10 Promising Video Games Totally Ruined By Microtransactions
Pay more... play less?
Nobody likes microtransactions, but developers keep forcing them into games in order to promote a false sense of “player choice” while rolling in ill-gotten gains scrubbed from the accounts of parents who don’t supervise their credit cards closely enough. There’s a lot to dislike about entertainment’s fastest-growing industry in 2018, and these slimy, conniving business practices are at the top of the list for many gamers.
Some infamously greedy publishing houses like Electronic Arts and Activision have slowly started to back away from such awful tactics after receiving the brunt of the backlash against their “games as a service” model. Yet, each EA Sports release seems to come across as increasingly desperate, and the Activision-backed Call of Duty: WWII literally encouraged players to watch each other open loot boxes, so we aren’t out of the woods yet.
The most unfortunate thing about this manipulative monetization strategy is that it has caused the untimely demise of several promising franchises over the years. From auspicious asymmetric multiplayer concepts to long-awaited reboots, no game was safe from the the industry’s ill-considered culling.
10. Evolve
The poster-child for mismanaged game releases, the hype surrounding 2K’s 2015 beast-slaying third person shooter fell flat the moment it hit store shelves. The overall gameplay was solid, but the title was so needlessly bogged down in micro-DLCs and paywall-barred content that it was almost impossible to enjoy for anyone unwilling to shell out even more money.
A game which had the audacity to release two seperate season passes and offered well in excess of $100 worth of DLC, very few players felt the need to stick around after the first few weeks. It picked up some buzz after going free-to-play in mid-2016, but that ultimately proved to be too little, too late.
Though the game’s dedicated servers were retired in July of this year, the game is still playable via a peer-to-peer connection, though player numbers are akin to the crowd Lawbreakers was drawing in a few weeks after release.
Something of an industry litmus test for aggressive microtransaction campaigns, it’s hard to believe that publishers would choose to follow in 2K’s footsteps after this unmitigated disaster. Gamers, for the most part, know when they are being swindled and will continue to be on the lookout for such scams.
9. Middle-Earth: Shadow Of War
2014’s Middle-Earth: Shadow of Mordor was a Game of the Year contender which proved that Warner Brothers could still push out some quality content following the lackluster Batman: Arkham Origins of the previous year. Notable for its combat and unique gameplay elements, Shadow of Mordor is perhaps the best Tolkien-related game release since 2007’s The Lord of the Rings Online.
Well known for its nemesis system by which players could target and build relationships around antagonizing orc NPCs, consumers had a reason to be excited about the game's 2017 sequel Middle-Earth: Shadow of War.
Unfortunately, Warner Brothers decided to meddle with the series’ flagship system by tying it to a universally-panned loot box mechanic. Now, instead of forming enemies organically, players encountered them entirely through an in-game gambling system which prioritized purchases with real-world currency.
The publisher has since made an attempt to save face by removing these unwanted microtransaction mechanics in early 2018, and the game is now much more enjoyable. That said, the damage has already been done, and WB is forever to be distrusted in the eyes of the gaming public.
8. Guitar Hero Live
Activision revolutionized the genre of rhythm gaming with their 2005 mega-hit Guitar Hero. Coming equipped with a five-button plastic guitar, wannabe rockers could jam out to some of their favorite tracks without fumbling around with a real guitar.
While a major triumph which spawned myriad successors and, along with the Call of Duty franchise, upheld Activision’s status as an industry leader, the series and genre as a whole had all but flatlined by 2011 or so. Not content to move on to something else, the publisher rebooted the franchise in 2015 with Guitar Hero Live, and it went over about as well as Gene Simmons’ solo career.
While the title brought back familiar mechanics, it faltered when it came to DLC and extraneous monetization. In an attempt to ape services like Spotify and Pandora, the game allowed players to tap into continuous music streams, the songs in which could only be repeated for a price.
Worst of all, rather than just offer specific songs for download like in previous games, Guitar Hero Live forced players to rent a song library for a 24 hour period. Costing $6 with each rental, gamers quickly grew tired of this consumer-unfriendly platform.
7. Metal Gear Solid V: Phantom Pain
1998’s seminal stealth hit Metal Gear Solid would captivate players and make audiences wonder just how far gaming tech could possibly go. Though the future seemed bright at the time, fast forward twenty years and Konami has turned the series into a survival-crafting mockery which charges a premium for something as simple as an additional save slot.
That is pretty egregious, but it isn’t quite as bad as Metal Gear Solid V’s Forward Operating Base DLC. This was unabashedly and without a shadow of a doubt a publisher attempting to sell an actual insurance plan for in-game items.
The way MGSV’s FoB insurance works is by replacing any stolen or destroyed items in a players base following an invasion by a rival player. Most people already don’t like dealing with insurance and all of its intertwined complications in real life, much less in a video game.
What’s worse, Konami’s insurance plans can and will expire, which naturally means that players will once again be forced to either deplete their MB coins or reach into their wallets to keep all of their nukes safe. Metal Gear Solid V was a fantastic farewell to the Kojima-fronted franchise, but this is insulting.
6. Dead Space 3
One of the first instances of what would come to be known as EA’s hideous “player choice” scams, survival horror masterclass Dead Space was turned into a pay-to-win slog marred with weaponry which required an exorbitant amount of resources to craft. These resources, of course, could be purchased with real-world money, and EA defended the mechanic by arguing that it allowed time-deficit gamers an option to speed through the experience.
Yet, not only would that require paying well over the game’s initial $60 asking price, but it also meant sacrificing the game’s quality as a result. Nobody likes grinding for resources or waiting on scavenger bots, especially not in titles as devastatingly tense as Dead Space.
Survival horror lives and dies on the thrill of just getting by with meager resources, and Dead Space 3 seems to have outed this mechanic entirely. Resident Evil was exhilarating because it was about surviving with a few herbs and a handful of shotgun shells until more resources were found. If the player could just pay for more, that would entirely defeat the purpose.
Electronic Arts will never learn, and, with Visceral games gone, Dead Space will remain just another casualty.
5. Deus Ex: Mankind Divided
In a move that ultimately resulted in one of 2016’s most controversial gaming conundrums, Square Enix opted to institute a weird system which promised to unlock a set of tiered rewards based on how many people pre-ordered Deus Ex: Mankind Divided in the months leading up to its August 23 launch.
That didn’t go down well at all, and the publisher was eventually forced to rescind these purchased-based pre-order bonuses in the wake of an overwhelming consumer backlash. Unfortunately, they didn’t opt to backpedal on the game’s annoying microtransactions which offered a surplus of useful in-game items for a real-world premium. A very clear instance of pay-to-win, this inclusion was curious given the game’s single-player nature.
Once again, Square Enix claimed that the inclusion of such microtransactions were intended to expedite the experience for time-crunched gamers, but that excuse, as always, fell flat. Monetization schemes like these cheapen the gaming experience and diminish any sense of player accomplishment, despite what most AAA publishers have to say.
Companies like Square Enix have long praised themselves for retaining the $60 price point of most releases, but these egregious microtransactions call that logic into question somewhat.
4. Assassin's Creed Odyssey
Assassin’s Creed was a revolutionary seventh-gen title when it released over a decade ago, but the series really started to wear on the nerves of consumers once it entered an oversaturated annual production cycle.
The abysmal, downright dysfunctional Assassin’s Creed Unity seemed to serve as a bit of a wakeup call for Ubisoft, and the publisher shelved a prospective 2016 Assassin’s Creed title to ensure a more polished experience. That said, when Assassin’s Creed: Origins dropped in 2017, it felt like more of the same, albeit with an increased focus on sidequest grinding and microtransactions.
2018’s Assassin’s Creed: Odyssey, though a well-reviewed game, took this to the nth degree by filling the mid-game with required level grinding. This was clearly built into the game with the intention of enticing frustrated players into spending some more money, and the fact that players can get their hands on an XP boost at a premium cements that idea.
Ubisoft has yet to sink to the levels of corporations like Electronic Arts and Activision in terms of reputation, but, if this keeps up, they’ll be finding themselves in some hot water.
3. NBA 2K18
2K Games’ sports-related output has long been mired in controversy thanks to the company’s appalling abandon when it comes to restraint concerning their monetization schemes, though they have long flown under the radar when compared to the outright insanity of EA’s Fifa series.
That changed when NBA 2K18 launched in September of 2017; a watershed moment for the gaming industry, 2K seemed eager to test just how far they could push in-game monetization with this title.
Quite literally everything was locked behind the game’s virtual currency, which was lazily labeled VC on the in-game storefront. While players could earn a steady trickle of this currency through regular pay, they would be forced to reach into their wallets if they wanted to circumvent the game’s massive grind.
Though it wasn’t the first NBA 2K game to include virtual currency, it was definitely the first to take things to such an extreme. Most heinous was the decision to charge for in-game cosmetics, something that should be taken as a bog standard feature in every sports game ever released. With that in mind, 2K18 felt more like a mortgage payment simulator than an actual video game.
2. Red Dead Online (RDR2)
While Rockstar Games’ 2013 release Grand Theft Auto V was quite literally the most profitable piece of entertainment media ever made, its online component was marred by a ridiculous paywall which cast a major diaspora between the in-game haves and have-nots. While most consumers were hopeful that the studio could have learned from its mistakes, it seems that similar monetization schemes will drag down the experience of Red Dead Redemption 2’s online component.
Red Dead Redemption 2 may go down as one of the greatest games of this generation, but that doesn’t quite excuse Red Dead Online from over-inflating the price of in-game transactions to the point of parody. Most items can be bought for gold bars—the game’s premium currency—which are very hard to come by and can be bought for real-world cash.
Though players can earn these gold bars organically, it can take hours of play to drum up just one of the things. Plus, with game-enhancing items like weapons and horses locked behind a major paywall, players unwilling to spend more than the initial $60 will be in for quite a grind.
1. Star Wars Battlefront II
Quite possibly the most infamous game of all time from the most infamous publisher of all time when it comes to scummy, money-grubbing schemes, Star Wars Battlefront II was raked across the coals by a company eager to skim every last dime from the pockets of its player base.
Consumers were totally appalled by the incredible reliance on microtransactions when the game released in beta in fall of 2017, and things were so bad that EA actually had to revoke these in-game purchases from the experience in order to quell what still ended up being one of the most notable fan outcries of the last few years.
Star Wars Battlefront II was clearly built from the ground up to sell its players in-game currency and loot boxes. Literally everything from character skins to weapon upgrades came from these star cards, and players weren’t happy in the slightest.
Microtransactions eventually made their way back to the game in April of 2018, but the damage had already been done. The title’s sales had suffered, and EA had made a blunder from which it is still struggling to recover.