10 Most Broken Escort Missions In Gaming History

A bad escort mission is truly one of the worst things in video games. These 10 absolutely suck...

sheva resident evil 5
Capcom

Plenty of people would argue that any escort mission qualifies for a ‘most broken escort mission’ list. They’re truly one of the worst things in video games, but I’ve really tried to whittle it down here.

There’s nothing that muddies the hero story quite like being followed by, holding the hand of, or in some cases literally carrying another person along with you. Especially one that the developers haven’t designed to be remotely self-sufficient or useful.

10. Princess Ruto In Jabu-Jabu’s Belly - The Legend Of Zelda: Ocarina Of Time

zelda belly
Nintendo

There’s a decent chance I’m about to unlock a memory here, because when I thought back to Ocarina of Time I couldn’t even remember an escort mission. Then the nightmare whale full of holes and the princess living its belly all came rushing back.

The reason Princess Ruto is just scraping in on this list is at least she straight up refuses to walk, so she can’t exactly get far if you drop her. On the other hand she straight up refuses to walk. For the uninitiated, Link’s job, and therefore your job, is to save Princess Ruto from inside Jabu-Jabu’s belly. Not only do you have to carry her around, she’s super rude about it, has a tendency to fall through holes, and if you leave her behind she’ll revert back to the original spot she fell to in the beginning and you have to go get her.

The pros are she can’t die and you can chuck her at enemies, the cons are, well, pretty much everything else.


9. For Pete’s Sake - Earthworm Jim

for pete's sake earthworm jim
Shiny Entertainment

Normally dogs in games make everything better, but things aren’t all they seem with the Jekyll and Hyde stylings of Peter Puppy.

The level ‘For Pete’s Sake’ features a clueless dog jovially strutting his way through the stage, but he’ll require your help. He can’t jump without you and if he takes any amount of damage he turns into a snarling murder dog who bites you, zapping you back to earlier in the level with less health. Yeah. Hard left there.

The level isn’t awful in and of itself but having to redo parts because you have to look out for someone else’s skin and not just your own is a pain. Also the overgrown mass of purple dog and teeth is genuinely creepy.

If that sounds crappy, Earthworm Jim 2 had you running back and forth to stop tossed puppies from splatting on the ground, so that’s a whole new level of agonizing.


8. Galen’s Escape - World Of Warcraft

World of Warcraft is positively notorious for its crappy escort missions, possibly none worse than Galen who seems dead set on making sure you both don’t make it out of there alive.

In the Galen’s Escape quest you find Galen in the Swamp of Sorrows, free him from a cage, and then he proceeds to try to get himself killed in various ways. Some players actually recommend emptying out the Swamp of foes before you let this timebomb out. He moves fast, pulls a tonne of enemies to you, and sometimes runs off and agros more enemies just in case you weren’t having a crap enough time.

He also has like no armour, isn’t healable, and, when given the choice, he’ll tromp right through an enemy camp instead of literally any other option. Fun.


7. Sheva - Resident Evil 5

Resident Evil 5 Sheva
Capcom

I know this is the first survival horror on this list but, boy howdy, it will not be the last. Can I pull off boy howdy? No, I don’t think I can. Let me know in the comments, but let’s talk about something even more painful than hearing me say that: escorting Sheva.

Resident Evil 5’s Sheva Alomar may be a stone cold fox but if you don’t have a friend to play as her you’re at the mercy of her AI which, to be nice about it, leaves a lot to be desired. Essentially what you’ll be left with is a game that’s basically one long escort mission. Despite looking precisely like the kind of badass you’d want watching your back, it turns out that due to some wildly clunky programming she rampages through ammo and supplies like it’s going out of style--

And let’s remember this is a survival horror game where that stuff is pretty bloody important--

She also manages to consistently stand exactly where you don’t want her to and bizarrely defaults to using her weakest weapons.

Of course, if she dies, you go back to the last checkpoint and lose a handful of years off your life out of frustration.


6. The Alchemist - Spyro 2

spyro 2
Universal Interactive Studio

Now this one is actually pretty easy... once you’ve played it through so many times you’ve committed his precise pathing to memory. Walk in the park.

Much like the dog that goes evil when he gets hit, in Spyro 2: Ripto’s Rage, you’ll need to protect the Alchemist as he persistently puts himself in harm's way by sidling right up to Earthshapers who want to kill him and you, instead of doing literally anything else. The Alchemist is delivering a potion to Hunter to cure his stone-encased feet, but you’d assume he must have some kind of problem with the Cheetah since he’s doing his darndest to take the worst possible route.

To add insult to maddening pathing injury, he pretty much dies after one hit, so chances are if you played Spyro 2 as a kid, this mission is not a favourite memory.


5. Every Eileen Mission - Silent Hill 4: The Room

Silent Hill 4
Konami

Plenty of horror game fans actually liked Silent Hill 4: The Room. What most of them didn’t like was every Eileen escort mission.

It’s at about the game’s midpoint when Henry Townshend’s neighbor Eileen is nearly beaten to death by Walter Sullivan. Now, that’s awful, but I’m betting you’ll feel less and less sorry for her as for the rest of the game her broken limbs become your problem.

The fact that Eileen can’t die sounds like it should take a load off your stress level, but the endings of the game change based on how injured she becomes.

Much like many of the other escortees on this list, Eileen is a dummy, or she’s programmed to be a dummy. Either way you end up babysitting a companion who, if you decide to give her a weapon, pointlessly tries to beat up on ghosts, brings a handbag to a shotgun fight, complains constantly, and is slow as hell.

She fights slowly and poorly if she fights at all, cuts your speed in half, and she can’t be healed so… I hope you had fun in the first half of the game.


4. Natalya - Goldeneye: 007

Natalya goldeneye
Eon Productions

Goldeneye’s Natalya may indeed be a Russian super-hacker but judging by the amount of time it takes for her to do anything, it’s possible she’s not a very good one.

Whether she’s at a computer or running alongside you, she’s never not a pain. There’s also a decent chance she magnetises to gunfire since her head always seems to be right between you and the guys who are shooting at you. Goldeneye: 007 is an absolute classic, but the section where you have to defend Natalya while she’s hacking may cause your eyeballs to pop out of your head.

The enemies are infinitely spawning, Natalya is taking her sweet time, and she also loves running ahead of you just in case she isn’t already in somebody’s sightline.


3. Legitimately Every Survivor Mission - Dead Rising

Dead Rising 01
Capcom

Dead Rising was a bit of a phenomenon when it came out in 2006 meaning A) you probably played it and B) me mentioning the escort missions may send you into a spiral.

See, the people of Willamette are so stupid they may in fact deserve to be eaten by zombie hordes. Throughout the game Frank comes across humans trapped by the undead who he needs to escort back to the safe room. But trying to save these guys from themselves is an absolute headache.

They run into walls, sprint toward gangs of enemies like they’re meeting old friends, and though they have weapons they’re almost completely incapable of using them.

It’s easily the fastest way to make the zombie apocalypse even less fun.


2. Amy - Amy

Amy video game
Lexis Numérique

You may not have come across the 2012 survival game Amy and, rest assured, after this video you won’t want to.

Instead of helping someone genuinely helpless through a crazy dangerous situation, you are the helpless person. That’s more fun than being the protagonist, right? On top of that your comrade isn’t a gun-toting house of bullets and brawn but a little girl called Amy.

Okay, she has superpowers that help her kill zombies, but she’s still a kid. And you’re, as I mentioned, useless.

It’s still mind-boggling what sort of sadistic dev team decided this is what video games really needed. Get too far from your child super-saviour, you die, try to speed up from her absolute snails pace, you die. I’m kind of cheating because this is a whole game and not a mission but just take this as a PSA. Look, the concept is cool, the execution is absolutely brain breaking.

There’s a reason it’s sitting at 25% on metacritic. If you want to escort a super kid go play A Plague Tale: Innocence instead.


1. Emma Emmerich - Metal Gear Solid 2

Metal Gear Emma Emmerich
Konami

If you’ve played all of Metal Gear then you knew this one was coming. It’s timed, it’s underwater, and an escort mission. The unholy trinity of game design is here to mess up your day.

The great thing about Emma Emmerich is that for the English V/O she’s voiced by Jennifer Hale. And that’s it, that’s the only good thing about her. Now, I’d generally follow Hideo Kojima’s wild ideas to hell and back but this one was just bad. Emma is scared of water which is a great start for this underwater mission, so you have to carry her everywhere Princess-Ruto style. She’s also scared of everything and screams at bugs on walls.

On top of that, she’ll sook and sit down waiting to die if she gets spotted which is pretty inconvenient since her AI is programmed to not know how to hide. In a stealth game.

For a girl who hates bugs and water needing to be escorted through a bug filled waterway she ensures that every moment is as excruciating for you as I imagine it is for her. She’s sort of all the worst things of our other options combined so here she sits in infamy in our top spot.

You can however knock her out and drag her ass through the level and trust me, you’re probably going to want to.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Jess has been a journalist and content creator in the games industry for over 15 years and has been WhatCulture's resident Australian import and sorry cop since 2020, upping the quotient of swearing and apologising in WhatCulture Gaming's annual blooper videos considerably. She previously worked at GameSpot for 10 years, most notably hosting GameSpot News in addition to E3 live shows, and PAX panels. She regularly livestreams a variety of games on her 'jessmcdonell' YouTube and Twitch channels and hosts the 'Do It On The Day' podcast. She has won awards for her news and feature work in gaming as well as an accolade for her comedic writing (likely an admin error). She can be found on X at @jessmcdonell and Instagram at @jessicamcdonell sharing her current videogame fixations, industry insights, and videos of her cat, Karma.