10 Most Shocking Video Game Sidekick Betrayals

We're still not over what Lance Vance did.

gta vice city lance vance
Rockstar

It’s handy when video game villains have big shootable eyes, maniacal laughs, or a penchant for kidnapping your girlfriend to signal that they’re super evil, but sometimes games throw you a wolf in sheep’s clothing.

In the roughest of examples, these can sometimes be the very people you’ve been trusting with your hide up until this point, so it’s a nasty feeling when they go and stab you in the back you expected them to be protecting.

In some cases you might be expecting it, in the most heartbreaking you absolutely were not, and we were spoiled for choice with this list.

Note: This list contains spoilers

--

10. Astrid - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim

skyrim astrid
Bethesda

Now it’s commonly believed that the Dark Brotherhood quests are the best guild quests in Skyrim, or I think that and now I’ve said online that everyone thinks that, either way they’re famous for their twists and turns.

There’s plenty of backstabbing going on in the infamous assassin-riddled brotherhood, but it’s usually the literal kind and less so the turning-on-your-own-team kind. That is, until Astrid screws the pooch, and her entire crew over. We’re playing it a little fast and loose with the definition of ‘sidekick’ here but Astrid is indeed your sister in murdery crime as leader of The Dark Brotherhood.

Problem is, Astrid gets a little suss when you’re cast as the new Listener, liaison to the Night Mother. She feels threatened and decides to get her betrayal on.

She sells you out to the Empire after sending you on an epic Emperor poisoning quest. Rocking up back at the sanctuary post-assassination as you’re well used to doing by this point is a real shock. Turns out you only poisoned a decoy, and Astrid’s betrayal attempt itself is double crossed as the leader of the Emperor’s special security force turns on her and sacks the Dark Brotherhood sanctuary. Many of your comrades die and you can find a decidedly charred and remorseful Astrid in the remains, asking you to kill her.


9. Master Li - Jade Empire

Bioware

BioWare’s Jade Empire isn’t quite an anime betrayal, but it is an excellent shock turn so let’s take a walk down memory lane.

Master Li was the brother of the Empire and your teacher in Jade Empire. For the first half of the game he serves as your mentor and everything’s all good, then once you vanquish The Emperor Li tells you how proud he is of you and then freaking kills you. The Water Dragon Spirit walks you through a little resurrection process but the biggest sting comes from realising you were just a pawn in Li’s major revenge scheme.

Also there’s the whole him becoming a god and proclaiming himself to be the new Emperor of the Jade Empire, that’s a bit of a problem too.

This was a turn plenty of players didn’t see coming, which makes it so fantastic. I mean, this guy made you who you were and had your back every step of the way, and that makes your final confrontation with your ex-Master bear a tonne of narrative weight.


8. Kendra - Dead Space

dead space kendra
Visceral

Kendra Daniels is one of the few humans scraping by and hoping to survive alongside Isaac on the USG Ishimura. For the most part she appears to be helping you find your girlfriend Nicole.

That is, until the end of the game when Kendra tells you that Nicole’s been dead the whole time. And she knew about it. She also reveals that she’s been using you to try to track down a piece of alien technology called the Marker for her superiors. She not only uses you to do her bidding the whole time, she drops the nasty news on you that all your efforts to rescue Nicole have been for naught.

She does die via being smooshed to smithereens by a tentacle though so maybe that’ll make you feel mildly better before you face your own depressing fate.


7. Big Smoke & Ryder - Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas

GTA san andreas betrayal big smoke
Rockstar

There’s some argument over which epic GTA betrayal is the nastiest, and the cruel turn of Big Smoke & Ryder absolutely belongs on this list.

The Grove Street Families stick together. Except they super don’t and the dudes you expect to have your back through thick and thin just totally screw you over after all. CJ’s lifelong friend Big Smoke and Ryder betray the GSF by meeting up with CRASH, that is, the Community Resources Against Street Hoodlums, and the Ballas gang, ultimately opting to sell everyone else out for money and power.

The insult on top of the crappy injury is CJ spotting the meeting as it goes down, including seeing the same car present when his mother was gunned down by the Ballas at the beginning of the game. Extremely uncool.

Delivering your own method of justice feels fair but the scene comes as a real shock and is honestly just super freaking disappointing.


6. Wheatley - Portal 2

Portal 2 Wheatley
Valve

Man, this one still smarts and I don’t know who I’m more mad at about it, Wheatley or the game.

The world of Portal is pretty cold and unfriendly as it is, so when Wheatley the wise-cracking personality core rocks up in Portal 2, it’s a real relief. It’s nice to have a quirky pal along for the ride and Stephen Merchant’s voicework makes the little dude all the more delightful. That is right up until he takes GLaDOS’s place and power corrupts him. At this point he totally turns on you and the worst part is we did not see it coming.

Fighting him also sucks because you still really want to have his back, but ultimately you have to boot him into space. Sorry, buddy. Still feels awful to see him floating through space all remorseful.


5. General Shepherd - Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

call of duty modern warfare 2 lieutenant Commander Shepard
Activision

If we’re covering our bases on brutal betrayals we absolutely can’t leave out General Shepherd. I’m sorry in advance for resurfacing this memory.

For some, this bastard will quite rightly be the worst of the worst on this list. Shepherd was the commander of task force 141 and sends the team on what are essentially suicide missions. Toward the back end of the story, Roach and Ghost are just about to obtain information that may help prevent World War 3. Modern Warfare 2 gets us across the fact that the Russians and Germans are bad news but it turns out the worst of all seemed to be on our team all along.

Turns out the dude who claimed to fight terrorism was in fact perpetuating it to cement himself as a war hero and prolong military action as a method of vengeance for many troops lost under his command.

Not only is that pretty freaking bad. Shepherd comes to save Roach and Ghost and instead shoots them and then burns them alive. Unbelievably uncool.


4. Vincent - A Way Out

A Way Out
Hazelight Studios

A Way Out is a co-op game. That’s co-op as in cooperative. You literally break out of jail together and learn all about each other’s families. That is until you hit the end and it turns out somebody is a big lying liar.

That somebody is Vincent who, despite acting like Leo’s partner in crime for the entire freaking game, reveals himself to be a police officer that’s been undercover the whole time, and has just been using Leo to avenge his brother’s killer. The turn comes out of nowhere and the worst part is your buddy next to you is playing the other party and only one of these guys is making it out alive. It’s a brutal end to an otherwise delightful cooperative adventure game.

If you want to know the fastest way to go from having a joyful time solving puzzles with your mate to having an enormous argument, this last level is the way to go about it. From my experience. I will be taking no further questions at this time.


3. Lance Vance: Grand Theft Auto: Vice City

Gta Vice City Lance Vance
Rockstar

Lance Vance was a fan favourite in GTA Vice City, a game that puts you in the shoes of Tommy Vercetti. While the two of you are mates it’s safe to say Tommy isn’t the nicest to Lance.

He goes out of his way to tell Lance that the Vercetti business is his operation, so, look, it may not come as the world’s biggest surprise when he turns against you. That doesn’t make it hurt any less when he heads back to his old boss to sell you out to your nemesis Sonny Forelli and the Italian mafia, though. Not to mention feeling pretty foolish if he did indeed get one over on you.


2. Dutch - Red Dead Redemption 2

Dutch van der Linde
Rockstar

Yes, Dutch. His shady lackey Micah sucks and he always sucked, but Dutch was your guy, Dutch was Arthur’s guy. You went through thick and thin having each other’s backs and for him to turn on you was absolutely cruel.

Dutch, the head of the Van der Linde gang, may not be the most villainous villain on this list, you could argue he’s hardly a villain at all, but watching him betray Arthur is totally heartbreaking.

We know Micah manipulated Dutch and played on his weaknesses, and Arthur starts questioning Dutch’s decision-making more and more as his calls make less sense, but the fact that it takes Arthur almost dying for Dutch to begin to listen to him about Micah being a massive douche is agonising. Even then, you feel so terribly let down, and your connection to Arthur makes it sting all the more.

The moment where Arthur desperately tries to convince Dutch that Micah is the rat and he just won’t believe you severely sucks. As does the fact that he gets most of the gang to side against you. Arthur deserved better.


1. Frank Fontaine - BioShock

Bioshock Fontaine
2K

Yeah, you know this one was coming. Even if you’ve heard this one a million times before it’s still an excellent story and a fantastically executed betrayal.

“Would you kindly” has become one of the most infamous phrases in gaming thanks to your sidekick Atlas AKA Andrew Ryan’s arch-nemesis, Frank Fontaine. The underwater epic adventure narrative comes to a head when you murder Ryan with a golf club and subsequently discover your friendly neighborhood guide Atlas is an infamous conman. Not only that, the entire personality of Atlas, his appearance, his family, and backstory was spun out of lies in order to have you do his bidding.

You discover that you’re Ryan’s son and you were kidnapped by Fontaine and conditioned to obey the trigger phrase “Would you kindly”, any request that begins with that phrase you’d feel compelled to complete. And it’s a video game so, you know, you did.

You felt betrayed by Atlas, and honestly betrayed by the whole damn game. There weren’t many who could truly say they saw that one coming.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Jess has been a journalist and content creator in the games industry for over 15 years and has been WhatCulture's resident Australian import and sorry cop since 2020, upping the quotient of swearing and apologising in WhatCulture Gaming's annual blooper videos considerably. She previously worked at GameSpot for 10 years, most notably hosting GameSpot News in addition to E3 live shows, and PAX panels. She regularly livestreams a variety of games on her 'jessmcdonell' YouTube and Twitch channels and hosts the 'Do It On The Day' podcast. She has won awards for her news and feature work in gaming as well as an accolade for her comedic writing (likely an admin error). She can be found on X at @jessmcdonell and Instagram at @jessicamcdonell sharing her current videogame fixations, industry insights, and videos of her cat, Karma.