10 Most Brutal Punishments In Horror Video Games

Paying the ultimate price.

Until Dawn Ashley
Supermassive Games

What are horror video games if not intense, nerve-shredding experiences where the player is constantly on their toes wondering what they might encounter next?

And with players so often having the terrifying odds stacked against them, it follows that they can end up severely punished for their mistakes, whether taking too long to complete a task, trying to rush their way to the end, behaving selfishly, or allowing curiosity to get the better of them.

Smart developers are able to exploit this risk-reward aspect to keep players in a state of high-tension, never sure that they're safe, though there are certainly times where players might consider it "cheap" or even unfair.

And so, whether savagely gory or simply devastatingly cruel, these 10 horror game punishments all left players agape at the harsh brutality of it all, of unforgiving developers inflicting insane fates upon those who didn't do the "right" thing.

On occasion it was a punishment most definitely deserved, but for the most part, these games gave players one hell of a raw deal...

10. James Commits Suicide If You Keep Your Health Low - Silent Hill 2

Silent Hill 2 Ending
Konami

The majority of the Silent Hill games feature a number of possible endings depending on the player's actions throughout, and typically the player isn't made aware of these conditions before starting.

As a result, your first experience with each game is likely to end badly, and surely no more harshly than in the brilliant Silent Hill 2.

Perhaps the most common outcome for first-time players is the "In Water" ending, where protagonist James ends up committing suicide by driving his car into a lake.

The primary factor for achieving this ending is allowing your health to continually remain low for extended periods before healing.

According to the game's internal scoring system, doing so indicates that you don't care about your life, and so, when it's all said and done, James consequently kills himself.

There are other factors which make this ending more likely - such as checking Angela's knife, reading a suicidal patient's diary, and so on - but the defining attribute is how attentive you are to James' health.

Health management is an important skill in any game, for sure, but doesn't this seem just a tad unfair?


9. Rebecca Dies If You Don't Rescue Her Fast Enough - Resident Evil

Resident Evil Remake
Capcom

In both the original Resident Evil and its brilliant remake, players who don't move swiftly enough to save Rebecca Chambers from the clutches of the Alpha Hunter will ultimately end up staring at her mutilated remains.

At one point in the game, you'll hear Rebecca scream from afar and need to track her down, but if you spend more than 10 minutes doing so, it'll sadly be too late for her.

In the original, you'd have to dispatch the Alpha Hunter and then find Rebecca's decapitated corpse in the corner of the room, but in the remake, you get treated to a nauseatingly graphic cutscene in which the Hunter slashes Rebecca's throat, spraying her blood all over the room.

Granted, reaching Rebecca in time takes literally one minute, but even so, that's a pretty harsh punishment for lolly-gagging.


8. Hoarding Money Gets You Crushed To Death - S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Shadow Of Chernobyl

STALKER Shadow Of Chernobyl
GSC Game World

Survival horror FPS S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Shadow of Chernobyl is a famously challenging game and one which really makes players fight for a happy ending.

The overwhelming majority of players will end up with one of the game's five "false" endings, which are activated if they discover the mysterious Wish Granter device within Chernobyl's sarcophagus.

Though several of the Wish Granter endings lead to a positive(ish) outcome for protagonist Strelok, the "greed" ending is a feat of straight-up trolling.

Basically, players who have more than 50000 RU in their possession will be forced to watch as Strelok asks the Wish Granter for enormous riches. At this point, money rains down from the sky, along with the ceiling, promptly crushing Strelok to death.

Considering how easy it is to hoard money in S.T.A.L.K.E.R. and how looting is highly encouraged given the barrenness of the game's world, many players were understandably pissed off that they met such a seemingly undeserved fate.


7. Trying To Flee Results In Death-By-Scissors - Clock Tower

Clock Tower
Human Entertainment

Clock Tower is one of the most influential survival horror games ever made, and its meticulous design carries through to its nine possible endings determined by the player's actions throughout.

Ironically, players who actually make the smartest and most believable choice end up being mischievously "rewarded" with the worst ending the game has to offer.

After protagonist Jennifer sees one of her friends killed by the murderous Scissorman, she finds a car in the mansion's garage along with a key.

Though the game's design implores the player to continue exploring the mansion, those adamant to escape using the car will indeed be able to start the car and drive away after a few prompts.

Though the end credits roll and Jennifer appears to make a successful escape, a post-credits scene reveals that Scissorman is hiding in the backseat, with the implication that he ends up killing Jennifer.

And that's what you get for doing what any rational human being actually would.


6. You're Lied To About Permadeath - Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice

Hellblade senua's sacrifice
Ninja Theory

Permadeath is one of the most stressful video game punishments there is, and in the brilliant Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice, upon encountering their first death, the player is informed that each subsequent death will cause Senua's "rot" to further consume her.

The implication is that, with enough deaths, the rot will envelop Senua completely and give players a permadeath Game Over, deleting their save and forcing them to start again.

This naturally created an added air of tension in the early days following the game's release, with players anxious that an honest mistake could result in them losing hours of progress.

But as it turned out, this was nothing more than a cheeky bluff from Ninja Theory, and after a certain point, the rot never actually progresses any further no matter how often you die.

It was a clever bait-and-switch for sure, and for those who played the game upon launch in particular, made them feel extra anxious every time they kicked the bucket.


5. You Must Kill Your Zombified Self To Get Your Gear Back - ZombiU

zombiu u
Ubisoft

ZombiU - or as it's called outside of its Wii U release, "Zombi" - is a neat little survival horror game taking place in the midst of an undead apocalypse.

Its most-praised feature was also its most mischievous, with players who end up snacked upon by the undead being faced with a bit of an existential quandary if they want to get their gear back.

After dying, you'll respawn as a new survivor with only base equipment, and if you want to regain possession of your prior wares, you'll need to track down your now-zombified self and kill them.

Though it's only a game at the end of the day, this was still a creatively eerie way to reinvent a major aspect of the genre, while ensuring that players absolutely earned the privilege of retrieving their gear.

The feature was very nearly cut amid concerns that it would force the player into too much backtracking, but mercifully, it ultimately made the cut.


4. Exploiting A Bug Unlocks A Secret Jump Scare - Slender: The Arrival

1439244

No matter how tough or punishing a video game might be, there's always the opportunity to cheat or exploits bugs for your own gain, right?

Well, the developers of Slender: The Arrival came up with a fiendishly clever way to further toy with players who thought they had a leg-up on the game itself.

Basically, players discovered that the game's third chapter, "Into The Abyss," features a bug where the player can move outside the bounds of the map, seemingly free of Slender Man's ability to creep up on them.

But after the bug became widely apparent, the game was patched so that anyone who used the exploit would be met with a shock jump scare from Slender Man himself, complete with the mocking text, "Not even a bug in this game will save you from me," and a prompt Game Over screen.

Just when players thought they could breeze through this section of the game scare-free, Slender Man went and smashed the fourth wall to pieces. Harsh? Perhaps. Incredible? Definitely.


3. Attempting To Escape On Your Own Gets You Killed - Dead Rising 3

Dead Rising 3 Nick
Capcom

Much like Clock Tower, Dead Rising 3's ending punishes players for acting out of understandable self-interest rather than stopping to think about their friends.

At the start of Chapter 7, players are instructed to head to the karaoke bar to meet up with their pals, but if you instead decide to immediately head to the escape plane without them, you'll unlock an hilariously harsh secret ending.

In this ending, protagonist Nick will be preparing to embark on a plane ride out of Los Perdidos, citing "Every man for himself," only to be confronted by friends Annie, Red, Rhonda, and Gary.

Nick gets punched in the face and left in the hangar as his four disgusted ex-buddies board the plane and leave without him, all while Nick tries to convince them that he was joking.

To rub salt in the wound, a title card then reveals that Los Perdidos was blown to smithereens with no evidence of survivors. That's...quite the overkill death, no matter how much of a selfish dick Nick was.


2. Ashley Loses Her Head For Investigating The Voice - Until Dawn

Until Dawn Ashley
Supermassive

It's said that curiosity killed the cat, and that's also true of Until Dawn's Ashley, who receives one of the most grotesquely violent deaths in video game history if players can't resist the urge to indulge a classic horror trope.

After Ashley is separated from her pals in Chapter 9, players will be given the option of either investigating a screaming voice or rejoining the group.

If you investigate the voice, you'll come across a trap door from which banging can be heard, and those who decide to open the trap door will be met by a Wendigo, which promptly rips Ashley's head clean off.

Now, we're not saying that opening the trap door was a particularly smart move, but did the punishment really fit the "crime" here?

It's certainly possible the voice was one of your friends in trouble, but alas, altruistic naivete ultimately just resulted in one of the game's gnarliest deaths.


1. Rage Quitters Get Put In The "Salt Mines" - Friday The 13th: The Game

Friday the 13th The Game
Illfonic

Though this punishment isn't of the brutally gory variety, it certainly is harsh regardless.

It's become increasingly common in recent years for online multiplayer games to deal with cheaters, griefers, and rage-quitters by confining them to their own gameplay lobbies rather than banning them outright.

And Friday the 13th: The Game came up with an especially savage way to deal with those who repeatedly bailed out of matches when they were losing and selfishly ruined the experience for everyone else.

In 2018, the game was patched to assign an internal "salt score" to every single player, and players would earn more salt by doing the following: leaving a match early, leaving while being killed, leaving while playing as Jason, and leaving while hosting a match.

Get enough salt and you'll end up kicked into the Salt Mines, a designated area for rage-quitters - or, as developers Illfonic themselves put it, "where Salty players go to play with their equally Sodium-soaked peers." Brilliant.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Until Dawn
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.