10 Outdated Video Game Design Tropes That Must Die In 2017
Why would you put the checkpoint BEFORE the cutscene?!
Despite graphics, level design and stories all improving over the years, many games still include mechanics that are outdated, lazy and/or just plain irritating.
Whether it’s complacency from the developers, rushed release schedules implemented by publishers or apathy from gamers, these issues have been allowed to remain, blighting many otherwise innovative and enjoyable video games.
Because as the technology improved during the early days of console gaming, trends began to appear; if one developer came up with something good, others would follow suit, creating the gameplay tropes and basic mechanics that gamers know and love today.
Unfortunately, because many of these tropes quickly became built into the very fabric of gaming, it’s now almost impossible to get rid of them. Trends and mechanics that were cutting edge during one console generation were already outdated by the next; let alone the current generation.
Because many of these tropes have become associated with specific genres and franchises, developers find it hard to improve or replace them. However, with gamers always looking towards the latest innovations in both hardware and software, they’ve become willing to accept that many of these once great tropes need to go.
10. Narrative Choices That Don't Impact Plot
Many video games now offer various ways to complete the story, often including some sort of ‘choice’ you have to make to advance the story in a certain direction. In games like Mass Effect, these narrative choices are well thought-out and really stay with the player long after they’ve finished the game.
However, some titles include gameplay or narrative choices that literally have no impact on the plot whatsoever. They make out that this choice or action will have a massive impact, but when you get to that point, you realise your decision made no difference whatsoever.
The story mode in FIFA 17, The Journey, was guilty of this. No matter how well you played, Alex Hunter always ended up on loan to a Championship club. You could score a hat-trick every game and be keeping that Gareth kid out of the team, but every single time you would end up on loan, while he became the golden boy.
The fact that this happens no matter what actions you take makes the early stages of the story seem pointless. Why bother trying to play well if you know this event is always going to happen?
9. AI Companions That Can't Keep Up
Many games include an AI companion that follows you around during levels. Sometimes they’ll help you out with specific skills, other times they are there to help carry your equipment, but most often they are there just so your character doesn’t sound stupid talking out loud to give exposition to the story.
Unfortunately, many games now make it compulsory to stick with these companions, meaning you can’t progress further in the level without them. This usually results in long periods of waiting at a doorway because your partner can’t keep up with you.
If you’re really unlucky and playing a particularly poor game, you’ll spend a lot of the time backtracking to try and locate your companion, only to discover the AI has gotten stuck behind a barrier back at the start of the level.
Technology has improved drastically over the years, so surely developers have figured out how to make the AI characters keep pace with the players by now? If the player’s character can run and jump over basic obstacles, why can’t the AI as well?
8. Grinding Achievements/Trophies
The introduction of the achievement and trophy systems for Xbox and PlayStation gave players even more ways to enjoy their favourite games. Instead of just finishing the story and maybe collecting some of the hidden items, there were now official ‘tasks’ to complete to encourage you to keep playing way longer than the standard 12 hour campaign.
However, some developers decided to add achievements with ridiculous requisites that were nothing more than grinding. Many achievements involve killing a certain amount of enemies, but some games took that too far and expected you to kill thousands of them, which would mean you playing for possibly hundreds of hours.
In the awful Godzilla PS4 game, one achievement asked you to fully upgrade every single character – which involved playing the repetitive campaign several dozen times for each monster.
Achievements that involve grinding in online modes are even worse – having to play an empty online mode for hours and hours just to get a little icon on your gamer profile is infuriating. There’s a reason they were called 'achievements' – it was supposed to be something extra to do to give you a sense of accomplishment.
Nowadays, spending hours just to get one trophy just gives you a feeling of ‘Why did I waste my time on that?’
7. Badly Designed In-Game Currency
Many games, particularly RPGs, use some sort of currency for buying items and upgrading stats/weapons. More complex games use multiple types of currency that can only be used for certain things, meaning you can’t just focus on one to collect if you want to fully appreciate the game.
However, many games that use multiple currencies don’t fully think them through, which can often lead to players having loads of one currency but barely any of the other.
In Homefront: The Revolution, you collect both dollars and resistance points. The dollars let you buy weapons and consumables, while the resistance points let you get special upgrades to your throwable weapons.
The only way to get the points is to do side missions, but having completed not even all of them and bought every single thing possible with the points, I had around 100 points left over. They can’t be exchanged for dollars or used for anything else, so those points become completely useless after a certain point in the game.
Having multiple currencies can improve the gameplay by making the player work for certain upgrades and giving them a way to separate character building from general gameplay, but developers need to make sure they balance the amounts of each currency you get.
6. Unlockable Items Only Available After Completion
In the days of season passes and pre-order bonuses, unlocking a new outfit or weapon via actual gameplay is quite rare and really gives a sense of accomplishment – you truly feel like you’ve earned that item.
However, this good feeling gets lost a little when you unlock something by completing absolutely everything in the game.
It sounds strange – you’ve beaten the game 100%, you should be happy; it's literally everything you can do – but that’s why the accomplishment is lost. What’s the point of getting a new outfit or weapon after you’ve done everything else? You’re not likely to play that game again after putting so much time in, so you’re never going to really use that new item.
You’ll usually play for a few minutes with what you worked so hard to get, but it’s a hollow feeling now that there’s nothing left to do in the game. Most of the time players will just lament the fact that this really useful item wasn't available earlier, as it would have made getting to 100% completion a lot easier.
The achievement/trophy for fully completing the game is more than enough for players to feel accomplished, so just drop these extra 'incentives'.
5. Terrible Checkpoint Placement (BEFORE Cutscenes?!)
The placement of checkpoints (more commonly known as auto-saves nowadays) has always been a vital part of any game. Too many and there’s almost no challenge, but too few, and you have to get to a certain point before you can turn off the game.
Unfortunately, some games seem to have issues with where they actually place their checkpoints. Many still put them just before a cutscene, rather than after it. This cutscene is often before a difficult section like a boss battle (and is usually un-skippable), meaning if you die, you have to watch the whole thing again.
W-H-Y.
Players don’t have a problem with repeating difficult sections of a game (that is the challenge of it, after all) but the fact you have to replay the easy parts constantly just to get to the difficult bit, is mind-boggling.
When you’re taking on a boss and you’re trying to work out the right pattern to beat them, you don’t want to redo the parts before the boss each time you die; you just want to get the chance to fight them again straight away while you've got some momentum.
4. 'Sprint Meters' And Bad Running Mechanics
No one likes walking in video games. Why would you walk if there are cars, boats, tanks and planes available to use? If players do find themselves on foot without the ability to fast travel, you can guarantee they’ll be spamming the ‘run’ button the entire time, or doing some sort of jump/hop/roll to go faster.
Walking is slow, which is why it’s irritating when certain games only let you run for a short period of time. Sprinting is something you can upgrade in games like Saints Row, but in franchises like Call of Duty you can only run for a couple of seconds at a time.
Considering you’re supposed to be a highly trained solider (and in the more recent games, have abilities such as wall-running and double jump), it’s ridiculous that you can only run for this short amount of time.
The challenge in Call of Duty is having multiple enemies attacking you at once with only a limited arsenal to defend yourself with, so why stick a restriction on running speed? All it does is drag out the sections where you have to go through a corridor to get to another gun battle.
3. Unskippable End Credits
Just like films and TV shows, video games include a credits sequence to make sure everyone who worked on its creation gets the recognition they deserve.
Understandably, these credits are longer due to more people working on games compared to other things, so most games either let you skip them, or include some form of gameplay or extra content to enjoy whilst they roll on by.
Assassin’s Creed 2 included a section that let you control Desmond in the modern day, whilst Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare let you listen to messages of the characters that had died during the campaign, for example.
However, some games still don’t let you skip the end credits. Have you ever been stopped from leaving the cinema before the credits had finished? (Being forced to wait by Marvel doesn’t count), and does your TV lock the channel until the show is totally over?
Forcing players to sit through 20 minutes of names with nothing else to do is just irritating. Even worse, thanks to the Marvel effect of having bonus scenes at the end of the credits, many games have started doing it as well, meaning many fans feel compelled to wait through the credits just in case there is something at the end.
2. Cutscenes That Replace Gameplay
In recent years, many games have tried to move away from the traditional cinematic cutscene in favour of the dynamic scene that plays out within the game, made popular by the Half-Life series. Some games do still use cinematic cutscenes, with Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare using a combination of cinematic and in-game renders.
However, some of the games that do still include cinematic cutscenes use them overzealously and as a result, instead of simply setting up scenes and continuing the story, they just take away control from the player and force them to watch events that they would rather be playing themselves.
The Mad Max video game (unrelated to the Fury Road movie) was guilty of this; many of the cutscenes went on longer than they needed to be, and prevented you from playing out the ‘cool’ moments. In one particular section of the game where you have to escape your hideout, you drive flat out towards the edge of a huge drop, but just before you reach it a cutscene triggers, showing Max make the jump and drive away.
Those are the moments gamers want to play, not watch. Imagine getting to the top of a roller-coaster, then having to watch someone else go over the edge – it’s a complete anti-climax.
1. Tailing Missions
Gamers have always found escort missions to be irritating, as most of the time the character you’re escorting is about as useful as a chocolate fireguard, but another mission type that is getting more and more annoying are tailing missions.
These missions have always been around, but the Assassin’s Creed series really brought them to the forefront of mainstream gaming. It made sense for those games to include them, seeing as you play an assassin who needs to track targets and gather information, but many games stick so rigidly to the mechanics of tailing someone that the end result often becomes ridiculous.
For example, in many open world games, such as Mafia 3, you have to follow a target in a vehicle without getting spotted. Stay too far away and you’ll lose them; get too close and they’ll see you.
However, to avoid getting too close you often have to stop several metres behind their vehicle, which in real life would be more suspicious than just stopping right behind them. The film 21 Jump Street parodied this scenario, which just goes to show how well known this tailing mechanic problem actually is.
Surely developers can reprogram these missions, although 2017 would be a great time to just ditch them completely.
--
Which other game design choices have completely passed their sell-by date? Let us know in the comments!