10 Modern Video Game Tropes Everyone Is Rejecting

The MCU-ification of game dialogue really sucks.

Forspoken cuff
Square Enix

Like everywhere else in pop-culture, trends come and go within the world of video games. As developers and publishers alike experiment with different ideas in the hopes of innovation and giving us something new, we can see a shift in the games we play where the ideas that work stick around for a while. The more successful an idea is, the longer its likelier to exist for.

Some of these ideas like the introduction of an analogue sticks, rumble pads in controllers, and figuring out that the left and right triggers are more intuitive than face buttons for driving have forever changed the games we play for the better.

Likewise, terrible ideas like loot boxes, purchasable online passes, and ridiculously overpriced DLC like Oblivion’s infamous horse armour have since been cast aside (even if it took a lot of push back from players).

Sometimes, though, what once seemed like clever ideas can quickly overstay their welcome if they become overused. After a while, the innovation loses its sheen and we’re left with tired tropes that feel outdated and lazy.

The sooner developers leave these tropes behind, the faster the industry can take another step towards in the right direction.

10. The Shift To Tiny Side Quests

Assassin's Creed Valhalla - Mystery
Ubisoft

Side quests have been a common occurrence within video games for decades. Extra pieces of content that gave us more to do outside of progressing the main story, these can be found everyone in contemporary games.

However, developers have never been sure on the best ways to handle them. For years, a side quest consisted of completing tedious fetch quests or other meaningless pieces of busywork. They were lazy means of padding out a game’s length without adding anything of substance.

And then The Witcher 3 and Assassin’s Creed Origins came along and changed everything by transforming side quests into their own character-driven stories that tied into the overarching plot.

In both these games, side quests provided something new and interesting to experience. Hunting out these quests were now worth our time. But, for some unknown reason, developers have taken two steps backwards by making side quests even smaller than ever.

Whether it’s Mysteries in Assassin’s Creed Valhalla or Cyberpunk’s singular objective Gigs, extra content has been diluted to bite-sized chunks of largely forgettable interactions that don’t add much, if anything, to the overall experience.

A return to The Witcher-style of quests would be ideal.


9. Every Game Having Its Own Eagle Vision

Assassin's Creed Eagle Vision
Ubisoft

One of the most unique aspects of the Assassin’s Creed series was the inclusion of what it called Eagle Vision. When activated, it highlighted enemies and targets, giving us a means to plan our next move and feel more like a skilled assassin. Around the same time, Arkham Asylum included a Detective Vision which, alongside enabling the caped crusader to examine vital clues, allowed us to locate enemies in the area.

Ever since then, having a version of these modes has become a common trope within modern games. Corvo had his Dark Vision in Dishonored, Geralt had his Witcher senses, and V could use their Kiroshi Optics implant to scan the environment. And that’s just a tiny selection of examples.

Within these examples, there’s an in-game reason why the character can see through solid walls, whether it be supernatural or technological. However, this trope has become so prolific that there doesn’t need to be any rhyme or reason to why characters have this superhuman power. The most egregious examples are Agent 47’s Hitman Vision or Joel’s listen ability in The Last Of Us.

There becomes a point in which pushing a button to show all the enemies removes most of the challenge.


8. Bullet Sponge Bosses

Destiny 2 - Savathun
Bungie

It's a trope that's been around for as long as games have, and yet bullet sponge boss fights have yet to be left in the past.

Designed to be harder and more challenging than any of the grunts and basic enemies you’ve been fighting, bosses are supposed to be tough and will need more than a few hits to take them out. They wouldn’t be much of a challenge if all it took to beat them was one well-placed headshot.

Go too far in the other direction and give said boss too much health, however, results in a different problem. Now the fight has become a prolonged slog comprised of chipping away at a hyperbolic health bar.

While adding multiple stages to longer boss fights can add some variety to the mix (look no further than Dark Souls to see how that’s done), plenty of games take the path of least resistance by sticking an uninspired showdown in a forgettable arena, with Destiny 2’s immensely powerful bosses being some of the worst examples in recent years.

Just as irritating is when boss battles are more about fighting waves of enemies than the boss itself. We're looking at you, Halo Infinite.


7. Forced Stealth Sections

spider man mary jane stealth
Sony

Variety in level design is a straightforward way to stop gameplay from becoming tedious. Nobody likes doing the same kind of objective repetitively for several hours at a time. It keeps the action fresh and exciting while offering the potential for imaginative and interesting challenges. Look no further than Psychonauts 2 or Neir: Automata’s constantly shifting gameplay to see how invigorating it can be.

But for some developers, gameplay variety is as unimaginative as adding in some stealth sections to stretch out a game.

Games with a specific focus on stealth can give rise to some rewarding challenges where skill, patience, and creativity payoff in satisfying ways. Even better is when detection isn’t an automatic game over, with the likes of Deathloop, Hitman, and A Plague Tale: Requiem showing how it’s done. But to some developers, stealth is little more than adding a crouch button, some cover, and an instant failure when spotted.

There’s nothing fun about forcing players into unneeded sneak sessions, especially if they’re entirely unnecessary. Titles like Observer, Call Of Cthulhu, and even 2018’s Spider-Man fell prey to this trope which was consequently met by unanimous groans.

Please, developers. No more unneeded stealth sections.


6. Battle Royales Everywhere

vampire the masquerade blood hunt
Sharkmob AB

Thanks to the mammoth success of the likes of Fortnite and PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds in the late 2010s, the Battle Royale format has since become part of what seems like every other game that's released.

Since then, Call Of Duty: Warzone, Rocket League, Forza Horizon 5, and Tetris 99 have joined the fray by adding their own version of the game mode. Even Halo Infinite looks to be getting one of its own, with rumours as recent as September 2022 all but confirming the news.

When done right, Battle Royales can provide nail-biting tension as player numbers dwindle and victory edges ever closer. It’s this reason which made the genre as immensely popular as it was in the first place. But just because a game can have one, it doesn’t mean that it should.

With so many iterations of Battle Royales from every possible angle, the news of another one being introduced generates more eyerolls than excitement for what has become another developer jumping on a bandwagon that left a long time ago.

Most annoying is that the ubiquity of Battle Royales detract attention from the ones that are genuinely excellent and unique such as Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodhunt.


5. Season Passes And In-Game Stores

Halo Infinite Season Pass
Xbox Game Studios

Just when we thought we got rid of the predatory invasiveness of microtransactions and loot boxes, greedy executives found another means of wringing as much money out of our pockets as possible. This is, of course, Season Passes.

Sometimes called Battle Passes, these are purchasable passes that give players access to extra content for the duration of a set season. With the rise of free-to-play games and the live-service gaming model, the Battle Pass option sounds like a reasonable means for a project to earn money over a longer period to support development while giving players shiny cosmetics without the need for any nefarious loot boxes.

However, the problems begin to appear when you notice how expensive these items can be. Especially when players have already purchased the game in question, asking them to shell-out around $10-$20 to get those premium items all adds up. Even worse is the gigantic cost of cosmetics in in-game stores, with it reportedly costing over $1000 to purchase everything in Halo Infinite’s first season.

While games like Sea Of Thieves have included versions of Battle Passes that are far less intrusive and cost effective, this tactic is becoming increasingly exploitative.


4. Game Worlds Always Getting Bigger

Cyberpunk Map
CD Projekt

Whenever a new game is announced, especially if it’s a new entry in a series, the chances are that at some point someone is going to boast about how unimaginably massive the map is. It’s only recently that Bethesda have revealed that upcoming sci-fi RPG Starfield will have 1000 planets for us to explore.

While the prospect of exploring a digital universe of this size suggests hundreds of hours of storytelling potential, bigger doesn’t necessarily mean better. That’s a lesson we’ve learned on several occasions.

The promise of a sprawling map is a promise for epic adventures set within a variety of different areas to explore and discover. This was the case when it came to Skyrim and The Witcher 3, with each new undiscovered location containing something worth seeking out.

However, a game’s world is only as good as the content that’s in it. And as maps get increasingly bigger, it becomes harder to fill them with meaningful encounters.

The sprawling streets of Cyberpunk's Night City make for a wonderfully realised dystopian setting. However, it's vast, empty areas and overreliance on side content to fill the map detracts from the overall experience of an otherwise excellent game.


3. Four Player Co-Op Games

Phasmophobia How To Play Prison Map By Downloading Beta Update
Kinetic Games

While there are countless and excellent games that are designed to be a single-player experience, there are likewise plenty of other excellent ones out there which are best enjoyed with friends. Whether it’s enjoying some couch co-op, setting out on a quest with a group, or getting everyone together for an evening of party games, company is always welcome.

What we don’t need more of, though, is more four-player co-op games. Especially within the horror genre.

Titles like Left 4 Dead and its sequel showed how exhilarating the four-player format could be for a horror experience, with the more recent likes of Phasmophobia’s co-operative ghost hunting gameplay proving how well it can work when done right. However, this formula has since become the go-to template for developers to jump on the latest trend.

In just the last few years, we’ve seen the likes of Devour, Back 4 Blood, GTFO, Pacify, Ghost Watchers, Lunch Lady, Forwarned, Sign Of Silence, and Labyrinthine just to name a few. And that’s not mentioning the plethora of asymmetrical horrors out there either.

Though there’s nothing specifically wrong with this format, the burnout has started to set in at this point.


2. Characters Acting Differently In Cutscenes/Ludonarrative Dissonance

Resident Evil Village Lady Dimitrescu
Capcom

The latter very much being an "academic" term, this trope is becoming increasingly more noticeable the more we've become made aware of it.

In short, this trope is when the actions a protagonist makes during gameplay don't match with how they're portrayed during cutscenes. One of the more blatant examples of this appeared in the Tomb Raider reboot in which Lara is shown to be deeply troubled with killing to survive within cutscenes, but effortlessly massacres dozens of enemies during the game.

Another and equally irksome example of this is when our over-powered and very competent hero becomes uncharacteristically foolish when it's time to move the plot forward and suffers a defeat or horrible injury that wouldn't have occurred had we still been in control.

Despite Ethan Winters of Resident Evil Village fending off hordes of infected alongside defeating powerful bosses, he nevertheless has a terrible habit of letting his guard down whenever there's a cutscene. It's these blunders which result in him getting in even worse situations.

Games like The Last Of Us Part II and Red Dead Redemption 2 have shown that it's possible for gameplay to feed into the narrative experience, so a future without this trope is possible.


1. "Quirky" Dialogue

Forspoken Game
Square Enix

Due for release in January 2023, Forspoken is set to be an epic fantasy adventure from Square Enix, which sees protagonist Frey transported to a sprawling world of magic and monsters in which she must use her newfound powers to get home.

With an expansive trailer highlighting an imaginative world, zippy traversal, and hinting at a grand story the developers are planning to tell, Forspoken looks like a solid entry into the PS5's library.

That is, however, if we forget about Cuff, a sentient magical bracelet who looks to be Frey's comedic sidekick.

While it's unclear what role this talking accessory will play in the wider scope the plot, his sardonic dialogue feels tonally out of place in the trailer. Smacking of a postmodern comedy style that peaked with Portal 2's Wheatley, Forspoken's comedy comes ten years too late.

As we saw with the bemused reception that met the Saints Row reboot, the era of "quirky" comedy has long since passed its best before date. While it is possible that Cuff could surprise us all, his brief appearance in the trailer doesn't bode well.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Forspoken
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Glasgow-based cinephile who earned a Masters degree in film studies to spend their time writing about cinema, video games, and horror.