10 Ill-Fated Choices That Wrecked Video Games Instantly
Just one bad decision can destroy a gaming company - but which ones did the most damage?
We love to pile on a gaming corporation or two when they make a massive blunder these days, but what happens when a company makes a choice so horrendous, it devastates their reputation and releases for years to come?
The gaming industry has been known to make some utterly baffling decisions over the years, including many that have lingered on decades after they were made. From the disaster of Atari's abysmal E.T in 1983 that practically killed the entire market to the modern onset of crunch in the biggest developers, it seems one of our favourite hobbies is never too far from controversy. It could be a console, game or an entire company going down in flames due to the actions of a few individuals that live in infamy.
Some decisions ruined entire games based on a number of major changes, others utterly killed the momentum of a company that had previously been doing so well. Getting into the list from the 1990s to the present, let's take a look back at some of the biggest - and most costly - mistakes made in gaming history.
10. Microsoft: Making Kinect And Forcing It Into The Xbox Brand
It's hard to deny that this generation, Microsoft has been on a losing streak with the Xbox brand. Despite improving their horrid leadership and providing better value with backwards compatibility and Xbox Game Pass, the Xbox One has fallen foul of failing exclusives and the fallout from a terrible launch. Most would say the decline of Xbox began in 2013 with the bland and tone-deaf console reveal, but it really began three years earlier.
I'm talking about the Microsoft Kinect, a now infamous peripheral that snatched the company away from their loyal fanbase and tossed them into useless gimmick-chasing garbage. The gaming community couldn't believe their eyes as humiliating E3 conferences, awful motion controlled titles and baffling decisions piled up. Star Wars: Kinect, Steel Battalion: Heavy Armour and Fighters Uncaged were just some of the many titles that proved how unresponsive and irritating the camera really was. Laughing it's way to the bank, Microsoft continued to force the device down people's throats as their exclusive line-up began to suffer.
Kinect ultimately became a ball-and-chain tied around the console's ankle that held the Xbox brand back. After years of angry backlash, Microsoft finally relented in 2014, releasing an Xbox One without Kinect and the device was abandoned quickly, causing Microsoft to slowly phase out support and discontinue it completely as of January 2018. While it may have scooped a high profit for the company, the Kinect remains a defining feature of Xbox's fall from grace over the last decade.
9. Nintendo: Using The Name "Wii U"
Following their smashing return to the top spot with the Wii, Nintendo set about making their next system using feedback as their guiding force. Getting millions of people into gaming was its biggest success, but the motion controlled system also faced criticism for its weaker processing power, limited online functions and lacklustre third party software line-up. Naturally, Nintendo sought to improve on these shortcomings but difficult times were ahead.
The fateful day came at E3 2011, where "Project Cafe" was revealed as the Wii U. Seemingly an omen for things to come, Nintendo's stock fell 10% with critics pointing out that even with improved graphics, the console was still lagging behind its competitors. The bigger problem with the system was the name itself; most consumers just didn't know what to make of the Wii U. Was it a tablet accessory for the Wii or a completely new system? By not being specific with its marketing, Nintendo was setting itself up for a major crisis in 2012.
What followed was what many fans refer to as the "dark age of Nintendo"; dismal console sales, a lack of quality titles and continued disappointment from the fanbase. The five years between 2012 and 2017 were rough for the company and it all came down to a badly thought out console title. Third party publishers began to drop their support, retailers like Asda refused to sell the system and the Wii U finished up as one of the worst-selling projects in Nintendo's history.
8. Sony: Pricing The PlayStation 3 At "599 US Dollars"
If Microsoft's decline has spanned the last decade and Nintendo's ran from 2012 to 2017, Sony's darkest hour ran from 2005 to 2008. Fresh off their wild success with the PlayStation 2 (which remains the highest selling console of all time), the company got cocky and greedy. They poured a ton of cash into creating a new cell processor for their next system, intent on making the most powerful console on the market. All this effort poured into technology distracted from what really mattered: games. At E3 2006, Sony's pompous attitude was put on full display to the gaming community.
At the drab and dismal press conference, Kaz Hirai took the stage and said the infamous line: "It requires a huge financial investment; 599 US dollars, but we must take risks to reap the rewards". In one fateful move, Sony had put a sizeable amount of gamers off the PlayStation 3 and branded themselves as an arrogant company in the process. The internet was quick to ridicule both them and the system no end, the phrase quickly reaching memeable status across the community.
As the PS3 came out of the gate struggling against the Xbox 360 and Nintendo Wii, this moment would continue to stick out more than the console's lacklustre line-up of games and reliance on gimmicks. Eventually in 2008, Sony dropped the price and the exclusive titles finally started to deliver, but the crippling error remains etched in gamer's minds.
7. SOE And Lucasarts: The NGE Update For Star Wars Galaxies
At the turn of the millennium, the very first MMO taking place in a galaxy far, far away began to take shape. Star Wars Galaxies from Sony Online Entertainment and Lucasarts became one of the most popular online multiplayer titles upon its 2003 release with an online community 400,000 strong. Opening its gates under the title "An Empire Divided" and following up with two expansions, the game appeared to be a success. But when tasked with evolving to keep pace with the competition, Galaxies suffered an epic collapse.
Released on November 8th 2005, the New Game Enhancements (or NGE) massively altered how players created and grew their character. Streamlining and neutering the gameplay was bad enough but the worst change lay at the character creation screen. Hardcore fans were horrified to learn that being a Jedi in Galaxies was available from the start, effectively negating hours of hard work. Previously, becoming a Jedi was an achievement that certainly gave players a true sense of pride and accomplishment, requiring them to discover specific actions to unlock a force-sensitive ability slot. Among the community, these rare characters were often revered.
An enraged player-base started to abandon Star Wars: Galaxies in droves. The developers desperately tried to bring back some older features to salvage the community, but it was too late. Galaxies would never recover and was eventually shut down in 2011, replaced by Bioware's Star Wars: The Old Republic. Effectively killed off with just one update, few MMOs have collapsed so spectacularly as Galaxies.
6. Ion Storm: The Making And Release Of Daikatana
Picture the scenario. You're John Romero, one of the pioneering minds behind the first-person-shooter genre. You go on to found the underrated Ion Storm with free rein. What do you do?
Grow a massive ego, over-hype your next release and doom the very company you created.
This is the sad tale of Daikatana, an almighty bomb that disgraced its first person shooter lineage when it was released in 1998. As Ion Storm's second title, the game is a textbook example of negligence and disappointment.
The antics of its creator were already a warning sign, as John boasted about the game constantly, taking advantage of his status in the gaming industry to up the game's chances of success. With Romero and the lead developers placed front and centre, working culture within the company began to degrade and this dropped to its worst level when the infamous and controversial advertisement for Daikatana came out in the press. "John Romero's about to make you his b*tch" is a laughably bad moment in gaming history, one that portrayed Ion Storm in a bad light and set the stage for the title's launch.
Selling a pitiful 8,190 units in the US, the game was a miserable failure. Romero has since apologised for his behaviour but, Daikatana is still considered one of the worst games ever made. Despite making the seminal Deus Ex (Helmed by Warren Spector, not Romero) the developer never really recovered financially. Many lamented Ion Storm's demise in 2005, who never reached their full potential.
5. Realtime Worlds: Overzealous Ambition With APB: All Points Bulletin
Game director David Jones is best known for founding DMA Design (now known as Rockstar North) and creating Grand Theft Auto back in 1997 . Beating his former studio to the punch, Crackdown became more than just a ticket to the Halo 3 beta in 2007; it was a fan favourite that both spawned a franchise and proved the developers had a strong eye for open world design.
Their next game was hailed as one David Jones had wanted to make for over fifteen years: a massively multiplayer online role playing title featuring warring gang factions. A whopping one hundred million dollars was poured into development on the ambitious project. When the game finally arrived in 2010, reviewers certainly weren't kind to it and the player population failed to grow at a rate Jones and his team were hoping for. Forced to sell off the APB licence, Realtime Worlds bled out and filed for bankruptcy in August 2010 just a few months after the game launched.
David Jones wouldn't make another game again until 2019's Crackdown 3. What's so disappointing about APB's failure and the subsequent demise of Realtime Worlds was the potential they both had. With a wealth of expertise and good reception under their belt, All Points Bulletin could have expanded on the MMO formula to deliver a setting and gameplay formula that diverged from the typical fantasy contemporaries of its day. But by over-extending and not tuning the fine details, Realtime Worlds abruptly collapsed, leaving the APB license behind.
4. 38 Studios: Taking Out A Loan In Rhode Island For Kingdoms Of Amalur: Reckoning
The Boston based 38 Studios was founded by Curt Schilling with relatively humble beginnings. While he originally wanted to make an MMO named Project Copernicus, the studio eventually settled on the well received if poor-selling Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning, a fantasy RPG published by EA. What followed was a wild saga of mismanagement, beginning with 38's relocation to Rhode Island in April 2011.
To fund development and also provide jobs to the US state, Schilling asked for a $75 million loan guarantee from the Rhode Island government. With the cash in hand, the studio went on a hiring spree. They even bought out fellow developer Big Huge Games and costs quickly began to stack up, particularly with its MMO ambitions being so expensive. 38 Studios began to run out of money close to Kingdoms of Amalur's release in February 2012. When sales failed to catch on, falling well short of the three million break-even mark, things got ugly. Developers went unpaid and concerns mounted.
When the final result had been tallied, 38 Studios owed $150 million in debt and closed its doors in June 2012, cancelling the MMO they were working on in the process. The foolish borrowing didn't just wreck the livelihoods of studio staff at 38, it also bled over into the Rhode Island government. Millions went down the drain and Curt Schilling was sued by the state, repaying $61 million. 38 Studios remains one of the most prominent gaming failures in recent memory.
3. Maxis And EA: Planting Always-Online Features Into The 2013 SimCity
Founded in 1987 by industry pioneer Will Wright, Maxis set the blueprint for city builders that still holds strong to this day. With multiple franchises and sequels, the wider series took the crown as the king of the simulation genre. Their acquisition by Electronic Arts in 1997 paved the way for The Sims to reach the masses throughout the 2000s.
While they had hit a few snags with a lukewarm reception to Spore in 2008, Maxis generally hadn't had too many missteps. That changed in the 2010s. When the company announced a new SimCity on new hardware, fans were naturally excited to see a modern update. They eagerly booted up the new game in March 2013, only to slam into a brick-wall; the game depended on an always-online system. On top of egregious server issues, a wave of outrage swept through the gaming community. It was an utterly baffling decision; who buys SimCity to play online constantly? The backlash grew fierce as review bombs and bitter rants quickly overran the title.
As a result, the Maxis Emeryville studio was closed by EA in March 2015, effectively downgrading the influential developer to lower status. Since the failure of 2013's SimCity, the once proud series (and the studio that created it) has been relegated to the mobile gaming scene, with SimCity Build-It released in 2014. Two years later, it would be surpassed by Colossal Order's Cities: Skylines, a title that gained high recognition for filling the gap SimCity left behind.
2. SEGA: Rushing Sonic The Hedgehog For The Franchise's 15th Anniversary
Sonic the Hedgehog was already on a losing streak in the early 2000s. After going multi-platform following the departure of the Dreamcast, SEGA and Sonic Team promised that their most popular character would return to greatness. Again and again, this failed to pass, with 3D titles slowly dragging the super-fast hedgehog to oblivion. The killing blow would come in 2006, Sonic's 15th anniversary.
Sonic 06 is notorious for being one of the most universally despised games ever made. Broken gameplay, a pathetic story, heaps of technical issues and intrusive loading screens are just some of the problems that made their way into its November 2006 release. SEGA required the game to be released in time for Sonic's special occasion, while splitting the team to work on the Wii title "Sonic and the Secret Rings". Instead of giving the team another year or so to polish the game, 06 was forced out the door and was subsequently ravaged by critics and gamers alike, a trend that would continue in the years ahead.
What SEGA didn't realise in 2006 was just how catastrophically damaging the game would be. The character has been trapped in a seemingly endless cycle of failed ideas and fan frustrations. While Sonic Generations and Sonic Mania were quality titles, they can't quite make up for the franchise's fall from grace. As the character struggles to overcome mediocrity, Sonic 06 was more than a failure; it was a crushing blow that still afflicts the character to this day.
1. THQ: Investing In The Udraw Game Tablet
With a wide range of games published under their banner, THQ once stood as a bastion of the middle market title. The publisher also tried their hand at capitalising on changes in gaming audiences. Conceived as a console accessory, the uDraw gaming tablet aimed to add a bit more interactivity and creativity to the gaming experience with specific titles.
Boasting a simple and straightforward user interface, many pundits agreed it would make a strong complement to Nintendo's system. It did well enough at first, selling one million units on the Wii.
What seemed like a reasonable idea at first quickly turned into a bargain bin bust as the accessory had no hope of cracking the hardcore console market. Despite a big marketing push for its second holiday season, gamers simply weren't interested in the device. The fact that it only worked with a limited range of games didn't help either.
The damage the uDraw tablet did to THQ is truly staggering; forced to cease production in February 2012, the unravelling was swift. While the Wii was a worthwhile install base for the tablet, the move towards PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360 was a calamitous decision that cost THQ dearly. An eye-watering 1.6 million units sat in the company's inventory collecting dust, generating a revenue shortfall of around 100 million dollars. It was a major factor that contributed to their bankruptcy in December 2012. The way one peripheral dragged down an entire publisher after twenty-two years in the business still looms large.