10 Pointless Video Game Mechanics Nobody Used

Yeah, we all played Skyrim to chop wood...

Skyrim busywork
Bethesda

Gaming as an industry has developed a habit of thinking that more in any respect is better. The focus on a lot of games is the size of the map, the number of characters, the number of hours you can get out of it and other such numerical, quantifiable elements.

Thus, a lot of features in games simply exist... because they can, filed under the umbrella term of "immersion".

You aren't forced to play the entirety of the game, so feel free to pass by the cooking mini-games, but sometimes valuable development time is poured into creating features and mechanics that have literally no meaningful function.

Even today when games are more expensive than ever, these mechanics keep cropping up, with no one contesting their inclusion despite not having any impact at all.

Ranging from busywork to time wasters that don't have any bearing on the story or core progression, I'm not talking about mini-games as they tend to have some enjoyment factor within a game, but instead the mechanics that have less functionality than even the most throwaway minigames.

10. Hunting - Tomb Raider

Tomb Raider
Square Enix

The beginning to Tomb Raider was incredibly baffling. It put a massive focus on survival, with the tutorial for the bow (the main weapon in the game) focussing around hunting. It made it seem like this was going to be a central mechanic, with the player having to stalk prey and remember to eat food.

But even the game realised just how pointless that was, and completely brushed past it as soon as possible. The option to hunt was always there, with plenty of animals running around, but there was no incentive to actually pursue that. All you got was a little XP.

It was obviously intended to be a central mechanic, as the bare bones exist in the game. However, over the development time, the idea was scrapped leaving us with a mechanic that no one used, and that no one cared about.


9. Chop - GTA V

GTA V chop
Rockstar

GTA V allowed you to own a dog. Sounds like a good idea but in practice, it's as useful in high-speed pursuits as your actual dog is. It was a neat idea, but Rockstar poured a tonne of effort into a feature that was relatively minor, and most players didn't use beyond the actual missions you were forced to do so.

It didn't help that every five minutes, the game reminded you about an app to train said dog, just to unlock tiny buffs to an already useless moveset. All Chop did was maybe kill one guy, all the while becoming more of a liability in a gunfight.

It came down to the fact that most players of GTA didn't go into the game with the intention of training a virtual dog. They wanted to shoot and drive and kill things. The effort required to make Chop barely worthwhile was far too much, and so the mutt ended up sitting around aimlessly for the entire time.


8. "Alcohol Mechanics" - Various

Red Dead Redemption Saloon Drunk
Rockstar

It is a bit of a laugh to drink your character into oblivion and watch them stumble around for a while, but what is the actual point of being able to do so in a game? Games like Red Dead Redemption and GTA have the ability to drink, but beyond making the screen blurry, there is nothing to it.

Players might use it once, but for something that took developers time to animate, develop assets and effects, it's useless. Maybe that development time wasn't vital, but it could have been put to better use and not simply made to create a passing annoyance if anything.

It is such a common feature that it is baffling how much it crops up. If its to do with immersion, then there is a small case to be made for it, but staggering out of a bar drunk of your head isn't exactly at the top of the list for immersive play.


7. Social Features - GTA IV

GTA 4 Bowling
Rockstar

Do you want to go bowling? No, no one wants to go bowling. GTA IV was a little misguided in accessing what its fans wanted. The social features were designed to create an engaging world, in which characters reacted outside of missions and cutscenes. However, they ultimately became a distraction to what players really wanted. To drive and shoot things.

And as a result, every call from dear cousin Roman was hung up or ignored. The sociality of the games was rarely used. It wasn't that they were a bad idea. But coming off of games that focussed on driving and shooting, they were a difficult sell. Especially when cousin Roman was a little... eccentric.

It comes down to the fact that no one plays GTA for the quiet character moments. Sure, they are nice. But when given the opportunity to mercilessly engage in a gang war, or spend quality time bowling, the choice is hardly a tough one to make.


6. Photo Modes - Various

Uncharted Lost Legacy
Naughty Dog

Most people accidentally use photo mode simply by clicking on the button whilst trying to play the game. Sure, some people use the feature, and it is stretching the definition of pointless, but the fact remains that people don't play games to take pictures. No one wants to capture the admittedly beautiful moment of snapping an ogres tusk off and impaling in its face.

Taking pictures of a game actively takes the player out of the game. Its counterproductive to the idea of immersion. You can't preach about wanting gamers to be engrossed and immersed in a world, whilst simultaneously pushing for them to update their gaming Instagram.

And devoting an entire button on the controller to such a feature is as useless as possible. Risking the chance of players creating a begrudging relationship with your feature by constantly accidentally pressing it is once again counterproductive.


5. Survival Skill - Fallout: New Vegas

Fallout new vegas
Obsidian

The survival skill is the perfect example of a useless feature. The game makes such a big deal out of the mechanic and devotes an entire portion of the tutorial to learning how it works. But it simply isn't worthwhile getting into.

It demands you sink valuable skill points into it, just to be able to craft certain items. And most of the time, the higher tier items aren't worth it. They add minute buffs to stats and never do anything that a good old-fashioned stimpack could manage. Or the bountiful range of drugs that can be used regardless of skill.

The skill wasn't worth it in the first place, so players didn't bother investing in it. When there was no obvious detriment to not using the skill, players just didn't bother, and campfires got reduced to passing thoughts.


4. Horse Taming - Red Dead Redemption

Red dead redemption
Rockstar

Putting aside the fact that horse-taming was boring, clunky and pushed to the side by the game itself, it just wasn't worthwhile. Most players developed some form of bond with the horse they had, and with no obvious benefit to rounding up one of your own, they just stuck with the default one. Or bought a new one.

After the mission in which you learnt the skill, it was never used again. Not even the missions bother to touch on it, instead, turning to shooting and the fun elements of the game.

The only time that it was useful was in the DLC, where you could break the horses of the apocalypse. But even then, those were rare encounters and most players would maybe use it once or twice.


3. Bone-Charm Crafting - Dishonored 2

DISHONORED 2 bone charms
Arkane Studios

Whilst it seems like a neat idea, the bone charm crating wasn't as useful as it made out. Unless you were one of those people who enjoy refining their character to the extreme, adding the tiniest buffs until you were the best of the best, the mechanic was useless.

Fundamentally, it came down to the fact that by the time it became useful, the game was over. Bone-charms were random, so there was no way to plan your character around them. You picked them up as you went. So, chances were you'd only really gather a couple really useful ones over the game.

And then there was the fact that bone-charm crafting was a purchasable skill. A skill that was put up alongside becoming a smoke monster and being able to clear a room with one crossbow bolt. Try as they might, arts and crafts don't compare to supernatural badassery.


2. Torches - Dark Souls 2

dark souls 2 gutter
FromSoftware

This is less of an unwanted inclusion and more a failed implementation. Dark Souls 2 was supposed to make use of a new lighting system that would shroud a lot of the game in impenetrable darkness. The player would have to decide between a protective shield or using a torch to see better.

However, before release, the game received a massive technical downgrade and the impenetrable darkness became a mild annoyance. The darkest areas in the game were light enough to easily be strolled through. And as a result, the all-important torches became... worthless. And no one used them. Despite the fact that they had their own segregated portion in the inventory, no one really cared for them.

And so players neglected to use what was supposed to be one of the games major selling points. They sorted some of the darkness in the Scholar of the First Sin remaster, but most people who played that had played the original and knew the dark and foreboding areas like the back of their hands.


1. Cooking, Wood Cutting, Etc. - Skyrim

elder scrolls cooking
Bethesda

Immersion comes from engrossing a player in your game. By creating a deep world that players want to lose themselves in. Immersion doesn't come from making your game as menial as real life. However, when it came to Skyrim, Bethesda didn't get the memo.

Being able to chop wood for some money isn't fun. Watching your player go through a long drawn out cutscene to have them haul a log onto the saw isn't immersive. Its useless busy-work that doesn't contribute to the game at all.

Then there is the cooking, which offers such a paltry reward that is fundamentally useless. Gathering all these materials just to create a lamb chop (that doesn't heal as much as the lowest tier healing potion, which can be found everywhere) is pointless.

Create an immersive game, not one that is just as boring as the real world. No one wants to chop wood or press a button to cook.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Skyrim
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

I like video games, writing and writing about video games. Expect sarcasm and the dry wit of a Brit. And the occasional rant of a unhappy Scot. You know... the usual.