10 Reasons Mafia 3 Will Be Better Than GTA 6
The student always becomes the master. Always.

So, you might have caught the supremely cool-looking Mafia 3 trailer -if not, check it out below - and been pleasantly surprised. Coming as the third instalment in 2K's cult series, it joins Saints Row as a franchise that began by aping everything GTA had made a name on, before slowly starting to do it better.
Unlike Dark Souls 3 - which proved in its 5-star excellence that nobody does that genre quite like FromSoftware - Rockstar's track record with GTA has been less than spotless. A left-turn in GTA IV saw them attempting to tell a far more serious and nuanced tale about life in America, only for fans to pretty much despise its flat tone and lack of experimental anarchy.
GTA V returned these qualities, but did so to such a weird, opulent degree that every aspect felt fleshed out, yet none were especially original or fun. And the less said about Trevor's controversy-courting torture scene, the better.
By contrast, Saints Row, Sleeping Dogs and now Mafia 3 are the outsiders looking in.
The latter in particular delivered a phenomenal crime caper in its second instalment, and by watching every misstep Rockstar have made, it's allowed 2K's new studio, Hangar 13, to learn from every single one, crafting an upcoming game that should be one for the ages...
10. There's ALevel Of Confidence GTA Hasn't Had In Years

I don't know about you, but there was a supreme lack of confidence displayed throughout GTA V, to the degree where it felt like a direct response to GTA IV.
Trevor, Michael and Franklin only barely contrasted each other when it came to gameplay and morality, their inclusions seemingly being intended to let you feel more 'comfortable' wreaking havoc, whereas Niko was forever talking about leaving his life of crime. It meant the entire game was stranded between having occasionally well-delivered and emotive cutscenes with memorable characters, yet they were squandered by not capitalising on any of their arcs.
Trevor and Michael's 'rebuilding friendship' idea fell apart when the former couldn't care less if his pal was mulched by the Triads, and Franklin was just a cipher for player intent, the decision to off his partners coming out of nowhere at the close of the story.
Such moral choices are indicative of what Rockstar started in GTA IV, but when you've got a game more preoccupied with unabashed escapism and chaos, there's not much room to build a meaningful narrative. Saints Row did soon this by doubling down on the anarchic elements of open-world crime games, whilst Mafia removed them and told a far more serious story.
You can't have both sides of this coin.GTA V played things way too safe, had too much money riding on it to take any real risks, and it shows.
9. It Has Shadow Of Mordor's Nemesis System

Thanks to some all-new details revealed in IGN's Beyond podcast, those who've gone hands-on have described a supremely brilliant-sounding evolution of Monolith's 'Nemesis system' from Shadow of Mordor. If you've not played that game, it involved a constantly-shifting hierarchy of enemy units, where you'll be killing off, turning and promoting certain figures constantly, remixing the oppositional ranks to best suit your approach.
All who played, wished that more games had a similar feature, and Mafia 3 is the first to implement one. The story sees you playing as one Lincoln Clay as he takes down the mob, soyou'll need to interrogate enemies to gain information on higher-level targets, turn them to your side,wipe the remainder outandtakeoverthearea itself, beforeinsertinga Lieutenant to run things while you're away.
Doing so means you've got to appoint one person whilst simultaneously annoying those who didn't get the promotion. You'll have to look after your own ranks whilst taking apart theirs, and already thissounds like a far more interesting mechanic than anything GTA's done since, erm...Vice City Stories' property management?
8. Driving Controls That Won't P*ss You Off

Another thing from IGN's podcast was the reveal that driving in Mafia 3 is actually going to be a fairly arcady affair. Whilst the word itself sounds like getting around the city might be pretty twitchy, you need only think back to Sleeping Dogs to get a feel for how a physics-be-damned approach can work wonders.
Apparently, by doing away with wondering about real-world physics and weighty car models, it allows chases to be more visceral and immediately controllable. In GTA you're always in danger of spinning off the road, hitting oncoming traffic or flipping your car at a moment's notice, all in pursuit of some quasi sense of realism that's at the heart of how it all handles.
If we're talking about design decisions made in service of playability, give me more arcady, bolted-to-the-road controls any day.
7. Innovative Open-World Mechanics That Make A Subtle Difference

Remember when you first played Saints Row 3, and realised you could enter a car by just leaping through the window, rather than opening the door? It was a subtle change, but one that made playing that game and hopping between going on-foot and in vehicles near-seamless.
For Mafia 3, 2K have clearly been looking into what else they could innovate on, and have changed the way you travel around the world in a similar manner to 2003's The Getaway. Where Sony's first-party title showed navigation towards waypoints by having your car's turning signals light up before turns, Mafia 3 is doing the same with in-world signage.
On coming up to junctions and turning points, different neon signs or light-up components in the world will show you the direction to go, in a way that means you never have to take your eyes off the road to stare at a mini-map.
It's a small change, but one that aids general navigation tenfold.
6. An Exemplary Soundtrack
Granted, Rockstar could take GTA back to another period in history, but they're all out of decades unless they want to start encroaching on Mafia/The Godfather game's already well-worn turf. As such, both GTA IV and V had pretty weak soundtracks by comparison to Vice City and San Andreas' more grander representations of their respective time periods, simply because there were less iconic tunes to choose from.
Setting an open-world game in a decade we can all look back on in retrospect aids in presenting the best songs from its entire period, as oppose to worrying about filling out random tracks for the sake of it.
To that end, 1968 is the setting of Mafia 3, and we've already had Dusty Springfield's 'Son of a Preacher Man' in the latest trailer, alongside The Animals' 'House of the Rising Sun', Hendrix's 'All Along the Watchtower', Creedence Clearwater Revival's 'Fortunate Son' and and The Rolling Stones' 'Paint it Black'.
Now that, is how to give your game an identity.
5. 2K Have The Freedom To Experiment

There's a sweet spot when it comes to game development budgets. Too little and you can't fulfil your initial vision, cutting back elements to ensure there's a shippable product somewhere at the end, whereas too much means that initial investment has to be recouped no matter what - cue endless focus-testing to 'guarantee' sales.
Assassin's Creed fell foul of the latter eventually, and I'd argue GTA V totally did too. For all the glossy world-building and gorgeous world that Rockstar had designed, it was completely emblematic of a studio with all the money in the world, yet nothing to spend it on. GTA III through IV felt like risky investments; a developer flexing their muscles in a thousand directions at once and seeing who was up for going along for the ride.
Mafia has this same sensation, too. 2K's budget allocations and the series' reputation as it stands is enough to let Hangar 13 try something completely new, alongside building the tone and feel of the series overall.
The new story trailer hammered home the idea of 'Raiden-ing' the Mafia canon, Metal Gear Solid 2-style,bringing in an external force to comment on and interact with the characters and tropes of the originals. Mafia feels like a franchise with everything to offer and a ton to still prove. It's something the existing fans want to shout about, and that alone will power the developers through to the finish like nothing else.
Rockstar already have your attention, always will, and that leads to a semblance of complacency you can already see emerging across GTA V.
4. There's A Major Story Focus

One of the biggest realisations you can have about the open-world genre over the years, is how its initial appeal - the whole 'let's explore and explode for hours'- has already waned, far past the point where pure wanton destruction would hold your attention for very long.
Yes, it's fun blowing stuff up and going on a random police chase, but not more fun than it used to be, and certainly not as we move forward, getting increasingly expansive versions of the exact same thing. To that end, an open-world game should be supplanted with a brilliant story; a perfect motivation for a character to indulge in the main missions, just as much as those around them. There should be a thrust to see the campaign through in a rewarding narrative sense, whilst also factoring into the genre being so freeform in the first place.
It's a delicate balance, but one that The Witcher 3 and Red Dead Redemption nailed. Mafia 3 looks to do the same. As Lincoln Clay, you're on a revenge mission, pure and simple. Cutscenes in the story trailer allude to explorations of his motivations and the toll it takes on his psyche, but it's a primary motivator that means you can wipe out all your targets at once -or do your bit exploring and restoring the city.
Ask yourself, what were the motivations of GTA V's cast? Crazy for crazy's sake, Mr. One-Last-Mission-Then-I'm-Done, and 'Sure Why Not', right?
3. Characters You Already Care About

Speaking of Lincoln Clay, he's a fading Catholic, Vietnam war vet, returning to his city of New Bordeaux, only to see the mafia's influence tearing the streets apart. Dude's like freakin' Daredevil and The Punisher rolled into one, the scene where a preacher is telling him of the dangers of what he's embarking on being very reminiscent of something from the former's first season.
The Punisher comparisons are apt too, as hardly anyone ever writes such a violently-motivated character well. Writer Garth Ennis' run on The Punisher MAX comics is exemplary, as is Jon Bernthal's performance in the Daredevil TV show; Clay's delivery of the line "You are who you are. No point arguing with yourself about it" cementing his intentions for the duration.
Clay looks like a guy who's going to die trying to take down the empires built by the likes of those you encountered in the past games. Mafia 2's VitoScaletta is also back and on-side, as they're seen working together in the initial reveal trailer. Considering both characters are killers who've seen their fair share of bloodshed,you can expect a lot to be spilt when they team up.
2. A Unique World With Immediate Appeal

Early in the trailer we get the narrator mentioning how New Bordeaux (Mafia's version of New Orleans, which also ties into Red Dead 3) has "survived the war of 1812, the civil war and God knows what else". It's a fairly subtle but effective way of giving the populace around you some much-needed character, history and place.
In GTA you can mow down thousands of pedestrians for days and barely bat an eye, but the violence in Mafia is far more real. It's gritty, repercussive, and felt from alleyway to motorway shootout.
Gun battles look to leave the survivors patching up their wounds and ambling towards the next milestone in their personal vendettas. And the same goes for the world itself. Lincoln Clay's personal vendetta against the very fabric of the city's makeup sounds like from the offset, it'll shake everything to its base foundations.
The character of New Orleans/Bordeaux is not only present in the soundtrack, but in the lively NPC animations taking part in their own lives as you wander past. It'll be a genuinely impactful experience to have a shootout amongst these people, or to barrel through groups as you chase down a wanted target - something that doesn't even register in GTA's more intentionally carefree model.
1. No Resources Wasted On Pointless Levels

There's a mission in GTA V where you have to move shipping crates around, and another where you enter the expertly-modelled interior of a social media developer, just to trigger a death that later happens in a cutscene.
If you needed something more telling of Rockstar's abundance of cash, look no further than the level design. You can count the amount of mechanically unique - and enjoyable - missions on one hand, whereas the rest were mostly routed in things we'd already done, albeit with fancier interiors.
Whilst Mafia 3 will most likely fall back on these tropes and let its version of the nemesis system do the talking, at least it'll be a thoroughly focussed affair; one where you play as a character with a city-levelling grudge, embarking on a mission with a defined endpoint.
All assets and the budget itself will go into fulfilling this idea, and its an approach similar to Sega's outstanding Yakuza games. Here's to an open-world masterpiece that takes the ball from a staggering giant and runs with it.
--
What do you make of Mafia 3's story trailer, and the series overall? Let us know in the comments!