10 Most Disappointing Video Game Villains
It's amazing how much a good game can be dragged down by a disappointing villain.
The conflict between hero and villain is often what makes a good story work. In almost all fiction - especially genre fiction - the hero's motivation is to counter what the villain has done, is doing, or will do. Every step of the main character's journey is spurred on by the villain's scheming - the villain acts, the hero reacts, and the journey continues.
Batman has his ideological opposite in Joker, who leads their never ending dance in his attempts to break Batman's beliefs in objective morality and order. Magneto's extreme tactics motivate the X-Men to perform their heroics in order to show the world that not all mutants want to be enemies with humanity, who in turn spur Magneto.
Now, this is all a very simplified explanation of storytelling, but it demonstrates why these kinds of fundamentals are so important. Because without a good villain, everything else ends up being kind of a dud.
Sometimes a lame villain is just boring or predictable, thus causing the story to become boring and predictable. Other times they just turn out to be wimps, ruining what should be a climactic and satisfying victory.
These are the most disappointing video game villains.
10. The Arkham Knight - Batman: Arkham Knight
As great as Rocksteady's Batman: Arkham series was, they always struggled with their villains. We all remember the bizarre and oddly cringe Joker-Bane monster at the end of Arkham Asylum. Arkham City course-corrected a bit by spreading out its major antagonist roles across a few characters. And finally they settled on an original villain in Arkham Knight.
Except he wasn't really original, as anyone with even a cursory knowledge of Batman lore knew it was Jason Todd, the second Robin who was thought killed by the Joker, only to return as the lethal vigilante, Red Hood.
And that's all the Arkhman Knight is - Red Hood with a different helmet and an entire mercenary army he got from somewhere. Oh and of course took the name of Arkham Asylum, which really made no sense in the context of the game's story and seemingly only happened to maintain the "Arkham" title used for the previous games.
Rocksteady should have just used Red Hood. The story would have been much better served having the dynamic between Batman and Jason from the beginning rather than saving it for an endgame twist everyone knew was coming.
9. The Collectors - Mass Effect 2
BioWare's Mass Effect had a decent main villain in Saren. Unfortunately he only truly resonated if you read the prequel novel that preceded the release of that original title. If you did, then the question the game raises of whether or not Saren is being controlled or influenced by some outside force becomes much more compelling.
Of course, in the end we find out that he has, in fact, been indoctrinated (brainwashed) by his "ship," which is actually one of a swarm of synthetic lifeforms called Reapers who wipe out life in the galaxy every several thousand years.
After a reveal like that, you'd expect to face them in some form in the sequel. Instead, we get the Collectors - mindless insectoid drones abducting humans as biomass to create their equally disappointing human Reaper (which its literally a giant Terminator.)
Learning the sad fact that the Collectors are what became of the Protheans - an ancient and extremely advanced alien civilization now reduced to mindless drones was a juicy bit of lore... but not when they've been wiped of everything that made the Protheans interesting. They're identical worker ants with no culture, personality or worthwhile connection to their past.
8. President John Henry Eden - Fallout 3
Secret U.S. government cabal The Enclave seemed to have met their end during the climax of Fallout 2. That game's protagonist, the Chosen One, not only destroyed their main base, but also killed the new President Of The United States.
So their return in Fallout 3 was a surprise. On the one hand, it made sense that the U.S. government might try to regroup in Washington D.C., where there are no established governments like the New California Republic to contend with. On the other, their defeat in Fallout 2 seemed pretty definitive. I mean, you did kill the President.
But what you didn't see coming was a secret second president... who's a computer. A computer who broadcasts on the radio mostly talking about how awesome he is. And, somehow, the voice of some guy they never even heard of is more than enough to rally the Enclave.
It just doesn't make a ton of sense. The Enclave had a power structure - you'd think they'd have a formal plan for succession. At the very least they'd have a massive power vacuum. So were they all just chilling, waiting for any random guy to declare himself President?
How does anyone ever lose to these guys?
7. Skull Face - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain
On a technical and gameplay level, Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain is a masterpiece, easily a contender for greatest stealth game of all time. From a story perspective, however, it manages to be a disappointment compared to previous entries in the series.
One major reason for this was budgetary issues and a falling out between designer Hideo Kojima and publisher Konami - who got out of the video game business entirely following this game's release. But there were still issues from the start, not the least of which was its primary villain: Skull Face.
For a series known for its iconic, over the top, hammy bad guys, the contrastingly restrained Skull Face just couldn't live up to the bombastic tone of the games. Cast opposite a mostly mute version of protagonist Snake (another budgetary issue), Skull Face simply does not have the charisma or personality to carry as much of the narrative as he needs to.
Subdued nihilism can be a very interesting character trait to work with, but when up against Snake's usual cast of villains who possess all the subtlety of pro wrestlers, anything less gets drowned out.
6. Lou And Mickey - Far Cry: New Dawn
Confusingly, Ubisoft's Far Cry spin-off, New Dawn, is the only Far Cry game to take place after Fallout 5's canon ending, in which the world is destroyed in nuclear war. I don't know, maybe choosing to end just one entry in an ongoing series with the end of the world was a little too bold.
But New Dawn is an enjoyable enough game. With some fun, almost Ratchet-and-Clank-like weapons and a world that looks like Mad Max by way of Claude Monet, the game is worth a look.
Unfortunately, for a series made exponentially more famous by its villains, raider twins Lou and Mickey are probably the most forgettable of the entire series.
While Far Cry's villains may have peaked early with Far Cry 3's Vaas, Lou and Mickey still manage to fall excessively far behind the curve. Just abut every other Far Cry villain has some sort of philosophy or guiding principal. The twins say they have some sort of vision for the future, but damned if anyone can figure out what it is.
All they do is find the craziest people to give guns to and mostly let them run wild while they play around on their dirt bikes.
5. Corypheus - Dragon Age: Inquisition
One thing BioWare's Dragon Age series has going for it in spades is world building, which is enhanced by the fact that the writers don't explain everything.
Amongst those mysterious details is what really resulted in the dreaded Archdemons and Darkspawn being unleashed onto the world. All we know is that things went horribly awry when a group of ancient mages tried to enter the Golden City at the heart of the Fade - the realm of dreams - and corrupted it. Ever since then things have just been bad.
One of those mages is Corypheus, who escapes from his prison and returns to the world to do terrible things. However, for a major player in the most important catastrophe to ever befall this world, his priorities seem a tad skewed.
In a world of Old Gods, Darkspawn and demons, Corypheus's main goal is to make all elves slaves and exterminate other non-humans. So basically, he's a giant racist.
What about the Golden City, his fellow mages still imprisoned, killing God - all the stuff he should want to do?
Nah, right now the elves gotta be put in their place, then we'll see. Maybe.
4. Devin Weston - Grand Theft Auto V
Rockstar's Grand Theft Auto series has never leaned too heavily on its villains. After all, some of the most colorful villains in the series are its protagonists. It's hard to top Vice City's Tommy Vercetti - a Ray Liotta-voiced psychopath, but it's equally as hard to get more forgettable than GTA V's Devin Weston.
As a character, Weston is about as white-bread as his name. Unlike the gangsters and dirty cops who make up most of the GTA cast, Weston is basically just your average rich guy. A venture capitalist with his hand in everything from the beer industry to insurance fraud, Weston is a cowardly opportunist who you immediately know is going to betray you.
After trying to steal everything from the three protagonists, Weston is easily kidnapped and stuffed into the trunk of a car. He begs for his life with the promise of the only thing he has: Money. A hollow promise since, like every GTA game, you probably have more money that you could ever know how to spend by the game's end.
The second you lock him back in the trunk and push the car off a cliff, you've already forgotten this guy ever existed.
3. Mannimarco, King Of Worms - The Elder Scrolls Series
Anyone who knows their Elder Scrolls lore knows that Mannimarco, the King Of Worms, is a huge deal... on paper.
Banished from the powerful Psijic Order due to his love of Necromancy, Mannimarco kinda flopped around for a while before reemerging during the events of TES: Online where he served the Daedric prince, Molag Bal. True to his reputation, Mannimarco was only able to be defeated by five of the most badass heroes in this world's history. But when you later come across his soul imprisoned for his failure in Molag Bal's realm of Coldharbor, he's throwing a tantrum and "demanding" his freedom like a spoiled child.
He eventually escapes and by the end of TES II: Daggerfall, Mannimarco becomes one of the rare villains to actually attain godhood - mostly through blind luck - transforming into a divine body known as the Necromancer's Moon.
Then he just doesn't do anything for a while.
In TES IV: Oblivion he manifests a new mortal body to go after the head of the Mages Guild, but is easily defeated by the player.
For being necromancy incarnate, Mannimarco doesn't do much of anything with all this power. And when he does, he's easily foiled. The guy is addicted to losing.
2. Scott Shelby - Heavy Rain
Poor David Cage. There's no doubt that the famous game designer has a lot of vision and imagination. Between Omikron, Indigo Prophecy, and Heavy Rain, he has some really interesting ideas that ALMOST come together. But inevitably, most of his stories end up going totally off the rails.
Heavy Rain is a game where you alternate between four characters all hunting down the same serial killer, the Origami Killer. So, who is the Origami Killer? Well, it turns out he's one of those four characters: private detective, Scott Shelby.
Through a series of flashbacks we learn not only of Shelby's motive - killing kids in his search to find a father who would sacrifice himself for his child - but we also see that the game was basically just lying to us whenever we controlled him, not showing us what REALLY happened.
Not only is Shelby disappointing because of his ridiculous motive, but we never even get much insight into that reasoning or his personality, since the game is just lying to us whenever we control him, or view his thoughts. We get no insight into who he is beyond a flashback and a monologue, so his character never develops, leaving us to wonder why we bothered with this guy at all.
1. Necron - Final Fantasy IX
OK, we get it. For a game about existentialism, in which every major character is facing their own existential crisis, you have to include death somewhere in there.
Death is the most basic building block of the entire concept of existentialist philosophy and psychology. It would be weird not to talk about or face death in some way.
But saving it for the very end of the game where the concept of death is embodied by a last-second boss encounter that appears out of nowhere and is more or less immediately forgotten isn't what I'd call... well, good.
After saving the world from the game's actual villain, Kuja, protagonist Zidane is suddenly addressed by a mysterious voice - Necron. He says he's been observing the game's events and has concluded that all life only exists to die, so he's gonna kill everything. You then fight and beat him, and he's undone by the revelation of how powerful the will to live is. That's the entirety of this guy's role in the game - a goth teen's journal condensed into a boss fight.