10 Hated Video Games That Became Cult Classics
We may have been too harsh.
When a hyped game fails miserably to meet expectations, the masses will make their disappointment crystal clear. There was such an outcry over Alien Colonial Marines, The Avengers, and Babylon's Fall, they are now regarded, not just as underwhelming, but infamous. Even though judgments like this are harsh, they're justified if the IPs in question are incomplete, buggy, or unplayable.
However, there are times where the mob mentality goes too far. The instant there's any hint an anticipated platformer, shooter, or RPG might not be a masterpiece, people jump on the bandwagon, declaring it as an unmitigated disaster. Gamers can become so overly focused on a single negative attribute of the game, they'll write it off without hesitation. Sometimes, the hate is so pre-emptive, people will criticise an upcoming title before playing it. (Look at what happened with Wind Waker.)
Now, that's not suggesting the entries on this list are perfect. However, they have so many redeemable qualities, it's obvious they never deserved the animosity they received.
These ten titles may have been reviled upon their debut, but they are now considered cult-classics.
10. Mega Man VII
After the success of Mega Man 2, Capcom churned out a plethora of sequels, hoping to milk the Blue Bomber for everything he was worth. Sadly, Mega Man 3, 4, 5, and 6 brought nothing new to the table, causing the platforming franchise to stagnate.
Although Capcom hoped Mega Man VII would reinvigorate the series, it was criticised for being formulaic and dated. The towering success of the rebooted Mega Man X, which was released two years earlier, further highlighted how obsolete the classic games had become.
But upon revisiting Mega's seventh outing, it's clear it shouldn't have been discounted. Even though MMVII follows the same formula as its forebearers, the gameplay is far more diverse. The instant the game begins, it's obvious the developers put more focus on story, humour, and Mega's relationship with his allies.
VII boasts a horde of secrets that can only be found with specific power-ups, encouraging players to revisit completed areas, after obtaining the desired item. The inclusion of a shop is clever, since it compels players to seek out currency and strategise which upgrades will give the heroic android the best chance of survival.
With its catchy tunes, creative level design, imaginative enemies, tricky bosses, and innovative weapons, it's hard to believe MMVII was considered a misfire.
9. Max Payne 3
Because Max Payne went into hiatus for almost a decade after Max Payne 2, it would've been easy for the developers to toss out more of the same, knowing that nostalgic fans would lap it up.
But when Rockstar took over development for Max's third adventure, they decided to overhaul everything. While the first two instalments were known for their atmospheric setting, cheesy dialogue, and panellised storytelling, Max Payne 3 shifted to a more linear and cinematic style. Our titular hero's appearance and wise-cracking demeanour also received a major revision.
Even though these alterations showcased the evolution of our cynical hero and the franchise in general, die-hard fans were disappointed this long-awaited sequel didn't resemble the preceding entries.
But judging Max Payne 3 on its own merits, there's next to nothing that can be faulted. Thanks to the vibrant colours and realistic graphics, the adrenaline-pumping, high-octane action has never looked better, especially during the bullet-time sections, which have been refined to perfection. Although the hardboiled detective tropes were deliberately parodical in the previous instalments, Max Payne 3's gripping narrative keeps things more grounded, without compromising the noir elements.
Looking at Max Payne 3 with fresh eyes, it's apparent that it's not just a marvellous title, but arguably the best of the trilogy.
8. Batman: Arkham Origins
Because Rocksteady's Batman: Arkham Asylum and Arkham City were borderline perfect, it felt like the prequel, Arkham Origins, couldn't match them. Fans were extra cynical, since this follow-up was handled by WB Games Montreal; a company so green, it didn't exist before Arkham Asylum. And with classic voice actors Kevin Conroy and Mark Hamill not returning, skepticism for Origins was through the roof.
Sadly, these concerns were apt. Origins did little to distinguish itself, since the setting, weapons, and mechanics remained mostly unchanged from the previous entries. The game froze so often, you'd swear Mr. Freeze was to blame.
With that said, Origins shouldn't be dismissed, especially by Arkham purists. The new Batman (Roger Craig Smith) and Joker (Troy Baker) fit their roles so well, the most attuned listeners couldn't tell the actors had been recast. The story explores the Joker's origins in a way rarely seen in any game before or since. It has some genuinely heart-wrenching moments, especially between Bruce Wayne and Alfred.
Also, the boss battles are top-notch. Rather than tangling with a legion of random goons, the boss battles in Origins has the dark knight fight... actual bosses!
And after the disastrous reception of Batman Arkham's successor, Gotham Knights, Origins is now looking like the unsung hero of the series, giving fans more incentive to revisit it.
7. Zelda II: Adventures Of Link
The top-down view has been a staple in The Legend of Zelda, dating all the way back to the original. However, Nintendo decided to mix it up for the sequel, turning The Adventures of Link into a side-scroller. The universal response was so overwhelmingly negative, Zelda II was hailed as the worst instalment in the series for years.
But with the benefit of hindsight, there's no question the rabble were too quick to judge this entry. Considering LoZ has stood the test of time by constantly reinventing itself, it's ironic Zelda II's biggest criticism was the fact it was too different. Many people who hate on the game never gave it a chance, since they switched it off when they saw it didn't follow the original's format.
By playing Zelda II for no more than an hour, any player can see how appealing and innovative it is. It was among the first games ever to effectively blend platforming and role-playing together. Fighting enemies rarely feels like a slog, since every encounter gives Link experience points, allowing him to enhance his weapons, armour, magic, and health.
The NPCs have their own patterns and movements, accentuating the game's world-building. Zelda II introduced many key component to the franchise's lore, including the Triforce of Courage, metered magic, and Dark Link.
Adventures of Link is not a masterpiece, but there's enough here to satiate any fan of the beloved saga.
6. Street Fighter III
Because Street Fighter II singlehandedly moulded the fighting genre into what it is today, it seemed impossible for any follow-up to have the same impact.
Sadly, the overwhelming "meh" that Street Fighter III received verified this notion. Critics found this instalment to be solid, but nothing special. At the time, other fighting titles, like Tekken and Soul Edge had embraced the third dimension. Because Capcom's sequel firmly maintained its 2D roots, it looked ancient by comparison.
But nowadays, SFIII isn't considered dated. Ironically, it's now regarded as ahead of its time. Unlike fighters like Marvel VS Capcom or Mortal Kombat, this threequel doesn't rely on showy moves, over-the-top combos, or screen-filling attacks.
Instead, it focuses on fighting in its purist form. During each match, competitors have to constantly think about positioning, timing, and parrying, rather than wailing on their opponent with cheap attacks.
SFIII's mechanics are so precise, it gave birth to the Daigo Parry incident, which is considered not just the best counter in video games, but the defining moment in competitive gaming history.
Although SFIII was once labelled as a blunder, it's now hailed as the most underrated entry in the series.
5. Days Gone
Critics were quick to peg Days Gone as just another sandbox title, chastising its empty open-world, minimal exploration, one-dimensional protagonist, and filler quests. Because of this, it looked like the zombie-fighting title would be quickly forgotten.
On the contrary, it got a second wind, thanks to positive feedback from the gaming community. Even though Days Gone only received middling scores on Metacritic, the populace were far more generous, rating the post-apocalyptic adventure between 8.4-8.7 on the same site.
Bizarrely, players seemed to enjoy everything that critics didn't. Rather than seeing Deacon St. John as a boring hero, fans thought the outlaw biker was relatable and uncliched. Yes, the open-world is sparse, but this makes it easier to admire the terrain's beauty, especially while zooming around on the motorcycle.
The gameplay is anything but generic, since players must manage resources, navigate hostile environments, strategically fight off mutant monsters, and devise tactics to survive encounters with human adversaries.
Even though it can take a decade for a game to be considered a cult-classic, Days Gone achieved that status in record time. Despite only being released four years ago, the rabid fanbase are already pining for more.
4. Doom 64
Doom dominated the FPS genre during the 1990s, causing the hellish shooter to be ported to every system that could run it.
Rather than porting Doom to the Nintendo 64, id Software collaborated with Midway to devise a brand-new instalment called Doom 64. Boasting a new engine, a bevy of rock-hard levels, and new sprites for all enemies, this N64 exclusive was shaping up to be one for the ages.
Sadly, the demon-blasting title failed to take the world by storm. With Nintendo shooters at the time, like Turok and GoldenEye 007, towering over the competition, Doom 64 looked like dusty relic.
But on further inspection, it's obvious Doom 64 was more than a copy-and-paste of the original. Instead of focusing on fast-paced action, this entry relies on atmosphere and ramping up tension. Rather than murdering everything in sight, there's a bigger emphasis on solving puzzles. Because of this, battling the denizens of hell is less frequent, which makes each encounter more shocking, since it's hard to know when the creepy critters will show up.
Over the years, Doom 64 has developed such a devoted cult-following, it's been ported and modded on multiple systems. Even though Doom 64 is meant to be a spin-off, it captures the spirit of the franchise perfectly, which is why many general players perceive it more like Doom 3 than the ACTUAL Doom 3.
3. Killer7
Video game director, Goichi Suda, has a gift for crafting underrated gems. Even though he's renowned for his work on The Silver Case, No More Heroes, and Lollipop Chainsaw, it took years before any of these titles received any recognition.
And nothing demonstrates Suda's unappreciated legacy more than Killer7. In a nutshell, Killer7 is a puzzle-themed shooter with on-rail controls, where the paralysed protagonist conjures assassins from his mind to complete missions. Unsurprisingly, it wasn't an easy game to market.
With its cel-shaded visuals, noir style, arthouse imagery, unconventional controls, and confusing premise, it was like Suda tried to make the project as niche as possible. Because this bonkers FPS went so far against the grain, it was no surprise it didn't gel with the populace.
However, Killer7's biggest criticism is also its greatest strength - there's nothing else like it. Although many people found the gameplay inaccessible, just as many loved its absurd uniqueness. Even though Killer7 could've fallen apart by trying to juggle too many eccentric ideas, it pulls it off (for the most part), offering players an experience unlike any other.
2. Assassin's Creed III
Based on the mesmerising promos and trailers, Assassin's Creed III was expected to be the the capstone of Ubisoft's iconic series.
Sadly, the third entry in the parkour-leaping, time-hopping tale was hampered by various issues. Glitches and long loading times interfered with the immersion. Connor was a compelling hero, but he couldn't compete with Assassin's Creed II's Ezio. Even though Desmond Miles' death should've been heartfelt, it was surprisingly anticlimactic.
Although ACIII isn't a bad game, it was regarded the runt of the litter for years. This is a pity, since this instalment exceeds other entries in many aspects. The combat has been fine-tuned, the weapons are astoundingly diverse, and the world-building is magnificent. Although Connor lacks the swagger of Ezio, he's a far more relatable protagonist.
By playing as the villain during the prologue, players got the chance to see the Assassin's conflict from the enemies' point of view, giving them greater insight in the overarching narrative. This was also a genius bait-and-switch, since many players initially assumed the dastardly Haytham Kenway was the hero.
Speaking of which, Haytham is arguably the best villain in the entire saga. Despite being a smug know-it-all, it's tough not to be swayed by his words, purely because of Adrian Hough's monumental performance.
Assassin's Creed III is, by no means, the best the franchise has to offer, but it's far from the worst.
1. Demon's Souls
Demon's Souls is the precursor of the esteemed Dark Souls saga, the tentpole of FromSoftware, and the pioneer of the Soulslike games. Due to its legacy, it's easy to forget nobody gave a damn about Hidetaka Miyazaki's open-world IP when it came out. Even Sony president at the time, Shuhei Yoshida, thought it was "an unbelievably bad game".
Being the devil's advocate, it's not surprising to understand why Demon's Souls didn't gain traction straightaway. With its lack of tutorials and merciless difficulty, the majority of players gave up before breaching the starting area.
The world-building is so subtle, casual players couldn't make heads or tails of the detailed lore, nor could they get the hang of the trial-and-error combat. Since Demon's Souls came out the same month as Assassin's Creed II and Modern Warfare 2, it looked like the gruelling title would get lost in the shuffle.
Slowly but surely, the fantasy role-player started making a name for itself through the oldest method possible - word-of-mouth. Seeing its potential, the developers got cracking on its spiritual successor, Dark Souls, which launched the sub-genre into the stratosphere. Even though the original Demon's Souls is a bit rough around the edges, it's apparent how this medieval marvel shaped the modern world of gaming.