10 Horror Video Games With Shocking Twist Endings

Yeah, you NEED to play The Sinking City.

Sinking city
Frogwares

There’s nothing quite like the feeling of thinking you have it all figured out, only to get to the end of a game and have that confidence snatched away and rubbed mercilessly in your face.

You thought you knew things? You fool!

It’s not essential to having a good experience of a game, to have a big twist at the end. Sometimes it can be just as satisfying to work things out and reach a resolution - or maybe even a cliffhanger. It is a bit of a treat, however, to be met with something so shocking and unexpected that you are sent flying back in your chair, reeling with the revelation.

Now, not all twists are created equal, some do nothing but confuse the story of a game and can leave you disappointed and frustrated. We have selected these ten as the cream of the crop, though- no disappointment here.

From classic villain reveals to mind-blowing, game-changing (literally) plot-twists, these games offer you a great selection of endings.

-

Note: Spoilers within!

10. Dead Space - Nicole Is Dead And Kendra Is A Traitor

Dead Space nicole
Electronic Arts

We’re going to start with a big one to get it out of the way. For those unfamiliar with the game, Dead Space follows the crew of the maintenance ship Kellion as they arrive on Aegis VII, a planet ravaged by a virus that reanimates corpses into zombie-like monsters called Necromorphs.

Protagonist Isaac wants to find out what has become of his girlfriend Nicole, as she was stationed there on another ship. Aegis VII is revealed to be the home of an alien Marker, the attempted weaponising of which was the cause of the Necromoph virus.

The main issue is choosing what to do with this Marker: it was previously bought about Nicole’s ship and indirectly caused the deaths of everyone aboard. Isaac intends to leave the marker on Aegis VII, but Kendra initiates the first of our big revelations: she is not just a simple computer technician, but works on behalf of the Earth Government, who demand that the Marker be brought to Earth.

With Nicole’s help, Isaac is able to thwart Kendra’s attempts to nick the Marker- only to have her drop another truth bomb. She reveals that Nicole has been dead all along: the Nicole that Isaac has been seeing, interacting with and at times even protecting from Necromorphs has been nothing more than a hallucination.

If you’re very observant then you may have been able to see this coming based on a few clues throughout the game, my favourite of which is that if you take the first letter from each of the chapter names, it literally spells out ‘NICOLE IS DEAD.’

Cheeky, that is.


9. Mad Father- Aya Follows In Her Dad's Footsteps

Mad Father Maria End
Active Gaming Media

Going a bit more obscure now we have Mad Father, an indie RPG released in 2012. The basic story follows a young girl, Aya, who tries to survive and escape her father’s house after finding out his intentions for her.

She is aware that he conducts experiments on human subjects in the basement, but when they escape one day it is revealed to her that he intends to kill and taxidermy her in order to keep her with him forever.

Basically her dad is a full blown psycho, even going so far as to kill Aya’s mother in the years prior out of fear that she would take Aya away from him.

As with most RPGs of its kind there are multiple endings, but if you play well and get the true ending then Aya’s real nature is revealed. After all the trauma and disgust in her childhood, finding out that her father was responsible for horrible mutilations and killings, apparently Aya isn’t deterred from a life of evil science but instead drawn to it!

Years later Aya runs a free surgery, offering medical assistance to anyone free of charge. We see her take in a poor woman and anaesthetise her, with her partner in crime (and also her dad’s former lover) Maria stating that Aya has followed in her father’s footsteps.

Combine this with the earlier showing that Aya’s dad’s surgical notebook survived the housefire, and we realise that she has become the very madman she earlier ran from: taking people off the street and murdering them on her surgical table.


8. Cry Of Fear - It Was All In His Head

Cry Of Fear
Team Psykskallar

Set in murky, grey Sweden, Cry of Fear starts with protagonist Simon awakening having been ploughed down by a car. He soon finds that he’s in the wrong part of town, with creepy, deformed monsters lurking around every corner.

As his adventure continues, Simon comes across Sophie, his childhood best friend and crush, and later a traitorous doctor. Depending on how you play, there are a few different specifics of how the ending can play out but the main reveal is this: that the whole traversal of the monster-infested town has been a figment of Simon’s imagination.

Having suffered life-changing injuries in a car-crash years earlier, Simon became deeply depressed and, on the advice of his therapist, began writing about his traumas in a book. The Simon we have been playing as is the fictional one from the writings, Sophie and the doctor are real people in his life (the latter being his therapist) and all the monsters represent Simon’s inner turmoils.

It’s basically one big psychotic episode, which makes it a bit better than the ‘it was all a dream’ trope but it’s still on thin ice.


7. The Sinking City - You Were Invited By An Evil Deity

the sinking city
Frogwares

Heading in for a bit of Lovecraftian horror now, we have The Sinking City. Our protagonist is Charles Winfield Reed, a private investigator who has been suffering with horrifying visions and nightmares ever since the war.

He receives an invitation from Johannes van der Berg, an intellectual in the town of Oakmont, to visit the town and uncover the cause behind his visions. Other people share the same ailment as him it seems, and most of them are in Oakmont. Eager to rid himself of his troubles, Reed goes along and, once there, is hired by a local to discover the cause of a serious flood that has caused havoc in the town.

As he uncovers the dark secrets of the town and those within it, it is revealed that the source of the flood isn’t just a result of poor city planning but rather an evil plot. Johannes van der Berg, the man who initially invited him, is revealed to be Hastur, a fellow of the monstrous entity Cthulhu. He invited Reed because his visions denote him as being one of the possible ‘chosen ones’ suitable for a ritual to reincarnate Cthulu.

What he had hoped was a place he could go to cure his ailments was instead a ploy to welcome in the apocalypse all along.


6. Stories Untold - It Was All A Trauma Trip

stories untold
Devolver Digital

The first chapter of Stories Untold consists of you playing as the unnamed player of another in-game game, set in a decrepit house and haunted by slowly surfacing memories, nasty notes and unplaceable anger.

Secondly, you play as a Mr. Aiton, conducting experiments on an artifact from a crash-site. The artifact appears sentient and, after establishing a connection with Aiton, communicates with his colleague (Dr Alexander) through another in-game game.

In the third chapter you play as James, a scientist in the arctic. A series of problems with communications lead James outside, where he attempts to fix a transmitter whilst other arctic stations command him to ‘wake up’.

See where this is going yet?

The final episode sees you play as James Aiton (a combination of the two player names we got before). It is revealed that Aiton has been in a coma following an accident and his memories need to be recovered; with the help of Dr Alexander and several of the settings and items from the previous chapters the full story is revealed.

Following a party, James drove drunk with his sister in the car and got into a collision. This resulted in his sister’s death, and he attempted to frame another driver for causing the incident. The previous episodes were projections of Aiton’s guilt, and the final chapter is the recollection of the truth being recorded by his doctor.


5. Resident Evil - Wesker Is Working For Umbrella

Resident Evil Wesker
Capcom

Back to another big one now we have the first Resident Evil game. You play as a member of the Alpha Team, sent to investigate some strange murders that have been occurring on the outskirts of Raccoon City, alongside a few others including Albert Wesker, the head of the team.

You learn on your journey that illegal experimentation is being supported by the Umbrella Corporation and carried out by a secret group, and that it is this experimentation that has created the monsters you encounter.

At points you can encounter members of the Bravo Team you were sent to find, including their captain who warns you that a member of your crew is a traitor. By the time you find the underground lab housing the experiments, Wesker reveals to you that he is a double agent and is intending to use the products of the experiments for his own gain.

To be fair, even with prior warning it is a nice twist. The focus of the game isn’t exactly to be Sherlock Holmes and find out the mole, most of the time you’re too busy focusing on just surviving!


4. Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly - The Twins' Fates Are Reversed

Fatal Frame II
Tecmo

This particular twist is a good one because it’s something quite different. There’s no double-agent enemy reveal, no revolutionary dream sequence- Tecmo really thought outside the box for this one.

Not directly related to the first Fatal Frame game, Crimson Butterfly follows twins Mio and Mayu as they find themselves in trouble with a dead town and a failed ritual. They learned that the town was swallowed by an abyss when they failed to complete a ritual, in which the younger of a pair of twins born in the town must be sacrificed to sate it.

The implied fate of the girls throughout is that Mio, the younger of the twins, is destined to die and complete the ritual. However, nearing the end of the game it is revealed that in the town the idea of an ‘older and younger’ twin is reversed: the ‘younger’ twin is thought to be the one who is born first, as the ‘older’ twin allows them to do so because they are weaker.

This reverses their destinies, so that Mayu is now the ‘younger’ twin and the one destined to die. There are multiple endings to the game but the ‘true’ ending is confirmed in the next game as being the one where the twins complete the ritual and, with their new-found knowledge, Mio kills her twin and fulfils the ritual.


3. Bioshock - You've Been Hypnotised

Bioshock would you kindly
2K Games

When the pieces all fall into place for Bioshock’s big reveal, it really is something to behold.

On arriving in the sunken city of Rapture, things seem to be totally ruined. There are evil Splicers running about, no civilised society remains and the whole place is in ruins- so thank goodness Atlas is there to help guide you!

After being in contact with the mysterious Atlas throughout the game, steering you through the dangers of fallen Rapture, by the time player-character Jack clocks that something is wrong things have already gone too far.

After being compelled to kill Rapture’s creator, Andrew Ryan, when he requests “would you kindly” do so, Jack connects the dots. He realises that the phrase has been the opener for many of Atlas’ requests and commands, and that it is acting as a trigger for a sort of hypnotic obedience state.

Atlas is no simple ally, and Jack has been brainwashed even before the start of the game. It makes for an amazing reveal when you consider that so much of Jack’s supposed free-will has been completely controlled by Atlas (or as it turns out, Fontaine) for his own means.


2. Silent Hill 2 - James Killed His Own Wife

Silent Hill 2 Ending
Konami

The Silent Hill franchise is certainly amongst some of the most well-known names in the horror game genre. Its second instalment first came out in 2001, following our player-character James Sunderland’s adventure to Silent Hill when he receives a letter from his dead wife (Mary) asking him to meet her there.

On his search for Mary, he encounters other traumatised people around the town and a small variety of hideous monsters. Eventually James finds a tape that shows him euthanising his wife, and the letter he supposedly received from her becomes a blank piece of paper.

He realises at this point that all the monsters he is seeing are products of his own mind, punishing him for killing his wife. Furthermore Maria, the doppelganger of Mary, must be slain again and again to make him relive the painful experience of seeing his wife die. James is the bad guy in his own story, and his trip to Silent Hill is a pilgrimage of repentance.


1. The Witch's House - The Witchy Switcheroo

The Witch's House end
GOODROID

Finishing strong we have this puzzle-based horror from 2012. The game begins as a young girl, Viola, wakes up in the middle of the woods. The only sign of civilisation around is a large house, which she must approach and enter- only to find herself locked inside.

Through finding various clues, you uncover that the house was inhabited by a witch named Ellen. Ellen was a sick child whose parents neglected her, so eventually she killed her parents and made a deal with a demon that transformed her into a witch. The demon promised to heal her of her sickness if she fed him enough souls.

After eventually gaining an item that allows you to burn through the thick rosebushes keeping you trapped in the forest, however on enacting this the true nature of your player-character is revealed. Prior to the start of the game, Ellen forced Viola to swap bodies with her, hence giving herself a vessel free of disease. Throughout the game, when playing as ‘Viola’ escaping the witch we were in reality playing as the witch inside Viola’s body, as Viola’s spirit inside the witch’s old vessel attempted to trap us in the house to get back her body.

In the end, Viola’s dad comes to rescue his daughter, completely unaware that the girl he is taking home is inhabited with the witch’s spirit, and that his real daughter (trapped in a sickly body) has been duped and left to die. It is a bit crushing because after the real Viola (stuck in the witch’s body) is not recognised by her own dad she can die of despair, but nobody could claim that it doesn’t make for a fantastic twist ending.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's shortest contributor (probably). Lover of cats, baked goods and Netflix Originals.