10 Most Hyped Video Game Moments That Were Massive Disappointments

How do you mess up pulling a Star Destroyer out the sky?!

star wars force unleashed
Disney

It must be a bizarrely distancing experience, putting together trailers for video games, movies and TV shows. The mandate is always, "Get as many eyes on this as possible", which in the world of film, results in an entire flick being butchered, its most spoilerific scenes being trotted out as final product be damned, once you've plonked down your cash, the 'film experience' literally does not matter anymore.

For gaming it's mostly the same, although there's a key difference when jumping from film to video games - your biggest selling points i.e. the actual gameplay and feel of a title, has to be fantastic, or the whole thing falls apart in the long run. You can't fake good gameplay either, can't manufacture solid mechanics or satisfaction. A movie can have bad scenes or acting, but it'll still continue towards an endpoint - in gaming, if the actual feel of something isn't quite right, people won't even reach the credits.

As a result, you'll occasionally see companies hang their products on one specific scene or gameplay mechanic, the impetus being to play through no matter what, hoping that when you do so, getting to control such a moment will make for The Greatest Thing Ever.

That's not always the case though, as the following games more than made clear...


10. Unmasking The Arkham Knight - Batman: Arkham Knight

Batman arkham knight jason todd
Rocksteady

It should've been one of the defining moments for the entire superhero genre - the first time we'd played a global game of "Guess who?", all the while being convinced that Rocksteady were going to unveil an entirely new character (as they repeatedly stated they would), or at least someone very interesting from Batman's past.

Instead... it was Jason Todd - otherwise known as "The most obvious choice since day one". Worse still, the very first thing the Knight says is "Time to die, old man", narrowing the options entirely to either Todd or perhaps Damien Wayne, at a push.

Cue the game providing a crash-course in Bruce's past with Todd (something never even mentioned or hinted at before) and an unmasking scene that had fans screaming, "Seriously?!", before a repetitive 'Sneak up and punch him' boss fight ended the encounter on a spectacularly flat note.


9. The Reaper Invasion - Mass Effect 3

mass effect 3
Bioware

Going into Bioware's trilogy-capper, we still had time. The galaxy-ending Reapers were still lightyears away at the close of Mass Effect 2, and surely this game was going to be all about mounting some sort of one-of-a-kind offensive to outwit and beat the- sorry what? They're here NOW?!

Yes, the game opened with the Reaper invasion of Earth right in the middle of a conference discussing precisely how to combat them.

Just how did we go from monitoring their every move to literally seeing them outside the front window?

Who knows, but you were immediately thrown into a jarring "All hope is lost... but here's a load of side missions anyway!" setup, as Mass Effect 3 got off to an incredibly stilted start - one that would put a sour taste in our mouths for the rest of the game.


8. Playing As Solid Snake - Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty

Metal gear solid 2 tanker
Konami

With video game budgets being what they are these days, no developer/publisher combo on Earth would take the risk of deliberately deceiving the public, but back in 2001, when Hideo Kojima had just came off the back of a genuine medium-changing video game in Metal Gear Solid, Konami pretty much let him do whatever he liked.

As such, the MGS 2 was marketed off the back of Solid Snake looking better than ever, slinking his way through a rainswept tanker and popping bullets into the limbs of various guards. What we didn't know until launch, was that all of this was taken from an optional opening prologue that only lasted about half an hour - the remaining 30+ hours would be spent in the company of Raiden; an albino fop with no field skills and a constant need to moan about his mission.

It was all done to highlight the immense difference between the two characters, showing Solid Snake through someone else's eyes - a great thematic choice, but Kojima, did you really have to troll the world to do so?


7. Fighting The Werewolves - The Order: 1886

The Order 1886
Ready At Dawn

Once word got out that Ready at Dawn's first next-gen outing was actually only a handful of hours long, us consumers smelt blood in the water. Then, when it started playing like one giant quick-time event cutscene with some of the most boring boss battles in gaming history, it was truly torn asunder.

The point stands though: Don't market your game off the back of battling werewolves in a Steampunk version of London if in-game they're going to boil down to tapping left or right to dodge, and occasionally attacking with a prolonged animation.

Such battles happened only twice in the entire game, and even then, they were carbon copies of one another. Tackling supernatural creatures as a gadget-equipped Knight of the Round Table in Victorian Blighty should've been phenomenal, but instead, the whole game felt about as worthwhile as PlayStation Home.


6. Surviving In The Desert - Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception

uncharted 3 drake's deception sand
Naughty Dog

There are two types of people in this world - those who like Uncharted 2 more than 3, and the reverse. I'm one of the former, precisely because of how flat many of U3's biggest moments fell.

Case in point: The desert stuff. Drake was shown in the game's PR as being pushed to breaking point, somehow surviving a devastating aeroplane crash and having to cobble together a survival routine from nothing. It looked to really let us explore Drake's psyche as he'd assumedly be without Sully or Elena, and only the sandy dunes for company.

Then you hit that point in the game, and Drake's Deception turns into that bit in Escape from Monkey Island where every direction you go loops back in on itself. It's supposed to make you feel helpless and lost, but thanks to its placement in the story, completely ruins the run-up to the big finale you were otherwise working towards.

When you finally make it out alive, it's not the "Oh, thank god"-style reaction that Journey gives you after that iconic hill climb, but more a "I am NEVER doing that again" feeling that cements Uncharted 3 as the third best of the quadrilogy.


5. Playing Hide N' Seek With A Xenomorph - Alien: Isolation

Alien Isolation Gif
Creative Assembly

This isn't as massive a knock against Creative Assembly's near-masterpiece as the other entries on here, but it must be addressed just how deflating the checkpoint placement is within their game.

Leading up to release, Isolation looked to be taking the inherent thrills behind the likes of Slender Man and the entire first-person horror revival, before injecting an actual Xenomorph into the proceedings. The twist? Its pathways and A.I. were random, as the developers aimed to replicate what it might be like to tussle with the creature head-on.

The problem though, was in the checkpointing. See, the Xeno could always kill you immediately, and you could only save at specific parts on the map, with everything from cutscenes to progression completely wiping if you died. No matter if you'd played for 40 minutes or four hours, if you went down, that was it.

Such a choice was clearly made to ramp up the tension, but bad checkpointing in any game is just infuriating. Rather than encouraging you to outsmart the creature using different items and routes through levels, you were encouraged to take the safest option every time - more often than not STILL resulting in losing half your chest cavity in the process.


4. Hacking - Watch_Dogs

Watch Dogs
Ubisoft

Ubisoft were never going to be able to capitalise on the unprecedented amount of hype built up for Watch_Dogs - but in a way, it was on them to not over-sell your gameplay options in the first place.

We were promised an intricately-mapped version of Chicago where everything could be hacked, experimented with and weaved together. In-game, this would surely manifest as a cool, in-depth system of choosing all manner of fancy functions, perhaps involving a UI that mimicked hacking into something?

Nope - you just held a button instead. The game did sporadically include a mode where you 'pilot' pieces of code from one place to another, but considering the entire premise of Watch Dogs lay in delving into the hidden layer of data underneath every technological product, it was a major letdown.


3. P.T. - Silent Hills

P.T. Silent Hills
Konami

In the decades to come, we'll look back on P.T. with increased fondness, its existence as an unintentional 'timed exclusive' of sorts giving it some immortal appeal.

You were either there when it happened (E3 2014), or you weren't - and if you were, the crushing realisation that P.T. (Playable Teaser) was going to be a full-on reboot of Silent Hill (named Silent Hills) helmed by both Guillermo del Toro AND Hideo Kojima, was better than any words could describe.

Then... in one of the most unceremonious business moves of all time, Konami sliced the head off MGS V and released it unfinished, before cancelling Silent Hills outright, ostensibly bowing out of the industry as far as anything other than Pro Evolution Soccer was concerned.


2. Discovering The "Missing Link" - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Metal Gear Solid V Phantom pain snake
Konami

I noted in an earlier entry about how no developer in their right mind would troll a modern audience deliberately, but yet again Hideo Kojima did it with 2015's MGS V: The Phantom Pain.

Throughout all the game's pre-release materials and advertising, we were continually reminded that MGS V would provide the "missing link" to bridge the prequel games, and that of the original two Metal Gears on the MSX. We'd supposedly discover what made the hero of MGS 3 slowly descend into a life of madness, what made him turn to using nuclear weapons as a means of defence, and precisely why Big Boss looked to be screaming in an abandoned field, before being covered in blood in another scene.

Then the game dropped and... nope. A twist revealed that there were actually two 'Big Bosses' all along (fitting nicely into the 2D games, as you fought the character twice), yet no effort was taken whatsoever to pad out the advertised "Downfall of Big Boss".

Like literally, nothing whatsoever. The game's real ending can only be found on the special edition bonus disc, and the way TPP wraps up doesn't go anywhere near the notion that Boss is anything other than a soldier.

Lame.


1. Pulling The Star Destroyer Out The Sky - Star Wars: The Force Unleashed

Star Wars force unleashed
Disney

To this day, I'm baffled quite how LucasArts ballsed up The Force Unleashed quite so much.

Both combat and your actual Force powers were pretty fun to deploy (if not forever paling in comparison to the underrated Psi-Ops: The Mindgate Conspiracy), but it was the reveal of a Star Destroyer being wrenched out the sky in the debut trailer that instantly became one for the Star Wars history books.

I mean, just look at it:

Can you feel the power of our main-man, Starkiller? Yes, it was pre-rendered, but woah baby, that moment with us at the helm would be even better, surely?

Guess again...

Instead of anything that gave you a feeling of tactility or power, you pulled the Star Destroyer out the sky by awkwardly positioning the two analogue sticks into just the right spot, Starkiller's hands awkwardly jutting to and fro like he was trying to land a plane in a hurricane.

It was like one of those lock-picking minigames from Skyrim or Splinter Cell - a far cry from the sensation that should've come with tearing one of science fiction's most iconic behemoths from the sky and bringing it to ground.

--

Which other games did you buy for one scene, only for it to fall apart? Let us know in the comments!


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.