10 Rare Video Games That Survived Development Hell
The development hell video games that somehow released.
There are few phrases in the gaming industry more likely to inspire anguish than "development hell". Reserved for those titles that were announced long ago but have suffered repeated delays, it usually turns out to be a death-knell - the final phase before a title is outright cancelled.
If a game's launch has been interrupted and rescheduled over and over, that's a massive indicator things have gone horribly wrong behind the scenes. Sometimes, the development has gone so badly, there's no chance it'll recover.
Now, that's not suggesting a heavily delayed game is guaranteed to be a disaster. But as Daikatana, Aliens: Colonial Marines, and (shudder) i'kem Forever proved, a drawn out and chaotic production is rarely a good sign. And as Silent Hills, Rainbow 6: Patriots, and Star Wars 1313 highlighted, a property can be scrapped entirely if development setbacks keep piling up or an outside impact curtails things unexpectedly.
Still, a few games have managed to overcome these odds, and release after years of protracted development.
But not only did some titles survive development hell, they turned out better than we could've ever imagined. It may have taken an eternity for these games to see the light of day, but there's no question they were 100% worth the wait.
10. Team Fortress 2 - 9 Years
After Team Fortress became a global phenomenon, Valve hired the creators of the Quake mod to work on a sequel. Since Team Fortress 2 was announced at E3 one month later in 1998, it looked like it would be out in no time.
When Valve decided the military shooter would work better if it adopted the new Source game engine, fans expected TF2 would be delayed.
That's when something very strange happened... or didn't happen, depending on how you look at it. For the next six years, updates on Team Fortress 2 were non-existent. No photos. No trailers. Nothing. Every time this coveted FPS didn't make an appearance at E3, it fuelled rumours the project had been shelved indefinitely.
But in 2006, Team Fortress 2 was re-revealed at EA's Summer Showcase. Due to its cartoony aesthetic, viewers could barely recognise the footage was cut from the same cloth as its predecessor.
Interestingly, the game's new look is what delayed development in the first place. Desperate to give the long-awaited sequel a distinct appearance, the developers built "three to four different games," each with unique designs. Only after the team agreed on the cartoony presentation was Team Fortress 2 reintroduced to the public.
9. The Last Guardian - 9 Years
After the success of Shadow of the Colossus, director, Fumito Ueda, was inspired to create a follow-up, centred around the protagonist's bond with a fantastical creature. This concept led to The Last Guardian - an action-adventure title, starring a child travelling the land with his adorable (but gigantic) animal friend, Trico.
Within two years, Team Ico had completed enough content to unveil a demo at E3 2009. Although the presentation left a massive impression, it created a problem. Despite game trailers often show footage that's superior than the finished product, Sony Computer president, Shuhei Yoshida wanted The Last Guardian to look just as good as the demo. Because Team Ico was a tiny studio, it was unfeasible to maintain Ueda's vision on PS3 hardware, encouraging Sony to shift the project to the PS4.
As more devs were brought in to assist, Ueda felt like his team were being pushed out, compelling Ueda to walk away to create his own studio, GenDesign. Because Ueda was still contracted with Sony, GenDesign worked alongside them to complete The Last Guardian.
It may not have sold well, but every Ico fan found The Last Guardian to be an utter delight from start to finish.
8. Dead Island 2 - 9 Years
Although delays aren't necessarily a bad sign, it didn't fill gamers with confidence to see Dead Island 2 being tossed around like a hot potato. When Techland abandoned the zombie title's production to work on Dying Light, Deep Silver had them replaced with Yager. Gameplay footage for the undead splatterfest was revealed at Gamescon in 2014, giving the impression Dead Island 2 had a smooth road ahead of it.
However, the two companies' ideas kept conflicting, resulting in Yager's departure in 2015, which was the same month they filed for insolvency. Hot off the success of Hitman, Sumo Digital was hired to take over.
By 2019, the publisher realised things weren't working out and let Sumo Digital go. By this point, Deep Silver went, "Screw it! We'll make it ourselves!" and handed Dead Island 2 to their own team, Dambuster Studios.
Ironically, Dambuster succeeded where everyone else failed, delivering a bonkers zombie title filled with sensational level design, compelling characters, top-notch voice acting, diverse weapon variety, and a slew of creative methods to kill the infected. Dead Island 2 isn't perfect, but turned out far better than expected.
7. DOOM (2016) - 9 Years
When id Software co-founder, John Carmack, announced Doom 4 was in the works at 2007's Quakecon, excitement was through the roof. Since the creators were also developing Rage, fans expected the latest Doom instalment wouldn't be out any time soon.
But the wait wasn't just long - it was hellish (literally and figuratively). Five years in, the team turned this sequel into a reboot, rendering most of their early efforts pointless.
The creative director, Kevin Cloud, switched things up, by making the game more cinematic, and akin to Call of Duty. The company's director, Tim Willits believed this version lacked "the spirit, it did not have the soul, it didn't have a personality." Coupled with Carmack's departure from id Software around the same time, it looked like the Cacodemon-blasting IP was suitably doomed.
Rather than giving up, Willit's team got back to work, rebranding the shooter as DOOM. By 2014, the project was finally coming together. DOOM went old school, focusing on minimal plot, nonlinear exploration, an avalanche of guns, piss-your-pants monsters, and a relentless combat.
6. Final Fantasy 15 - 10 Years
With Final Fantasy's sprawling story, enormous ensemble, complex mechanics, and vast world) to explore, gamers expect the production of each instalment to be long.
But ten years? Final Fantasy 15 spent so much time in limbo, it felt like it was never coming out. Like most games caught in development hell, this sequel started off completely different. In fact, it wasn't a mainline entry to begin with. Back in 2006, it was a spin-off of FF13, called Final Fantasy Versus 13.
Within a year, there were internal discussions about revising the IP into a core title. Sadly, this decision wasn't finalised until 2012, meaning the team spent six years on vaporware. To save time, the director, Hajime Tabata, could've repurposed Versus XIII's material for Final Fantasy 15. But with the PS4 and Xbox One set for release in 2013, the whole project had to start from scratch, to ensure FF15 was ready for those systems.
When things started taking shape, Tabata suffered another setback. As the game's scope increased, Tabata decided to split elements of the story into separate projects, including DLC, a CGI feature film, and an animated series. Rejigging all these factors delayed Final Fantasy 15's launch until 2016.
5. Prey (2006) + Prey (2017) - 11 Years
Prey has a unique distinction, since the 2006 and 2017 version both took 11 years to to complete. Starting way back in 1995, 3D Realms intended Prey to showcase moveable portal technology - a mechanic that creates and moves portals in real time. Due to changes of leadership and immense technical issues, development was put on hold.
When 3D Realms circled back in 2001, they hired Human Head Studio to create a different version of Prey, which maintained the original design and concept. Prey launched five years later, selling a million copies in two months. With the extra-terrestrial shooter raking in cash, the publisher greenlit a sequel weeks later.
Due to rights issues with Bethesda, the developers couldn't start making Prey 2 until 2011. Unsatisfied with Human Head Studio's progress, Bethesda scrapped the project in 2013, before hiring Arcane Studios to develop a reboot, also called Prey. Despite sharing the same title, this follow-up has few ties with the original, working more like a cosmic Groundhog Day title, rather than a straight-forward survival horror.
Even though both versions of Prey were well-received, it's wild how it took 22 years for these two games to come to fruition.
4. Diablo III - 11 Years
After the staggering success of 2000's Diablo II, Blizzard North got cracking on the sequel the following year. Because the first two instalments were assembled very quickly, it looked like gamers wouldn't have to wait long for this devilish threequel.
However, Diablo III had such a troublesome production, Blizzard didn't officially announce it for eight years. And when World of Warcraft took the MMORPG community by storm, it became Blizzard's top priority, pushing Diablo III on the back-burner.
Blizzard's owner, Vivendi, believed the project wasn't up to standards, which inspired 30 Blizzard North members to leave and start their own company. Blizzard North was closed down two months later, forcing Blizzard Entertainment to take over.
But Diablo III wasn't out of the woods yet. The game's aesthetic was drastically changed three times, delaying it further. The external beta testing ran into various issues, stretching out development even more.
When Diablo III was finally released, it required a ton of patches before it was considered playable. Ironically, it's the only entry on this list which would've benefitted by being delayed a bit longer.
3. Kirby's Return To Dream Land - 11 Years
Kirby can be summarised in one word - simple. Due to the straightforward controls, gameplay, graphics, mechanics and level design, this adorable platformer is astoundingly easy to pick up on. Since a Kirby game has been churned out pretty frequently for the last three decades, one would imagine the production on each title would be easy.
And yet, Kirby's Return to Dream Land's development lasted 11 years, since it was completely rehauled on three separate occasions. (Interestingly, two of these canned versions led to the creation of other Kirby games.)
Although the original incarnation was previewed at E3 in 2005, it was cancelled, since HAL Laboratory had difficulty programming the multiplayer. This version was eventually reworked into 2018's Kirby's Star Allies.
For the second attempt, the creators tried to make an open-world title. This version didn't pan out, but the concept was repurposed for Kirby and the Forgotten Land. The third version, which was meant to have Kirby return to his side-scrolling roots, was terminated early in development.
After suffering three strikes, a lesser company would've given up. Instead, HAL Laboratory acknowledged the previous attempts didn't work, because they were forcing in multiplayer support. When the team focused on a single-player title, Return to Dream Land came together without issue.
It all worked out in the end, since Return to Dream Land was among the best Kirby entries, and even managed to inspire a remaster in 2023.
2. Mother 3 - 12 Years
Mother 3 had such a unpredictable production, Nintendo changed which system it was supposed to feature on three-and-a-half times. (Don't worry, all will be explained.) When the producers, Shigeru Miyamoto and Satoru Iwata, began development in 1994, they envisioned the whimsical RPG on the Super Nintendo.
Over time, Iwata and Miyamoto repurposed Mother 3 for the Nintendo 64, believing it would work better in 3D. As the project grew in ambition and size, it was decided to turn the Earthbound sequel into a launch title for the N64 peripheral, the 64DD. (That's where the "a half" comes from.)
When the 64DD bombed, Mother 3 was repurposed (again) for the GameCube. After years in development with little to show for it, the game's writer, Shigesato Itoi, announced Mother 3 had been shelved.
So, when the cutesy role-player was announced for the Game Boy Advance in 2003, the public were readying to hear the word "cancelled".
But for the first time since production began, the odds were in the developers' favour. Mother 3 suffered no more hiccups, allowing Nintendo to release it on the GBA in 2006.
1. Metroid Dread - 16 Years
The GBA title, Metroid Fusion, received high praise from critics, particularly for the stealth sequences, where our heroine, Samus is pursued by her doppelgänger.
Although production on a follow-up started in 2005, it took four years before the project, known as Metroid Dread, had a playable beta. Unfortunately, Sakamoto was unhappy with the prototype, believing the hardware wasn't good enough to create a terrifying antagonist. (This is weird, since the big bad from Fusion was genuinely unsettling.)
When Sakamoto announced Dread's storyline had been finalised in 2010, it seemed like things were looking up. And yet, Dread was nowhere to be seen for the next decade, even though other Metroid titles were released, including Metroid: Other M, Metroid: Samus Returns, and the god-awful Federation Force.
That's why it was shocking when the long, long, long-awaited sequel was officially announced at Nintendo Direct on June 15 2021. Stranger still, this presentation revealed the alien-blasting platformer would be available... in four months! Even though fans were thrilled, they were also skeptical, since it was unlikely a game 16 years in the making could live up to the hype.
Miraculously, Dread obliterated all expectations. It received universal acclaim and sold three million units, making it the most successful entry in the franchise. Because Dread turned out so well, fans are more psyched than ever for Metroid Prime 4. (Fingers crossed that we don't have to wait as long this time.)