10 Most Disappointing Video Game Sequels Of All Time

How do you follow up a great game? Not like this.

dragon age 2
Bioware

Even for the biggest studios, it’s an incredibly tall order to create a new and innovative IP that really takes off. Perhaps it’s even more difficult for AAA studios. For all their cachet and acclaim, the spotlight of the global industry is upon them, and there’s an awful lot of money on the line.

Smaller indie developers have a little more leeway to try something new, but the uphill battle to get projects the attention and sales they deserve is an entirely different headache.

Regardless of the scale of the team involved in creating a successful title, though, the issue of managing the follow-up is a universal one. Fans want more of the same, but not too much of the same. They want a budding series to evolve and grow, but not to change too much. In some blessed cases, a sequel arrives that gets the balance just right, but expectations are outrageously high and disappointment is, sadly, all too common.

Whether because they took off in a strange new direction, lacked that star quality that came before or were just mediocre, here are some of the most disappointing sequels in gaming.

10. Dead Space 3

Dead Space 3 Ending
EA

Resident Evil 4, as previously mentioned, blended survival horror and third-person action about as effectively as possible. 2008’s Dead Space was another title that seemed to nail this.

Isaac Clarke is no formidable soldier, but an engineer who fights the horrific hordes on the Ishimura with (primarily) just salvaged mining tools. Battles are frantic, gross and gory, but (and this is paramount) they take a bit of a back seat to the palpable atmosphere the game generates throughout.

While Dead Space 2 largely followed this same template, 2013’s Dead Space 3 was perhaps a step too far. Mechanically, the reverse was true: The player’s journey across Tau Voltanis emphasized customizing weapons to give them a range of ridiculous attributes, and populated the world with vast swathes of enemies to try out your creations on.

For long-term fans, perhaps, something was a little lost in translation as a result. The trademark psychological horror was largely forgotten among all the shooting. Couple this with the fact that this would prove to be the last entry in the series (after the closing of Visceral Games), and fans are still hoping that Dead Space gets the swansong it deserves.


9. Prince Of Persia: Warrior Within

prince of persia warrior within
Ubisoft

Ubisoft’s 2003 release Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time is a celebrated action adventure. It’s very difficult to reboot a classic series, but this release certainly did it in style.

Sands of Time is a tricky action title, boasting fantastic platforming sections that showcase the Prince’s remarkable athleticism. Control of the Sands of Time is woven into both the platforming (time can be rewound to undo a death) and the combat, and it all tied in together to make an excellent package.

The 2004 sequel, Prince of Persia: Warrior Within, isn’t a bad game. Expanding the Prince’s combat capabilities and opening up the various stages he explores, it actually built on Sands of Time in some areas. Most disappointingly, though, it completely changed many of the best aspects of the previous title. Seeming to slap copious amounts of dark and unnecessarily edgy paint on everything, the softly-spoken Prince of the previous title was lost.

In getting so close to a truly stellar sequel to a fantastic title, before making missteps that could have been avoided entirely, it was all the more disappointing.


8. Dragon Age II

Dragon Age 2
BioWare

The Dragon Age series represents BioWare at their best: A deep, involving set of RPGs, with choices, consequence and lots and lots of dialogue. If all these elements wrapped up in a fantastical setting appeals to you, you’re surely a fan already.

Dragon Age II, however, represents a turbulent time in the series. Hawke’s adventure is one that never quite seemed to know what it wanted to be.

It offered the player more freedom than before, in terms of the choices they made, but its questionable pacing meant that you were never quite sure how or when they would turn out to matter.

Most egregiously, perhaps, it struggled to carve out a world that was truly its own, with some very familiar-looking settings popping up throughout. The difficulty, perhaps, was that Dragon Age: Origins had set such a high bar.

There may never have been a sequel after Dragon Age II.


7. Resident Evil 6

Resident evil 6
Capcom

There will always be highs and lows for any long-running series. In the case of Capcom’s beloved survival horror franchise Resident Evil, the sixth numbered release would probably qualify as a major low.

Resident Evil 4 changed the formula forever. It implemented a new, visceral, action focus to proceedings, but it pulled it off with aplomb. It’s one of the most celebrated games ever made, in fact, and the pressure of following it up was surely immense.

In attempting to do so, Capcom gave us Resident Evil 5 and 6. The former may not be a masterpiece by any means, but it remains an enjoyable enough action-heavy romp, packed with some of the most absurd and memorable moments the series has to offer. Resident Evil 6, sadly, seemed to take this new direction a little too far.

It tried very hard to apply the fanservice (Chris Redfield and Leon Kennedy meet in one super-theatrical cutscene), but none of its campaigns really felt like the beloved series. Resident Evil’s reputation truly suffered, but thankfully Resident Evil 7 and Village have gone some way to reviving it.


6. Star Wars: The Force Unleashed II

star wars force unleashed 2
LucasArts

Adaptations of beloved franchises like Star Wars need to be treated with tremendous care.

Fans are as invested as it’s possible to be, and they want authenticity in their Star Wars games. The most iconic characters, vehicles and locales, combat that feels just the same way, and epic space battles and cosmic drama worthy of the name.

Star Wars: The Force Unleashed II had a great chance to deliver all of this. The new take on Starkiller could have been a visceral treat to control, as could the anti-hero’s lightsaber.

Sadly, the game was a big critical disappointment, failing to refine the solid foundation the original set down. The true tragedy of The Force Unleashed II was that it wasn’t deemed worthy of a true sequel on the arrival of Disney, leaving fans only to wonder what could have been.


5. Duke Nukem Forever

Duke Nukem Forever
Gearbox Software

Duke Nukem is one of those characters that was undoubtedly a product of his time, but has managed to remain iconic regardless. With his brash ways, his huge and implausible arsenal of weaponry and his mastery of the one-liner, he has that timeless cheesy action hero appeal.

A lot was riding on 2011’s Duke Nukem Forever. It needed to honor the Duke’s not-so-good name, and prove a worthy addition to his adventures that had come before. Sadly, the project seemed doomed from the start.

Duke Nukem Forever’s sad fate is one of the most infamous tales of development hell in the industry’s history. Once it finally arrived in players’ hands, it was plain just how far the genre had come, leaving the Duke far behind.

It proved to be a very basic FPS, and to add insult to injury, its performance was very bad on a range of platforms to boot.


4. Mass Effect: Andromeda

Mass Effect Andromeda
EA

Just as with Dragon Age, Mass Effect is another BioWare series celebrated for its grand creative scope, its deep characterization and story beats that have a genuine impact on the player.

That whole business with the Reapers and the tragic choice that had to be made is the sort of thing that sticks with a gamer for life.

2017’s Mass Effect: Andromeda was ultimately a victim of its own hype. The games had developed quite the following by this point, but for many, Andromeda just didn’t live up to what had come before.

In an era of developers launching games that just didn’t perform up to snuff, and then patching them after the fact, this was a very high-profile example of that practise. Its narrative, too, seemed to lack focus and urgency, qualities that the series really has nailed at times.

Ultimately, the future of Mass Effect was put into jeopardy by Andromeda’s shortcomings.


3. Crash Nitro Kart

Crash nitro kart
Activision

Crash Team Racing, as kart racer fans will surely know, was a triumph. The Mario Kart series spawned legions of pretenders and hopefuls, but ultimately, only Crash Bandicoot’s 1999 effort really challenged it.

The problem, after Sony’s system acquired its own kart racing classic, was following it up. Crash Nitro Kart arrived four years later, and the PlayStation 2 title really didn’t push the envelope.

The roster of racers was always going to be a sticking point, as (just as with Super Smash Bros. versus PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale) the Crash Bandicoot series doesn’t have as many notable names. What Nitro Kart did elsewhere, though, was simply throw more of the same together and open the big box of Kart Racer Zaniness to see what it could find.

Vicarious Visions didn’t take the change to stamp their own style on Naughty Dog’s original, and the game was so similar to it in some areas that it has the feel of a bit more of an expansion pack. In 2019, fortunately, Crash Team Racing Nitro-Fueled bundled the content of both games together (as pictured here).


2. Paper Mario: Sticker Star

Paper Mario Sticker Star
Nintendo

Long-time players of the Paper Mario series generally know what they’re getting into: a colorful, irreverent experience, which leans into the whole everything-is-made-of-paper concept and emphasizes it throughout.

For many, 2004 GameCube title Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door represents the pinnacle of the format. It’s tremendously fun and varied, with a large cast of characters that each have handy abilities in battle. The RPG elements seemed finely tuned to allow for strategy without becoming too deep or too shallow.

The titles since seem to have failed to get this delicate balance right. 3DS title Paper Mario: Sticker Star remains a controversial example, leaving behind those RPG trappings for the gimmicky titular sticker system.

It may not be a bad title (the stickers can be fun to experiment with, and the writing is on point as ever), but it just didn’t live up to what came before.


1. Fable 3

fable 3
Lionhead

The original Fable was truly a revolution. The trouble, as we’ve discussed, is that developers can simply never win.

On its 2004 launch, this vast, ambitious, Peter Molyneux-designed RPG delivered creative, engrossing gameplay. The land of Albion was one unlike anything genre fans had explored before, and it has become the stuff of legend in the years since.

With the first instalment being so revered, it’s nothing short of tragic that the entries that followed perhaps failed to hit the same high notes. Fable 3, in particular, remains controversial.

The game, for some, lacked the weighty decisions that the player sometimes had to make earlier in the series, and elsewhere in the genre. This was particularly unfortunate given the much-anticipated role of monarch players are given later. Without this nuance, the experience wasn’t the step forward that it could have been.

The series continues to have an incredible mystique, as a Microsoft exclusive, and there’s tremendous pressure on the upcoming Fable 4 to deliver.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Dragon Age 2
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Chris Littlechild hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.