10 Lies Video Games Could Never Recover From

We won't buy something from someone who cheated us before.

Overwatch 2
Blizzard

Arguably the most important part of a video game’s sales is marketing. It doesn’t matter if you made the greatest game of all time if your mom's the only who buys a copy.

Electronic Arts spent 961 Million dollars on marketing in 2022, alone - and that was only 16% of the 5.8 Billion dollars the industry spent on marketing that same year.

Even successful Indie game publishers say that you should plan for 25-50% of your budget to be marketing. A game that takes $5,000 to make, might cost another $2,500 getting the word out. The general consensus of some companies is simple: For each dollar you spend on marketing you can expect to bring in one buyer.

Now, of course, there are plenty of hurdles in selling even a great game. Maybe you’ve gone gold in a busy release window? Maybe the market’s saturated by low-quality titles of the same genre or theme? Or, y’know, maybe you made just a bad game? All things that can crap on your sales.

Sadly, a common way to get around that last one is the age-old technique of straight-up lying. And while it may work more often than we, as consumers, would like - that's not always the case.

10. Killzone 2 - That Fake Reveal Trailer

Killzone 2
Sony Computer Entertainment

In 2005, Guerrilla Games revealed Killzone 2, a sequel to their 2004 FPS that had, admittedly, middling reviews. So much for it gunning for the title of ‘Halo Killer’.

They put forth a very nice looking trailer showing, what they claimed, was actual gameplay. Though some believed that the PlayStation 3 was not mechanically capable of graphics of that quality in-engine.

While many cried foul that the video had been pre-rendered footage, the company continually claimed it was legitimate and not pre-rendered. After the truth came out that it was, in fact, a giant cutscene, Guerrilla Games switched from lying to gaslighting. They claimed the video was a “target render” for what they hoped the game would look like.

But the damage was done and consumers didn’t trust what was going to be released. When Killzone 2 came out in 2009 too many people remembered the lies. Sony expected to sell 2 million copies in North America, alone, but by their cut-off the game only sold half that... worldwide.

An added insult was that Sony had hoped Killzone 2 would convince people to go out and buy their console just to play it. But PS3 sales actually went down after Killzone 2 was released.


9. Halo 5: Guardians - The Master Chief Vs. Lock Marketing

Halo 5: Guardians Master Chief Spartan Locke
Microsoft Studios

We go from Halo-killer to Halo itself. Halo 5 was touted as series regaining its foothold in the industry after fans were disappointed with initial release of the Master Chief Collection and the lack of longevity for Halo 4’s multiplayer.

A big marketing aspect used was the rivalry between Master Chief being chased by Agent Jameson Locke. They even produced an audio-play starring Keegan-Michael Key as a journalist tasked with uncovering the lies behind Master Chief’s falsified records.

A lot of players expected the game to culminate in a climactic battle between the two Spartans. The marketing really played up the idea of Locke hunting down Master Chief. However, everyone was left quite disappointed when the climactic showdown lasted all of five minutes and ended in a ‘bro moment’ where Locke and Master Chief decided to work together.

Many felt they were suckered in by a bait-and-switch. Some outlets actually felt that Halo 5’s storyline was a step backwards, worse than Halo 4’s. Not the glowing reviews Microsoft had hoped for.

Furthermore, feeling burned by Halo 5, when Halo: Infinite was shown off in 2020 the once-fervently loyal Halo fanbase was brutal in their critiques. So angry were the remarks about the game, no matter how endearing Craig the Brute may have looked, Microsoft decided to delay the game a year, to polish it before release.


8. Overwatch 2 - Two Will Work In Tandem With One!

Overwatch 2
Blizzard

Activision-Blizzard was once one of the most beloved companies in the video games industry, but in recent years they’ve been wracked by some pretty egregious issues. Between the “Don’t you have phones?” Diablo Immortal incident and the entire Warcraft III: Reforged debacle, it’s been a rough few years. Not to mention far more important investigations into rampant, and egregious, sexual harassment and discrimination within the company.

One of their flagship titles, Overwatch, was considered ground-breaking back in 2016. Between solid gameplay and deep, interesting lore, players couldn’t get enough of it. Which was actually one of the biggest complaints about the game - players wanted a story mode, preferably a full-on campaign.

They teased the idea with their yearly Archives events, but that just made people want it more. Players were overjoyed when the company announced that Overwatch 2 would be based around a story mode and would work in tandem with the original. If you were only interested in the story mode - buy Overwatch 2. Only interested in online multiplayer? Overwatch 1 is still your game.

Between much of the dev team’s leadership departing the company and news that major changes were coming, it wasn’t entirely a surprise when the announcements clarified that the first game would cease to be and would be replaced by the now free-to-play sequel.

Top that with a major overhaul to emulate a more Call of Duty-like experience, rather then the trend-setting team-based hero shooter that the original was, and Overwatch went from genre-defining to trend-chasing in a flash.


7. Cyberpunk 2077 - Gonna Sell 30 Million Copies Within 12 Months!

Cyberpunk crashes
CD Projekt Red/Reddit:jak_412

CD Projekt Red first announced what would ultimately become an open-world game set in a futuristic dystopia back in 2012. It had all the staples of a solid cyberpunk theme and after their success with The Witcher 3, CDPR was a darling of the industry. People believed that they could do not wrong.

After several missed milestones, some caused by several major developmental shifts, Cyberpunk 2077 finally came out in 2020. It was the perfect recipe for success: Beloved company, a genre that wasn’t over-saturated, multiple ways to play, and a terrifying virus had forced everyone to lock themselves at home.

And that’s where things went wrong. Apparently 500 people working for nearly a decade wasn’t enough.

Though the game still sold incredibly well, it was not as wildly as was expected, largely due to the game being almost unplayable for many. Game-breaking bugs, genitalia clipping through clothes, and a journalist suffering a grand mal seizure made many swear off the game.

The release was considered so disastrous, Steam and Gamestop had to create new return policy loopholes to keep angry fans sated. Said to have 'dangerously underperformed', it damaged CDPR's reputation so badly that the company's stock plummeted by upwards of $1 billion and they were hit with lawsuits by investors and even a government investigation.

How dangerously underperforming was Cyberpunk 2077? Leading up to release analysts expected it to sell 30 million copies within the first year, but it actually sold 13 million in that timeframe. Less than half.

At least the tie-in anime, Edgerunners, was awesome.


6. Fallout 76 - It Does Not 'Just Work'

Fallout 76
Bethesda

The Fallout series has survived a complete shift in play style before. Fallout started life as an isometric top-down strategy RPG, much like the Jagged Alliance series and Fallout’s spiritual predecessor Wasteland. After Bethesda took control of the franchise in 2004, it shifted the design into a first-person shooter with RPG elements.

When they first acquired licensing rights for Fallout, Bethesda tried to work with the original publisher, Interplay Entertainment, to make an MMORPG. The Fallout MMO made it as far as the beta stage, before Bethesda pulled the plug and engaged in a lengthy court battle with Interplay over it, finally ending in 2012.

Apparently they never got over that desire, because in 2018 they announced Fallout 76, a prequel that would be an MMO. Already people were cautious of it, but many were hopeful that Bethesda could do it again.

They couldn’t.

Totally absent of narrative NPCs, a staple of the series regardless of genre, and beset by horrible bugs and crashes, the few people who put in the effort to play 76 wound up being trolls who delighted in messing with other players. It became popular to reference Bethesda frontman Todd Howard when talking about features of Fallout 4 at an E3 presentation, and because Fallout 76 saw those issues continue, it certainly did not "work".


5. Star Citizen - Release Date: 2014

Star Citizen
Cloud Imperium Games

Cloud Imperium Games’ Star Citizen has won numerous funding awards since it popped up on Kickstarter in 2012 - many of them containing the words “most crowd-funded ever”. In only a year CIG had raised $2 million on Kickstarter, alone, and had a grand total of $15 million when all other funding sources were included.

By 2022, CIG has gathered over $500 million for the game from crowd-sourcing alone, as well as over $60 million from investors buying seats on the company’s board. At the five-year-mark, in 2017, the company’s financial reports suggested they have already spent $193 million on development. With around 4 million backers giving half a billion dollars and 11 years of development, you might expect Star Citizen to be an amazing game.

Well, it’s not even a game, yet.

An alpha version giving players a few tidbits of scattered gameplay has been released, but there is no actual game to speak of. Not great for something with a promised delivery date of 2014.

Many of those 4 million backers have raised complaints, and in some cases even lawsuits, demanding refunds for their crowdfunded investments. Refunds that are reportedly very difficult to arrange and receive.

CIG is pretty mum on how much money they've been forced to give back, but reports suggest at least 25% of backers were demanding refunds in 2015 alone. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has reportedly received over 100 formal complaints regarding CIG, to date.


4. Assassin's Creed Unity - "Not Going To Ship Anything Less Than 100% Quality"

Assassin's Creed Unity
Ubisoft

In 2013 then-president of Ubisoft North America, Laurent Detoc, said in an interview "We're not going to ship [a 70% complete game]. It damages the brand." He discussed, without naming names, how damaging AC III's release was with its bugs and glitches, not to mention the narrative pacing issues.

Cut to 2014 and we have Assassin's Creed: Unity. French politicians called the game blatant propaganda, feminists were unhappy with the lack of any playable female characters even though arguably the most famous assassin of the period was Charlotte Corday (who appears in a single mission), and other game devs were laughing at Ubisoft for claiming that women were too hard to model, animate, and voice - even though they had done so several times before.

And even if you ignored all of that - the faceless eyes of Arno Dorian spread like wildfire through the gaming community. Apparently Detoc's words were totally false. Even those who ignored the bugs and glitches and spoke positively of the game still chastised framerate issues, poor AI programming, the controls, and the inclusion of co-op multi-player only missions in a franchise built on single-player experiences.

The game was so poorly received that Ubisoft offered players a free game from a six-game catalogue... but only if they signed away their right to sue. Unity wound up poisoning the well so badly that the next game in the series, Syndicate, debuted as the 2nd worst selling game of the whole franchise.


3. Godus - Good 'Ol Peter Molyneux

Peter Molyneux
Georges Seguin (Okki) [CC BY-SA 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0)]

Peter Molyneux was the master of over-promising and under-performing. He helped to make some of the best-selling games of all time: Populous and Fable. Quite a step up from his self-funded first game, The Entrepreneur, which sold only two copies.

After The Entrepreneur’s failure, Molyneux got a lucrative contract with the Commodore computer company. The representative had mistaken Molyneux's baked beans company for a networking software company of a similar name and offered him a contract that included free computers. Molyneux, perhaps foreshadowing his eventual reputation as one of the biggest liars in the industry - strategically leaned into the falsehood.

Molyneux founded his own development company, 22cans, to return to the ‘indie’ space after the successes of the Fable series and they produced the strange multi-user game, ‘Curiosity: What’s In The Cube?’

Molyneux stated that whoever solved the final puzzle of the game first would receive a 'life-changing reward'. That reward was a cut of the profits from his next game: Godus. Unfortunately for the winner, Godus has never made a profit.

Despite a successful crowdfunding campaign, 22cans admitted after an early-access release they couldn’t deliver on the promise and would just stop and make something different. Molyneux promised updates by Christmas 2021 - which, you might guess, never came.

Between backers demanding refunds and continually begrudging Molyneux and his company as blatantly disgraceful liars, the company’s latest game to replace Godus’ development was announced as a remake of The Entrepreneur... with blockchain software!

Nothing says things are going well like jumping on the already crumbling NFT bandwagon.


2. Aliens: Colonial Marines - A Game So Bad It Got Sued

Aliens Colonial Marines Dance Gif
Gearbox

A game based on the legendary 1986 film Aliens shouldn’t be that hard, but Gearbox also made Duke Nukem Forever, so...

Gearbox’s attempt at an Aliens game was Aliens: Colonial Marines. Moody, atmospheric, and what seemed like pretty tense firefights with a dogged creature hell-bent on killing you, your friends, and anyone who may have ever heard your name in passing. But what we got was...a moody pile of garbage. When it worked it was underwhelming.

When it worked.

Because it didn’t. The Xenomorph AI was so poorly done that the game’s difficulty was more like a Mario Bros. title with moody lighting. And said lighting wasn’t as good as promised, either, due to a marked downgrade in graphics compared to tech demos.

Years after its release it would be discovered the AI impairment was due to a simple typo in the code. But the damage was already done. Sega canceled plans for a Wii U port, and any hope of a sequel died quicker than a space marine in a Xenomorph fist fight. More pressing was the class-action lawsuit over false advertising that resulted in Gearbox throwing Sega under the bus and leaving them to pay the plaintiffs $1.25 million.

Play Aliens: Fireteam Elite, instead, if you really need a space marine fix.


1. Ouya - A Console For Everyone

Ouya Console
Ouya, Inc.

Ouya’s self-titled video game console could probably earn a spot on this list itself, not the least of which being the controversy of whether or not it even qualified as a system. But there's a juicier story to tell. You see, when what some dubbed an overpriced smart phone surprised few by underperforming upon release, Ouya got a wild idea.

That idea was called the “Free The Games Fund”. Indie developers crowdfunding their games on Kickstarter would be eligible to see Ouya match whatever the campaign ended on - as long as it made at least $50,000. Unsurprisingly it didn’t take long for the titles that qualified to be called out for some shady business.

Accusations that many of the backers were fake abounded: Many of the profiles shared similar name and avatar styles and had never backed another project, but was suddenly throwing large sums of money on these random indie games. Along with the fact that at least one of these shady backer accounts matched a missing person’s report.

With such bad news as Kickstarter suspending the campaign of one of the projects and the founder of another threatening to sue people criticizing their claim to securing NFL licensing, developers started delisting their games from the Ouya in protest.

While some did eventually return, the whole idea turned out to be self-defeating. A console that already lacked games, couldn’t afford to lose the ones it did have. Unsurprisingly, after basically shutting down two years after that, the Ouya is considered one of the worst commercial disasters in gaming console history.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Overwatch 2
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Author of Escort (Eternal Press, 2015), co-founder of Nic3Ntertainment, and developer behind The Sickle Upon Sekigahara (2020). Currently freelancing as a game developer and history consultant. Also tends to travel the eastern U.S. doing courses on History, Writing, and Japanese Poetry. You can find his portfolio at www.richardcshaffer.com.