10 Open-World Video Game Tropes EVERYONE Is Sick Of

The age of the oversized open-world is over.

final fantast 15 final fantasy XV
Square Enix

Adding an open world to your game is the new cover-based shooting, quick-time event, or amnesiac hero.

But like the aforementioned tropes, it's often just included in a game because it's the 'in' thing to do. Originally designed to add a depth of realism and immersion that pre-planned, linear set pieces have just never been able to do - so many cases of open worlds are totally lacking.

So many developers create open world games and brag about the size of the map, or the number of random encounters you may face along the way. But is that actually a positive thing?

Is it better to have 500 square acres of dead, empty worlds - or would 10 acres of a living, vibrant game world be a more fun option?

There are good open world games out there, but there are so, so many bad ones, too. Here are the things that open world games need to stop doing if they want to be better.

10. Manually Picking Up Each Resource And Item

Red dead redemption 2
Rockstar Games

Between the prevalence of crafting systems and fetch quests you're going to be hard pressed to find a game that doesn't require you to pick up items on a regular basis. Open World games are filled with random tat to pick up.

From bullets in a radioactive toilet to flowers in a meadow to hitting a rock with your weapon to get ore – you're going to be gathering stuff for a lot of your play time.

One thing we really can't stand, as gamers, but are forced to tolerate is a collection animation each and every time we pick up an item.

Remember Connor in Assassin's Creed III and Arthur Morgan in Red Dead Redemption 2? Kill an animal? You've got to cut it open with a cutscene each time. Anything like this gets so much worse if it's un-skippable.

Sniper Elite 4 has you snatch documents from a table immediately, but you have to spend a full minute holding down the 'raid pockets' button and watch an animation, just to find out the enemy wasn't carrying anything useful.

Just let players auto-collect as they pass by the item. Especially egregious if there's a disconnect between types of items or collection styles.


9. Over-Encumbrance

skyrim mod
Bethesda

You can't risk an auto-grab mechanic unless you deal with encumbrance. We've all seen the memes about a Skyrim player with a backpack full of cheese, skulls and weapons, picking up a lone flower and suddenly being too heavy to move.

If you can only carry so many items or so much weight, then picking and choosing what you carry is important. But by now devs should know that gamers are just going to pick everything up. You can never be sure when it's going to be important, right?

Extra points against the game if the only way to get rid of an item is to discard it forever. At least let players sell it for a pittance, they took the time to collect it, after all.

Sliding scales of encumbrance are one way to fix the issue – the more you're carrying the slower you are. But developers need to consider the most important aspect of the debate:

Does even having encumbrance make my game better... or simply more tedious?

Generally it's just tedium. If your game isn't survival horror or hyper-realistic, you probably don't need encumbrance at all.


8. Enemies You Can Only Fight With Other Players

pokemon go raid
Niantic

Open-world MMOs are famous for these massive 'raids' and 'world bosses', to the point that they're generally lauded as a feature.

Parts of the world or enemies you need to fight to advance a story or get an important piece of gear for your character – but they can only be defeated by a team. Or maybe even a small army!

Even more egregious are games that you can play entirely single-player, except for a couple of things where you need to seek out social interaction to win. Having fun playing this game with a tight storyline by yourself? Well, if you want to get that extra special item you've had your eye on, you'll now suddenly need to talk to other people and set up a team.

High-level character in Conan Exiles with a maxed out combat thrall by your side want to fight the first boss enemy you come across, right after the 'tutorial'?

Four hits and you're dead, but at least you took down its health by 4%. Go get your friends and come back! Oh, you don't have friends? That's okay, the boss just holds the only way to get the strongest items in the game, no big deal.


7. Bad Map Design

Assassins Creed Map
Ubisoft

One thing that an open world needs, well any world really, in order to be explored, is a map.

Whether it's the soliton radar in Metal Gear Solid, the minimap in the corner of your screen in a thousand other games, or the over-arching map you see when you press the pause button - your game needs a map.

So many open worlds have such poor map design. From titles like Cyberpunk 2077 that make their map nearly unreadable with all of the icons and logos sprawled all over it, or the deluge of games that thought "not holding the player's hand" meant not showing you where you were, or giving any indication of locations.

Genshin Impact is a prime example of an 'okay' map - it's not too over-inundated with info like Cyberpunk or Assassin's Creed. But it is guilty of another cardinal issue: Having fast travels in the middle of nowhere - a place with no important resources or quests. Meanwhile, a place you're going to be at for quests twice a week is a two-minute sprint from the nearest spawn point.

And don't get me started on maps with no icons or way-pointing at all!


6. Bad Minimaps/Quest Markers

Ghost Of Tsushima Fox
Sucker Punch Productions

We touched on this in the last entry, but even a good map can be ruined by poor waypointing or an inability to easily access the map. If the only way to get to your map is to hit pause, open Items, select map, then watch a map opening animation - then we're gonna have a problem, friend.

There's a school of thought that minimaps in the corner of the screen are bad UI design and detractors who say minimaps are better than not having anything there. I won't bother to open up that debate here - but we should all consider how the game tells us to get from point A to wherever point B may be located.

There's tons of clever ways to handle this - from an NPC with the player saying "Hey, I think we need to go through that door" to just having stuff glow a certain color. But in open world games so often it's entirely up to the player to choose where to go.

Ghost of Tsushima's wind and the Mafia remaster's road signs when driving are excellent examples. Genshin Impact's elemental sight that goes away when you move is not.


5. Empty, Uninteresting Environments

Final Fantasy Xv Open World
Square Enix

One major difference between an open world game and the actual open world is that in the real world there's people and things to interact with. So many open world games are filled with...just...nothing.

A lot of games try to replicate a vast, interactive world by just filling it with more enemies to fight. All that does is make getting from one place to another more tedious.

The second most prevalent option is filling open world maps with little sidequests, a random NPC on a barren farmstead sitting in a chair saying “Can ya'll fetch me some randomium ore?” If you're lucky it will be nearby, but often it's on the other side of the map.

Another option is to include NPCs who just roam about and you can talk to, but it often creates a disconnect to the reality of the world. Like the brave soldier patrolling a mountain road who ignores you fighting creatures because he's only scripted to talk.

All of these are really just masking the fact that open worlds are often dead worlds with no imagination put into how the world interacts with itself.


4. Environmental Glitches

Witcher 3 roach
CDPR

Every game has some bugs in it when they're released. One of the boons of the modern online era is that developers can release patches to fix them.

Unfortunately that, along with tight development cycles, has led game makers to become complacent with their QA tests. And open world games suffer the most because of this.

Sometimes a linear game with very little room to deviate from the designated path will have a weird spot where you can clip through a floor, get caught on a wall, or shoot through a door but not through the gap in a railing.

Open worlds have so much open space, and yet so many moving, interconnected parts to consider, that even with months of crushing QA it would be tough to find - not to mention fix - every instance of weird bugs.

But the unforgivable annoyance is when these games are left for years without blatant glitches getting fixed. Elex came out in 2017 but still has story quests you can complete by exiting the dialogue tree too soon. Given lacklustre sales compared to other games cited in this list, I doubt those will ever fixed.


3. Illogical Barriers

Spyro Reignited Trilogy Stone Hill Invisible Wall
Activision

A lot of games have barriers to keep you from getting to places you're not supposed to be in, whether temporary or permanent.

Sometimes it will be an impassible river because your character can't swim, or even an ocean with no boats, maybe it's a well-guarded barrier gate or just a fence that's impervious to all forms of ammunition. And of course the most dreaded gaming guardian of all - the invisible wall.

A lot of games have flimsy reasons why you can't get somewhere, but open world games are the worst. Touching on our earlier entry about dead, empty worlds - try entering a building in an open world game.

Why can't you enter that building? The doorknob doesn't work?

One of the more annoying ones is having your assistant character say some variation on "Let's not go that way/do that, yet", then mind-controlling your character to walk in the opposite direction. It's seen in Ocarina of Time, Genshin Impact and even Persona 5.

One of the more interesting versions of this is the "Brine" of Dragon's Dogma. Go too deep into the water? Get possessed/eaten by a magical man-eating underwater cloud.

As you do.


2. Bad Tutorials

Driver Tutorial
Reflections Interactive

This is especially the case in many 'survival open world' games, such as Conan Exiles or Life is Feudal. But even a regular game may come without a pertinent explanation of how your character interacts with the world. Many open world games seem to feel the need to give you no guidance on where you fit in.

There's two parts to this, of course.

The first is that developers don't want to flood players with menu upon menu upon menu. That's boring.

The second is that developers want the player to experience the interactive features by exploration. The problem with the latter is that if you have nothing to tell you, or to incentivize you, to interact with something in a particular way - you might miss it altogether.

This is a tough balance for game developers because you can easily shoehorn your players into a guided mode of play where they only receive prompts in the order you want them to do things and getting bored from too much guidance. But you can also leave them fluttering in the wind, getting bored from not knowing what to do.


1. Unnecessarily Limited Stamina

Zelda breath of the wild
Nintendo

Your game is the largest open world ever created? The map encompasses over 500 square miles of mountains, rivers, cities, and plateaus? And the character I'm going to play as can only sprint for 25 feet at a time before being so exhausted he has to walk at .5 miles per hour?

Who actually wanted this?

There can be beneficial reasons for including stamina in an open world game. When you're running from enemies it makes things more dramatic that you can't run forever, climbing becomes a puzzle because you have to determine what route to take and when to rest, and it forces the player to take a break and look around for more efficient routes to speed up their movement.

But when you're rehashing the same section of the map over, and over, again - limited stamina can really grow annoying - quick, fast, and in a hurry!

A good fix for this is to make stamina be situational - like running while enemies are nearby makes you shed stamina while sprinting, but just running around won't. Climbing will reduce your stamina, but vaulting over a table would not.

How can my character expect to fist-fight dragons if a ten-meter dash totally gasses them?


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Author of Escort (Eternal Press, 2015), co-founder of Nic3Ntertainment, and developer behind The Sickle Upon Sekigahara (2020). Currently freelancing as a game developer and history consultant. Also tends to travel the eastern U.S. doing courses on History, Writing, and Japanese Poetry. You can find his portfolio at www.richardcshaffer.com.