10 Impossible Video Game Side-Quests That Cost You 100%

200 correct button presses in a row, anyone??

Final fantasy X
Square Enix

Side quests should be designed to offer more to a video game. They give us more reasons to spend time in its world and breathe in that extra lore and, of course, pick up bonus loot. The best side quests can be swift and a fun twist on the formula or, on the other end of the spectrum completely, be lengthy and rewarding in a deeper way.

Some may say side quests are totally optional content and that is technically true. But games that know how to use their side quests well just feel like more complete and enveloping experiences, that warm players to the idea of gunning for that 100% trophy.

As stories off the beaten path, there's certainly more space for experimentation and less time for testing. Because the focus is and should be on the main story of a title; sometimes side quests wind up buggy, unbalanced or just outright far too long.

This list will take a look at side quests that were broken, unfair or confusing. Perhaps more time and attention should've been taken or considered on this so-called optional content, because it stopped many players from completing everything the game had to offer.

10. Flying Rats - Grand Theft Auto IV

GTA 4 pigeons
Rockstar

In every Grand Theft Auto game there’s always “that one side quest” that you don’t want to do. In GTA IV, it’s bound to be shooting the 200 pigeons located all over Liberty City, which is the number of hidden packages in Vice City and graffiti tags in San Andreas combined.

Even spotting them at all with a guide can be tricky as GTA IV is not the most colourful or eye-catching game so it’s easy to miss a grey pigeon in the very grey Liberty City. And with a list of 200, you’re bound to make a mistake when working your way through it.

There’s nothing quite like spending hours tracking down collectibles and not knowing which single one you missed, prompting you to do the entire list again - or throw your controller at the screen, whatever happens first.

To make this side mission even more time consuming is the fact that firing weapons on city streets will, naturally often incur the wrath of the local PD.

Shooting all 200 pigeons gets you the game’s best helicopter on the MeTV skyscraper, but it rarely spawns if you use the window washing platform to reach the top. Meaning in order to use your helicopter, you may need a helicopter to get there which… puts the hours you spent to get the reward into a humbling perspective.


9. Swabbing Duty - World Of Warcraft

world of warcraft swabbing decks
Blizzard

An MMO is what you make of it; you can choose to pursue the main path, the minor quest lines or nothing at all if that makes you happy. Some players, the most hardcore of the bunch, will do their best to fulfill as many good deeds as possible.

With role playing games, sometimes overcoming a challenge is merely about grinding out some more experience, getting a few more levels on your character and coming back to it stronger. Whilst World of Warcraft has plenty of difficult quests, it’s the inability to use this approach that makes Swabbing Duty the most distressing of all.

Rushing around a pirate ship cleaning back stains that almost immediately respawn is so outside of the usual RPG skill set anyway but the twitch timing Swabbing Duty demands means that if your connection isn’t strong enough you don’t stand a chance. Players have created keyboard bindings and macros, and even then reportedly spent hours or even days trying to beat this impossible task.

Imagine their embarrassment finding out that a particular crew mate, when spoken to, will do it for you for 1GP. Whilst you should be proud if you managed this yourself, there’s no harm in cheating this one so you can move on with your life.


8. Old School Ghoul - Fallout New Vegas

Fallout New Vegas Raul
Bethesda

Journeying into a new part of the map and getting your head kicked in is an effective way for a game to shuffle the player in a particular direction and teach them not to stray too far, too soon. It was true of 1987’s original Final Fantasy and it’s still seen today in open-world titles.

Wandering too close to Black Mountain in Fallout New Vegas will prompt a new quest line but chances are the Super Mutants in the area will make you turn tail and run. That’s fine, right? After all, there’s lots more to do and see and the beauty of a game like Fallout is the ability to work through the game’s content as a player sees fit. Therein, however, lies the problem.

Ghoul mechanic Raul can be found in Black Mountain. Like other companions, Raul has a couple of quests tied to his story but when the game launched players had issues launching Old School Ghoul.

Having journeyed through the world beforehand, speaking to specific NPCs previously would cause a bug where this quest wouldn’t start. Raul, who it turns out is some kind of prima donna, wouldn’t engage in conversation with certain characters if the player had already spoken to them.

It was like being punished for exploring the game and, despite a major patch, players still report issues with this quest line today.


7. Jump Rope Genius And Hero Of The Beach - Super Mario Odyssey

Mario Odyssey Jump Rope
Nintendo

Typically, the hardest optional quests in video games tend to involve late-game trials and boss fights that test your mettle. It’s not usually simple sports mini-games that cause players to rip their hair out.

In Super Mario Odyssey's Metro Kingdom, players can find a park and play a jump rope game to grab two of the game’s Power Moons. What makes Jump Rope Genius' demand for 100 perfectly timed jumps particularly difficult is that the game starts off slow and gets faster over time, causing players to carefully shift speed. One mistake and you’re back to that slow start again.

Forget the likes of Bowser, players had more trouble with a skipping rope. When the game released, gamers found any way they could cheat the system after spending so long trying and failing to tick this off their checklist.

Things get perhaps even worse at the later Beach Kingdom of the game, where there are two Power Moons associated with the beach volleyball mini-game where you have to return the ball 100 times. This is so notoriously hard that the accepted strategy is playing in two-player mode so that someone can help as Mario’s new friend Cappy.

With over 800 Power Moons to collect, it’s embarrassing and all too likely that the few short of your 100% run could well be these unreasonably hard mini-games.


6. No Stone Unturned - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

Skyrim Stone of Barenziah unusual gem
Bethesda

What induces a sense of trepidation with collectibles isn’t always the number. Sure, 420 flags in the first Assassin’s Creed is definitely its own beast but something with simply 24 can be just as unobtainable. At least most open world games will mark collectibles on the map…

In Skyrim, picking up your first unusual gem starts off a quest for the Thieves Guild. The Stones of Barenziah are important to them, as gemstones once a part of a crown. The Dragonborn is then tasked with tracking them all down, with no information to go on beyond that.

Skryim is not exactly a small map but more than size it’s got lots of places to explore, investigate and inspect. What are the chances you put over a hundred hours into the game and manage to find all 24 stones? Pretty low, particularly since a few of them appear in areas you can only access a handful of times.

The reward isn’t even worth it anyway as it merely increases the chance of finding gemstones. Since any players who managed to do this without a guide will have done so by checking out every nook and cranny of the world, you’re likely to already be pretty minted.

Then again it may be worth finishing once you’ve started just to make inventory space, since the Stones of Barenziah don’t even stack. Rude.


5. The 1000th Lum - Rayman 2: The Great Escape

Rayman 2 Lum
Ubi Soft

According to Rayman lore, the fairy-like Lum represent the Knowledge of the World which is why Rayman 2’s antagonist Admiral Razorbread eats one. In humorous, almost fourth-wall breaking fashion, players watch the heads-up display of total Lums decrease from 1000 to 999.

Thus, Rayman must now journey through the world to grab the rest. Filling the counter of 999 Lums isn’t too bad but most players didn’t realise that there was, in fact, a final 1000th collectible.

In the Tomb of the Ancients stage, there is a hidden recess in a wall which takes players to a secret area with a giant stone skull and the 1000th Lum.

However, if you happen to be playing the Nintendo 3DS port, getting that secret Lum is an experience that is marred by glitches. The spider web that should bounce you into the skull’s eye-socket does no such thing so players have to use the tiny spiders crawling on the skull to take damage, hoping that it throws Rayman high enough to reach the ledge. Once inside, the Lum is there for the taking - however the game will softlock as Rayman touches back down onto the ground.

It is possible to grab the Lum, pause and exit the stage to keep it but not only does that require good timing but the ability to maintain your cool after struggling to get it in the first place.


4. The Nintendo Gallery - The Legend Of Zelda: Wind Waker

Wind Waker nintendo gallery
Nintendo

Whilst Wind Waker is a bright, colourful and beautiful affair it surely has some downright long-winded and frustrating parts. Locating the pieces of the Triforce sunken into the great sea is one thing but that fails in comparison to collecting the figurines.

Carlov and his Nintendo Gallery reside on a small island tucked away near Forest Haven. Showing him a full colour photo taken on Link’s Deluxe Picto Box of one of the game’s many enemies or characters means that Carlov can construct an appropriate figurine. That sounds like a nice chilled little collectible… but it’s the numbers that make it truly daunting.

There’s 134 figurines to collect. The Picto Box only holds three photos at a time. And for every statue that Carlov makes takes a whole day which means frequent use of the Song of Passing to speed up time.

If that doesn’t sound like enough of a time-sink, there are a handful of pictographs that can only be taken at just one point in the game. Missing these ultimately means doing yet another playthrough of the entire quest just to snap a good picture of your missing model.

So brutal was this side quest that it was one of a few things heavily tweaked when bringing the game to the Wii U with the HD version, but it’s still something most players will avoid.


3. Venus Sigil - Final Fantasy X

Final Fantasy X Thunder Plains
Square Enix

Getting the ultimate weapons for your party of characters in an RPG should by no means be an easy feat but many players have a serious bone to pick with Final Fantasy X over its side quest choices.

Not merely content with making you find the weapons themselves, FF10 requires crests and sigils to unlock each weapon’s potential.

Perhaps the worst offender is the Venus Sigil which unlocks the power of Lulu’s Onion Knight doll. Players are required to go to Thunder Plains, the land of perpetual storm, and stand around avoiding being struck by electricity.

Looking out for the lightning flash is your prompt to move and you’ll need to be eagle-eyed and quick on the draw. Not only do you need to avoid 200 bolts of lightning, it needs to be consecutive.

Eventually, if you’re playing a later release, an achievement will pop up to let you know that you’ve done it correctly. However, on the PS2 version, there’s no way of knowing without diligently counting every correct dodge as the game doesn’t do it for you.

If you lose count, do you start again? Or just keep going and hope you do over 200 before you leave? These are the things that keep players up at night… or drive them away from collecting the celestial weapon at all.


2. Ranni’s Quest - Elden Ring

Elden Ring Ranni
FromSoftware

Elden Ring is very much about trusting your instincts at times and Ranni’s quest is an adventure all on its own in the truest sense. It’s easy to get lost along its very vague and very varied list of objectives, locations and numerous boss fights.

Even getting an audience with Ranni is a process of elimination for some players as there’s a handful of reasons why this quest line might not open up, ranging from talking to a certain NPC or performing a ritual of absolution.

To start, Ranni requests the Fingerslayer Blade which is obtained by slaying Radahn and journeying into Nokron. From here begins a long and arduous journey that pits the player against multiple bosses and brings them through many different locations, some of which are notoriously difficult.

Getting through Carian Study Hall means fighting or avoiding the notorious Preceptor Miriam and a particularly challenging moment finds the player battling The Baleful Shadow and then immediately trudging through everyone’s favourite Lake of Rot. And it’s not just brawn either, don’t forget the pure guesswork of repeatedly talking to a doll of Rannie until she gives up more information.

At the very least this often unfinished quest line does have a great reward, allowing players a true treat of an alternate ending for the game.


1. The Pac-Man Quest - Baten Kaitos Origins

Baten Kaitos Origins
Namco

Many players of this 2006 GameCube RPG may have an unspoken agreement that it doesn’t count, but there’s no getting around the fact that most players have not and will never get 100% in Baten Kaitos Origins.

In the world of Baten Kaitos, a Magnus is an item that can absorb the essence of other things such as weapons or magic and this lays the groundwork for the game’s card-based battle system. One particular Magnus is quite literally Bandai-Namco’s Pac-Man… and he’s never been hungrier. To complete the Pac-Man quest, players must feed him every other quest-based magnus in the game.

Basically this side mission, which will take longer than every other quest in the game combined, requires players to use up every major collectible they can obtain. The issue here is you can’t afford to overlook a single one; which means making sure to grab the few that are totally missable, cultivate the handful that take 30 real-world hours to grow and give up the best weapon in the game in order to satisfy Pac-Man’s insatiable hunger.

Baten Kaitos Origins has no way of telling you which of the 222 Magnus you’ve offered up already, so you better have your own checklist handy. Is it worth it in the end? Well, you get permanent critical hits… in a game you’ll almost certainly never want to play again, after all that.


Watch Next


Contributor

Coming from a content creation background that now spans over two decades, Psy cut her teeth on personal video production and community radio. Originally joining the team as a writer and presenter, she added video editing duties to her responsibilities over time and became the longest-standing editor of the irreverent gaming show Tues Your Own Adventure. Psy has worked on many previews and reviews, long-form editorials (either her own, or supporting as an editor), as a frequent quizmaster and more. Praised for the two-pronged attack of her hard work ethic and light-hearted editing style, Psy is otherwise known as a font of retro video game knowledge which has caused her to rack up many gaming quiz wins. Outside of WhatCulture, Psy runs First Aid Spray Podcast - a long-running channel that focuses on Resident Evil in all of it's forms. You can follow her on BlueSky at http://psywhite.bsky.social and Instagram at http://instagram.com/therealpsywhite