10 More Video Games Cancelled For Ridiculous Reasons
When promising games got kicked to the curb.
It's a simple fact of the video game industry that far more games are cancelled than we ever actually hear about, but when a game has been public knowledge for a certain amount of time, a cancellation can really sting fans.
It hurts all the more if the game in question both looked extremely promising and was ultimately cancelled for reasons which fans find unacceptable, perhaps even ridiculous.
While there are undoubtedly myriad business calculations that go into the tough decision to cancel any video game, these titles were all cut loose with a rationale players couldn't even begin to comprehend.
From long-awaited games that were basically completed yet remain frustratingly unreleased, to cowardly publishers who refused to make a bold bet and complete an enticing project, to those who just frittered away the production budget on strippers and booze, these 10 games never came to fruition for unconscionable reasons.
While there's the remote possibly that one or two of these games could be revived in the future, for the sake of your own sanity you're better off just assuming they're deader than disco...
10. LucasArts & Free Radical Design Couldn't Agree On Anything - Star Wars: Battlefront III
After the first two Star Wars: Battlefront games were released in 2004 and 2005 respectively, it was reasonable to assume that a trilogy-capping entry into the franchise would be released in 2006 or 2007.
LucasArts ultimately hired Free Radical Design (TimeSplitters) to replace the developer of the first two games, Pandemic Studios, yet in 2008, after Battlefront III had been in development for roughly two years, Free Radical announced they had lost the rights to finish the game.
According to the company's co-founder Steve Ellis, Battlefront III was mostly finished, but LucasArts didn't want to commit to the marketing spend necessary to promote a Star Wars game, while an anonymous LucasArts employee claimed Free Radical weren't devoting adequate resources to development and missed deadlines as a result.
Gameplay footage from various leaked sources at least confirms the game to have been in an advanced state of development, and in 2016 a leaked build was even posted online, playable with a modded Xbox 360.
Ultimately the blame can't be squarely aimed at either Free Radical or LucasArts: it's clear their visions for the project weren't at all aligned, and each side had major problems with the way the other conducted business.
The result was fans missing out on a hugely anticipated sequel and the franchise sitting dormant for almost an entire decade. What a waste.
9. The Budget Was Spent On Booze, Restaurants & Strippers - Ant Simulator
Though it wasn't nearly as hyped as Battlefront III (obviously), Ant Simulator did nevertheless capture the Internet's imagination with its novel what-you-see-is-what-you-get concept.
Ant Simulator was a project spearheaded by Eric Tereshinski, who acquired $4,400 in development funds by creating a series of game creation YouTube tutorials via Kickstarter.
However, in early 2016 Tereshinski posted a video announcing that his two business partners, Tyler Monce and Devon Staley, had spent both the initial funding and also some additional development money on hitting the town. He said:
"They had secretly spent the overwhelming majority of both our Kickstarter money and the Ant Simulator investment money on liquor, restaurants, bars, and even strippers."
For their part, Monce and Staley refuted the claims and even considered legal action, but all the same, production on Ant Simulator was shuttered without sufficient funding to complete it, and has scarcely been spoken about since.
8. The Publisher Pursued Another Fallout Game Instead (Which Also Got Cancelled) - Fallout: Van Buren
Van Buren was the original version of what would eventually become Fallout 3, as developed by the series' original Black Isle Studios outfit in the early 2000s.
However, publisher Interplay Entertainment were decidedly more interested in bolstering their console division, developing their PS2/Xbox Fallout game Brotherhood of Steel at the same time.
In fact, Interplay so high on the idea of Brotherhood of Steel that they actually commissioned a sequel before it had even been released.
Worse still, they pulled Black Isle team members off development of Van Buren, which was very nearly complete, so that many of them could work on Brotherhood of Steel 2 instead.
Ironically, Brotherhood of Steel 2 never came to fruition after the critical and commercial failure of the original in 2004, and amid major financial issues, Interplay ended up laying off the entire Black Isle team in late 2003, effectively killing any prospect of Van Buren's completion.
Fallout 3 was of course eventually made by Bethesda and released in 2008, while numerous former Black Isle staff members went on to work for Fallout: New Vegas developers Obsidian Entertainment, allowing them to incorporate some of their ideas from Van Buren in the process.
7. Because Of COVID-19 - Anthem Next
BioWare's Anthem was widely expected to be the next big thing for the "live service" AAA shooter, so the world was shocked when it released to aggressively mediocre reviews, decrying its blandly formulaic story and gameplay, generic open-world format, and myriad technical issues.
In February 2020, a year after the game's initial release, BioWare announced that they were planning to give Anthem the Final Fantasy XIV-esque "soft-reboot" treatment, with a team of 30 employees committed to figuring out how to re-shape the game.
But another year on, BioWare confirmed that their Anthem Next revision had been cancelled, citing the challenges caused by the COVID-19 pandemic:
"Working from home during the pandemic has had an impact on our productivity and not everything we had planned as a studio before COVID-19 can be accomplished without putting undue stress on our teams."
While there's no denying that the pandemic has severely hampered games development around the world, and BioWare's stance is a sympathetic one to an extent, it's also not a particularly convincing excuse for shuttering a game most had already given up on.
With so many AAA video games still making it to release, it's far more likely that BioWare and EA basically used COVID-19 and a desire to avoid crunch as a scapegoat for discontinuing support.
In reality, they probably crunched the numbers and realised that it's not financially viable to try and reboot a project that interest has already waned in.
6. Konami Didn't Believe In The Dreamcast - Castlevania: Resurrection
Castlevania: Resurrection was originally intended to be released in March 2000, and in addition to being a more action-centric Castlevania game, was also supposed to be the series' first foray on the Sega Dreamcast.
But Resurrection was quietly cancelled, and according to the game's art director Greg Orduyan, this was at least in part due to a general lack of faith about the Dreamcast's ability to perform in the crowded gaming market.
Sega's console had admittedly gotten off to a slow start, but the irony is that this precise mindset and unwillingness to roll the dice on such an ambitious piece of hardware is precisely why the Dreamcast failed.
Somewhat ironically, Resurrection was cancelled the very same day that Sony announced the PS2, seemingly hammering two nails into the Dreamcast's coffin at once.
While being wary of new tech is one thing, getting a game into a clearly deep stage of development only to shelve it is something else altogether.
5. It Was "Too Linear" - Project Ragtag
You won't find many cancelled games more often lamented than Project Ragtag, the third-person, single-player Star Wars game that began development at Visceral Games (Dead Space) in 2013.
With Uncharted creator Amy Hennig directing the game, which would revolve around a heist set in the wake of A New Hope, expectations were high for Star Wars to basically get the glossy, high-octane Uncharted makeover treatment.
However, the mammoth commercial success of Star Wars Battlefront in 2015 caused EA to lose interest in Ragtag, diverting resources to the development of Battlefront II while preventing Visceral from hiring more team members.
Throughout 2016 many Visceral employees were either laid off or quit, and though the remaining team worked hard to hammer the game into shape, in October 2017 Visceral was closed, with development being handed off to EA Vancouver.
EA cited the personnel change as a result of the original game's linear, story-heavy style, hoping to reboot it as "a broader experience that allows for more variety and player agency."
Despite this, reports emerged by early 2019 that the new version of Ragtag had also been cancelled.
On top of all this, the original Ragtag's cancellation seemed all the more baffling given that EA went on to release the entirely single-player Jedi Fallen Order in November 2019.
4. Nazi Iconography Prevented Selling It In Germany - Indiana Jones & The Iron Phoenix
Before any project is formally greenlit, it's important for producers and publishers to do their damn homework, which they evidently didn't on Indiana Jones and The Iron Phoenix, the planned sequel to 1992's point-and-click adventure game sequel Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis.
The story was to be set after World War II, with the Nazis attempting to retrieve the Philosopher's Stone to resurrect Hitler and the Wehrmacht, forcing Indy to spring into action.
This sounds neat enough, but development was met with numerous obstacles, including an inability to settle on a consistent aesthetic, and the departure of the main programmer, Aric Wilmunder, early in production.
But the final straw for LucasArts was the realisation that the game wouldn't be releasable in Germany due to censorship laws preventing use of Nazi imagery such as Swastikas.
Given that Hitler was the primary antagonist and the game was set to be awash in Nazi iconography, the decision was made to discontinue development after a year of work, at which point it was adapted into a Dark Horse Comics series instead.
Even though adventure games performed extremely well in Germany at the time, was the German video game market really substantial enough that it merited cancelling the entire game for the rest of the world?
3. Sony Made The Developers Finish Lair Instead - Animal Wars
Animal Wars was an action-RPG from Factor 5 (Star Wars: Rogue Squadron) that began development in 2004 as a PS3 exclusive. Per its title, the game would focus on anthropomorphic animals battling one another during The Great War.
Despite the extensive concept art leaked for the game, development was basically undertaken by a skeleton crew.
And before much of the game could actually be assembled, Factor 5's relationship with Sony began to curdle, as the studio's bigger PS3 exclusive, Lair, was struggling through development.
As a result, Sony cut off funding intended for Animal Wars and funnelled it instead into Lair, forcing them to complete that game while leaving no money behind for Animal Wars, causing its de facto cancellation.
The tragic irony is that Lair went on to receive wildly mixed reviews and tank commercially, while those who worked on Animal Wars insist that it was an extremely promising project, far more so than Lair.
2. Microsoft Felt Expectations Were Too High - Scalebound
PlatinumGames' action-RPG Scalebound was first announced at E3 2014 to a rapturous response, seeming to basically deliver Devil May Cry with dragons.
Though word on the game was suspiciously quiet in the years that followed, Scalebound's cancellation in early 2017 still came as a huge shock to the industry.
Considering that the game seemed to be relatively far along in development in the few gameplay snippets released to the public, it was tough to imagine how things could've gone so wrong that the game was cancelled entirely.
Some months later, Xbox head Phil Spencer suggested the game had been cancelled because Microsoft came to realise it couldn't even begin to live up to fan expectations.
He freely admitted Scalebound was revealed too soon, while PlatinumGames studio head Atsushi Inaba felt that the cancellation was a result of both sides failing to deliver on their promises.
Scalebound's cancellation was so baffling to players that many remain convinced the game could one day be reintroduced, especially as Inaba has confirmed he'd love to return to it.
1. Two Team Members Were Almost Crunched To Death - Sonic X-Treme
Sonic X-treme began development in 1994 and was intended to be both the first ever 3D Sonic the Hedgehog game and the first original Sonic game on the Sega Saturn.
Despite the obvious appeal of such an ambitious project, setbacks were numerous, from political divisions within the Sega Technical Institute to the challenges of developing for 3D, to the Saturn being a difficult platform to program for.
To meet the intense deadline imposed upon the team by Sega of Japan, programmer Chris Coffin cancelled his apartment lease and moved into the office, working 16-20 hours per day to finish the game.
Four months before Sonic X-treme's December 1996 deadline, Coffin contracted severe pneumonia and designer Chris Senn became so ill with exhaustion, having lost considerable weight, that he was told by a doctor he could be dead within six months.
And so, two months before the deadline, producer Mike Wallis pulled the plug on the game, citing the inability to get it finished with two of the most pivotal talents out of commission.
Now of course, no video game is worth the health or, worse, the lives of the people creating it, though this really just speaks to how absurd crunch culture truly was back in the '90s, let alone today.
It's only ridiculous because it clearly didn't have to be this way, but Sega was so desperate for a lucrative Christmas 1996 release that they encouraged their employees to damn-near kill themselves.
Had a realistic release target had been set, perhaps mid-1997, then Coffin and Senn would've had a much better time, and fans would've actually gotten the damn game. And all it would've taken was Sega executives making slightly less that quarter.