10 Hated Video Game Sequels You Should Play
Don't write these off just yet.
Very little on this planet comes under more scrutiny than a video game sequel.
As such it's a tough tightrope developers have to walk to make one that's successful. Give players more of the same and they might return in droves... or they might decide your game is a lazy cash grab and get bored of the series. Take a huge risk and you might win fans over with strong creative ambition... or they might criticise you for losing the core of what people loved so much in the first place.
As a result, there have been plenty of titles that have disappointed over the years, even becoming a source of Internet controversy. However, the Internet can be a pressure cooker, and often a title's perceived slights completely dominate the discourse and become incredibly overblown, with fans declaring it the worst thing ever with no redeeming qualities.
It's rare for a game to be bad from end to end though, and the following titles don't deserve to be completely written off. They're worth trying yourself, even if it's only out of morbid curiosity.
10. Mass Effect 3
Mass Effect 3's infamously hated ending essentially did to the franchise what Game of Thrones' final season did for that show's reputation: it made fans wonder why they ever cared in the first place. Ten years later, it is true that ME3's out-of-nowhere anti-climax is disappointing, but do you know what? It's been a decade, and talking about this sequel's ending has been done to death - it's boring.
There's so much more to this title than just the final twenty minutes, and so much in there to love. While the ending may drop the ball in terms of paying off player choices, other story segments categorically do not. Tragic deaths, longtime conflicts finally coming to a head, cameo appearances, picked-up romantic relationships and more tantalising consequences of the player's decisions litter this title, providing satisfying conclusions to almost all the major arcs in the trilogy.
The combat is better than ever too, enough so that it was enjoyable enough to sustain an entire multiplayer suite many fans assumed would be a tacked-on mess.
Is Mass Effect 3 a perfect game? Hell no. The way the RPG elements are scaled back is incredibly disappointing, but its highs are undeniably high and combined with all the great DLC in the recent Legacy Edition remaster, makes for a fun, captivating final adventure.
9. Ninja Gaiden 3: Razor's Edge
Under no circumstances should you play Ninja Gaiden 3. That sequel is an embarrassing entry in the franchise, a hack-and-slasher that strips away all the personality of the previous instalments in favour of a more "mainstream" plot about military soldiers and illuminati-style conspiracies, streamlines the combat until it borderline plays itself, removes key weapons and items, and has some of the most ham-fisted social commentary of the 2010s.
Its re-release though, Ninja Gaiden 3: Razor's Edge, improved on the core game so substantially, it's practically a whole different experience. Re-introducing depth to the combat, adding in the series' signature gore and even removing cutscenes that were ridiculed in the base game, this new version is an apologetic do-over.
That doesn't mean it hits the spectacular OTT highs of Ninja Gaiden 2, nor does it retain the intricacies of the level design and pacing of Ninja Gaiden 1, but it does succeed as a straightforwardly satisfying action game. Lower your expectations, revel in the gratuitous combat, and Ninja Gaiden 3: Razor's Edge is worth your time if you swore it off a decade ago.
8. Resident Evil 6
Take this one with a caveat, as I'll happily admit I'm probably the biggest Resident Evil 6 simp on the Internet.
At the time of release, the response to this sequel was a wake up call for the whole series. A bloated, over-indulgent mess that attempted to fully sever the franchise from its survival horror roots, the critical kicking that Resident Evil 6 got at the time finally made Capcom change course and soft-reboot the whole thing with Resident Evil 7.
With space from its release though - and knowing that it wasn't the harbinger of doom for the whole series it could have been - Resi 6 can be enjoyed as a weird, ridiculously budgeted experiment, one whose excess makes it a spectacle from start to finish.
Across three campaigns (and a "secret" fourth), switch your brain off and enjoy Capcom throwing everything at the wall and hoping something sticks. Fortunately for players, while a lot of ideas bounce straight off, there's enough that do click to make playing through the game satisfying. The shooting is tighter than ever, the added focus on melee combat shakes the flow up nicely (even if it never stops being insane to suplex zombies), while each playable character is unique enough to hold their own individual storylines.
It's nuts, it doesn't always work, but good lord am I glad it exists.
7. Devil May Cry 2
Devil May Cry 2 is the only game on this list that's genuinely bad. An outright stinker, this ill-fated sequel is still worth playing, however, because it shows you exactly how not to produce a follow up.
Everything that made the original so beloved is absent here. The lush, gothic interconnected levels are swapped out for empty city streets and bland warehouses, the tough combat is replaced with boring button mashing, the humour is almost entirely absent, and there's only a handful of bosses (with some just being repeats of bosses from the first game, to add insult to injury).
All of those botched elements, though, make it fascinating to play. The runtime is incredibly short which means you won't just be punishing yourself for hours, and playing DMC 2 will make you appreciate every game before and after.
This sequel could have tanked the whole franchise, but instead the developers learned from its mistakes to create arguably the best spectacle fighter of all time with Devil May Cry 3.
6. Dead Space 3
Dead Space 3 is not what most fans wanted. It's not what I wanted, especially after the second game perfected its blend of action-horror, giving players the Aliens to the first title's Alien.
Similar to Resident Evil 6, this third game was made in the pursuit of truly breaking into the mainstream action genre, downplaying many of the overt horror elements from past titles and adding in a co-op mode. It was also an experimental release for EA, being one of the publisher's first forays into the realm of microtransactions.
It's definitely a flawed title, and misguided in its overall creative direction, but there's one thing to remember: this is still made by Visceral Games.
As such, Dead Space 3 is put together with a polish and sheen still leagues ahead of what some developers are capable of today. The chunky combat encounters remain tightly staged and executed, the larger environments hide more secrets than ever, zero-gravity segments are expanded, and there are still a few scares for good measure. If treated as a straight action game rather than survival horror, there's a solid 7/10 experience in there.
Just don't be put off by the opening that has you fighting humans instead of monsters - that was unforgivable.
5. Doom 3
Doom 3 owns.
A departure from the previous two lightning-fast FPS classics, this third game slows the pace down and encourages players to drink in the atmosphere. Though still a gory, violent experience, Doom 3 is more about darkly lit corridor-crawling, wondering where the next demon or zombie is going to jump out from.
That change in direction is what makes it particularly interesting to revisit today. There's nothing else like it in this franchise, and with it re-telling the story of the original Doom, the sequel feels like a strange, alternate reality version of a game that defined a generation.
It helps that the engine still holds up incredibly well decades later, with striking lighting, convincing monster designs and weighty combat adding to the immersion. The environments steal the show too, eventually getting more blood-soaked, surreal and metal as you head into Hell itself.
It feels a bit trite to say 'they don't make these types of games today', but a title like Doom 3 really is unlikely to be made in 2022 on this scale, and as such is always primed for a revisit.
4. Call Of Duty: Infinite Warfare
Call of Duty games always have their critics, but it's rare for one to be outright hated - at least by the casuals as well as the hardcore fans. The one exception to this is Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare, which made all the wrong headlines when it was first announced for having some of the most disliked trailers ever for a blockbuster release.
However, it was less about the quality of the game or trailers themselves, but rather the general direction of the whole franchise. By this point, COD had transformed itself into a futuristic shooter series, with double jumps and wall running and sci-fi weaponry. Despite having three sub-franchises, Activision refused to provide players with a classic boots-on-the-ground experience.
It's a shame that this disgruntlement was taken out on Infinite Warfare because, especially when it comes to the campaign, it's a truly noteworthy entry into the series. With memorable characters, heartbreaking deaths and gameplay that added layers to the regular twitchy combat, Infinite Warfare was doing anything but resting on its laurels.
While its multiplayer suite is redundant now, it's still worth picking up to play Call of Duty's most underrated campaign.
3. Crysis 3
"Can it run Crysis" is a phrase etched into the minds of gamers everywhere. This first-person shooter set the benchmark for what was possible on PC for years, establishing itself as the most technically advanced game on the market. Its inevitable sequel traded that infamy for a more streamlined, console-friendly sequel, and while not as iconic as its predecessor, was still well-received. Sadly, the same cannot be said for Crysis 3.
Pretty much forgotten as soon as it arrived, this sequel from EA was viewed as stale at the time, failing to innovate on the choice-heavy combat of its predecessor. Even worse, its new features like a bow and arrow, were viewed as simply copying trends of the time, as other titles like Far Cry 3 and Tomb Raider had similarly used the weapon at the heart of their marketing.
While it is true that Crysis 3 is anything but a trend-setter, that doesn't mean it doesn't use its familiar bag of tricks in satisfying ways. The nano-suit the player is given is still empowering, allowing combat scenarios to be approached with brute force or a deft hand. With bigger areas, stealth is way more viable this time around too, and while stalking your prey in the overgrown streets of New York, Crysis 3 starts to feel like the best Predator game we never had.
Did it revolutionise the FPS genre like the original? No. Did it deserve to kill a whole franchise dead? Hell no.
2. Fallout 76
Unlike most games, live service titles can claw success from the jaws of failure. A terrible launch is not a complete death sentence, and if a new live service game tanks, the developers and publishers have two options: either hold their hands up, cut ties and promise to do better with the next game or knuckle down and put the work in to transform what they already have into a quality product.
Of course, there's no guarantee that committing to the latter approach will actually work or, more importantly, that fans will be open to forgiveness if they do pull it off. With Fallout 76, there's understandably still a lot of trepidation. This thing was a tire fire at launch, and a lot of longtime players simply thought the idea of a multiplayer Fallout title was antithetical to the franchise's entire appeal.
Well, it took them a good few years, but Fallout 76 is no longer the complete write off it once was. With a bunch of major substantial updates, there's way more game there than there ever was and, more importantly it (mostly) works.
Sure, some of the updates added in elements, like NPCs, that should have been there at launch but taken in its current state, Fallout 76 may be able to win you over.
1. Dark Souls 2
When discussing the best From Software games, it's going to be rare to hear the name "Dark Souls 2" brought up unless it's in the phrase, "well at least it's not as bad as Dark Souls 2!"
Any sequel to one of the most beloved games of all time was going to come under heavy scrutiny, but this effort was pretty much disowned entirely as not being a "true" successor. That reputation is partly because the original director sat the sequel out, as well as its controversial changes to how healing works, the move away from the interconnected levels of DS1 and increase in humanoid enemies and bosses. Put simply, it's a very different game to Dark Souls 1, both in its mechanical focus and story, but that's what makes it so noteworthy.
Unlike a lot of sequels that rest on their laurels, DS2 attempts to etch out its own identity, and mostly succeeds. Yes, the world isn't connected and doesn't make geographical sense, but it's not supposed to, and with that trade off you get some of the most visually unique - and visually surprising - areas in the whole series. Humanoid enemies are repeated and come at you in large numbers, but sword duels are incredible and the increased volume of targets forces you to play in a more aggressive way.
For every change, there's a reason behind it. It might not be as polished as Dark Souls 1, but it shouldn't be written off because it's not just more of the same.