10 Most Polarizing Characters In Video Games
Ashley in Resident Evil 4. Love or hate?
Video games are fundamentally character-driven. Most games have a hero and a supporting cast, and we all have our favorites, as well as our runts of the litter.
For the most part, people tend to agree on who's the best and who's the worst, but every now and then, we come across a character who's executed in such a way that the community can't agree on which end of the spectrum they belong.
Cue tons of heated discussions about whether such characters are the worst thing ever, or the best thing since sliced bread. Whether someone is a fan or a hater, they are likely to be just as passionate about the character as the person on the opposite side.
On that note, let's run down some of the most polarizing characters in gaming history. In every case, there are compelling arguments for, and against. Which side will you stand on?
10. Olgierd - The Witcher 3
The moral conundrum the player faces in The Witcher 3's Hearts of Stone DLC is quite a difficult one, so naturally, it tends to cause a lot of arguments within the game's community.
In the DLC, Geralt needs to settle a dispute between Olgierd, the cocky leader of a band of thugs, and Gaunter O'Dimm, a literal devil that the former made a pact with. While it may seem counterintuitive to side with Gaunter, some people actually believe that Master Mirror deserves to claim Olgierd's soul. Mostly due to the fact that Olgierd is not a very good person.
Olgierd's life is filled with terrifying acts of cruelty and plenty of self-serving choices, which culminated in his pact with the devil. To top it all off, some people don't much care for his arrogant and violent attitude.
On the other hand, there are those who think Olgierd deserves a second chance in life. They recognize that he deeply regrets the choices he's made, and believe that the curse that Gaunter cast on him has already made him suffer enough.
Olgierd's plea remains a huge topic of discussion among Witcher fans to this day. It just goes to show how complex his character is.
9. Ulfric Stormcloak - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Ulfric Stormcloak is the driving force behind the entire civil war questline in Skyrim. He's responsible for the aptly-named Stormcloak rebellion: he murdered the previous High King of Skyrim with the power of the Voice, and he is openly opposed to the Thalmor regime, which forbids the worship of Talos in the region.
His decisive actions mixed with his hatred for Thalmor rule make him a very popular leader, not just in the world of Skyrim, but also among fans of the game. The fact that the player shares the same prisoner cart with Ulfric at the start of the game is also an important factor in making his character appear more sympathetic.
However, some evidence in the game has turned a good chunk of the player base against Ulfric. According to notes the player can find inside the Thalmor embassy, the Stormcloak leader was deliberately manipulated by the Thalmor. The Elves brainwashed him into hating the Empire so that he would start the rebellion and weaken their enemies. The game even suggests that Ulfric's cause is secretly sponsored by them.
Some see Ulfric as a brilliant and charismatic leader. Some see him as a fool who abuses an ancient power to unwittingly aid his sworn enemies. In either case, his character is the subject of many heated debates.
8. Raiden - Metal Gear Solid 2
The release of Metal Gear Solid 2 was probably one of the greatest betrayals in video game history.
Hideo Kojima teased the return of Solid Snake in the sequel, giving fans hope that they would get to play as the beloved superspy again, but when the game finally came out, what people got was a brand-new protagonist, Raiden. Naturally, this decision didn't go over well.
What hurt Raiden's popularity even more was that his character came off as incredibly whiny and naïve. Compared to Snake, he was like a confused little boy who had no right to be the protagonist of the sequel to one of the greatest games ever.
It wasn't until Raiden's character was developed and made more competent in later games that people began to flip their opinions on him. He then gained even more credibility after being transformed into a badass ninja cyborg in Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance.
Still, the hate surrounding Raiden during the release of Metal Gear Solid 2 lingers on the internet to this day, and is unlikely to ever truly disappear.
7. Ashley Graham - Resident Evil 4
Ashley Graham's character is an interesting case, as it wasn't necessarily her personality that divided Resident Evil's fanbase, so much as the game mechanics related to her.
Ashley is the daughter of the US President that Leon Kennedy needs to rescue in Resident Evil 4. In terms of her attitude, she is an optimistic but level-headed young girl, which makes it really easy for the player to care about her safety and well-being.
However, as friendly as Ashley may appear on paper, her character ends up being really annoying due to a certain mechanic.
Since Ashley is not a fighter, the player needs to protect her by fending off enemies and helping her hide from danger. This may not sound totally bad, but due to the awful pathfinding in Resident Evil 4, Ashley ends up walking into your line of fire, or right into an easily-avoidable bear trap all the time. It doesn't take much time for you to start hating her AI's stupidity.
Despite this, some fans still manage to separate AI Ashley from the way the character was written, and can appreciate her good sides. But of course, others can never forgive her for making them restart the same level over and over again!
6. Jack - Mass Effect 2
Throughout the Mass Effect series, Commander Shepard joins forces with a lot of different characters. A good percentage of them are adored by fans, while some are unanimously hated (looking at you, Jacob).
However, there is also the rare character or two that receives an incredible amount of both love and hate at the same time.
Jack is one such character. As the most dangerous biotic criminal in the galaxy, she obviously has quite the mean streak, but unlike other "bad" characters in Mass Effect, she's extremely volatile and easily provoked, and she snubs most of Shepard's attempts at conversation. This, combined with her snarky and self-aggrandizing attitude, makes a lot of people dislike her.
On the other hand, those who have the patience to pursue a friendship or a romance with her discover that her bad personality is just a coping mechanism developed due to her traumatic childhood as a test subject. The more you get to know her, the more vulnerable she becomes, which is why some people consider her to be the most dynamic and sympathetic character in the series.
5. Garrosh Hellscream - World Of Warcraft
The Cataclysm expansion pack for World of Warcraft introduced a lot of controversial features and changes to the game. One of them was a change of leadership within the Horde faction, where the beloved Warchief Thrall was replaced with Garrosh Hellscream, an ever-furious and brutal warmonger. Suffice to say, many people weren't too happy about this replacement.
There were many things about Garrosh that made him a particularly unpopular leader. He didn't care about destroying the world in order to reach his goals, he caused a lot of in-fighting within his own faction, and on top of that, he was also outright racist towards non-orcs within the Horde.
When Cataclysm came out, most people shared the same hateful sentiment towards the new leader. However, as times changed and new Warchiefs were introduced, some people actually began to appreciate Garrosh and think of him as someone representative of the true essence of the Horde: its savage sense of honour, and veneration of raw strength.
Warchief Hellscream may not have been the most popular leader, but he was certainly one that inspired many debates within the WoW community.
4. Sindel - Mortal Kombat 11
Sindel from Mortal Kombat was not a source of controversy within the franchise's community until her retcon in Mortal Kombat 11.
Up until this 2019 release, Sindel was considered a victim of terrible circumstances. She was originally the queen of a realm called Edenia that was invaded and conquered by Shao Kahn. In order to save Kitana, her daughter and heiress to Edenia, she unwillingly married Shao Kahn and obeyed his every command. Fans of the game loved this depiction of Sindel, as it made her look like a noble and caring person.
However, in Mortal Kombat 11, the writers decided to retcon Sindel into being an evil person from the start. In this version of events, Sindel was never brainwashed, and she secretly married Shao Kahn of her own free will so that the two of them could create the greatest power couple in existence.
Naturally, such a radical change didn't resonate well with many fans - it felt like a betrayal of their sympathies towards her original, tragic fate. However, not everyone felt this way about the retcon. The bad girl Sindel appealed to some fans, who considered her transformation to be an entertaining plot twist that took the franchise in an interesting direction.
3. Trevor Philips - Grand Theft Auto V
The protagonists in Grand Theft Auto games are pretty much never the good guys. They steal, they rob, and they murder people, but as it turns out - even in a game where you're meant to act like a hardcore criminal - there are some boundaries that can't be crossed without making a few people upset.
One of the three playable characters in GTA V, Trevor, is an unhinged psychopath who, on top of the aforementioned stealing and killing, dabbles in cannibalism, torture, gasoline huffing, and many other insane things that would make even a veteran criminal sick in the stomach.
Naturally, Trevor's appearance in GTA V was met with mixed reactions upon the game's release. Some people loved playing as a crazy, over-the-top serial killer, stating that his antics were a nice break from the serious and depressing tone of GTA IV. Others were deeply disturbed by his behavior, and felt uncomfortable having to put themselves in his brain-covered shoes.
And speaking of those brain-covered shoes (spoiler alert!) it probably didn't help Trevor's reputation that the first thing he did in his introduction was kill a beloved protagonist from the previous game. Then again, you can't deny that he knew how to make a memorable entrance.
2. Sera - Dragon Age: Inquisition
Much like Mass Effect, Dragon Age has an impressive roster of companions that aid your character along the way. Most of them have pretty extensive backstories and very dynamic personalities, but then, there are characters like Sera.
Sera is an elven archer who loves to prank people, especially if they're stuck-up and rich. Due to her quick wit and love of inappropriate language, she is easily one of the most entertaining companions in Dragon Age: Inquisition. Her carefree attitude has earned her a big following, but she is also not without some very obvious flaws that have earned her an equal amount of haters.
One major issue with Sera's character is that she never seems to develop in any meaningful way. Whereas others tend to change over time, Sera is always stuck in her ways of pranking, and her irrational prejudice towards elves and magic. If you disagree with her in any way, she will immediately disregard you or start insulting you. And if you try to defend your traditions as an elf who romanced her, Sera will even break up with you over your differences.
It seems humour and character development don't mix well together.
1. Abby - The Last Of Us Part II
A list of polarizing characters wouldn't be complete without mentioning Abby from The Last of Us Part II. However, it's impossible to talk about her without any spoilers, so just in case you're interested in playing the game and haven't got around to it yet, you have been warned!
To those who have played the game, the reason so many people despise Abby is pretty obvious. She killed Joel! With a golf club, of all things!
Now, there are naturally some other minor issues with her character, like her dismissive attitude towards some of her companions, and the fact that she repeats the same mistakes as the person she despised. However, these character traits - or rather the way in which Abby develops past them - are also the reason why so many people defend her character against the hate.
After Abby kills Joel, the game lets you experience her life prior to that moment and gives you a chance to understand her better. The game then tries to humanize Abby in the present day, forcing you to question whether or not she's actually a villain for acting the way she did.
This arc made many people appreciate a character who the game initially wanted them to hate, but then again, it's easy to understand why some couldn't forgive her for Joel's death.
Watch Next
The Last Of Us: You'll Never 100% This Quiz