10 INSANE Video Game Risks (That Totally Paid Off)
It takes guts to reboot Kratos.
Sometimes, it feels as though the creative industries take place in a different universe to most other career choices. Whilst it sounds like a wonderful thing to produce art for a living, there are countless stories of the difficulties and doubt from those who craft video games.
After all, games are largely produced to a deadline and studios need to make a return on their investment.
As such, there are always tough decisions to make along the way, and potential risks to take to see a project through to its intended completion.
But sometimes, a risk is worth taking because the reward can be so great. Very few truly great games have totally smooth development periods and there are plenty of tales to pick from where devs were faced with truly unthinkable choices.
In this list we'll look at just a few stories from developers who have taken gambles on ideas that could've gone horribly wrong. In the end though, they wound creating memorable pieces of entertainment and fans should be thankful for their bravado. From creating stylistic changes in private to putting your livelihood on the line, the following games took huge risks in the name of artistic expression.
10. Halo's Multiplayer Is Scrapped Four Months Before Release
The history of Halo: Combat Evolved is one with a series of pretty hard shifts along the way. The game started life an RTS title developed for Apple computers, and somehow ended up as a tentpole first-person shooter for Microsoft's Xbox. Not only was making an FPS for a console in this time period a risk, where the formula was still being worked out, but doing so far an unproven machine was incredibly daring.
What's funny about Halo is that originally it was conceived with a multiplayer focus, and the story coming later. However, it almost released without it. Just four months before the game's launch, the current multiplayer was deemed not good enough.
So, with the real possibility of running out of time and shipping without a dedicated multiplayer mode, what the team had made was crumpled up and thrown to the devs from Bungie West who had just finished work on Oni.
Bungie called the multiplayer "shoe-horned in" in later interviews because of this but all the same it spoke to the power of Halo's engine, and the hard work put in thereafter, how good it turned out to be. Multiplayer became the reason many people flocked to Halo, and it crafted legions of LAN-party enthusiasts. It's sequel was pretty much the game that made Xbox's online services as big as they came to be.
9. Trey Parker Walks Out Of Hospital For South Park: The Fractured But Whole
Creating South Park must be a taxing affair, despite it's disarmingly simple look. In fact, because it's visually a straight-forward program, it actually means that creators Matt Stone and Trey Parker can risk putting episodes together at the eleventh hour basically every week.
In this way, South Park is able to adapt and react to breaking news or trends in ways that most shows cannot.
2014 saw the release of the RPG South Park: The Stick of Truth. The creative duo were rather detached from it's development however, and wanted to be more in tune with the creation of it's 2017 sequel The Fractured But Whole.
However, Trey Parker had to deal with a different kind of stress due to an emergency gallbladder removal and so getting his voice parts done for the game were a tricky situation. The team described the surgery as setting them back "two and a half weeks" during the recording of more than 30,000 lines of dialogue.
As (South Park art director and voice actor) Adrien Beard recalls, there was even a day that Parker convinced his Doctor to let him leave the hospital, go to the office to record voice over, and then head straight back to his ward when he was done, because he wanted to the game to be "sweet".
Proving, ultimately, that Trey Parker can't help but live life inside of a creative whirlwind.
8. Resident Evil Saves Capcom After Being Told To Cancel It
Capcom may be among one of the most beloved and illustrious developers in gaming today. Their back catalogue is long and wonderfully varied, and it's all thanks to taking chances.
In 1993, in order to diversify their portfolio, young developer Shinji Mikami was made lead on a new horror project despite his hatred for being spooked. The idea, of course, was that he would use his fearfulness to craft something fresh and effective.
But during the early 90s, the studio was facing near-extinction. Despite some huge successes, the sales of constant Street Fighter II revisions and Mega Man sequels were dwindling. According to Itchy, Tasty: An Unofficial Guide to Resident Evil by Alex Aniel, Capcom hired an American financial consultant to evaluate their business. With the fledging Biohazard three years into production, helmed by a relative unknown, the consultant suggested scrapping the untested project and hedging a safer bet elsewhere.
Tokuro Fujiwara, the game's producer, insisted that Capcom see development through. Mikami didn't learn of the near-cancellation of his game until nearly a decade later.
By this time, of course, it's success was more than assured. Resident Evil absolutely devoured the company's sales expectations upon release and saved them from financial disaster. Capcom estimates that the Resi franchise has moved over 124 million units worldwide to date, in part thanks to Fujiwara's belief in the game.
7. The Wind Waker's Graphics Are Kept A Secret
In 2000, Nintendo showed a tech demo for their brand new system, the GameCube that saw Link and Ganon face-off in a graphical engine not unlike what had come before in Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask.
Eiji Aonuma, director of the next game in the series, felt that this was old hat by this stage. He was not enthused by the demo and was instead inspired by an artist's sketch of a cartoony, oddly proportioned Link with giant eyes. He knew this was the direction he wanted to go, but he also knew that Shigeru Miyamoto and company would hate it, so held off on showing the game to his colleagues for as long as possible.
Miyamoto was said to have "literally cringed" at the first sight of the Wind Waker and through development reminded Aonuma that it wasn't "too late to change course".
More than just his own distaste for it, Miyamoto likely knew it was a risk. Yes, Zelda had only been 3D for a few years by this point but 1998's Ocarina of Time had been massive. Such a departure would surely upset the applecart. Of course, famously, it did.
But both fans and Miyamoto came around to Wind Waker and in the long-run it set the groundwork for Zelda being a series that stylistically breaks new ground with most major releases.
6. God Of War 2018 Forges On Despite Boss' Disapproval
When rebooting the God of War franchise, Santa Monica Studios had a hard road ahead of them.
Director Cory Barlog gave a keynote speech at Devcon 2018 about God of War's complex behind-the-scenes story and it was one filled with doubt. Because the game was a complete refresh for the series, with the engine and art and so on being worked on in tandem, producing a good demo for playtesters was nigh-on impossible. Many who did it play it were furious by the changes to the gameplay and leading man Kratos.
The most worrying moment came just six months from launch. President of Sony Interactive Entertainment Worldwide Studios Shuhei Yoshida visited the studio to get hands on with the game. According to Barlog, it was a buggy mess and Yoshida played it whilst shaking his head in silence. He didn't say a word to Barlog, but the director heard from a colleague that bumped into Yoshida later that he what he played had "horrified" him.
Some people would see the lack of a verbal reaction was a big red, stop sign. The word "horrified" could've put some developers in a tailspin. It was make or break time. Did God of War slow it's roll and perhaps consider a different direction? Instead, Barlog and team put their noses to the grindstone.
And in so doing, released a title that rightfully won several end of year awards.
5. Cuphead Developers Remortgage Their Homes
Video games aren't just made by huge studios with dump-trucks full of cash, sometimes they come from the bedrooms of passionate programmers who use their free-time to work on their art. Cuphead is one such story, and a successful one indeed, considering that it was met with high praise and spawned a Netflix animated series.
Cuphead's development began around 2013 as a dream in the minds of brothers Jared and Chad Moldenhauer. A short clip of the idea of a run-and-gunner inspired by 1930s cartoons was posted on YouTube which grabbed the attention of Microsoft. After striking a deal, the ball was really rolling and industry interest grew because of just how unique and stunning the art style was.
As the game's demands grew, so did the need for more staff and more investment. As such, the brothers decided to quit their day jobs (which yes, they still had even after signing a release deal with Microsoft) and even re-mortgage their homes in order to spend on supporting the fledgling studioMDHR.
In the economy of today, even being able to afford a mortgage at all seems like a dream come true for some people. But Cuphead's devs took a gamble by selling their houses back to the bank in order to see their game come to life.
It gives the final boss of the game's gambling aesthetic a deeper meaning indeed.
4. Sega Gives Away Their System Seller
The Mega Drive got the head-start on Nintendo's 16-bit NES sequel and it was an impressive little machine but it lacked a true, eye-catching must-have game-changer. Thus, Sega went about creating a mascot. Thankfully for them it worked, as Sonic the Hedgehog proved to be extremely popular with those got to play the game before it's release in July 1991.
However, Sega of America made a pretty incredible decision a few months later to start including the game free with the console.
Previous Genesis systems had come with Altered Beast, a fine game but not on Sonic's level. Sonic was the title everyone was talking about. On the one hand, there was hesitance that they would lose money from consumers who would normally buy the console and the game. However, this proved to be fruitful as it instantly attracted more people who needed that extra bit of incentive.
In fact, to keep everyone happy, those who had bought a Mega Drive before Sonic's release could apply for a free copy of Sonic the Hedgehog - which only helped to make sure that the Blue Blur was the only character anyone was talking about in 1991.
The long-lasting positive effect of such a decision meant that more people were prepared and ready to make 1992's Sonic the Hedgehog 2 the fastest selling video game launch to that point in history.
3. Modern Warfare's Best Level Is Crafted Independently By A Medical Student
Applying for a job in the arts is always a risk in itself, so props must go to Mohammad Alavi. Despite being offered placement at a medical school, he was side-tracked by the growing popularity of his passion project gaming mods. Putting aside his promising medical career, he went to university to study game design.
Most games, especially AAA titles like Call of Duty, are crafted by teams of hundreds these days. This wasn't so much the case in the early 00s. When Alavi joined Infinity Ward, he was one of thirty who applied themselves to whatever needed doing to realise the overall vision.
As such, an idea Alavi had for a stealth-based level presented him with a choice. Either he went to busy programmers with the concept who may not have time for it, or he learn to do it himself. Alavi described the code for his mission being "a mess" compared to the pros but what was important was that it functioned as intended when he presented it to his team.
That stage was All Ghillied Up, the highly memorable moment of Modern Warfare's campaign where things slow down for a moment. Instead of being an all-out shooting gallery, the mission is all about precision, careful planning and vulnerability.
Oh, and just to prove he wasn't a fluke, Alavi also went onto craft Modern Warfare 2's "No Russian", one of the franchise's most impactful cinematic moments.
2. Final Fantasy XIV Turns Spectacle Into Spectacular
At the end of 2012, the long-storied Final Fantasy series hit its lowest ever point. After the much derided trilogy of FF13 games, the next entry in the franchise needed to really sing. Instead, it croaked.
Final Fantasy XIV was meant to be the evolution of the series' previous MMO efforts but was anything but. Even aside from major performance issues, it just wasn't fun. It was bogged down in convoluted systems and menus and it's core loop seemed to be made up mostly of tireless grinding.
Developers Square were presented with several, unenviable options on what to do. After a year of the game being a laughing stock and disappointment for invested fans, Square announced they were pulling the plug and starting over. For a name like Final Fantasy, at this point an institution in gaming, it was a bold move. Getting it right this time was so important that it delayed many other titles from the company.
With a new director and producer in Yoshi-P, who had not worked on the original FF14 nor even met most of the existing staff, the next two years were an exhaustive challenge.
Thankfully, they paid off. Final Fantasy XIV rubber-banded from being an embarrassing disaster to being an immediately impressive title that went onto critical acclaim, industry awards and becoming one of the front-running MMOs of the modern era.
1. Broken Age Starts The Era Of Crowdfunding
Video games are a business. Your game can be as crazy as you dream it, but it needs to sell, and so producers are likely to select safe bets.
This leaves small teams and untested ideas out in the cold, without the monetary support they need to get off the ground. Enter: crowdfunding.
Double Fine were a respected group amongst their fans but hardly a mainstream studio. Figurehead Tim Schaffer was known for his love of classic adventure games but his attempts to make them had been repeatedly rebuffed by investors. And so he decided to use Kickstarter to make his dream game happen.
Broken Age was really the first big crowdfunding success story in gaming. It smashed it's goal of $400k, coming in at $3m when the campaign ended. The game released to positive reviews, but more than this showed many other studios that this was a possible route if you had something that caught enough attention.
Broken Age really opened the floodgates for indie titles like Shovel Knight, Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night and Yooka-Laylee, just to name a few, to even exist.
Every one of these projects is a risk as those who support your project have certain expectations (at the very least a finished product at some point), and the whole process is fraught with possible issues. Still, when it works, it really shows that the gaming industry is not beholden exclusively to giant corporations.