10 INCREDIBLE Indie Horror Games You Need To See
2023 horror is next-level essential.
The horror video game genre is extensive, to say the least. While everyone knows about Silent Hill, Resident Evil, and Dead Space, there are loads of excellent smaller titles that get lost in the tide of new releases.
While video games being more popular than ever and dozens of games hitting storefronts everyday is a great thing for players, it means it’s almost impossible to stay on top of every great thing coming out. Even if you’re a niche genre fan. In light of that, we’ve made a list of a bunch of excellent indie horror games that were released to little or no fanfare to try and help you out.
While of course naturally all of these games have been played by somebody, almost all of them have flown so far under the radar that they’re sorely under-appreciated by most so we’re going to go ahead with our mild exaggeration title and say nobody played them.
That said, if you’ve played any of these or know any even more underrated indie horror classics please let us know in the comments.
--
10. Exhibit Of Sorrows
Kicking off with a truly bizarre entry we’ve got the spooky adventure Exhibit of Sorrows by a day of joy.
This horror game is playable for free right from your browser and proof that excellent things do come in small packages.
It’s fairly nontraditional in structure and genre. You’ll navigate back and forth through exhibits in an exhibition entitled the Exhibit of Smiles. Naturally things go sideways incredibly quickly and although it’s all over in about twenty minutes it is deeply disturbing, especially if you’re unsettled by body horror, torture, or spooky clowns. There’s a lot of spooky clowns.
Personally, I’m not fussed with scary clowns but the themes and amount of pain you have to inflict on the characters to get through this one had me legitimately queasy.
This one is super easy to have missed if you didn’t hear about it through word of mouth so if you’re a fan of a free fright, you ought to check it out for yourself. Just don’t say I didn’t warn you.
9. Duck Season
Duck Season was released in 2017 by Stress Level Zero, which, can we just say, is a hilarious name for a company that makes virtual reality horror games.
And that’s exactly what Duck Season is, a VR horror game designed to bring you back to the late 80s, the insinuation being that your Mum was supposed to buy you Duck Hunt and instead you ended up with this hellscape where everything is wrong. At least you can shoot the dog in this one, it’s an improvement in that way. Everything starts off fine and dandy albeit with a twisted version of Duck Hunt but once you see that the dog is clearly a man in a suit or an animatronic giving serious Five Nights at Freddy’s vibes it's clear nothing is chill here.
On top of that, plenty of Steam reviews have claimed they refunded it because it’s too scary.
You’re unlikely to have played this one because of the double whammy of it being both an indie release on Steam and a VR game but as of 2019 it came out as a non-VR Steam version so you can check that out if you like the sound of it but don’t have a VR headset. It’s a clever spin on a classic with a bunch of disturbing lore and seven different endings so there’s a lot in there.
8. Faith: The Unholy Trinity
Admittedly we’re getting a touch more popular with this one but we’re still firmly in indie territory and this one is just too good not to talk about.
Faith: The Unholy Trinity is a pixel horror game inspired by both the era of retro 8-bit games and the Satanic Scare of the 1980s which is really quite a combo. You play as a priest investigating a case of demonic possession that goes about as well as these things ever do which is to say, poorly. You’ll perform exorcisms, cleanse haunted items, and explore the underbelly of a Satanic cult in a medley of creepy settings.
The game also utilises rotoscoping to deliver some truly terrifying scares.
The retro look and sound works perfectly to build an atmosphere of total unease and dread as you make your way through each chapter of the story. The aesthetics are as fascinatingly unique as they are horrifying and enough can’t be said about the stellar soundtrack and hugely disturbing warped sound effects. There are also loads of secrets to be found if you’re brave enough to look for them.
7. At Dead Of Night
Another horrifying game that’s admittedly a touch more popular than the others on this list and yet another hilariously out of place developer name, we’ve got At Dead of Night by Baggy Cat Ltd.
This 2020 horror game is particularly unique as it blends elements of ghost hunting games, traditional horror, and horror movies by way of FMV. The reason I say it’s a touch more popular is that a lot of YouTubers and streamers were playing it for a while there so it may have ended up on your radar, though there’s a decent chance you never picked it up yourself for the sheer reason that this game looks wear-the-brown-pants scary. You play as Maya, a student trapped in a haunted hotel run by a psychopath and, you know, none of that is good.
You’ll need to deep dive into killer Johnny’s past using a ghost & spirit voice receiver and digging around the hotel to try and unveil his dark secret and rescue your friends all the while trying not to get murdered.
I’ll be honest, my heart rate got too high just watching the trailer for this one but if you can handle it or you’ve played it already, let the rest of us know how tough you are in the comment box.
6. The Closing Shift
There’s plenty of great Western horror but I think a lot of us can agree that nobody does horror quite the same as Japanese horror offerings and The Closing Shift by Chilla’s Art is a perfect example.
Slipping well under the radar when it was released toward the beginning of 2022, this spooky adventure pops you in the unfortunate shoes of a waitress working the titular closing shifts at a cafe. There is an optional VHS filter that makes everything look shaky and even more horrifying if somehow this game isn’t scary enough for you. It’s relatively short, clocking in at around two hours during which you’ll hustle around the cafe while gradually realising you’re being stalked. There are a handful of unsettling jumpscares, the graphics vary between genuinely realistic and horrifying character models, and there are a bunch of endings to achieve. Spoiler alert, they mostly don’t end well.
There’s also the added horror of working customer service which honestly might be worse than the whole stalking thing, we’re not sure.
5. From The Darkness
There’s more than one game on this list where it seems like you’re alone but you’re definitely not and the 2021 psychological horror game From The Darkness by N4bA is absolutely one of those. Known only for a small handful of indie horror games, this studio has crafted a superbly uncomfortable exploration adventure where you’re inside an old Soviet apartment that once belonged to your grandfather.
And you’re in the dark. Because of course you are.
The apartment is horrifying in and of itself and not just because it’d still run you a million dollars to buy the decrepit piece of crap in Sydney, Australia. It comes packed with creepy dolls, rotting wallpaper, and something crawling around in the dark watching you. There are a handful of really good jumpscares, light puzzling, and it's a genuinely frightening and relentlessly tense trip throughout.
It’ll only take you an hour or two to knock over but since you’ll be white-knuckling it that whole time you might find that’s for the best.
4. The Happyhills Homicide
It may have ‘happy’ in the name but don’t let that fool you because the word ‘homicide’ is just five letters later. I trust you picked that up from the title but I’m going to call attention to it again just in case. The Happyhills Homicide is another free game you can simply download and play right from a browser. It’s been a huge underground hit with fans but you’d be forgiven for never having heard of it.
The narrative is flipped a little here, though, as you play the role of the murdering killer clown, not the murder-ee, and you need to take out your victims in various gruesome ways.
By gruesome, we really mean gruesome, this game is particularly nasty even though it uses pixel art and a set of 2D environments. I don’t want to give too much away but you’ll shock a guy into knocking his face into a stool which chops his jaw off and then you’ll smash his buddy’s head into a wall until he has been fully unalived. Like I said, nasty. That said, the creativity of planning and executing the kills is genuinely unique and pretty fun.
Assuming you don’t have a weak stomach, of course.
3. Tattletail
If that last one was a little too bloody and not scary enough for you then I hope you were freaked out by Furbys as a kid because this is going to be the frightfest for you.
This far down the list it seems like we can confirm the 80s and 90s were definitely a scarier time because for this particular adventure we’re kicking it back to 1998 when every boy and girl wanted a Furby- I’m sorry, I mean a Tattletail. This 2016 first-person indie horror has you wandering around the house Tattletail in hand doing your best to avoid Mama Tattletail who isn’t nearly as kid-friendly as her offspring. Then again, forgetting to feed, brush, recharge, or generally disobey your little Tattletail will result in it making noise that attracts Mama.
If it isn’t clear by this point, attracting her attention is not something you want to do.
This is the first game by Waygetter Electronics and it’s a really clever idea with some solid execution. It’s also woefully underplayed so if you need another interesting horror game to add to your pile you could do much worse than this one, especially since you’re getting a decent chunk of horror for a crazy low price.
2. Stay Out Of The House
There’s nothing like a horror game title that’s already insinuating you shouldn’t play it but I know for a lot of you fear fanatics out there that’s just going to bait you in more so let’s talk about Puppet Combo’s 2022 horror game Stay Out Of The House.
Puppet Combo have made exactly three horror games that can be found on Steam and to give you an idea of who they are their names are as follows; Murder House, Christmas Massacre, and finally Stay Out Of The House.
This time around you’ll be doing your best to manage your stamina as you venture around a spooky home belonging to a serial killer who is also a cannibal. The game is inspired by 80s slasher films and utilises a wildly unsettling aesthetic that incorporates low-fi retro graphics and a creepy VHS overlay. You play as a young woman on a roadtrip whose boyfriend goes missing prior to your own kidnapping. You’ll then need to seek out an escape, decide whether to rescue survivors, and whether to fight back while navigating the madman’s house of horrors. On top of that, you’ll also have to avoid his twisted family members.
While it’s comforting that even cannibalistic serial killers have families that’ll stick by them, nothing about the rest of this game is reassuring in the slightest.
1. No One Lives Under The Lighthouse
In Marevo Collective’s self-proclaimed slow-burn retro horror, things move at a milder pace than they do in some of the other games on this list but somehow that only adds to the tension. You’re the new lighthouse keeper but not the kind anybody is going to want to marry and keep company because your lighthouse is mad haunted and the last guy went missing which is deeply uncool.
The story delves into places that are deeply Lovecraftian with genuine scares, a palpable sense of place and creepy atmosphere, as well as well-crafted sound design. While it seems that you’re just going through the motions doing monotonous tasks in your new gig, we’ve learned by this point in the list that nothing is as it appears.
It’s all delightfully unsettling as you try to uncover the secrets of your predicament, the setting, and what lies in the shadows. Or in this case, under the lighthouse.