10 Massively Misleading Trailers NOTHING Like The Final Game

Buyer beware.

As video game trailers have become more lovingly made and often cinematic rather than reflective of actual in-game content, there’s been a growing disconnect between the game we think we’re getting from the trailer and the game that actually comes out.

This got particularly bad around five to ten years ago and there’s since been a consumer backlash that’s resulted in studios often adding a watermark to their trailers or demos to tell you whether they’re cinematic or depicting in-engine footage.

Even though things are arguably getting better, it was still a seminal point in time when gamers had to learn a hard lesson not to judge a game by its trailer. This isn’t to say the problem is entirely fixed as of 2021, but you’ll recognise a lot of these titles from a handful of years back.

I should say that though all these trailers led us astray, that doesn't mean the games that came out of them were necessarily bad. Unless you’re talking Aliens: Colonial Marines. Then it’s bad.


10. Aliens: Colonial Marines

Aliens Colonial Marines
Gearbox

Yeah, you knew this one was making an appearance so let’s just get it out of the way now and then we can talk about a game you probably actually like.

The 2013 FPS by Gearbox Software has garnered so much hate over the years that it’s pretty much a meme at this point. Expectations were set so high by all of the pre-release marketing, namely the trailers which depicted extraordinarily tense encounters with the titular aliens. The trailer is a genuinely chilling work of art showing the nigh-on hopeless struggle of the soldiers in their fight against one of fiction's greatest villains and if the game had delivered it would have been an absolute masterpiece.

It’s actually sort of depressing that the game in that trailer doesn’t exist because what we got instead was a buggy mess with really average graphics and a boring story.

Not to mention the fact that the game also appeared to have committed the cardinal sin of being released unfinished. Saying this one was lacking in polish is a really nice way of putting it.


9. Cyberpunk 2077

cyberpunk 2077 johnny
CD Projekt Red

There’s a whole pile of games that fall into the No Man’s Sky club of wildly overhyped video games that have no chance of delivering on their promises, but Cyberpunk 2077’s marketing to release transition rubbed too many gamers the wrong way to not include it here.

We were sitting on our hands for years waiting for Cyberpunk 2077 to come out, and for many of us the trailer had us at the neon-bathed locations teeming with life and quests, super tense encounters, and epic story beats. Of course, this is the problem with cinematic trailers where the pacing is tailored in a totally different way to the actual game. Though the biggest problem is exemplified by thisbarb’s comment on the official trailer which says “Wait a minute. Did I buy the wrong game?!”

In the lead up to its release the question of what the game even was and how it played circulated a lot and was never comprehensively answered.

Upon release the game was riddled with bugs, in dire need of a patch or three, and in such a bad state on last generation consoles that it had to be removed from the PS4 store front. On top of that, a lot of players reported that the world didn’t feel alive at all, missions felt grindy, and some touted features like the flow-on impact of your lifepath, story-altering player choices, and drone usage outside of specific missions just didn’t seem to happen at all.

Unfortunately, eight years of hype is pretty hard to live up to even if you’ve got a solid game, and while plenty of people enjoyed Cyberpunk 2077, plenty more felt super let down.


8. Doki Doki Literature Club

doki doki literature club
Team Salvato

You’re either the kind of person who’s into dating sims or wouldn’t touch one with a ten-foot pole. Now, I don’t judge you either way but I reckon anybody who watched the trailer for Doki Doki Literature Club and thought “that’s the game for me” did not end up enjoying it.

Personally, I think this game is masterful though there is a lot of front loaded actual dating-game mechanics to get through at the start which is a bit of a slog for those of us who don’t like dating sims.

That said, when things switch up they seriously switch up and you either know exactly what I’m talking about or you haven’t played the game yet and I’m not going to spoil it for you. Let’s just say things get horrendously dark to the point where you’ll want to throw on an old favourite sitcom when you’re done to wind down and get yourself some brain bleach.

The only thing in the trailer that’s representative of the game as a whole is the first line that reads “This game is not suitable for children or those who are easily disturbed.”

The trailer also features a lot of the characters in the game and some of the early game activities and chats you’ll engage in with them but that’s where the similarities stop. This is a trailer that’s intentionally misleading and for that we applaud it and happily pop it on our list.


7. Watch_Dogs

watch dogs
Ubisoft

Whenever anyone asks me about a game I was so hyped for that didn’t live up to my expectations my brain immediately goes to Watch Dogs.

What a trailer, what a premise. Ubisoft’s 2013 E3 showcase even brought out a gameplay trailer that looked absolutely beautiful. It actually looks a bit better than Watch Dogs: Legion does now.

Of course, that trailer was likely made by rendering out a vertical of the gameplay in the section of the world they’d elected to show off, so when gamers got the final release in their hands it looked significantly worse. On a personal note, the driving controls also physically hurt me.

Players also complained of the middling narrative that didn’t match up with the compelling story trailer, and issues with the hacking gameplay mechanics which seemed to work better in theory than in practice. Though it wasn’t the technical marvel gamers were promised, the game still has a lot of fans for trying something different which was exciting from Ubi who at this point were on their 14th Assassin’s Creed game.

On the upside, Watch Dogs 2 was an absolute hit, probably thanks to the far more chill level of anticipation from fans who felt duped by the original.


6. Crackdown 3

Crackdown 3
Microsoft

Crackdown 3 is yet another example of what happens when you take years to release a game and can’t match up to the hype that’s naturally escalated over that time.

Even if you don’t know anything about the Crackdown series, you probably remember the Crackdown 3 trailers featuring Terry Crews who absolutely gave us the impression someone stole his yoghurt. The trailers made it look like chaotic, bombastic fun for the new generation but what gamers got was just more of the same old same old Crackdown.

Now, that’s fine if that’s all you were after but there wasn’t anything that set this game apart like the trailer suggested. One of the big selling points was the 2015 trailer’s claim that there’d be one hundred percent destructible environments. This didn’t happen at all. It was supposed to be implemented in a competitive multiplayer mode which, even then, wouldn’t let you destroy everything, but that was quickly abandoned too.

The 2015 trailer said that Crackdown 3 would be delivering the classic gameplay in a brand new way. Well, at least they were half right.


5. Anthem

Anthem game
Bioware

Another game we can pop in the ‘oof’ category is the gloriously promising and ultimately underwhelming Anthem.

BioWare games are so generally celebrated that pretty much everybody I know went and played all the Mass Effect games again when Legendary Edition came out. I’m actually still working through them on Twitch right now and why not, they’re great games. But it’s the almost universal love for these games, and Dragon Age, that had gamers amped up for Anthem.

Though we had received Mass Effect Andromeda two years prior, so maybe we should have been prepared. Anthem’s pre-release trailers were gorgeous, laced with intriguing story beats, and included what looked to be super exciting co-op combat.

Anthem still has you hooked out the gate because it’s absolutely beautiful, then you start playing and it all pretty much falls apart from there.

Combat was painful, the mission structure was tired and repetitive, it was buggy as all get out, and the story was incredibly weak. It seemed that Anthem tried so hard to be the next Destiny killer, it wasn’t much of anything on its own two feet. The studio completely dropped the ball on everything but the traversal and just two years after its launch EA announced they’d be pulling the plug on the game.


4. Brütal Legend

Brutal Legend
Double Fine

If you know anything about Brütal Legend it’s that the game stars Jack Black, it’s an ode to heavy metal, and it’s an action game where you run in and hit things with your giant axe, right?

Well you’re right on the first two but you’d be forgiven for assuming the third given that publisher Vivendi absolutely buried the lead that the game was more of a real-time strategy. That’s because they thought a hack-and-slash game would sell better, which would be fine if that's what they actually had on their hands. The trailers absolutely make it look like the game is a fast-paced action romp, and the publisher even released a demo that led players to believe the combat would be more hack-and-slash oriented than it is. You have to feel bad for the players who ran into battle head-first and couldn’t figure out why they kept dying.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m definitely not saying the game is bad, but the effort that went into trying to frame the game as something that it wasn’t in pre-release trailers was remarkably weird.


3. No Man’s Sky

No Mans Sky
Hello Games

I hate to put No Man’s Sky on these lists because I feel like that studio has had more than enough pile on hate for one lifetime but it has to be said, nobody expected this game from that trailer.

And by ‘this game’, I, of course, mean what arrived at launch. No Man’s Sky is a completely different beast now and one that far more players are genuinely enjoying. At launch though, well we return to “oof”. Those on the studio’s side say it was a matter of misinterpreting scope and accidentally making false promises while some gamers still call the difference between the marketing and what was released as an outright scam. At its core the trailer seems to be somewhat accurate. The worlds look about right though they’re far less densely populated with interesting flora and fauna than suggested, and it is largely about exploration which seemed to be the case.

That’s sort of where the similarities stop, though.

Procedurally generating a universe meant that a lot of the time players were landing on really boring, often repetitive, and sparse planets. The space battles of the trailer were pretty much nowhere to be seen until a post-release patch, multiplayer was absent, and the basic quest structure was maddeningly repetitive, largely asking you to find the same sorts of things to fulfill the same sorts of tasks for reasons that were ambiguous at best.

It’s really admirable to see how far the game has come in the years since and whoever you want to put the blame on, we can all agree this is a prime example of the dangerous industry hype machine.


2. BioShock Infinite

Bioshock Infinite Elizabeth
2K Games

I really loved BioShock Infinite, for the record, but there’s a fair few things that don’t add up between its trailer and the final product.

The visual design is pretty spot on but otherwise the announcement trailer was a somewhat eerie sequence of you falling through the air, spotting Elizabeth and her calling you over on a floating sea of roses before a metallic hand grabs her and you continue plummeting. Irrational’s first early gameplay demonstration depicted a far darker Colombia than the one realised in BioShock Infinite. It’s significantly more cold and lifeless, inhabited by power-wielding villains and feeling far more like BioShock’s Rapture.

The gameplay is similar, but Elizabeth is shown to be an AI companion capable of powerful magic, not just, you know, someone who throws you ammo.

Why Irrational didn’t go down this route is unclear, though we know Infinite’s development wasn’t exactly smooth sailing. Plenty of mechanics and ideas clearly needed to be dropped due to them not being practically feasible with the technology of the time, or the inevitable need to narrow the game’s scope.

Even still, when the game’s that good without its full breadth of ideas you can’t be too upset.


1. Dead Island

Dead Island Definitive Collection
Deep Silver

Dead Island is not a game with an emotional story about the zombie-riddled post-apocalypse. There’s no heartfelt Lee and Clementine relationship at the core, nor is there a deep and emotional mechanic that alters the game around your player choices.

It kinda seemed that way, though, since Dead Island had one of the most emotional announcement trailers we’ve ever seen.

Watching a little girl run for her life and fight to survive alongside her family is absolutely heartbreaking and harrowing. It’s really quite genius on the production side, the whole thing plays in reverse and is super artistic, it just doesn’t really make sense for the game it’s advertising which is anything but sincere. The trailer did get two things right: there are, in fact, a lot of zombies, and the game is set in a tropical holiday resort. Dead Island, in essence, is an open world game where you craft cool weapons and kill stuff. Mostly zombie stuff. And some characters yell “Yeah, bitch!” when they get a kill.

I don’t think anybody yelled “Yeah, bitch” when the Dad had to throw his little zombie daughter out the window but, the trailer isn’t voiced and I don’t want to assume.

The Dead Island 2 trailer is far more upbeat, but that came out seven years ago with no game release date in sight, so it’s safe to say that one is firmly in development hell. Maybe it’ll be a Last of Us-esque emotional tale about the heartbreaking horrors of the zombie apocalypse, who knows.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Crackdown 3
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jess has been a journalist and content creator in the games industry for over 15 years and has been WhatCulture's resident Australian import and sorry cop since 2020, upping the quotient of swearing and apologising in WhatCulture Gaming's annual blooper videos considerably. She previously worked at GameSpot for 10 years, most notably hosting GameSpot News in addition to E3 live shows, and PAX panels. She regularly livestreams a variety of games on her 'jessmcdonell' YouTube and Twitch channels and hosts the 'Do It On The Day' podcast. She has won awards for her news and feature work in gaming as well as an accolade for her comedic writing (likely an admin error). She can be found on X at @jessmcdonell and Instagram at @jessicamcdonell sharing her current videogame fixations, industry insights, and videos of her cat, Karma.