10 Harsh Truths We Don't Want To Admit About Awesome Games
10. World of Warcraft Requires No Skill Whatsoever
The Awesome: For the better part of a decade, World of Warcraft has reigned supreme as the world's most popular MMORPG - peaking at 12 million users, and presently resting at roughly 7 million - while also spawning countless expansion packs, pop-culture spoofs, and even an impending movie. The Truth: Though infamous for its fiendishly addictive gameplay, WoW really is just another repetitive MMO that doesn't require much skill to beast through. It's all about how much of your existence you are prepared to pour into the game - that is what will largely determine how much you get out of it. Though the large player base helps us become immersed in this huge world, it's really pretty simple stuff that relies on players spending their time away from work just throwing themselves into another kind of grind.
9. Gran Turismo Is Just Not Very Fun
The Awesome: Gran Turismo aims to provide an authentic racing experience like no other, complete with fully-licensed vehicles and a clinical, unprecedented level of attention-to-detail. The franchise, now with its sixth major title awaiting release, has shifted over 70 million units worldwide and garnered tremendous critical acclaim. The Truth: Yet, in aiming so firmly for the obsessive petrolhead demographic, Polyphony Digital haven't adequately taken care of more casual players. Though the staggering level of detail, both in the visuals and the technical aspects of each car, is admirable, this is at the expense of an overall sense of fun; there's a clinical feel to everything, from the glossy game menus to the fact that the beautifully-rendered vehicles still can't be properly damaged (due to most car companies not wanting to see their cars get crumpled). Though one can't argue with the value for money or comprehensive nature of the experience, PD could do with injecting a little more fun and levity into their titles; some more colourful menus to start, perhaps?
8. GTA IV Was Too Serious For Its Own Good
The Awesome: GTA IV surged onto current-gen consoles in style, delivering a visually stunning experience that also put more effort into the narrative than any of the previous games and introduced a thrilling multiplayer component. The result was a tremendous success, selling over 25 million copies and a metric ton of Game of the Year commendations. The Truth: Few can argue with the integrity of GTA IV's storytelling, but at the same time, it felt like Rockstar were trying a little too hard to make GTA a serious game that had the water-tight narrative of a great movie or TV show. The result was an experience that, though engrossing, wasn't anywhere near as fun as the previous games in the series, placing a larger onus on its epic story and less on what has always been the most enjoyable aspect of these games - the mad satire, killing hookers, getting in crazy car chases and, of course, the kill frenzies that were notably absent from GTA IV entirely. Thankfully, GTA V seems to have restored a lot of the peripheral elements that GTA IV omitted in favour of a more streamlined, story-focused effort, so hopefully GTA V is back to the fun that seems more abundant in the Saints Row franchise these days.
7. Okami Is Just A Good-Looking Zelda Clone
The Awesome: A visually stunning tale that combines elements from Japanese myths, legends and folklore, and though it never found a huge audience, it was marked out as IGN's Game of the Year, while receiving ecstatic praise from most of the gaming press. The Truth: One can't doubt the entrancing appeal of Okami, but let's take a look at what the game involves for a moment - you explore a vast world, slowly learning new moves and obtaining more equipment as you gain access to new areas, while encountering tough puzzles. Doesn't this sound just like, well, every Zelda game ever? Add in the cel-shaded look, and it's easy to see why people think the two are so similar at a core level, even if they are rooted in entirely different settings and plots. One can't blame Clover Studio too much - after all, why not borrow from successful formulas? - but the game's originality and ingenuity have nevertheless been overstated a tad.
6. Metal Gear Solid IV Barely Makes Sense
The Awesome: The fourth Metal Gear Solid game brought Solid Snake's epic journey to a fitting end, delivering one of the most intense and downright stunning titles on the PS3. It wouldn't win the franchise many new fans, but damnit, it delivered. The Truth: As exhilarating as the game was, did it really make a whole lot of sense? To be fair, this criticism could also be leveled at most of the other games in the franchise, but it reaches its most logic-challenging apex in the fourth game, as Hideo Kojima strives to answer every last possible question we had about the game's world and characters. The result? While thrilling, the game used magic to explain far too much (nanomachines is Kojima's version of midichlorians), and asked us to buy some down-right insane plot twists (Revolver Ocelot wasn't the douchebag villain we thought all along). That said, if you're invested into the franchise this far, you're likely to just go with it. It's one of those barmy rides you just have to accept in its insanity or leave well alone. Amazing while you're playing it, it nevertheless causes us to ask many more questions on reflection.
5. Resident Evil's Tank Controls Render It Almost Unplayable
The Awesome: Essentially the game that helped popularise the survival horror genre, Resident Evil was a terrifying zombie game that then spawned a hugely successful franchise, as well as a financially successful movie series. The Truth: Back in 1996, we were so amazed by everything else that Resident Evil had to offer that we didn't care if the tank controls were utterly horrific, making maneuvering away from the various enemies a royal pain, and causing the game to be much more frustrating than it needed to be. Nowadays, following the retooling of the franchise that occurred in the fourth game, going back to the original titles is an utterly torturous experience, and the last time I tried playing the first RE, I ended up quitting after half an hour because I just found the control scheme so disruptive to the experience.
4. Guitar Hero Is For People Who Suck At Actual Guitar
The Awesome: Enormously successful rhythm game franchise allowed players to strum a plastic peripheral to blast through some of their favourite rock music hits. The franchise made billions of dollars and became a general pop-culture phenomenon, before slowly outstaying its welcome and becoming a relic. The Truth: It may have taken people a few years to realise this, but the only reason anyone would play a plastic version of a real guitar...is because they're not skilled enough to play a proper one. Why does a child want a plastic guitar for Christmas? Because they can't play a real guitar but want the cool sounds. The same principle is true here, and though the game's sheer audacity and party appeal kept it popular for several years, eventually we all began to realise how utterly ridiculous we looked playing plastic guitars in our living rooms, and later on, playing plastic drum kits and even singing (badly) into a microphone. Though Rock Band tried to latch onto the idea of incorporating a real guitar into the game and promoting actual guitar play, it was too little too late, and both franchises died a death.3. God of War Is Nothing More Than A Brainless Hack 'N Slash Game
The Awesome: Best-selling action adventure franchise that pits the player as a vengeful Greek demigod who takes on the Gods in a series of epic, larger-than-life encounters. Gleeful violence ensues. The Truth: Superbly executed though these games unquestionably are, is there really much more to them than meets the eye? This might be gorier and boast slicker graphics than we're used to for the genre, but is it really much different than the hack 'n slash titles we've been playing since forever? Don't get me wrong; I'm not ragging on the simplicity of the genre, but given the ecstatically positive reviews the series has generally received, one might have expected more nuance than button bashing and relatively simplistic - though gloriously enjoyable - combat. There's not a lot of intelligence to the games, though they do deliver some brilliantly brutal set-pieces.
2. The Walking Dead Has Dreadful Graphics
The Awesome: Telltale Games' massively acclaimed episodic graphic adventure series helped breathe fresh life into the world of the AMC TV show, forging a more emotional connection between its characters than the show has ever managed. The Truth: There's no denying the quality of the game's writing, but from a visual perspective, it really underwhelms. Though we shouldn't perhaps expect superb graphics from a graphic adventure clearly made on a relatively low budget, the game's disappointing aesthetic is at odds with the extremely nuanced nature of the scripts and voice actors. While most of us are able to look past it because, of course, gameplay matters so much more, these games would open their market up even more if the next "season" poured a little more cash into the look of the game. Given the original's success, I'm sure Telltale can afford it now...
1. Every Zelda Game Is Basically The Same
The Awesome: Huge adventure game franchise is notable for being, alongside Mario, Nintendo's mainstay series, with sales of 68 million units to date. The Truth: I feel that if I've played one Zelda game, I've pretty much played them all; they might look a little different (cel-shaded) or employ new gimmicks (motion control), but at the heart of it, the story generally involves Link having to rescue Princess Zelda from Ganon in a variety of ways. Every time a new Zelda game is announced, I'm hoping to hear Nintendo flirt with something truly new, but archetypes being archetypes, they seemingly don't want to rock the boat and miss screwing things up. The healthiest way to treat the Zelda games is to look at each one as a "reboot" that doesn't have a continuous chronology; otherwise, we're all going to succumb to franchise fatigue, if we haven't already. The next Zelda game will doubtless sell like hotcakes just as every other has, but would it really kill Nintendo to try something a bit more out there? I guess with the Wii U's failure, this probably isn't the time to try something new... Are there any Earth-shattering gaming realisations you've come to over the years? Let us know in the comments below.