS2 title were also completely outdated compared to predecessor Sonic Heroes and tried to do absolutely nothing different with the "explode at warp 9 through every level" gameplay. Even the much touted gun-play element is unusable, with aiming proving almost impossible at times. This is a title that offered nothing to the franchise but frustration and more of the same. Anyone but the most resolute Sonic fan would hate this.
5. Dragon Age 2
A game which appeared too quickly after Dragon Age Origins, DA2 arrived with a sparkling new interface and great graphics. All good then, right? Wrong! This game has one of the sloppiest story lines ever cobbled together, with characters that are almost completely unlovable. The scale of the story is tiny by comparison to its predecessor and as a result the game time much shorter and the maps more repetitive. The mechanics of talking to your allies, where you have to go "back to base" is annoying at best and lifts you from the game completely at worst. One of the superior aspects of Origins was stopping and interacting with the companions who were rich and varied in both character and observations. DA2 lost that almost entirely; the fighting mechanic was a little more complex than repetitive button mashing rather than true turn-by-turn RPG goodness. But the worst crime of all were the cameos; Zevran's mutilated appearance, in which he lost much of the charm of the original, Captain Janeway appears for about six seconds at the beginning and then disappears to no relevance at all. This game was a massive disappointment and quite frankly should have been given longer development time (talking to you EA) or never released at all.4. Star Wars Rogue Squadron 3: Rebel Strike
After the massive success/only reason you had a GameCube of Rogue Leader, this was probably the biggest let down we could have not wished for. The horrible additional gameplay mechanic of running around on foot, fighting the Empire from the ground in a concrete flight suit was clunky and unfinished. The airborne missions were lacklustre by comparison to Rogue Leader. Although the graphics were good for the time, the joy of piloting an X-Wing or whatever vehicle was your preference was lost. The level design was poor and the game play felt unnaturally padded out. Lets face it, Rogue Leader had covered the source material much better already.
3. Resistance 2
Although not one of the masses that idolized Resistance: Fall of Man - an average shooter with a good story - I was still massively disappointed with this sequel. The core gameplay is still the same, which means that it offers little to nothing new except for multiplayer of course. The game lacks polish and character compared to the predecessor; one of the stand-out changes is the confined environments where the story feels very linear. Do this, go there, now, as opposed to a more open world, where exploring a little is both possible and rewarding - like in Fall of Man. The multiplayer proved that there is a reason to limit the number of players; 40 is way too many to keep up with unless you are a seasoned pro sniper. Luckily we can skip this mess and move on to Resistance 3, a game which offers everything that this one didn't. Leave it in the bin.2. Super Mario Bros. 2
Ever wondered why Super Mario Bros. 2 drifts so far from the superior Super Mario Bros formula with Mario 3 reverting immediately to type? Well, that is because Mario 2 was never supposed to be a Mario game at all and it shows. Strange power ups and hurling vegetables at enemies replaced the classic squash them by jumping their head tactic. Whereas Mario 3 offered some interesting elements, such as flying through the traditional Mario-esque environments, Mario 2 took us out of our comfort zone into a strange world which couldn't decide if it was Mario or something else entirely, because it was sort of both, a direction that was never really explored again...and no surprise.
1. True Crime: Streets of New York
No list of crappy gaming sequels would be complete without this master class of how to not make a game. Put up against Grand Theft Auto, True Crime: Streets of LA fared reasonably well. It was in essence the same type of game but with the cop/criminal elements reversed and a gifted cast to pull it off. While Streets of New York boasted a good cast, the dialogue and story is horribly inept. Technically, the frame rate of the game is awful and continuously drops out, as well as causing more than the occasional freeze. From such humble, improbably beginnings, the True Crime series died with this unfinished mass of pixels. While the first game laid a good foundation to build a platform from which to take on Rockstar's legendary sandbox, the second game took a wrecking ball to everything and left the market with only one choice, Rockstar's choice. Weak characters, weaker story, and poor gameplay is compounded by game-stopping bugs and errors. This unfinished game was a massive waste of money and hope. Agree or disagree with the list? Can you think of any we have missed? Let us know in the comments below.