10 Reasons You Were Wrong About GTA IV

The under-appreciated sibling of the GTA family deserves far more praise.

Rockstar's Grand Theft Auto has undoubtedly become one of gaming's biggest and best franchises. From its humble, top-down origins with the PS1 and PCs to the absolute juggernaut GTA V has proven to be with the newest generation of consoles, the journey into the spotlight has been an impressive one. But while all of these games have their critics and detractors - citing "crass features" and "shady morals" - from outside of the gaming community, there's only really one title in the series that has never found full favour from its own audience. 2008's GTA IV tends to be seen as the weakest entry in the current 3D style, with criticism levied at oversensitive driving controls, a bland colour palette and even the lack of personality carried off by the game's protagonist; Niko Bellic. The list of gripes players have had with this game is surprisingly long for a title that garnered multiple 'Game Of The Year' awards after its release, but still hardcore fans of this version are getting harder to come by. Not content that this game should be getting such a bum deal, we've decided to leap to the rescue of Niko & co to bring the world the case in favour of GTA IV. So if you're among those who've struggled to find favour for this instalment, read the following ten reasons you were wrong about GTA IV and see if they can change your mind. Already like the game? Read on anyway, and see if your favourite features have made our list.

10. A Truly Engaging Story

While the overriding ambition for virtually every GTA protagonist has been to rise up to seize fortune and power over rivals by any means necessary, the story in Rockstar's 2008 instalment added some much-needed depth to this drive. Niko's journey to America comes from a place of desperation; motivated by leaving a war-torn country and convinced by the boasts of cousin Roman, he makes his way to Liberty City. Upon arrival he quickly finds Roman may have embellished a few of his glory stories, setting in motion a chain of events that sees Niko take matters into his own dirty hands. The story is so involving because at its basic level it is relatable; it's really nothing more than a question of whether the grass really is always greener on the other side? Players with Niko will see this question posed early, before discovering that the answer is the grass is whatever colour you like on the other side, so long as you know how to get dirty jobs done well!

9. Fantastic Physics

The console generation gap between San Andreas and GTA IV meant that Rockstar had a whole new set of hardware to play with when it came to developing the next instalment of their flagship series. When the game finally released, it was clear that this gap represented a major leap forward and a lot of time well spent. The physics in this game probably offered the best showcase of how far things had progressed. Just walking through the streets of Liberty City was enough to demonstrate this, as Niko bumped and bashed his way past civilians who all react and move realistically. In combat enemies would stagger and fall believably for each sustained wound, and Niko himself became sluggish when riddled with leaden shots. Even the silliest of examples demonstrated a great technical feat; managing to drop a car from the top of a high-rise would yield results in line with what you'd expect from such an impact, and Niko's body would twist and contort on the 'Wasted' screen each time he was killed in an explosion. This game set out a lot of the groundwork for the great physics in Max Payne 3, which in turn saw its advancements honed later on in GTA V. Call it the circle of life, if you like...

8. Questions Of Morality

As part of the main storyline, players were asked at numerous points to choose between two polarising options for how to deal with a particular person or event. These populate the action with some truly tough decisions, and the best of them would have left players really scratching their heads as to whether or not they had chosen the 'right' answer. The first players encounter is whether or not to kill the Vlad's henchman Ivan, or to look kindly and spare his life. Even though this decision seems obvious given the character's association with antagonist Vlad, there's still the slightest nagging doubt following players at the moment the game puts the outright decision to them. It's likely most of you reading this ultimately chose to off the poor soul, but sparing his life yields a playable random encounter later in the game as Niko bumps into him again. Interestingly Ivan, if spared, cuts all ties from his former life with the mafia and takes up a slightly more reputable employment. The way these decisions shape the future of Liberty City and its inhabitants in the game shows just how much depth Rockstar put into the events of GTA IV.

7. Liberty City

It's true that Rockstar seem never to have had a problem with getting locations right within their big, open world titles and GTA IV's version of Liberty City was absolutely no exception to this. Liberty City - the series' recreation of New York - represents probably the busiest location the studio have tackled, but that daunting task was dealt with perfectly. The streets truly felt alive in Liberty City, with the various districts operating with the various character types one would expect in real life counterpart NYC. Strolling around the park will present players with joggers and flirting couples, while striding the streets will see them bumps into suit-clad businessmen and hustling hobos. The beauty of Liberty City isn't just in the inhabitants, either. While the map may not match the variety offered in a region like San Andreas, Rockstar managed to make it genuinely feel like a city. Bustling, impressive and at times more than a little imposing, Liberty City is one of Rockstar's greatest creations to date.

6. That Bank Robbery Mission

Many modern games become memorable for particular moments that really stick with players. While some can become victims of this and fall into the shadow of one defining event, Rockstar's GTA games have been so chock-full of such moments that they can coexist and be mutually appreciated. For GTA IV, that moment comes early in the second half when Niko teams with Packie's crew to tackle a bank robbery. The mission, while relatively short in comparison to some of GTA V's larger tasks, is as chaotic and intense as players would come to expect from the series. After a typically entertaining cut scene, the whole thing turns into a gigantic firefight with the LCPD as Niko & co try to make their escape with substantial sums of money in tow. This mission represents the best mix of small-scale, relevant humour and the grand spectacle of a huge third person shooter. The fact that it makes a repeat appearance and recycles cut-scenes later in the second DLC story speaks to how well-integrated and memorable this event was in the overall experience.

5. A Wonderful Supporting Cast

Having already mentioned Rockstar's skills with location crafting, it would be foolish to fail to applaud the staggering frequency with which they are able to assemble a diverse cast of characters with each new instalment to the series. In the bustling, cultural hub that is Liberty City, this cast has never been stronger or more entertaining. Characters like Brucie Kibbutz, the self-conscious narcissist, or Lil' Jacob, the mellow drug dealer/resilient goon, are what makes a parody of life like Grand Theft Auto keep ticking over. No matter how good the story and gameplay may be, a story-driven game like this simply could not function well without an interesting and believable set of characters to play it out. Many of these characters from Liberty City have managed to leave lasting impressions on the ongoing series, too, with many of them appearing in GTA V in name or sometimes even full appearance. Don't be surprised if these names keep on popping up in GTA VI, as well...

4. The Introduction Of A Cover System

The oft-criticised style sub genre of 'cover shooters' seems to be flooding the gaming market these days. While immensely popular with developers and gamers alike, they are not without their detractors and many have criticised the style for making games too easy. Adding it into a popular series like Grand Theft Auto could be risky, then, couldn't it? Well no, not really. While GTA: San Andreas was a great game, its gunplay and action sequences now feel remarkably static having played the latter instalments with decent cover mechanics. The only motion players could make in San Andreas was to crouch, run or roll, leaving shootouts feeling immensely precarious and a tad unrealistic. The cover mechanic was a much-needed addition to the series, and the games have continued to become all the better for it. GTA is a series that now represents some of the most intense and dramatic action sequences, many of which would have been rendered impossible were it not for this change in GTA IV.

3. An Online Experience

While 'Grand Theft Auto' and 'Online' are probably starting to feel like they go hand in hand, this was not always the case and the precedent had to start and be set somewhere. For that we need look no further than GTA IV's early version of the now iconic online mode to see how the origin was found. Offering console support for up to 16 players, this mode contained many of the game types that players have come to enjoy in the huge online community that exists today. Taking place within Liberty City, the mode also included a free mode and a team-based variation on this called party mode. This online addition looks a lot like the skeleton of GTA:Online without all of the meat and muscles added. Rockstar tested the waters with this - and a few others - before diving head first into a fully fledged online community with their latest game. Thanks, GTA IV!

2. Two Excellent DLC Additions

Perhaps a little unfair to allow for additional content to be touted as a strength, but since they were so well embedded into the original's story it's difficult to imagine them as afterthoughts. For that reason, these excellent DLC packages have to be considered as one this game's big successes. Brining with them a new protagonist each time, both The Lost & Damned and The Ballad Of Gay Tony offered a look at Liberty City through different eyes to Niko's and the results were fascinating. While Johnny's story is a dramatic, hierarchical struggle, Luis' offered the kind of carefree chaos of earlier titles as players took control of the titular Gay Tony's assistant. These games brought with them some of the features that many players may have felt were "missing" from GTA IV and added even more depth and variety to Rockstar's turn in the big city. If anyone out there has ever judged GTA IV as inferior without having played these extras, then there's simply one thing to do... play them!

1. It Was The Perfect Precursor For GTA V

With the exception of the more traditional DLC packages, ultimately the seriousness of GTA IV was seen as the largest departure from the series' norm. While we know some fans didn't enjoy this, it's important to realise that it served as a well-timed break before Rockstar took us back to a little more of the silliness with their recent return to Los Santos. It's true that absence really does make the heart grow fonder, and so giving players something a little more unexpected with GTA IV meant bringing back the absurdities that have made the series a powerhouse felt all the sweeter in the end. GTA V just feels like more of a Grand Theft Auto game overall and, while its predecessor was responsible for some great changes and innovations as the series grew, moving back to this expected style was a move choreographed to perfection. So, did that do it? Are you now looking at the adventures of Niko, Roman and all of Liberty City's other go-getters in a kinder light? Join the discussion in the comments below!

In this post: 
GTA GTA IV
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Gareth is 28 years old and lives in Cardiff. Interests include film, TV and an unhealthy amount of Spider-Man comics and Killers songs. Expect constant references to the latter two at all times. Follow on twitter @GJCartwright.