10 Most Rewarding Open-World Video Games

When every step is worth it.

Lillith Borderlands 2
Gearbox

Ever since Grand Theft Auto III changed the landscape of gaming in 2001, open-world titles have become increasingly plentiful, wide-ranging and ambitious.

Obviously, you’ve got genre-splicing first-person heavyweights like the Borderlands, Elder Scrolls, Fallout, and Far Cry series. Likewise, there are loads of third-person stylistic mashups to go around, including the Horizon, Saints Row, Mass Effect, Just Cause, and Assassin’s Creed franchises.

Even the creation of one-off gems – such as Mad Max, Sleeping Dogs, Burnout Paradise, and Shadow of the Colossus – has become more likely over the last twenty years.

Sure, there are occasional misses, such as the glitchy Two Worlds, the regressive Crackdown 3, and the repetitive and bland Fuel. After all, developers need to pack their sandbox universes with enough worthwhile gameplay, plot, and unlockables to keep players engaged for dozens of hours (so it’s easy to drop the ball in one way or another).

Luckily, none of the games on this (unranked) list succumb to those trappings. In fact, their engrossingly balanced mechanics, storytelling, characterizations, environments, and/or bonuses make them far more satisfying and enduring than their predecessors and peers. Be they recent favorites or older classics, they’re easily the most rewarding open-world video games to date.

10. Grand Theft Auto V

Grand Theft Auto V Michael
Rockstar

No disrespect to the comparatively authentic nature of GTA IV or the nostalgia of GTA: San Andreas, but GTA V absolutely delivers the richest package.

For one thing, its multiple protagonists and intersecting narratives pushed Rockstar North’s knack for compelling plots and distinctive personalities further. It’s all wildly tongue-in-cheek for much of the playtime, but there’s also sizeable pathos and relatability to Michael’s mid-life crises, Franklin’s plight for survival, and Trevor’s meta depiction of the player’s own desensitization to lawlessness.

There are a ton of great missions and other activities to do, too. From the adrenaline-fueled heists of Prologue, The Jewel Store Job, and The Big Score to the satirical Friend Request and surreal Risk Assessment, the trio are never wanting for a cool new operation.

Plus, they get to engage in cinema, real estate, racing, and various sports in-between, allowing Los Santos and the surrounding areas to be remarkably involving.

What really elevates GTA V, though, is its myriad surprises. Be it hidden UFOs and ghosts, countless references to pop culture, or secret locations and landmarks, the core experience is infinitely deepened by ancillary treats.

(Of course, the PC modding community and GTA Online have done wonders as well.)


9. Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption Jack Marston
Rockstar

Rockstar Games had quite the task in front of them in following up both 2013's GTA V and 2010's Red Dead Redemption. Unsurprisingly, they totally delivered, crafting the greatest open-world action/adventure Western known to man.

Taking place well before its precursor, its examination of the Van der Linde gang’s deterioration is enormously absorbing for its complex relationships and broader historical commentary.

There’s the typical smorgasbord of secondary pursuits, unique NPCs, and gratifying dividends in which to indulge. However, Red Dead Redemption 2 would be fulfilling without any of those things because the sheer breadth and realism of its five major regions are enough to keep players glued to their controllers.

The icing on the cake comes when you realize that – SPOILERS – it ultimately connects to tragic previous antihero John Marston via its epilogue and bittersweet 100% completion cinematic.

Admittedly, Red Dead Online isn’t nearly as successful as GTA Online (in terms of popularity, lucrativeness, and gameplay), to the point that the studio is pretty much giving up on it.

That said, it’s still a good time –the Frontier Pursuits, Moonshine, and Blood Money updates introduced significant additions – and its issues don’t take away from the strengths of its single-player paradise.


8. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

the witcher 3
CD Projekt RED

Although Cyberpunk 2077’s multitude of missteps severely hurt CD Projekt Red’s reputation, it’s hard to completely turn against them due to the excellence of 2015’s The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt.

Let’s start with its leading recreational activity, Gwent, a dynamic card game whose addictiveness yielded a separate free-to-play spin-off (Gwent: The Witcher Card Game). Yes, fist fighting and horse racing are cool, but there’s no denying that Gwent is the chief auxiliary draw.

It’s also got an encyclopedic level of lore to digest, with heaps of idiosyncratic people, places, and precedents to learn about.

Whether you’re traversing the dense metropolis Novigrad or the dark swampland Velen – and/or partaking in romances with sorceresses such as Yennefer and Keira Metz – you’re consistently enamored by the title’s novelistic aspirations. (That’s doubly true once you dive into all the enticing DLC.)

Equally important is the fact that star Geralt – and most of his friends and foes – are morally questionable, so there are few outright heroes or villains in the Continent.

It's no wonder why The Witcher 3 became the cornerstone of the franchise. After all, its monumentally satisfying offerings sparked newfound interest in both the preceding games and books and the subsequent Netflix show.


7. Elden Ring

Radagon statue Elden Ring
FromSoftware

The latest entry on this list, Elden Ring sees developer FromSoftware continuing to improve upon the soulslike formula of their most recent triumphs (Dark Souls III and Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice).

Primarily, its immensely varied setting – the Lands Between – circumvents a common downfall of open-world games by providing a massive locale that’s actually full of things to discover. (In contrast, a lot of titles prioritize gigantic yet relatively barren areas.) From hidden grottos, castles, and the like housing weapons both inanimate and alive, to towering enemies begging to be found, there’s always an exhilarating reason to go beyond the beaten and obvious path.

Elden Ring also eschews virtually all traditional standards of handholding by forgoing waypoints and – by and large – map markers. As a result, players find more investment and agency than usual in finding cool stuff and finishing quests and other tasks. Granted, this might be frustrating at first, but the feeling of finally conquering an obstacle or encountering something new is more than worth it.

Add in some truly fascinating lore, ample means of character customization, and better equilibrium between challenge and accessibility and you undoubtedly have the best soulslike journey ever made.


6. Horizon Forbidden West

Horizon Forbidden West
Guerrilla Games

Horizon Zero Dawn was arguably the greatest game of 2017, which is particularly commendable considering that it was such a marked departure from the bleak FPS mayhem of Guerrilla Games' Killzone saga.

Naturally, they outdid themselves with Horizon Forbidden West.

While just about every sequel looks better than its predecessor(s), Horizon Forbidden West’s awe-inspiringly detailed and diverse visuals are particularly pleasing because they enhance what’s already a fascinating depiction of a post-apocalyptic United States.

It doubles down on its precursor’s propensity for rewarding sightseeing (regardless of what missions and collectibles players are discovering in the process). With enhanced aerial traversal, newfound underwater exploration, and a host of new machines to meet, there’s far more enthralling discoverability.

On that note, gameplay improvements and additions such as the Pullcaster, the Shieldwing, fresh elemental damage types (acid and plasma), retooled skill trees, and amended focus abilities mean that controlling Aloy and battling foes is much more fun, complex, and malleable.

Plus, the storyline once again merges plot progression and personal moments beautifully, with returning characters and newcomers alike adding relatability and depth to the series’ expansive lore.

Although Horizon Zero Dawn didn’t necessarily need a follow-up, we’re very happy that it got one.


5. Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Metal Gear Solid V.jpg
Konami

Simply put, Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain’s transition into absolute open-world autonomy revolutionized the franchise and redefined the style.

Not only can ostensive protagonist Punished/Venom Snake attempt missions in any order he sees fit, but he can approach each one in dozens of ways. Maybe he’ll be completely stealthy by subduing (or capturing) enemies as he quietly progresses toward his main goal. Or, maybe he’ll go in guns blazing and cause unmitigated destruction and death.

Of course, there are plenty of other choices to make within those extremes, and with the option of relying on one of several distinct human or animal companions for help – as well as incorporating lots of cool unlockable tools – the possibilities are close to infinite.

Mother Base is incredibly changeable and entertaining, too, as you never know what absurd things your teammates may be saying or doing. Along the same lines, most NPCs will react to your actions and changes to their environment, sparking drastically unpredictable playthroughs.

Even the narrative is emblematically silly yet disturbing, flashy, and convoluted, so it’ll keep you fascinated and confused the whole time.

Despite its unfinished state, Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain is still highly enjoyable.


4. The Legend Of Zelda: Breath Of The Wild

Breath Of The Wild Champion's Ballad
Nintendo

Few IPs are as beloved as The Legend of Zelda, and a big reason why is its dependable and charming formula. Thus, Nintendo’s audacious decision to step away from it with 2017’s free-roaming Breath of the Wild could’ve been contentious.

Instead, it led to a brilliantly inspired renovation that many aficionados rank as the series’ best entry.

Yes, the dungeons and bosses are typically inventive and generous when it comes to collectables, upgrades, puzzles, fights, and the like; however, it’s the fact that Link can venture virtually anywhere he wants whenever he wants that turns his adventure into a genuine breath of fresh air.

That independence also leads to a wonderfully intriguing Hyrule, with quirky characters, self-referential easter eggs, alluring locations – both high and low – beckoning players for as far as the eye can see.

To accomplish everything, you’ll need to harness weapons and other devices both recycled and reinvigorating. From a varied arsenal of swords, bows, and bombs to unique instruments like the Savage Lynel Crusher and the Boulder Breaker, BOTW features some tremendously imaginative and enjoyable tools.

The icing on top? A cameo appearance from the late, great Robin Williams as Hylian wayfarer Dayto.

How awesome is that?


3. Ghost Of Tsushima

Ghost of Tsushima Jin Sakai
Sony Interactive Entertainment

Fans of the Sly Cooper and/or Infamous titles weren’t sure what to expect from Sucker Punch Productions’ latest effort. Fortunately, the award-winning Ghost of Tsushima proved to be their masterpiece.

Chiefly, hero Jin Sakai’s tale incorporates the savageness and serenity of the samurai lifestyle. Amidst the fierce confrontations and graphic consequences are abundant opportunities to settle down at a hot spring, craft a lovely haiku, engage with animals, or just marvel at the breathtakingly sundry and sophisticated island of Tsushima.

Part of that joyful feeling of investigation comes from how the almost HUD-less perspective lets nature lead the way via wind patterns and flying birds.

There are also thematically enriching collectibles galore, with headbands, masks, helmets, and other accouterments adding greater authenticity, customization, and motivation to uncover every inch of the land and complete as many tasks as possible.

Speaking of impetus, its depiction of Feudal Japan is compelling from story and gameplay standpoints, too, as the three main groups of missions (Tales of Tsushima, Mythic Tales, and Jin’s Journey) pack a lot of diversity as they guide you to intriguing new residents and plot developments.

Naturally, the music deserves praise for its cultural validity and stylish flexibility as well.


2. Fallout: New Vegas

Fallout New Vegas
Obsidian

It's a debate as old as time (or at least as old as 2010): Is Fallout: New Vegas better or worse than Fallout 3? Well, as much as the third entry set the template for the future of the franchise, it’s New Vegas that remains its superlative offering.

Las Vegas is inherently among the most visually arresting cities in the United States; therefore, combining its glitzy excesses and assorted terrains with the post-apocalyptic results of nuclear devastation is automatically enthralling.

There are massive amounts of flexibility regarding the RPG elements, too, permitting the comparatively multifaceted courier to become almost anyone the player envisions. Furthermore, his ability to become a brutish nincompoop, a suave bandit, a meek yet intelligent explorer, or any combination therein means that just about every decision is satisfyingly pliable.

Although the quantity of quests is perhaps a tad low, the quality of them is top-notch. Beyond being able to tackle them in numerous ways, nearly all of them are engrossing narratively, with a variety of tones being employed across its main, side, and unmarked expeditions.

Oh, and the Lonesome Road DLC even squeezes in an amusing nod to Planet of the Apes. What more could you want?


1. Borderlands 2

Borderlands 2
Gearbox

Okay, so Borderlands 3 is technically advanced and Tiny Tina's Wonderlands is an outstanding but significantly different spinoff. Nevertheless, neither of them tops this first sequel as the most rewarding Borderlands experience.

While every follow-up to the original had worthwhile scoundrels on both sides of the morality scale, this one houses the greatest cast of characters.

The four playable people (Axton, Maya, Zer0, and Salvador) are enchantingly entertaining and adaptable, giving players plenty of incentives to explore each one’s class traits and personality. Obviously, Claptrap is enhanced in several areas, too, meaning he’s funnier and more useful this time around. Let’s not forget that Borderlands 2 introduced the lovably douchey Handsome Jack, either.

The in-game environments are also hugely captivating and individualized, with the desert landscape of the initial Borderlands juxtaposed by icy battlegrounds, industrialized hubs, radioactive caverns, and the like. Naturally, these additions spawned a larger swath of colors and textures, so it’s looks superb in general.

Lastly – and maybe most importantly – the weaponry was a big leap forward, with a wider array of guns and other kits handling better and lending themselves to increased customizable loadouts.

Ten years later, Borderlands 2 is still the apex of the series.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Hey there! Outside of 'WhatCulture,' I'm a former editor at 'PopMatters' and a past or present contributor to 'Kerrang!,' 'Consequence,' 'PROG,' 'Metal Injection,' 'Loudwire,' and more. I've written books about Jethro Tull, Opeth, and Dream Theater, too, and I run a creative arts journal called 'The Bookends Review.' You can also find me talking about horror on YouTube (as Hairless Horror / @hairlesshorror)! Oh, and I live in Philadelphia and teach academic/creative writing courses at a few colleges/universities.