10 Recent Failed Video Games That Became Cult Classics
Found anyone who doesn't LOVE Deadly Premonition?
The enjoyment that comes with a video game experience can be one of the best feelings in the world but, for some, the added sensation of feeling like they're in a well-kept secret can take things even further.
Not every video game is created equal, and not every title can enjoy the accolades and sales of the Super Marios, Grand Theft Autos and Call of Dutys of this world. And whilst gamers often associate flopping commercially with a poorly-made game, that isn't always the case.
In fact, there have been plenty of video games that have shown a lot of promise and still ended up by the wayside. Be it an ambitious storyline, a dramatic change in tone or just an overly-saturated market upon release, there are many reasons why a game or series might not hit the heights a publisher had hoped for.
Nevertheless, these games are still treasured by their fanbases and wear their 'cult classic' honours with pride.
Here are some of the best examples of games that started off on the back foot, but have successfully gone on to find their own little corners of the industry.
10. Mad Max (2015)
2015's Mad Max is an open-world survival title developed by Avalanche Studios. Whilst not following the events of any one Mad Max film, the game clearly takes a lot of inspiration from them, with its post-apocalyptic wasteland setting. One of the first titles to emphasise vehicular combat across its open world, players are required to upgrade their rides as they battle Scabrous Scrotus' gang.
However, in an era where open-world titles dominated the market, Mad Max failed to make the splash Avalanche were hoping for.
The bulk of its mixed reception stemmed from the game's storyline, which only came to life right at the end (by which time most players had tossed it to the back of their library). The game's quests also came in for some flack, as well as a number of technical bugs that hadn't been ironed out.
Nevertheless, the game's setting and Batman Arkham-esque combat has seen Mad Max's standing with gamers begin to climb again. On the back of a possible sequel being in the works, the game saw its player count jump to its highest point since October 2021 with a peak of 2,436 players in September 2022.
9. Sunset (2015)
2015's Sunset is an interactive storytelling experience that deserves more love than it gets.
The game is played from a first-person perspective as players follow Angela Burnes, an African-American housekeeper who performs a number of tasks for her client, one hour before sunset. The more she cleans, the more the world around her begins to change and the more of her story is uncovered.
The game is an intimate and visually stunning experience to play through, but still one that far too many gamers haven't actually experienced yet. The game's development was partially funded by fans on Kickstarter, raising $67,636 on the platform in total.
However, despite earning a considerable amount of praise for its looks and tone, Sunset has remained one of the gaming world's best kept secrets. Nominated for the Games for Change award at The Game Awards 2015, Sunset only sold 4,000 copies in its first month on the shelves, with roughly half of those being reserved for its Kickstarter backers.
The commercial failing of Sunset led to Tale of Tales announcing they would no longer be involved with the gaming space, but that hasn't stopped the title being a cult classic among those that helped get it off the ground.
8. Shenmue III (2019)
The Shenmue series has garnered an infamous reputation for being a 'cult classic' sort of series.
Back in the Dreamcast days, the original Shenmue title had been developed as the most expensive video game in the world; however, by the time it came to the series being rebooted with the third edition, developers had resorted to Kickstarter campaigns to get things off the ground.
Making history as the highest-funded game on the platform, Shenmue III launched in November 2019 and instantly began to divide opinions with its by-the-book approach to things.
Labelled a 'core niche project' by Lars Wingefors, the game sold half the amount of copies as the remastered original Shenmue title, with many reports suggesting sales had been much lower than what had been hoped.
Nevertheless, the game's faithfulness to its series' roots has continued to sit well with the fans who did receive it well.
Following the release of the Battle Rally DLC in January 2020, Shenmue III jumped to 13,000 followers on Steam and has since gone on to elevate that number even higher to just shy of 15,000 as of October 2022.
7. Deadly Premonition 2: A Blessing In Disguise (2020)
2010's Deadly Premonition holds a record in the Guinness Book of World Records for being the most critically-polarising video game in the world, and it's understandable how Access Games ended up with that honour.
The story of Francis York Morgan's investigation into the Raincoat Killer was filled with meme-worthy flaws, but remains a wonderfully dark whodunnit story that proved so popular with its loyal followers, we got a port on Switch in 2019 and a fully-fledged sequel in 2020.
Toybox Inc.'s title instantly garnered a mixed reputation from critics for its less-than-impactful storyline compared to its predecessor. Blessing in Disguise also came with serious technical limitations, none more obvious than its painfully slow frame rate that could reach as low as five per second.
But, the quirkiness that made the original such a cult classic was still very much at play and that meant the game would continue to house a dedicated crop of fans. The eccentric characters were a big plus (especially the returning Morgan), and a 7/10 rating on Steam is a much kinder score that such a technically-flawed title can usually expect to receive.
If nothing else, the existence of the game and the original Deadly Premonition's port over to Nintendo's latest system shows interest in this divisive series is still going strong.
6. Full Throttle (1995/2017)
Cult classics like Day of the Tentacle have become synonymous with the last days of LucasArts, but there are plenty of other names that also deserve more recognition. Perhaps no game has been unfairly left on the sidelines more often than Full Throttle.
Originally released as Tim Schafer's first game as a lead developer, the game featured voice acting from the likes of Mark Hamill and Hamilton Camp, and its greasy, grungy aesthetics made it one of the classic point-and-click adventures from the 1990s.
In 2017, following the likes of Day of the Tentacle and Grim Fandango, Full Throttle was given the remastering treatment. However, despite an overhaul to the graphics and the option to play either the original or contemporary version, the game failed to match the impact of those other classic titles and faded back into obscurity again.
Nevertheless, just like with the original, the game has been preserved by its loyal fanbase. The series received its first push on to the mobile world with an iOS port, and further releases even followed right up to the Xbox One in October 2020.
5. Civilization VI (2016)
Sid Meier's Civilization series has always been one of the most successful turn-based titles, however, it was 2010's Civilization V that the series really hit its commercial peak. A PC exclusive, the game enjoyed critical acclaim during its lifetime and is still played by its loyal fanbase.
It was a long wait for the game's sequel, with Civilization VI eventually releasing in October 2016. From the off, this was a game that was designed to do away with everything players had learned from Civ V. A new technology tree, districts outside of cities, and random engagements were all thrown in with Civ VI to create a totally fresh-feeling entry.
However, upon release, Civ VI was subject to a spyware controversy, with the original release having Red Shell's ad tracking bundled in, and the game received some lukewarm receptions following the decision to remove features such as the Diplomatic victory option too.
Thankfully, the game's impressive strategy ceiling, two major expansions and a slew of additional updates led to most of the issues being addressed and Civ VI's reputation gradually began to claw its way back to the heights of its predecessor.
Civ V might still be the go-to title in the franchise but, for those who stuck it out, there are still plenty of loyal fans who love its sequel.
4. Marvel Vs. Capcom: Infinite (2017)
Off the bat, Marvel vs. Capcom: Infinite was a seriously ambitious title which always had the risk of flopping hard. The sixth main entry to the series, the game's reception pre-release hardly put the title on the best footing.
The removal of series staples like character assist moves and three-on-three battles gave the impression Capcom were going all in on a new formula for Infinite.
This might have been one of the reasons why the game failed to make much of a splash in terms of both sales and reception. A 72/100 score on Metacritic is hardly a crisis, but Capcom ended up missing their sales target for Infinite by a million copies or so, only selling half of the two million target they had set.
But, the wholesale changes the game brought has certainly endeared the title to those players who have stuck around. More open-ended fighting systems help give the game a more personalised feel, rewarding more hardcore players who invested more hours into Infinite with a higher skill ceiling.
3. Scott Pilgrim Vs The World: The Game (2010/2021)
2010's Scott: Pilgrim vs The World is one of the most celebrated box office bombs in the world of cinema. A huge chunk of the film's $85 million budget was spent on practical and digital effects to produce the striking comic art style that was always going to make the jump over to the gaming world an inevitability for the series.
Scott Pilgrim vs. the World: The Game was released in August 2010 and is a curious coming together of Bryan Lee O'Malley's universe and the art style of Drawn To Life's Paul Robertson.
Like with the novels and film, the game sees players take control of Scott Pilgrim and his friends as they battle with Ramona Flowers' seven evil exes. The Beat 'em Up title received some solid praise for its art style, however, most reviews upon release were fairly scathing towards the lack of a drop-in mode, online multiplayer, and how grindy the game was.
The game and all of its DLC were delisted in December 2014 after Ubisoft's licence expired. But, after a seven-year absence, the publishers announced that a remastered version of the game would be landing for players in January 2021 with both a digital and hardcopy coming out filled with unique special editions and various other promo pieces.
2. Nier (2010/2021)
As a spin-off title based on the fifth possible ending of the original Drakengard title, Nier was always in danger of being a cult classic. The game was released in April 2010, with the Japanese market getting two alternative releases featuring a different protagonist.
Set in a post-apocalyptic world set 1,000 years after the ending of Drakengard, Nier has some impressive acting and received some praise for its storyline and soundtrack, but overall it failed to win the majority of fans and critics over.
The bulk of the criticism for the game came aimed at its visuals, with the majority of reviews believing they just weren't up to standard for some of the grandiose sights players would be treated to. Commercial sales also weren't much to write home about either, with director Yoko Taro claiming: "we weren't really in the red, but it wasn't exactly a success either".
Nevertheless, for Drakengard veterans especially, the game proved to be a hit with enough fans to justify an updated version that sold over a million units and a full-blown sequel Nier: Automata in 2017.
1. Shadow Man Remastered (1999/2013/2022)
Out of the long list of titles that have never managed to break into the mainstream, Shadow Man might just be the heaviest hitter of all. Originally released in 1999, this voodoo-centred adventure title drew some polarising opinions in part due to just how darn difficult it was to complete in the pre-YouTube days.
Nevertheless, its presence on nearly every console under the sun in the early 2000s and original themes made it a favourite for horror fans around the world, prompting Nightdive Studios to make a remastered edition via GOG.com in 2013.
The game was eventually added to Steam that year but was strictly limited to PC systems which, for a title that was available on three separate consoles back in the day, wasn't the smartest decision.
Fan appetite for a true remastering hadn't been quenched, but thankfully Nightdive came back strong with 2021's Shadow Man Remastered.
Released for Windows, Switch, the PS4 and Xbox One, the port featured 4K resolution, better shadow mapping, per-pixel lightning and a completely revamped approach to physics, controls and AI behaviour.