10 Phenomenal Video Games NOBODY Bought

Sunset Overdrive walked so Hi-Fi RUSH could run.

Sunset Overdrive
Microsoft Studios

Within the world of video games, there have been extraordinary success stories of record-breaking sales and acclaim alongside soul-crushing lows of development hell leading to devastating flops.

Usually, our understanding is that good games sell well while the truly awful ones are left to be forgotten. After all, who wants to spend their hard-earned money on something that nobody seems to like?

This isn't always the case, however. Sales numbers aren't always a solid indicator of a game's overall quality, with there being some genuinely incredible and genre-defining games failing to draw in the crowds.

There can be any number of reasons for why this could be the case. The game, through no fault of its own, could be sent out to compete with equally great titles that happened to sell better. The marketing campaign may have been a disastrous misfire. Or the interest from general audiences just wasn't there at the time.

While some of these titles have since gone on to achieve the recognition they've deserved since day one with a dedicated cult following and newfound appreciation from the wider community, they nevertheless failed to make much of an impression when they first hit the scene.

10. The Saboteur (2009)

The Saboteur
Pandemic

The final game to come from Pandemic Studios before they closed their doors, The Saboteur can best be described as Grand Theft Auto meets Assassin’s Creed set within a stylised German-occupied France. In it, you play as Irish racing driver Sean Devlin who becomes caught-up in the French resistance.

By combining third person shooting with stealth, driving, and even some parkour, this title centred itself around a supremely playable mix of mechanics that kept moment-to-moment gameplay fun and fresh.

The biggest draw, however, was undoubtedly the art design. Occupied areas of the city are presented in a slick black-and-white, punctuated with splashes of vibrant reds from blood sprays and explosions. It’s only when enemy forces have been vanquished from that borough that colour returns to the Parisian streets, bringing them back to vibrant life.

For everything that this game got so spectacularly right, it's a tragedy that The Saboteur went completely under the radar on release. It’s only in the past few years that this cult classic has begun to get the recognition it deserves.

Between the developer's closure and the lack of interest at launch, the unfulfilled potential for a sequel has remained a sore spot for fans of this fantastic game.


9. Kingdom's Of Amalur: Reckoning (2012)

Kingdoms Of Amalur ReReckoning
38 Studios

Kingdoms Of Amalur: Reckoning was doomed to fail from the start.

Arriving just three months after the world-shaking release of Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, this vibrant and ambitious RPG didn’t stand a chance, despite having a lot of good things going for it. High profile names like acclaimed author R.A Salvatore, comic book artist Todd McFarlane, composer Grant Kirkhope, and Elder Scrolls designer Ken Rolston were all attached to the project.

Set in a sprawling fantasy world brimming with personality, Amalur enabled players to create and tweak their chosen hero to their liking while allowing for experimentation and variety.

In short, the gameplay was exceptional for 2012.

Amalur received glowing reviews from critics and remains a beloved cult hit to those who played. Sadly, this underrated RPG didn’t make much of a splash in terms of sales.

Whereas Skyrim racked up over three million copies in the first 48 hours, Amalur barely scraped half that in the first three months. Moreover, the unimpressive sales figures combined with massive overspending by developers 38 Studios saw the studio close their doors for good soon after.

With a remaster cracking the UK sales charts, though, Amalur did get a happy ending.


8. The Surge 2 (2019)

the surge 2
Focus Home Interactive

Set within a dystopian near-feature that's been overrun by rogue machinery, The Surge's challenging combat and epic enemy encounters drew comparisons to Dark Souls. But Deck 13's title was more than a generic sci-fi Soulslike - it was genuinely forward-thinking and came with the neat idea of targeting specific parts of enemies to acquire the best loot.

The sequel likewise took the foundations of its predecessor and built upon them in substantial ways, with the combat system seeing the greatest improvement.

Not only was there a wider variety of enemy types, but enemies could now coordinate with each other thanks to an improved AI system. Moreover, the introduction of new weapon types and character customisation meant that players could now experiment with different playstyles, with a revamped parry system adding a further level of challenge to encounters too.

Put simply, The Surge 2 was bigger, better, and a more refined iteration of what the first game offered.

While this title earned favourable reviews from critics, the interest from customers just wasn't there. Since its launch, this title (along with the series) has since fizzled into obscurity.

Given that The Surge 2 is more than a generic Soulslike, this fate was unmerited.


7. Sunset Overdrive (2014)

Sunset Overdrive
Insomniac Games

Set to be a flagship title for the Xbox One, Insomniac's Sunset Overdrive proudly wore its charismatic personality on its sleeve as it saw us bounce and zip around Sunset City while eliminating gooey, energy drink monsters.

Traversal was just as snappy as the writing; it was simply an all-round blast to play. It's understandable, then, why this Xbox exclusive launched to rave reviews, and why Microsoft seemed to hope that this game would help boost the sales of their new console.

But this wasn't the case. Despite having everything going for it, Sunset Overdrive reportedly only shifted a disappointing 1.16 million copies to customers. For comparison, Insomniac's Infamous Second Son launched the same year and sold more units in its first 9 days.

The reason for this game's disappointing performance was likely due to a combination of Microsoft's notoriously mishandled launch of the Xbox One, alongside confusing marketing. Though the trailers and snippets of gameplay we were shown at the time looked flashy and entertaining, nobody knew exactly what the game was.

With the title still included as part of Xbox Game Pass, curious players still have the chance to dive into this wild ride to see exactly what they missed.


6. Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem (2002)

Eternal Darkness Bathtub
Nintendo

While Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem is now revered as a cult gem and often attributed as being one of the greatest horror games ever made, it nevertheless failed to make any sort of impact when it launched on the GameCube back in 2002.

Despite its revolutionary game mechanics and critical acclaim, Eternal Darkness was a massive commercial failure, selling fewer than half a million copies worldwide.

After inheriting an ancient book full of evil knowledge from her grandfather, the plot follows Alexandra Roivas as she uses the eldritch tome to unveil the hidden secrets of its previous owners.

However, this game is most famous for its sanity system which obliterated the fourth wall. From manipulating the TV volume to displaying error messages and announcing that save files had been erased, the devilish design of this survival horror ensured that those who played it were in a perpetual state of unease.

Eternal Darkness's commercial failure was down to it only being available on the GameCube where the audience for survival horror just wasn’t there.

With Nintendo promptly axing a follow-up and a crowdfunding campaign for a spiritual successor bombing, the biggest tragedy is fans will likely never see this iconic classic resurrected from the dead.


5. Ōkami (2006)

okami game
Capcom

Instantly recognisable thanks to its gorgeous art style that makes this fantastical game look like a stunning watercolour painting, Ōkami is a wonderous action-adventure game inspired by Japanese folklore.

In it, players step into the paws of Ōkami Amaterasu, a sun goddess who takes the form of a white wolf, where you use the unique mechanic of a magical paintbrush to help defeat enemies and solve puzzles.

Originally released on the PlayStation 2, Ōkami earned unanimous critical adoration and garnered the beginnings of a diehard fanbase. Unfortunately, this praise didn't translate into sales.

The commercial performance was nothing short of disastrous. By the end of 2007, this masterpiece struggled to achieve 270,000 sales worldwide.

Releasing on the Nintendo Wii a year later proved to be not much better, with sales hitting only 600,000. The result was so terrible that this game was named the "least commercially successful winner of a Game of the Year Award" by Guinness in 2010.

Following Ōkami HD's release on Xbox One and PlayStation 4, however, this Zelda-like adventure would go on to sell a whopping 3.8 million copies, as of 2022.

It took over 15 years, but Ōkami finally has an audience deserving of its legacy.


4. Psychonauts (2005)

Psychonauts Raz
Majesco Entertainment

Coming from the mind of Tim Schafer (the madcap creator behind Full Throttle, Grim Fandango, and Day Of The Tentacle), zany 2000s platformer Psychonauts is still cherished today for its imaginative gameplay, hilarious writing, and its memorable cast of oddball characters.

In it, we play as Raz. He's a hot-headed youngster with psychic abilities who runs away from home with grand ambitions of becoming a Psychonaut, an elite group of spies able to enter the minds of others. However, when the summer camp he's attending is attacked by the crazed Dr. Loboto, it's up to him to save the day.

For all the adoration this game has received over the years (including a highly anticipated and equally acclaimed sequel in 2021), it's staggering to think that barely anyone played Psychonauts. By the end of its first year, the award-winning game struggled to sell 100,000 copies, which cost publisher Majesco Entertainment $18 million in losses.

Psychonauts sold 400,000 copies by 2012, but it wasn't until Double Fine put their game on digital platforms in 2015 where sales began to pick up. As of 2015, Psychonauts has sold approximately 1.7 million units, which is still an audience smaller than what this game deserves.


3. Beyond Good & Evil (2003)

Jade Beyond good and evil
Ubisoft

Set on the distant mining planet Hillys, Beyond Good & Evil saw players take on the role of photojournalist turned resistance fighter Jade who, alongside her anthropomorphic pig uncle Pey'j, find in a fight against alien invaders known as the DomZ.

Combing fluid combat with platforming, puzzle-solving, stealth, and racing, this title was a breath of fresh air when it launched in 2003. And when we weren't preoccupied with saving the world, we were just as enthralled with taking in the environments and photographing the wildlife.

Another game that's since garnered a dedicated cult following, Beyond Good & Evil likewise failed to make an impact on audiences when it launched. While there are no official sales figures available, the game has been recognised as a commercial failure.

With a complete lack of marketing for the game at the time alongside incredible titles like The Simpsons: Hit & Run, Manhunt, and Ratchet & Clank: Going Commando just some of the games that released around the same time, it's not hard to see what happened. Ubisoft's game was sadly lost in the crowd.

With a sequel stuck in development limbo, however, the future of this series is still unknown for the collection of fans.


2. System Shock 2 (1999)

System Shock 2
Irrational Games

System Shock 2 is frequently praised for the enormous influence its left on modern games. Alongside being creator Ken Levine's precursor to BioShock (a game which was marketed as System Shock's spiritual successor), this title is routinely named as the inspiration behind gaming heavyweights like Dead Space and Prey.

After an unnamed, amnesiac soldier awakens to find the Von Braun starship they're onboard has become infested with alien parasites, the game sees them explore the ship's claustrophobic corridors to discover what horrors befell the crew.

By blending taut survival horror action and role-playing elements with immersive level design and jaw-dropping plot twists, System Shock 2 was remarkably ahead of its time for 1999. Despite its revolutionary design, critical acclaim, and multiple awards, it nevertheless failed to find an audience, selling less than 60,000 copies within its first year.

It didn't help that it launched between Half-Life and Deux Ex, however the final nail in the coffin was when all support was stopped shortly after its launch. This meant that it wasn't long until the title was completely unplayable.

Thanks to a team of dedicated modders who's work paved the way for a re-release of the game, System Shock 2 was saved from disappearing forever.


1. EarthBound (1995)

Earthbound Nintendo
Nintendo

Known as Mother 2 in Japan, EarthBound was the second entry in the Mother trilogy and is commonly held as being one of the best Nintendo games of all time.

Set in the modern day, this fantastically bizarre RPG saw protagonist Ness fight back against a cosmic force of evil known as Giygas alongside his friends. With quirky dialogue that frequently broke the fourth wall and insane sections of gameplay that tasked us with catching zombies with fly paper and fighting a demonic tent, it was impossible to tell what bonkers thing this game would throw at us next.

It's unbelievable, then, that EarthBound was a cataclysmic failure in the US, selling a measly 140,000 copies. The reason for this was down to horrific marketing.

For some unfathomable reason, advertising executives decided to promote the game in Nintendo Power, not on its ingenious qualities, but on the idea that it, quite literally, reeked.

For readers of the popular magazine, their first introduction to EarthBound was giant text boldly declaring "this game stinks". Alongside this discouraging statement were an assortment of scratch and sniff pictures that smelled of farts and rotten food.

Why anyone thought this was a clever idea is a mystery.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Glasgow-based cinephile who earned a Masters degree in film studies to spend their time writing about cinema, video games, and horror.