10 Most Disappointing Video Games Of 2018
Fallout 76 makes Assassin's Creed: Unity look like a polished masterpiece.
It's been a bit of a weird year for video games. Unlike the blistering pace of 2017, 2018 featured a hectic start and finish, but a whole load of nothing in the middle, where new games were about as rare as making it through a forrest in Red Dead Redemption 2 without barrelling straight into a tree.
Still, the past 12 months will be remembered as being home to some of the biggest releases of the entire generation. Between the aforementioned Red Dead, God of War, Spider-Man, Monster Hunter, Celeste and Assassin's Creed: Odyssey, some of the decade's best critical darlings dropped across 2018. On the other hand, some of the generation's biggest disappointments also limped onto shelves in between this orgy of greatness.
From high-profile sequels that could tarnish entire franchises going forward, to some of the most broken, buggy, garbage fires that somehow only got worse as patches tried to fix them, while some developers reached higher heights than ever before in 2018, others suffered a pretty major fall from grace.
10. Shadow Of The Tomb Raider
Since Square Enix rebooted Tomb Raider back in 2013, they've been dogged by bad luck and even worse business decisions. The initial reboot was a cracking title that dropped in the twilight of the Xbox 360 era, confidently reintroducing players to a new version of Lara Croft. Unfortunately, it didn't sell anywhere near publisher forecasts, and the decision was made to make the sequel an Xbox exclusive (despite the series historically being associated with the PlayStation brand).
Again, the game was a knockout, deepening the strong foundations set in the original. But it sold even less than its predecessor and the brand's popularity plummeted. After a swift developer change, however, there was hope that the final entry in the reboot trilogy, now releasing across every platform simultaneously, would reignite the fire under the series.
Once again, though, the title came and went without any fanfare, only this time it was justified. Not a bad game by any means, Shadow's attempt to push the franchise even more into quasi-open world territory made the whole affair feel a little bloated, while the general gameplay structure had progressed little since Rise, which just couldn't cut it in a year that saw so many other popular names reinvent themselves completely.
9. Dynasty Warriors 9
Even though it's been chugging along fine for years now, contempt has been brewing in the Dynasty Warriors fandom. As Koei continued to milk the franchise for all it's worth, churning out sequels and seemingly putting in the bare minimum amount of effort, there was the hope that the ninth main instalment could right the ship. Instead, it sank it.
While it didn't take a total beating from critics, die-hard fans revolted against it, with the most common complaint being just how lazy it was. From the visuals to the battles themselves, there just wasn't all that much appealing about the sequel, with the archaic gameplay being exacerbated by bugs and a general lack of polish.
The idea was to transform Dynasty Warriors into an open world game like Assassin's Creed or Just Cause, but unfortunately the devs seemed to take all the worst ideas and habits from those releases, and completely forget about the good ones.
8. Battlefield V
As I said in my review, Battlefield V isn't a bad game. When everything clicks, EA's sequel can be a blistering depiction of all-out-war as players scramble to use the limited resources at their disposal to turn the tide of huge multiplayer matches. With that said, the amount of content at launch, combined with the myriad of bugs and issues that shouldn't have made it into the final release, make disappointment an inescapable feeling no matter how much you enjoy the moment-to-moment gameplay.
Booting up the sequel to find that a lot of the features talked about in the run-up to release weren't actually available, such as the battle royale and Tides of War live service, was deflating, as was some balancing issues with the Medic class and frustrating glitches that made long sessions a test of patience. It didn't matter that a lot of this was indeed flagged before the game dropped - simply knowing about something in advance doesn't justify it.
Throw in consistently disappointing moves from DICE, such as the last-minute delay or the recent delay of the first patch because a game-breaking bug was discovered in it days before it was set to go live, and it just seems like nothing can go right for Battlefield V.
7. Far Cry 5
Another game of two halves, there's so much in Far Cry 5 to love. The gameplay loop of exploration, scoping out enemies and taking them out by any means necessary is better than it's ever been, and the lush Montana sandbox itself is full to the brim with fascinating environmental stories to stumble across.
Sadly, while you can make your own fun, the actual bulk of the story, all about twisted, religious cult leaders threatening the end of the world, at no point lived up to its potential. There were flashes here and there, cool threads about brainwashing and hypocrisy, but they were pushed mostly to the side in favour of misplaced humour and a rote, repetitive structure of performing the same basic missions in order to take down each area's leader.
Perhaps in response to the political backlash that was garnered before launch, the end result tried its best to offend nobody on either side and be as impartial with its potential commentary as possible. By doing that though, it ended up saying nothing at all and its characters devolved into caricatures wrapped up in nonsensical plot twists that, in hindsight, seemed to have been crammed in simply so a post-apocalyptic spin-off could be made.
6. Vampyr
One of the most interesting projects set to drop in 2018, Dontnod's Vampyr is a far cry from their last game, Life is Strange. Maintaining the ethos of making sure the player is in charge of their own story, this new project was a far more conventional RPG, dropping players into a recreation of London circa 1918 as a recently-turned vampire who happens to also be a doctor.
The opening in particular promises so much, as the player awakens in a mass grave with an insatiable bloodlust. The game never really lives up to the potential of its introductory hour though, with its mission variety and combat in particular making for an experience that's repetitive and uninspired, at least when it comes to gameplay.
There is a lot to like if you dig deep enough though, from its intoxicating world to a good chunk of its characters, but it's hard to escape the feeling that, in the end, none of its disparate features really coalesce.
5. The Inpatient
Even though they've delivered one of the best horror games of the generation in Until Dawn, Supermassive Games have gradually fallen from grace ever since. Rather than producing another AAA experience, the team split off to work on Sony's PSVR, which initially birthed the great Until Dawn: Rush of Blood. Sadly, what followed was Bravo Team, a terrible VR shooter and Hidden Agenda, an ambitious but deeply flawed multiplayer experiment.
Fortunately, The Inpatient looked to turn the tide. Although it was still playing in the VR toybox, the horror game was returning to the Until Dawn setting, with some pretty crisp-looking visuals and the promise of a terrifying story to boot. If there were two things Supermassive didn't stop delivering during their experiments it was great horror and great stories, so The Inpatient couldn't fail, right?
Well, what should have been one of PSVR's biggest hitters ended up as nothing more than a damp squib. A short, underwhelming experience that failed to be even as scary as the on-rails shooter Rush of Blood, The Inpatient was the poster child for the PSVR's difficult few months at the start of the year.
4. Sea Of Thieves
It's no secret that Rare haven't exactly been at their best for, well, over a decade by now. The iconic developer has mostly been relegated to the sidelines, but with Sea of Thieves, their ambitious, multiplayer pirate game, it looked like they had recaptured some of the charm and creativity that defined their early work.
In a way, they did as well. Sea of Thieves can be a joy to play with a band of fellow marauders, travelling to uncharted islands to steal a load of treasure and then defend it against incoming players who want to take it off your hands. Sadly, it didn't take fans long to realise that's all they'd be doing, for pretty much the entire game.
At launch, the exclusive lacked content to sustain the kind of time sink the developers were hoping for, with the world itself appearing sparse and lifeless. Rare did promise content drops over the coming months, and have constantly tweaked the game and delivered on these promises to the point where there's far more to do today, but that initial disappointment still lingers.
3. State Of Decay 2
In a generation where Microsoft have been lacking in quality exclusives, the zombie survival game State of Decay became a surprising heavy hitter for the company. The original garnered a loyal fanbase, with its constantly evolving world offering a genuinely unique experience that the competition didn't have.
Inevitably, a sequel was announced, and with Microsoft pleased with the first's success, and looking to buy the developer Undead Labs outright, hopes were high that with more support and money behind it, the sequel could be both bigger and better.
However, while it's far from a bad game, State of Decay 2 wasn't the major next step for the franchise that most were expecting. Instead, it released with a litany of bugs that made the experience far more frustrating than it should have been, lacking the overall polish that most expected from the follow up. Throw in mechanics that were all too similar to the original and a lack of real innovation all around, and the general feeling was that Undead Labs simply provided more of the same.
Again, for some fans that was more than fine, but for others hoping that the title was going to be the franchise's defining moment, it was undoubtedly deflating.
2. The Quiet Man
Okay, so let me explain how The Quiet Man could ever be considered a "disappointment". The game clearly looked troubled from its strange-as-all-hell announcement, followed by Square Enix just dropping the title onto storefronts out of nowhere. With that said, underneath the weird marketing and odd FMV cutscenes was a genuinely ambitious idea.
Attempting to represent what it would be like to be a deaf video game protagonist, The Quiet Man's story plays out almost entirely in silence, with few subtitles letting the player know what's actually going on. Consequently, it's on them to piece it together just like the hero they're controlling, which could have made for a unique, insightful challenge.
Unfortunately, said story would be virtually incoherent even if there was sound (which there is, as the game can be played for a second time with the dialogue turned on). The ambitious idea at the heart of the title is obfuscated by terrible gameplay and even worse acting, resulting in one of the worst releases of the year.
1. Fallout 76
It could never have been anything else, could it?
Bethesda's first foray into the hazardous realm of online multiplayer 'live services', Fallout 76 has continued to be an utter trainwreck since it launched earlier in November. A multiplayer spin-off could have genuinely been a fine idea if pulled off well, but with every passing day it's clear that Bethesda put in the bare minimum amount of effort to push it out the door.
From the quests to the enemies to the world itself, the actual moment-to-moment gameplay would have been underwhelming, but it's the sheer amount of bugs and issues that've made the title so notorious. Put simply, the game barely functions, and when it's not throwing broken missions at you it's leaking every player's personal information onto the web.
The disappointment extends beyond the game itself though, as Bethesda couldn't even ship the right bag out to fans who picked up the expensive special edition. It's been an absolute shambles of a launch, to the point where it's not even funny to laugh at. It's just sad.