10 Most Intense Video Game Franchise Rivalries

Try not immediately picking a side for each one of these.

The gaming world is overflowing with trolls and fanboys. We just can't help ourselves, viciously flaming one another over the most trivial issues - which in case you hadn't heard, your favourite game/console/character/developer is crap, and you're an for thinking otherwise. The bottom line is that once we've chosen a side there isn't much that can change our minds. Fierce competition between game franchises for example, has had us in the midst of an all-out war since the dawn of the industry. We can really only commit our time (and money) to one good football game or one incredible online shooter at a time, so it makes sense that developers fight tooth and nail to make sure that their product is the genre leader. And this, in turn, leads to a hellish battle for market supremacy. Sometimes its the blatantly derivative cousin of a popular game which steals ideas and reaps the rewards, others a massive franchise facing off against a young upstart underdog. Often these competing franchises are split along the console divide, fanning the flames of fanboy wars to ridiculous levels. Occasionally these two titles can co-exist in the gaming space, but in other cases one becomes the dominating force within its genre while the other scampers off with its tail between its legs. Is it a silly thing to argue about? Probably, but that's never stopped us before. When you're passionate about something, tempers are bound to flare. But this article is not about raising pulses or laying bait for the trolls, it's simply a look back at the epic battles which have burned a hot streak through the industry over the years. Many of you will have strong feelings either way regarding these gaming face-offs, but that's the point. If you feel we've missed any vital feuds, or if we've stepped on any toes along the way, let's hear about it in the comments below.

10. Forza Motorsport VS. Gran Turismo

We'll kick things off with a real minefield of a rivalry, particularly explosive since it cuts the field between Xbox and PlayStation militia. Forza came late the party, but has quickly stolen a huge slice of attention from Polyphony Digital's infinitely realistic Gran Turismo franchise. Of course these two aren't the only heavy hitters in the racing world - we can't ignore the weight of Need For Speed, DiRT and numerous others - but the Forza VS. Gran Turismo feud has been particularly intense. Two flagship console exclusives; two brutal, unforgiving racers; we weigh these two on the same scale because they offer an incredibly similar gaming experience. Historically both have scored consistently high on Metacritic, although that has been a feeling in recent years that things have become a little too clinical - realism is all fine and well, but must it come at the expense of fun? In that regard we might give Forza the points for this round, purely because the latest instalment, Forza Horizon 2, brings an injection of buzzing excitement that critics and gamers can't seem to get enough of. Then again, the Horizon sub-brand is a different beast to the core Forza franchise, so that is perhaps not an entirely fair comparison - once again it's pretty hard to narrow this down.

9. Quake 3 Arena VS. Unreal Tournament

Nothing fires up factionalism like competitive multiplayer. And few multiplayer face-offs burned as intensely as the great Quake 3 VS. Unreal Tournament war at the tail end of the nineties. The original Quake quickly despatched of it's closest competitor Duke Nukem 3D in the mid-nineties, but id Software had a bigger fight on their hands up against Epic Games' frantic, team-work focused shooter. After the awkward storytelling attempts of both Quake II and the original Unreal, Q3 and UT basically ditched the idea of narrative completely - by 1999 we were all about twitch reflex multiplayer deathfests. The two camps were equally fanatical in their support, and there was very little grey area between them. You could love one, or the other, but not both. Which is quite odd, really, because the core experience was rather similar. Blisteringly quick, this was multiplayer FPS gaming at its most distilled. Can we call a winner? It's hard to say, but considering that Quake 3 Arena was still a standard feature of numerous professional gaming tournaments for almost a decade after its release, we might give id Software's creation the nod in this contest.

8. UFC Undisputed VS. EA Sports MMA

This match-up earns its place on our list for somewhat different reasons to the rest. EA Sports' first entry in the world of MMA gaming failed to spark too much excitement, failed to live up to the hype, and ultimately failed to take a meaningful stab at UFC Undisputed's position as the premier MMA franchise. But the case of UFC Undisputed VS. EA Sports MMA will be remembered more for the action behind the scenes. We all know that EA likes to stamp its name across every sport worth playing. That's just how they roll. But when it came to the rapidly growing sport of mixed martial arts, EA wanted nothing to do with it. UFC boss Dana White famously proposed an MMA game to the game publishing powerhouse, and was promptly told to bugger off. As the story goes, EA execs didn't consider mixed martial arts to be a real sport and wanted to distance themselves from the brand, so THQ stepped in and grabbed the UFC license instead. There's nothing wrong with choosing not to sign a sporting license if you're not interested in it, that's an executive decision that EA felt was right at the time, but it was their sudden backtracking and stance-reversal which left a sour taste in many mouths. As the UFC became increasingly popular, THQ's licensed UFC Undisputed franchise started pulling in some critical heat, leaving EA feeling left out of the party. So they had a change of heart regarding this brutal art... it seemed that MMA was worth their attention after all. Upon announcement of EA Sports MMA, Dana White prohibited any UFC-signed fighters from any involvement with it, putting their careers on the line if they stepped into EA's ring. What followed was a messy brawl between fighters, promoters, managers, game publishers and everyone else involved. The result? And unremarkable first effort by EA Sports, an epic collapse of THQ, and a "match made in heaven" deal when EA bought the UFC license after all. And then disappointed us with EA Sports UFC.

7. Guitar Hero VS. Rock Band

Oh, how the mighty have fallen. There was a time when rhythm gaming was a driving force in the industry, letting us all live out our rock star fantasies in the comfort of our homes, and filling Activision and EA's pockets with cash in the process. Guitar Hero wasn't the first rhythm game, but most will agree that it was the one that blasted the genre into the public eye. Developer Harmonix was soon picked up by MTV Networks, which is when they really spread their wings - with the genre on the up, it was time to take things from a one-man-band to full-on rock epic, with the multi-instumental Rock Band. And suddenly the grandfather of this corner of the rhythm gaming genre was left on the back foot. Those still faithful to the Guitar Hero brand had a tough time justifying their convictions in the face of the undeniably brilliant Rock Band. When Guitar Hero III went to fight it out with Harmonix's new creation in the 2007 holiday season, a lot of longtime Guitar Hero gamers jumped ship. The social party aspects of a four-piece band that Rock Band was built around made it really hard to resist. New Guitar Hero developer Neversoft was forced to play copycat, also taking their franchise in a multi-instrumental direction for Guitar Hero: World Tour. Gamers weren't convinced though, and the Guitar Hero franchise started to feel more and more like a second-rate knock-off of Harmonix's pioneering efforts. Fast forward to 2014, and both Rock Band and Guitar Hero have all but disappeared from public consciousness - years of relentless rhythm games with very little innovation left the market completely saturated, with only the heavily technical Rocksmith still making any impact.

6. World Of Warcraft VS. All Contenders For The MMORPG Throne

Few games have had the cultural impact of World Of Warcraft - Blizzard's gargantuan MMORPG even has an entire episode of South Park dedicated to it, and that's got to tell you that we're dealing with a monster. World Of Warcraft forged a new image of what persistent online gaming could be, and earned a massively dedicated user base in the process. It also sounded an alarm to other publishers and developers: "There is big money to be made here, chaps, so get to it." But, as it turns out, the MMORPG formula is a tough one to unravel and recreate. So, instead of a market flooded with compelling options to replace Blizzard's cash cow, we see World Of Warcraft stepping up to the plate time and time again to knock the stuffing out of anyone trying to steal its spotlight. It's incredible actually - not even the mighty Star Wars license has carried enough weight to wrestle the crown from this gaming hall-of-famer. You could argue that Bungie has cracked it with Destiny, the bastard child of Halo and World Of Warcraft, but they're vastly different creatures really.

5. Street Fighter VS. Mortal Kombat

Imagine the surprise on Street Fighter's face when Mortal Kombat showed up, puffed up with true American bravado, dripping with blood and a reckless disregard for subtlety. Sub Zero, Raiden and the lads threw the gaming world into a frenzy, with parents and frumpy politicians calling for an outright ban on this horrific mess of a fighter. Back in the early nineties this level of ultraviolence was unheard of, and kids swarmed around the arcade cabinets like moths to a flame. Midway (now NetherRealm) did things very differently to Capcom, and gaming audiences responded to it with feverish excitement. Street Fighter II, at the time considered the epitome of one-on-one fighting excellence, was a more considered, more technical affair. Mortal Kombat was dumb and vicious. Midway took obvious queues from the Street Fighter playbook, but reworked it enough to give us a distinctly different kind of brawler. The two franchises have followed contrasting paths since then - Capcom has consistently improved and refined the Street Fighter experience, where Mortal Kombat suffered something of a midlife crisis during its lifetime. The beat-em-up landscape looks very different now, with NetherRealm really coming into their own since the 2011 franchise reboot. As we head towards Mortal Kombat X, it's safe to say that regardless of Street Fighter's slick, masterful gameplay, Mortal Kombat is the more relevant fighter right now.

4. FIFA VS. Pro Evolution Soccer

EA Sports and Konami have been going at it for over a decade now, trading blows year after year in a bid for football gaming supremacy. It's another epic West vs East stand-off, and a showcase of the subtle differences between Japanese and western game design. Pro Evo, or Winning Eleven as it's known in its home country, has long been looked at as the superior translation of soccer, compared to the more grandiose FIFA with its swagger and pricey official licenses. EA likes to be the star of the show when it comes to sports games, but haven't always had things their way in the football arena. No matter how much money they threw at the problem, for a good few years there wasn't much EA Sports could do to get one into the back of the net against Pro Evo. But EA Canada got their groove back towards the end of the last decade, and since FIFA 08 they have been heavily on the attack. For the past few years Konami has barely had a shot on goal. The thing with soccer games is that, unlike with platform games, third-person shooters or open world adventures, most of us only have the attention span (or budget) for one. And with Pro Evo Soccer 15 available this month Konami will be hoping to convince gamers that the PES brand is once again the one to go for.

3. Wii Sports VS. Every Other Motion-Controlled Sports Game

You're welcome to disagree, but you would be wrong (obviously). Had it not been for the ridiculous success of Wii Sports - and, by extension, the Nintendo Wii - this whole motion-controlled gaming mess could have been avoided entirely. But Wii Sports was a hit, shifting over 80 million copies worldwide, and so obviously Sony and Microsoft jumped on the bandwagon. And so both Kinect and Move can be blamed on this cheeky little sports game. You can't blame the competition for wanting to grab a piece of the flappy-arms motion-control pie, but you can't blame us for not buying into it either. Wii Sports earned our attention because it broke new ground, but by the time Microsoft and Sony started churning out similar rubbish for their failed peripherals, no one cared. Microsoft is being quite tenacious in its approach to push Kinect 2.0 for the Xbox One, but Sony seems to have gotten the message with regards to motion gaming - we want to sit and twiddle our thumbs on a gamepad like in the olden days.

2. Call Of Duty VS. Battlefield

It's Activision versus EA once again. These two mega-publishers really have a lot of history between them, don't they? When it comes to online multiplayer competitive first-person shooters, the Call Of Duty VS. Battlefield saga has to be the battle which has defined the last console generation. In a number of ways Battlefield is the lesser of the two - neither game has a particularly strong singleplayer campaign, but the far-fetched Hollywood narratives which Treyarch, Infinity Ward and now Sledgehammer Games have tossed together for Call Of Duty have been notably superior to the lacklustre efforts from EA DICE. Call Of Duty also sells in huge numbers, pouring cash into Bobby Kotick's swollen wallet, while Battlefield is lagging significantly. The gameplay itself tells a different story. In action, there is a sense that Battlefield has emerged as the more mature shooter - it's focus on squad unity and cohesion in battle makes it a game for friends to play together, work together and win together. Call Of Duty is undeniably more flashy, but it's more of a peeing contest than Battlefield, following a gaming model which has stagnated in recent years too. The franchise seems almost bulletproof though, because regardless of flagging critical ratings the kids keep lining up to buy each incrementally updated version year after year.

1. Mario VS. Sonic

Today the gaming industry is loaded with iconic characters, but in the days when gaming was still something of a niche market it was a very different scenario. Console holders traditionally built their brand on one key mascot, and hoped for the best. We saw Sega stumble miserably trying to sell Master Systems on the back of the forgettable Alex Kidd, while Nintendo struck gold with an unlikely hero; the moustached plumber Mario. It wasn't until Sega introduced the world to an equally dubious character - a supersonic hedgehog - that the console wars really kicked into gear. Stark naked except for a pair of dodgy red sneakers and Mickey Mouse gloves, Sonic The Hedgehog gave Mario a solid run for his money, unlike any competing mascot who had come before him. The epic Sonic VS. Mario duel was a battle of unprecedented scale for its time, a proper taste of the kind of fully weaponised console exclusive face-offs we see driving sales (and troll wars) regularly these days. The skirmish burned furiously for a time, but it fizzled out with a sorry whimper when Sega started falling apart at the seams. Today we see the two teaming up in games like Super Smash Bros. Brawl and the trite Mario & Sonic At The Olympic Games. Sonic's later failings can't detract from his legacy though - the spiky chap was largely responsible for pumping Sega's 16-bit consoles into peoples homes for years. But history has shown us that he was punching above his weight class, up against an adversary that was well out of his league. While Sega's speedy creation has been reduced to supporting cast status, Mario has gone on to sell over 400 million games since his inception, making Nintendo's most formidable brand the clear winner in what is probably the biggest franchise war of all time. Are there any that we missed? Let us know in the comments which franchise rivalries you always end up getting stuck into!

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Game-obsessed since the moment I could twiddle both thumbs independently. Equally enthralled by all the genres of music that your parents warned you about.