10 Insulting Microtransactions Video Games Had To REMOVE

Sometimes they listen.

shadow of mordor war talion
Monolith

Gaming is a different landscape now than it was when Bethesda first set off the microtransaction controversy bomb with Elder Scroll IV: Oblivion's infamous horse armor. The very concept of microtransactions was seen as bizarre and repugnant. And while many of us still hate them, we have to accept that they aren't going anywhere.

The system of monetizing games after original purchase is now as entrenched in the industry as special editions and pre-order bonuses. You can safely assume that most games will have microtransactions of some sort and usually you just have to suck it up and hope for the best.

And yet, the controversy itself hasn't gone anywhere.

Microtransactions are as irritating now as ever - we're just used to them. And, hey, occasionally they're even done well. And by "well," I just mean not entirely predatory and exploitative. Publishers get a little greed. As a treat.

So it really says a lot when they go so far that we simply can't take it anymore, as is the case with the following implementations games had to remove, or continue to feel the wrath of consumers.

10. Lootboxes - Middle Earth Shadow Of War

Middle-earth: Shadow of War
Monolith Productions

Regular microtransactions were bad enough, but when publishers introduced lootboxes - packs of randomized rewards inspired by mobile games - they crossed a line. In fact, they crossed so far over the line that actual governments had to get involved.

In the case of Middle Earth: Shadow Of War, the whole concept seemed especially egregious, for a couple of reasons:

First, Shadow Of War is a SINGLE PLAYER game. The concept of loot boxes had mostly been exploited in multiplayer titles, where the logic made sense. If multiplayer games are running for years, it's understandable why a publisher needs a steady revenue stream, even if it can be a predatory one. In a full-price single player game, it comes across as downright greedy.

Second, the finale of the game was essentially one unbelievably long grind of taking and defending bases for hours. And if you wanted to see the game's true ending, beating it was the only way.

What publisher WB Games essentially did was lock the game's ending behind a sloth's-pace grind that could only be alleviated by spending real life money on loot boxes, which didn't ensure that you would even get anything helpful.

People justifiably revolted and the "feature" was removed.


9. Star Cards - Star Wars Battlefront II

Star Wars Battlefront 2 Star Cards
EA

Electronic Arts is, infamously, a major AAA video game publisher almost universally hated by gamers everywhere. But with Star Wars: Battlefront II's microtransactions, they overreached so far that they attracted similar ire from politicians. This was due to their predatory approach to microtransaction loot boxes within the game.

In addition to usual items like in-game currency, items and weapons, Battlefront II's loot boxes also included Star Cards - a needlessly complicated system for improving your character's abilities. This literally meant that by spending real money, you could objectively give yourself an advantage over other players.

And the more you spend, the better your odds of getting really good cards. At least, that's the gambler's mentality EA was exploiting (especially in younger players) to make stacks of cash. Fan backlash was enough for EA to remove paid loot boxes entirely.

However, this practice drew national attention, even resulting in the state of Hawaii introducing legislation targeting such business practices.

EA's stock plummeted amidst the controversy and the company gained a reputation among parents for encouraging their children to gamble. And with the company committing more to single player games going forward, it seems to have changed the direction of the company completely.


8. Pay-To-Win Boosters - Ghost Recon: Breakpoint

Ghost Recon Breakpoint Team
Ubisoft

`Ghost Recon: Breakpoint being released to middling reviews was somewhat confusing. Its prequel, Wildlands, didn't light the world on fire but did debut to generally favorable reception. It stands to reason that a sequel would reinforce and build on that foundation.

And while Breakpoint may have had its own unique gameplay issues, those aren't the whole story behind its 5/10 and under scores.

The big issue is with the egregious microtransactions. Publishers aren't trying to hide their greed when literally every single thing in the game can be bought with real money. Every weapon, weapon upgrade, vehicle, item of clothing and cosmetic item can be purchased with real money, making the bulk of the actual gameplay redundant.

As if those weren't bad enough, the Early Access release of the game also featured "Time-Saving" Boosters, allowing players to purchase experience points, crafting materials, and even skills.

Rightfully received as an unambiguous pay-to-win scenario, publisher Ubisoft later removed the items claiming their inclusion was an "error.

Kinda weird that they didn't catch this error until after the deafening fan backlash, but that's none of our business.


7. XP Boosts - Marvel's The Avengers

Marvel's Avengers
Square Enix

In another case of an unapologetic pay-to-win model, Marvel's Avengers - already a huge disappointment in virtually every other regard - also introduced experience point boosts players could purchase with real money.

With one of the game's main criticisms being a truly insane grind to develop your characters, the post-launch addition of the XP boost was especially damning.

If that weren't bad enough, this came after promises to payers that microtransactions would only be for cosmetic items that didn't affect gameplay. And in yet another comical twist, the XP boosts were also introduced after a patch that significantly reduced the amount of XP earned in the actual game.

Combined with the game's overall poor quality, it really felt as though publisher Square-Enix was pulling out all the stops to make money back on a sure-fire expensive disaster, and in the most insulting ways possible.

Players were so incensed that it took less than a month to remove the XP boosts. But we can't help but wonder how much they made off of them during that brief period.


6. All Of Them - Redfall

Redfall Game
Arkane

After a significant information leak consisting mostly of in-game screenshots, it was revealed that Redfall, the next game by developer Arkane, was going to be something a little different from their usual output.

Games like Dishonored and Prey featured large, open levels, but were still praised for being linear single player games with engrossing stories. But leaked Redfall content suggested something resembling Borderlands or Destiny - games notable for being multiplayer and based largely on the pursuit of loot in the forms of items and guns.

The fact that another one of those leaked images showed a microtransaction store came, sadly, as little surprise. If it is going to be a so-called live-service game - a genre known for having years-long lifespans - it would require microtransactions in order to maintain revenue.

Needless to say, it was very much not what fans expected and they weren't happy.

In a later, official gameplay demo where the microtransaction menu was noticeably absent, it seems like Arkane had heard them loud and clear. But with many details about Redfall still under wraps, time will tell.


5. Cosmetic Item Pricing - Halo Infinite

halo infinite
343 Industries

Halo fans were excited when developer 343 Industries released the game's multiplayer component, for free, ahead of the full game's scheduled release date. And the gameplay was largely praised.

After some controversial changes to previous games in the series, Infinite's multiplayer was a return to form. It just FELT like Halo again, for the first time in a long time.

And you can't really blame them for including microtransactions. Any reasonable person understands that multiplayer component designed to live well past the life of a full retail product needs money from somewhere to keep running.

At least, they were understanding, until a Reddit user did a little simple math and determined that in order to buy all of the items, which were only available for a limited time, players would have to cough up over $1,000.

People were rightfully furious, especially since such pricing contradicted promises previously made by the developer. 343 were then practically compelled to make changes to their pricing, as well as the very structure of the store itself in order to offer more varied options for purchases.


4. Shaders - Destiny 2

Destiny 2 Subclass Artwork
Bungie

Shaders are a popular kind of item in Bungie's Destiny that allow players to change the color of their equipment. This feature was beloved by fans. With its limited character creation options, shaders went a long way for diversifying player appearances.

Naturally, Bungie brought them back in Destiny 2. Why wouldn't they? It's a fairly basic mechanic seen in similar games. But there was one major change: shaders were now single-use items.

Unlike in the original, where shaders were permanent and could be applied any time, Shaders in Destiny 2 would disappear after one use. This resulted in a form of scarcity that made players not want to use them.

What if you find an amazing shader, apply it to your weapon, then find a new one ten minutes later? This mindset lead to many players anxiously hoarding them, waiting for the "right time."

It should come as no surprise that the reason for this was that shaders were now available for purchase. Oops, you wasted that shader you were saving! No worries. Sooner or later its bound to turn up in a loot box. And then you'll be even more anxious about wasting it, since it cost real money.

Bungie eventually conceded, making shaders permanent again.


3. Item Pricing And Availability - NBA 2K18

NBA 2K18 VC
2K Games

The 2K Sports series of games - which includes NBA2K18 - has a solid and dedicated fanbase. Being closer to a basketball sim, they love the series for its realism. So the fact that publisher 2K chose to turn this entry into an absolute grind in order to push microtransactions wasn't just enraging - it was disappointing, which we all know is way worse.

Not only was the in-game currency required to upgrade your character, but it was also required to unlock the vast majority of options for customizing your character - a favorite feature of fans.

Grinding to upgrade your character is bad enough. It eliminates the natural progression of the game, forcing you to replay content you might not want to. But locking almost all of the cosmetic items behind exorbitantly expensive pricing was nothing short of greedy.

For context, playing the game normally might net you around 500 Virtual Currency. That means playing a minimum of two games every time you want a tattoo or a pair of sneakers, priced at 1,000 VC.

Developers heard the outrage of fans, lowering the price of many items to 100 VC. Unfortunately, for many fans it was too little, too late.


2. Gems - My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic

My Little Pony Friendship Is Magic Background Ponies Slice Of Life
Hasbro Studios

Developer GameLoft's My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic is hardly the first or only mobile game to feature over-priced microtransactions.

In fact, such practices are the norm for mobile games, most of which are free to download. But what makes Friendship Is Magic stand out is the nature of the game itself targeting mostly children.

The goal is to return the missing six protagonists to their world. The catch is that advancing through the game only unlocks the option to purchase them individually with gems, which are scarce, doled out one at time every few levels.

For context, the final pony cost a staggering 500 gems or around $30. And that's just one. Just to complete the game required literal years of grinding or around $100.

Everyone was legitimately turned off. Not only is this an obvious attempt to exploit the game's many teen and even adult fans, but children as well, many young enough that they don't understand the value of money.

Eventually, Gameloft dropped the price of that particular pony to only 50 gems, or $8, but that was all. And it came with a begrudging announcement attributing the outcry to "a select few older fans." An audacious statement, to say the least.


1. Lootboxes (Again) - Payday 2

payday 2 heist
Overkill

Payday 2, a cooperative shooter series with a niche, but devoted, fanbase actually released without microtransactions. So it's a little confusing that developer Overkill chose to add them later in the form of in-games safes that required drills (purchased with real money) to open and reveal a randomized weapon skin as a reward.

So... they were basically loot boxes. A wildly unpopular mechanic couched under a thin veneer of gameplay.

What's worse is that, unlike most shooters, these weapon skins weren't just cosmetic, but also boosted the stats of weapons. Meaning that game became not only pay-to-win, but also a gamble as you didn't even know what it was you were buying. Overkill lost the loyalty of their fans practically overnight.

In a rare display of humility, Overkill actually took the L on this, removing microtransactions, making the weapon skins free, and going on to add more free content in months that followed. Even better, this came with a mea culpa acknowledging that they broke their fans' trust and would work to regain it.

Fortunately, they did. Now if only the rest of the industry could be so decent.


Watch Next


Contributor

At 34 years of age, I am both older and wiser than Splinter.