10 Most Disappointing Video Games Of 2022
So The Callisto Protocol is a huge disappointment, huh?
2022 has been an excellent year for video games. God of War: Ragnarok, Elden Ring, Immortality; there has been a wide array of brilliant games from a bunch of different genres that have dropped over the last twelve months.
However, there are still some who view 2022 as a disappointing year. That could be because while there has been no shortage of amazing titles to jump into, there have been just as many that have disappointed. Indeed, the candidates for this year's most disappointing list have been plentiful, with major AAA releases, long-awaited new IP and indie darlings all failing to deliver on their promises.
Of course, that doesn't mean all the following games are bad. In fact, some are still recommendable despite their flaws, but there's no denying that they didn't hit the lofty heights that fans and critics expected from them.
On the other hand, some picks are straight up terrible with no redeeming features whatsoever. These are the titles you'll definitely see crossover with our worst of 2022 list.
So, from dodgy reboots to bloated sequels, these are the biggest disappointments of the year.
10. Saints Row
Some gamers may tell you that Saints Row wasn't a disappointment, because everyone expected it to be bad to begin with. While yes, there was a vocal section of the playerbase that wrote the title off as soon as it was announced, so offputting was the humour and new aesthetic, the initial trailers looked promising enough. The writing and outdated stabs at hipster culture may not have impressed, but the open-world anarchy still looked like a lot of fun, as did the extensive customisation options.
It's a testament to just how bad the eventual game was, then, that it managed to disappoint even players who only expected brainless anarchy. That's because Saints Row is not just an underwhelming game, it's a truly turgid one. Playing like a 5/10 open-world actioner from 2009, everything about this reboot feels archaic, from the clumsy combat, to the mundane mission objectives to the insulting graphics and technical hiccups.
If you told someone this was a Duke Nukem Forever situation where the game started development a decade ago, they'd probably believe you. Even as an old-school throwback though, the game doesn't work because the glitches and insulting A.I. made it virtually unplayable at launch.
Whether you're a die-hard fan or an intrigued newcomer, Saints Row has nothing to offer anyone.
9. Dying Light 2
A common theme on this list is that a lot of the most disappointing games feel like relics of a bygone era, and Dying Light 2 is no different. Had this sequel launched even four years ago it probably would have resonated more with players, but unfortunately its Ubisoft-esque approach to open-world design today feels needlessly bloated and rickety.
Though the core tenants of what made the original title so memorable are still here - those of course being the excellent parkour system and punchy melee combat - they're diluted through a quantity-over-quality approach to new systems and mechanics that muddy that game's tight focus.
It is at least ambitious, striving to be closer to an RPG with branching narrative choices and fleshed-out side missions and characters, but sadly the writing of this new content is not up to scratch. Cutscenes drag on, characters are frustratingly one-note, and the world building is nothing we haven't seen in a million post-apocalyptic games before.
It's a shame, because there's a lot to enjoy at the heart of this sequel, but like its worst inspirations, you have to cut through so much BS just to get there.
8. Ghostwire: Tokyo
Tango Gameworks was, at one point, one of the most promising new studios in the industry. With The Evil Within they crafted a promising debut, and with its sequel delivered one of the defining survival horror games of a generation.
All eyes were on their third project, Ghostwire: Tokyo, to follow up that winning streak. A shift to a first-person style of gameplay might have been a risk, but there was trust that the devs could pull it off. After all, they actually released a first-person mode for The Evil Within 2 post-launch, so it's not like they didn't have practice.
Unfortunately, after a bunch of delays and internal shifts, Ghostwire: Tokyo didn't live up to its potential. Repetitive gameplay, meandering pacing and a story that didn't really get going until the end, while there are parts of the title to enjoy - and you will still get a kick out of it now it's heavily discounted and expectations are low - it sadly didn't live up to the quality we know the talented people at Tango are capable of.
7. Pokemon Scarlet & Violet
There's nothing more deflating than a video game that has clear potential releasing before it's ready. We've seen botched launches take down everything from Cyberpunk 2077 to Battlefield 4 and sadly, Pokemon Scarlet & Violet is the latest casualty.
The second major Pokemon game this year, Scarlet & Violet by all accounts is an inspired, refreshing instalment in the long-running franchise. Expanding on the classic gameplay by implementing more open world, RPG elements and mini-games, it's the most ambitious sequel in years, but that ambition has come with a price.
That's because the latest Pokemon is, quite frankly, unacceptable. Plagued by bugs and glitches (some hilarious, others game breaking), there's no way this was developer Game Freak's intended vision. Production wise, it doesn't feel AAA, with ugly graphics and presentation dragging down what should be a vibrant and lived-in world.
This is one of the biggest franchises in the world, but it doesn't appear that the developers have the resources they require to produce a polished and premium experience. It feels like a product that's cut a lot of technical corners, which is so disappointing when the gameplay itself is this good.
6. Rainbow Six: Extraction
Rainbow Six: Extraction is the kind of idea that only works if you strike while the iron is hot. Spun off a time-limited co-op mode from Rainbow Six: Siege, where players teamed up to kill aliens and complete objectives, Ubisoft decided there was enough potential there for the mode to headline its own game. With a few aesthetic tweaks and a much bigger budget, Rainbow Six: Quarantine was put into development.
Unfortunately, then the entire world was put into quarantine.
Delayed multiple times over the pandemic and changing its name to avoid association with real world happenings, Rainbow Six: Extraction finally released right at the start of this year and... it was fine. It was a game. It was ok if you were playing with mates.
In fact, it was perfect Game Pass fodder; a decent time with no barrier to entry that successfully blended the mechanics of Siege with a new, more explosive setting. However, it was not a memorable title, and that arguably didn't warrant the resources required to flesh it out into a full game.
5. The Dark Pictures Anthology: The Devil In Me
Supermassive Games was riding a renewed high at the mid-point of this year. Their successor to Until Dawn, The Quarry, signalled a major return to form for the studio, acting as a standout horror adventure game with pristine production values, buckets of gore, and a level of polish that had evaded the team in recent years.
Consequently, all eyes were on the devs' second release of 2022 and the latest in their Dark Pictures Anthology series, The Devil In Me. Though the previous entries were a little hit and miss, expectations were high for this one.
Not only had Supermassive Games been going from strength to strength, but the concept of The Devil In Me (that being a filmmaking crew are trapped in a deadly building full of Saw-esque traps and games), the top-level talent and inclusion of one of Hollywood's greatest actors in Jessie Buckley, all promised big things.
Unfortunately, the latest entry in the Dark Pictures Anthology turned out to be just... another entry in the Dark Pictures Anthology. Clumsy new mechanics, thin characters and a lack of scares sucked the promise out of this release, and made The Quarry look like a fluke rather than a confident new beginning.
4. Diablo Immortal
For a little while, it looked like Diablo Immortal could be the biggest redemption story of the year.
Blizzard’s mobile spin-off was infamously criticised when it was first announced - not helped by the company’s own arrogant assertions that fans should shut up and be happy with the franchise’s move to phones - but the end product seemed solid. When fans finally installed the free-to-play title this year, they were impressed by the excellent visuals, addictive gameplay loop and wealth of content.
But then, the grind set in, and it was clear that once you hit the twenty-hour mark, Diablo Immortal was an over-monetised mess.
Hiding some of the more nefarious business practices until the late game, it became apparent that Blizzard was pushing fans to microtransactions at every turn to skip the grind, and keep the progression going. Even worse, it seemed as though high-paying players were incentivised by pay-to-win systems that gave them an edge in PVP battles.
This huge disappointment led to a barrage of review-bombing crusades, and rightly so. Blizzard was so close to having something special, but ultimately gave into greed at the last hurdle.
3. Crossfire X
You probably forgot Crossfire X even came out this year, didn't you?
In a way, it was expected that this lifeless first-person shooter would die on arrival. Even launching day one on Game Pass, there was little hope that a military shooter which looked ten years out of date would find an audience.
However, one thing did intrigue fans and raise expectations considerably: the involvement of Remedy Entertainment. Though they were only involved with the single-player, the creators of Max Payne and Control naturally brought a level of hype to the project, and with the devs saying they were inspired by the likes of Metal Gear and Resident Evil, there was the hope the game would be way more subversive than first thought.
Unfortunately, Crossfire X was just as disposable as everyone feared it would be, with bog-standard shooting and bland level design falling short of the developers' influences.
2. Gotham Knights
Of all the games on this list, Gotham Knights is one that you can still have a lot of fun with. The superhero open-world adventure has a lot to admire, with strong character writing, decent combat and four different heroes to play as.
Unfortunately, Gotham Knights is disappointing because for everything it gets right, there's a misstep to balance things out. Tragically unbalanced and boring boss battles, a lifeless open world, repetitive side missions and more plagued the title, which generally felt like it released six months too soon, despite already being delayed for a whole year.
And then there's the technical issues. Despite cutting ties with last-gen machines, Gotham Knights rarely hit a smooth 30fps on consoles, and with graphics that were hardly setting the bar on the new machines, it was unclear what exactly was so "next-gen" about the game.
Some people love it, and you can see why when isolating certain features. Others, however, simply couldn't get past the title's many flaws, and you can't blame them.
1. The Callisto Protocol
I know, I'm surprised too.
Of all the major games releasing on December 2 - those being Marvel's Midnight Suns, Need For Speed Unbound and The Callisto Protocol - nobody expected this long-awaited survival horror title to be bottom of the pile. But, as NFS and Midnight Suns received rave reviews and strong word of mouth, there was only one word doing the rounds to describe Callisto: disappointing.
Despite dripping with lush next-gen visuals and atmosphere, it became apparent that set dressing was hiding pretty dodgy core gameplay. Attempting to blend classic over-the-shoulder survival horror shooting with a brawler-based melee and dodge system, Callisto's moment-to-moment combat devolves into a cheap and frustrating mess of button mashes. Games like this are supposed to be hard, of course, but Callisto takes the p*ss with unbalanced encounters and horrible checkpointing.
Throw in a weak story and so-so level design, and The Callisto Protocol wasn't quite the Dead Space beater everyone was expecting.