10 Greatest Open World Games Of All Time

Is Elden Ring the best open world game of all time?

elden ring siofra river
FromSoftware

The dominant genre of gaming for the past several years is by far the open-world game.

Since designing a linear experience is somewhat difficult and god knows game devs are not being treated nearly well enough to make it worth the trouble, much better to just make a big open world and drop a bunch of random activities into it and call it good.

However, the open world is an art form in and of itself. If done well, the open-world game is the most immersive form of gaming there is until VR fully catches up to the rest of the industry. A great open-world game brings a universe to life like nothing else can, letting players walk down its streets, meet its people, and feel the weight of the epic quest on their shoulders.

Doing that right isn't easy, especially with how bloated the industry is with the things. It takes a clear vision, a writing staff that's completely on the same wavelength with the tone, story, and world-building, and almost OCD levels of attention to detail. All of this is on top of the game having to not only be fun to play but having a central hook to help it stand out from the pack.

These are the ten games that best managed it. The greatest open-world games made thus far.

10. Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag

The Jackdaw Assassin's Creed Black Flag
Ubisoft

Never underestimate the innate appeal of sailing around singing sea shanties.

The one part of Assassin's Creed III that everyone agreed was fun were the short segments where you got to sail a boat (except for that one stealth mission we don't talk about) so Ubisoft decided, screw it, let's build an entire game around it!

What resulted was Black Flag, a game built entirely around being a pirate and sailing around raiding the high seas. As seen with similar games like Skies Of Arcadia, that alone can be enough to be entertaining, but Black Flag takes it a step further by making this game OOZE detail out of every pore.

From every port having its own personality and subculture, to the sea shanties sung by your crew, to the awesome raids you can pull on enemy ships and bases, this game does everything in its power to make you feel like a pirate, and it understands that the best way to do that is to make the seas you sail feel alive.


9. Borderlands 2

Borderlands 2
Gearbox

The most famous entry in Gearbox's beloved looter shooter franchise, Borderlands 2 is a MASSIVE game, even by today's standards. Even without the nightmarish amount of DLC that can be bought for this one game, the world of Pandora is one of the most well-realized settings in gaming history.

The planet of Pandora is a harsh, brutal, just barely liveable world filled with the kind of wildlife that makes Australia look like...well, any country that ISN'T Australia. But while the first Borderlands gave players a good introduction to its brutal ecosystem and the volatile societies of people forced to survive on it by the corporations that dumped them there, 2 explores it to a degree that leaves the first game in the dust. it's no wonder that when you ask someone about this series, they immediately jump to the second one.

One would think the looter shooter elements would detract from the gameplay, but the way the game ties the weapon variety back into the world-building, giving every gun a specific arms manufacturing corporation to belong to - each coming with its own unique gimmick - was a stroke of genius.

And even if the guns you get for quests are hilariously inferior to what you're currently packing, like any good open-world game, the side quests are still worth it, often packaging tiny world-building details or character arcs into hilarious side activities.


8. Just Cause 2

just cause 2
Avalanche

The Just Cause games are famous, one might even say notorious, for having NIGHTMARISHLY huge worlds. Rico Rodriguez is given entire countries to run around in these games, and they go out of their way to make the player intimately aware of how big these worlds are.

Just Cause 2 hit the perfect balance of all four Just Cause games currently out. The nation of Panau feels absolutely massive, with cities, towns, villages, military bases, and more stuffed into every inch of this faux-Asian nation.

Of course, with worlds this big, the means of traversing them is key, and one would think Just Cause 3 with its kickass wingsuit would make it a sure win. While the wingsuit IS indeed fun as all hell, its speed and the sheer size of the world demanding its use makes the scenery blend together.

Meanwhile in 2, getting around on your parachute and magical, physics destroying grapple lines is easy enough, but there are also cars and boats, and planes that Rico can ride in. Making the means of traversing Panau fast but not TOO fast means there is more incentive to memorize every detail of the world.


7. Elden Ring

elden ring
FromSoftware

The Souls series was practically begging to be turned into an open-world game, as the series has always skirted along the edges of that genre since its inception. Elden Ring takes that flirting with the open-world genre to its logical extreme.

While Demon's and Dark Souls kept themselves to a series of winding mazes specially built to feel bigger and more complex than they might actually be, Elden Ring is a true blue, card-carrying open-world game, and it's one of the best.

Obviously, since Elden Ring is an open-world game, the player has a lot more variety in how they move around, such as - at long last - an actual jump button. Don't think for a second, however, that this makes the game easier. In fact, don't be shocked if you just randomly run into a super boss in your first few minutes of wandering around and get immediately atomized.

On top of capturing the danger that the Soulsborne series is known for, Elden Ring's lore and story are some of the most fascinating in gaming history, with the entire narrative centering around the player solving a murder mystery. Except the murder victim is, well, the entire world.

There are factions to join, optional bosses to fight, cute multi-armed eldritch doll witches to smooch, and in true Soulsborne fashion, the player is given naught but the gentlest of nudges in the direction of any of them.


6. Minecraft

Minecraft Game
Mojang / Microsoft

Few games get quite as open-world as Minecraft, seeing as how most games plop you down in their open-world with, you know, a point to it all. Go here, beat up this guy, cry over this dude, climb this tower etc.

Minecraft, meanwhile, has no point to it other than what you, the player, make of it. It is the ultimate building simulator and has only grown more powerful and complex in the years since it came out.

You wanna build an entire city, right out of your imagination? You wanna build a one-to-one replica of the mansion from X-Men, complete with a button that makes it explode, as is the destiny of the X-Mansion? You wanna just make giant knobs?

Minecraft not only lets you do it, it gives you all the resources and gizmos needed to make that forest of giant knobs dance a merry jig. Sure, it isn't for everyone, due to its appeal lying squarely in the player's ability to give themselves a project, but it is one of the most acclaimed games on the market for a VERY good reason.


5. Far Cry 3

far cry 3
Ubisoft

The game that would define Ubisoft's development formula for the next decade and counting, Far Cry 3 remains the best open-world game Ubisoft has made thus far.

The Rook Islands, where Jason Brody and his trust fund brat friends are terrorized by the psychotic Vaas and his merry band of bipedal murder monkeys, is one of the most interesting settings in Ubisoft's library. The islands are just big enough to make exploration fun and interesting, but also compact enough to make traveling from one interesting thing to another less of a slog. Something later Far Cry games can't attest to.

Far Cry 3 also perfected the main claim to fame of the series all the way back in the beginning: the fact that the environment is as active as you are, and the enemies and wildlife are always moving even when you're not around. You could be scoping out an enemy base, ready to make your move, only for a tiger to come in and attack the guards, throwing your entire plan out the window.

Because the Rook Islands are large but not TOO large, there was a real back and forth between you, the enemies, and the wildlife of the island. Which is why Far Cry 3 is, to this day, still the best Far Cry game.


4. Marvel's Spider-Man

Spider Man Ps4 Crime
Insomniac

Insomniac didn't need to go as hard as they did with Marvel's Spider-Man, they honestly really didn't. But they did, and thank god for that because the end result was one of the greatest superhero games of all time.

The detail put into this game is frankly obscene. Not quite as much as will be seen in the final three, but the number of tiny worldbuilding details stuffed into Spider-Man's interpretation of New York, stuff that most players would never think about, brings its world to life in a way few games do.

The problem with most open-world games is accounting for the player being a little jerk who will ruin any story you're trying to tell by having the great noble hero go on a killing spree. Well, in Spider-Man, the game goes out of its way to make it impossible for Spidey to kill or harm anyone, having the punch button turn into a high-five when around civilians, and webs sticking crooks you punch off cliffs to walls.

And the swinging, well, we wouldn't even be discussing the game if it screwed that part up, would we? Easy to learn, and satisfying to master, Marvel's Spider-Man earns its place in the top five purely on the web-swinging being the most fun traversal method on this entire list.


3. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

the witcher 3
CD Projekt RED

The Witcher trilogy have mostly been radiating in the background of the RPG scene, loved mainly by fans of the books. While in terms of storytelling and worldbuilding they were unmatched, matching that with appealing gameplay was always something CD Projekt RED struggled with.

And then Witcher 3 came along.

The Witcher 3 put the entire series on the map, made CD Projekt RED a force to be reckoned with in the gaming industry, and is still one of the best RPGs ever made, with one of the best open worlds in RPG history to boot.

What makes The Witcher 3's open world so intriguing is its attention to detail with incorporating gameplay into the story. To give just one example, a lot of gamers these days have grown to resent the mini-map, feeling it limits progress and peer pressures the player from exploring. The Witcher 3 not only lets you turn the map off, but will even ensure you won't get lost by having quest givers realistically give directions to the mission objective. If you want to find the objective, you have to listen carefully and pay attention to the road and landscape, as the peasants you will so often take missions from will name landmarks and general areas instead of anything concrete.

That kind of confidence in the player is scattered all over this game. The Witcher 3 not only has a richly detailed open world, but it is also built to ensure that you get absolutely lost in it.


2. Grand Theft Auto V

GTA 5 GTA V
Rockstar

Even all these years later, GTA V still reigns supreme as the best Rockstar open-world game.

Until Red Dead Redemption 2 went overboard with details that, frankly, nobody was asking for (okay, I'm sure SOME people were asking for a game with realistic horse testicle physics, I just don't see those people as the kind a triple-A publisher should consult) Grand Theft Auto V was the game that shocked the entire industry for years with the sheer amount of detail crammed into its world.

Clothes react realistically, all the way down to different shoes reacting to movement in unique ways, the AI on the NPCs is still unmatched by most of the industry to this day, you can even run into (and then murder) story-important NPCs - including the other two player characters you aren't controlling at that moment.

Going back to GTA V will always lead to you running into something you hadn't noticed before, some new little detail or tidbit that adds just that little bit more life into Los Santos. And all without horse testicles. Imagine that.


1. The Legend Of Zelda: Breath Of The Wild

BOTW Great Plateau
Nintendo

Deciding the top spot for this list was the closest call your scribe has ever made in the three years he's been writing for this site. I had to replay every game in the top 3 just to really narrow it down, and blasphemous as it may appear to many, Breath of the Wild is nothing short of the greatest open-world game ever made.

The methodical pace, the risky but not TOO risky combat, the myriad ways this game encourages and rewards exploration while still being casual friendly, it's all polished to a mirror shine.

The flaws that the game has, such as the weapon durability to name an example, become less and less of a problem as the years wear on, leaving only what this game does right shining even brighter.

Hyrule is at its peak here in terms of portrayal, equal parts serene and desolate, beautiful but dangerous, fresh and new and yet also frighteningly old, with relics from EVERY past Zelda game to be found somewhere in its fields and mountains and deserts.

Maybe Tears Of The Kingdom will top the foundation laid here, maybe not. But for now, Breath of the Wild sits atop the throne as the best open-world game out there.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Elden Ring
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

John Tibbetts is a novelist in theory, a Whatculture contributor in practice, and a nerd all around who loves talking about movies, TV, anime, and video games more than he loves breathing. Which might be a problem in the long term, but eh, who can think that far ahead?