10 Rarest N64 Games Ever

If you think game retail prices are bad, don't try digging up these relics.

The Nintendo 64 is a nostalgic console for most of us, whether it reminds you of your childhood or not, there's no denying the Nintendo 64 was a fantastic gaming machine. It had a superb library of titles, a great controller, and it represented Nintendo at their very prime. Of all the great exclusives that were released in its seven year life span, some true classics immediately come to mind, such as; Super Mario 64, Mario Kart, Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time and Majora's Mask, Banjo Kazooie, Super Smash Bros, Goldeneye, Perfect Dark and of course Star Fox 64. It may be hard to believe, but it's been over eleven years since the console officially became obsolete, paving way for the Nintendo Gamecube. Over the years, many of those large, chunky ROM cartridges have become absurdly valuable as video games often do as they age. It's all part of the gradual process as games progress from just a form of entertainment, to eventually becoming priceless antiques. As time progresses, more and more of those cartridges will be lost, misplaced, forgotten or broken, each one becoming rarer in the process. In fact several are already incredibly hard to find, most of which demand huge, ridiculous price tags for a game of several generations past. In study of this fascinating trend, here's our list of the rarest and most expensive N64 games, to date.

10. Bomberman 64: The Second Attack

Hudson Soft's iconic mascot Bomberman has had a rough transition to 3D gaming, with his adventures on the N64 being no exception to that statement. Bomberman 64 sold badly, but Hudson followed through with a sequel anyway, after the spin-off Bomberman Hero. It's arguable both the bad selling nature of the first and the saturation of Bomberman titles were what caused a severe lack of interest in Bomberman 64: The Second Attack. Japanese copies seem to retail at £25, while a North American version will equate to roughly £55 depending on the exact source. The rarity of the game can also be attributed to the relatively unknown publisher of Vatical Entertainment, there's little to no trace of the company's history on the internet. Mediocre reviews and critical reception of the first game also didn't help the sequel, as fans had started to lose interest in Bomberman by that point. Whether it's worth its price tag or not, Bomberman 64: The Second Attack is a rare sequel that's rather hard to obtain.

9. Ogre Battle 64: Person Of Lordly Calibre

Orge Battle 64: Person of Lordly Caliber is an RPG strategy game hybrid, and a sequel to Ogre Battle: March of the Black Queen and Tactics Ogre: Let Us Cling Together. Like many J-RPGs, Ogre Battle 64 had a wide release in Japan, but didn't release nearly as many units in the US, presumably because J-RPGs don't tend to be as popular with western audiences. In note of this trend, Atlus played it safe and under produced Ogre Battle, making it incredibly hard to find English language copies of the game without paying a fortune. Japanese versions can cost as little as £20, while US imports cost up to £65 typically, assuming you can actually find a seller. The price doesn't wholly reflect the rarity of the NTSC copies, presumably there's a lack of interest in the franchise, hence why the price isn't a lot higher - little supply, little demand.

8. StarCraft 64

Blizzard's hit real-time strategy game helped put them on the map, helping to establish, pioneer and perfect the genre that is now a mainstay of PC gaming. However, Nintendo were bold enough to seek out a port of the popular game on the N64, which at the time wasn't well received. Critics and fans alike didn't want to play a complex strategy game without a mouse, as the core integral mechanics; resource gathering, map scouting and combat all require constant monitoring and commands, all of which made the N64 controller's analog stick and directional pad feel disadvantageous. These problems tied with a quiet release in 2000, over two years after the PC version launched, caused the N64 port to drift into obscurity with a very small amount of units sold and produced. There's been a spike in the price of StarCraft 64 cartridges in the last few years, since the release of StarCraft 2 which has seemingly encouraged people to dig out this version. The rarer, Australian pal copies can cost over £100, while the more readily available US edition costs around £60, unboxed. Blizzard's sci-fi RTS would go on to define the genre, but the N64 remains ever obscure.

7. Mario Party 3

Board games have never translated well to video game format, given the dull and meticulous layout of most Monopoly or Cluedo games for example, of which there have been countless over the years. That being said, Mario Party is undeniably one of the best local multiplayer game series of all-time, proving to be a hit on each and every Nintendo console it's released on. The most praised entries in the franchise are those which kicked the block-punching fiesta off on the Nintendo 64, with 1, 2 and 3 being particularly cherished by collectors. The first two aren't that hard to track down for £30, but the third instalment had lacklustre sales and a smaller run of units, this is because Nintendo anticipated it would sell badly due to the arrival of next-gen consoles in 2002. The price in question tends to vary a lot as there are still a fair few sources you can buy it from. The lowest price option on Amazon is £85 without a case or manual, while it can be purchased via buy it now on Ebay for £70, £120 boxed, or presumably for lower if you attempt to win an auction. Of all Nintendo classics on the N64, Mario Party 3 is one of the most expensive and rare due to a smaller print run and an inconvenient release date.

6. Paper Mario

With the huge success of Nintendo's Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars, its unsurprising that the company would want to recreate that hit with a sequel. However, due to their collaboration with Square on the project, Nintendo had to rebrand the sequel as Square weren't available to develop the game. Thus, Paper Mario was born. Nintendo management didn't have a lot of faith in the game as they produced a small amount of cartridges with very little advertising. Its 2001 release date in North America and in European territories only worsened sales. Due to the rise and advent of the series on the Gamecube and the Wii, as well as the dedicated die-hard Mario fanbase, there's still a huge demand for Paper Mario on the N64. Paper Mario can cost as much as £65 for just the cartridge, or up to £80-90 with a case in decent condition. Paper Mario isn't insanely rare, but Nintendo's dedicated plumber loving fanbase will make obtaining a neat copy of the game both expensive and hard.

5. Harvest Moon 64

Harvest Moon is a series far ahead of its time, it arguably beat the addictive nature of IOS related farm games and other things of that nature by a good twenty years. By the time Natsume had their second non-handheld entry in the Harvest Moon series, most players were unfamiliar with it, passing it up for more appealing titles. As a result, Harvest Moon would not sell many copies on the N64 and wasn't reprinted. The series has since become incredibly popular with certain audiences via the numerous DS, Gamecube and Wii releases, which have given the obscure N64 version a daunting price tag on copies of the game. Harvest Moon for the N64 can cost as much as £90 pounds boxed, due to sheer demand and a minimal print run from Natsume. Again, Harvest Moon isn't directly as rare as other games, but its recently found popularity and cult appeal have made it an incredibly hard game to find at any reasonable price.

4. Conker's Bad Fur Day

Often regarded as one of the last golden age games made by Rare, Conker's Bad Fur Day is an acclaimed cult hit that shocked N64 users everywhere with its adult references, humor and mature disposition. Players take control of the alcoholic red squirrel known as Conker, embarking on a journey to cure his hangover and recover his girlfriend Berri. The game is now deemed an N64 classic, regardless of its small sales figures and overall unit shipments. Conker's Bad Fur Day's lack of sales can be attributed to a lack of acknowledgement by Nintendo, an absence of advertising and publicity, but ultimately it suffered most from a weakened demographic as the game didn't appeal to children, unlike most of the N64's game library. The fact it was released very late in the console's lifespan also didn't help sales, as the N64 was retired within a year of Conker's launch date. Amazon has copies listed at £100 onwards, while Ebay listings show the game being valued at £90-£200, depending on condition and if it's boxed with manual, or not. There are a surprising amount of copies still in circulation, showing how popular and sought-after Conker's Bad Fur Day still is over a decade after release.

3. Snowboard Kids 2

Atlus have somewhat of a reputation among collectors for making incredibly rare games. This is often due to the fact they deal with a lot of niche properties and obscure titles, so they tend to issue minimal print runs that immediately make the game rare, straight off the bat. An obvious example of this rule is Snowboard Kids 2, which was released in tiny quantities, with no reprints as the game was not popular, or known of at all. We were unable to find any copy of the game for sale on Amazon, while two Ebay listings have the game at £150. The game may be incredibly rare, but it'll hard to sell at that kind of price as it doesn't have the sheer appeal of other rare games which are sought after because of general game quality, not just because they're collectors items. Nevertheless, Snowboard Kids 2 is a seldom seen cartridge for the N64.

2. ClayFighter 63 1/3: The Sculptor's Cut

Besides the wacky title, Clay Fighter 63 1/3 is a fairly average fighting game which pales in quality compared to many of the N64's other premiere fighting titles such as Mortal Kombat, Super Smash Bros and Fighter's Destiny. It features a variety of oddball characters all animated in stop-motion, after the clay animation was highly criticized from the second Clay Fighters game. Most critics panned the game due to it having a slow pace, abusive combos and sub-par controls. It's not the demand or appeal of Clay Fighters 63 1/3 itself that makes it desirable, but Clay Fighters 63 1/3: The Sculptor's Cut was a re-released version of the game with additional content, exclusive to Blockbuster. While you could certainly rent the game at Blockbuster, you couldn't purchase it outright anywhere, hence why there are so very few copies in existence. Amazon has the game listed from $250 upwards, with no copies seemingly on Ebay. The box and manual are said to be worth hundreds on their own, as there are so few of them - most store owners immediately threw them away as they were intended for rental only. The exclusivity of the game to North America also adds to the already ridiculous price tag. The Sculptor's Cut adds 4 playable characters, in addition to some minor menu, feature and gameplay edits, making it a must for collectors only. While it's not often desired because of the game's apparently shoddy quality, Clay Fighter 63 1/3: The Sculptor's Cut is undoubtedly one of the rarest N64 cartridges in existence.

1. Yoshi's Story: International Version

Serving as a sequel to Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island, Yoshi's Story was yet another Yoshi solo adventure. The player would take control of the Yoshi in a variety of colors, in a bid to return their world to its normal state after it has been turned into a picture book by Baby Bowser. The world you play in very much resembles a pop-up book, with various textures represented in the graphics such as cardboard, cotton and wood - an idea that inspire Kirby's Epic Yarn and the upcoming Wii U game, Yoshi's Woolly World. Much like Clayfighter 63 1/3, it's not the standard retail version of this game which is rare, it's the bizarrely named international version which is a highly collectible item, often regarded as the rarest N64 cartridge in existence. As you'll see the cover says 'not for resale', this version was originally meant to show off the game before release, which is probably why the game's text is in Japanese, before Nintendo had the full translation available. Other than a different cover, the game's Japanese text and the fact it only works on American consoles, there's virtually no difference between this game and a regular retail copy. As for the price, it's so hard to actually find one for sale that coming up with a price is all but impossible.

Contributor
Contributor

Sam is an experienced Film, Gaming and Wrestling writer, critic and journalist who was written for a vast number of different entertainment websites. Follow him on twitter at @Sams_Reel_Views.