10 Recent Video Games Critics Hated (But Players LOVED)
Terminator: Resistance is awesome. End of discussion.
Though video game publishers put an awful amount of stock in the Metacritic scores of their releases, there's really no accounting for taste - we all like what we like.
And while it's fair to say that the majority of critically scorned video games quickly fade into the cultural ether, there are those few that manage to find an audience no matter that the reviews fell far short of the expected mark.
These 10 video games all reviewed much worse than just about anyone was hoping for, whether disappointingly received or outright panned, and yet the response from general players was a lot more favourable.
From examining the Metacritic user scores and Steam reviews of these critically pummelled games, we're able to glean a picture of those rare titles that were loved by a large portion of players even with dozens of negative reviews dismissing them.
In some cases it's as simple as players being less burned-out on certain types of games than critics, while elsewhere players benefitted from day-one and post-launch patches which weren't available during the review period, ensuring their experiences playing the game were quite different.
Whatever the reason, though, these critically besmirched games fared way better with gamers at large...
10. Days Gone
Days Gone was one of Sony's most anticipated AAA exclusives during the PlayStation 4 generation, though ended up releasing to wildly lukewarm reviews, netting a paltry 71 Metascore.
This paled massively compared to other PS4-exclusive blockbusters like Bloodborne (92), Uncharted 4 (93), Horizon Zero Dawn (87), God of War (94), Marvel's Spider-Man (87), Ghost of Tsushima (83), and The Last of Us Part II (93).
Critics complained that Days Gone failed to be more than a fairly cookie-cutter open-world action game, offering up a generic, unremarkable sandbox, matched by a mediocre story and uninteresting lead character. Many also felt the game's critical path massively outstayed its welcome.
Yet it fared far better with general players, with almost 10,000 Metacritic user votes awarding it an 8.4 average score. Additionally when the game hit PC it received an 8.7 score, as well as a "Highly Positive" rating on Steam from over 20,000 players.
While players are generally far more forgiving of over-familiar mechanics and aesthetics than critics, that surely can't entirely account for the critic/player disparity here.
Despite selling relatively well across PS4 and later PC, Sony decided not to press forward with a sequel, reportedly due to the disappointing critical reception.
9. The Ascent
Cyberpunk-themed action-RPG The Ascent sure looked like an absolute blast pre-release, but reviews were ultimately disappointingly middling, with Metascores of 68 on Xbox Series X and a somewhat sunnier 74 on PC.
For a game which Microsoft marketed fairly heavily and pushed extensively in their various livestreams, it was undeniably a letdown, with many critics lambasting The Ascent's mediocre shooting mechanics, nothing story, repetitive mission design, and especially its abundance of bugs.
Players were far more enthusiastic, however, with the game landing 7.9 and 7.8 scores on Xbox Series X and PC respectively. Its Steam rating is also "Mostly Positive" from over 11,000 customers.
This gulf of opinion can be somewhat easily explained - the version of The Ascent played pre-release by critics was riddled with bugs which had been patched out by the time much of the general public got around to playing it.
A large chunk of regular players therefore got a considerably more hassle-free experience, which likely aided them in being less-bothered by its repetitious aspects.
That and the fact that many played it for "free" on Xbox Game Pass, which is certainly going to make otherwise objectionable elements a little easier to accept.
8. SpongeBob SquarePants: Battle For Bikini Bottom - Rehydrated
SpongeBob SquarePants: Battle for Bikini Bottom received mixed-positive reviews when it originally released for PlayStation 2, Xbox, and GameCube back in 2003, but when the "Rehydrated" remake came out in 2020, critics weren't quite so thrilled.
The new version landed an unremarkable 68 Metascore on PS4, with many reviewers noting that little effort had been made to update the original platformer for modern audiences.
As a result, much of the gameplay felt unpolished and unreasonably frustrating to contemporary players, who may reasonably have been expecting some quality-of-life refinements.
Incredibly, though, the user score from over 2,000 players sits at a stonking 8.9, and on Steam it holds an "Overwhelmingly Positive" rating from 9,000+ user reviews.
It's not much of a secret that jaded critics are considerably less-susceptible to nostalgia than players, especially players who would ever consider buying a remake of an almost 20-year-old SpongeBob SquarePants game, which likely accounts for the divide.
Players, with their warm, fuzzy memories of the original and more forgiving attitude towards its more dated mechanics, simply relished in the dopamine boost this nostalgic treat gave them, complete with some shiny new graphics to match. The definition of comfort food.
7. Travis Strikes Again: No More Heroes
The No More Heroes games have generally been well-received by critics, though 2019's Travis Strikes Again remains the outlier of the four mainline titles.
With a mere 67 Metascore, most critics were lukewarm-at-best on the game, many dismissing it as a bland, repetitive hack 'n' slash title that felt more like a limp imitation of a Suda51 game, and one that at eight hours in length grossly outstayed its welcome.
Players gave it a far more welcoming 7.8 user score, though, and on Steam it retains "Very Positive" reviews.
Given that Travis Strikes Again is an unashamedly "for the fans" game, that might account for it performing better within its customer niche.
There's also the fact that players were much less likely than critics to be blasting through the game - in critics' case to meet embargo - and becoming exhausted by the repetition on offer.
That it launched for the cheaper budget price of $29.99 probably didn't hurt either.
6. Pathologic 2
Open-world survival horror game Pathologic 2 received wildly polarising reviews upon release, scoring a 9/10 from Edge Magazine but to the same token landing 5/10 from Gamespot, while Rock, Paper, Shotgun hated it enough that they didn't even finish it.
Its Metacritic score shook out at an aggressively mediocre 64 on Xbox One and a slightly better 70 on PC. Though some critics praised its atmosphere and ambition, it was widely raked over the coals for its frustratingly demanding survival mechanics, abundance of bugs, and irritating combat.
Conversely the user rating settled on an impressive 8.7, and on Steam it holds a "Very Positive" rating from over 5,000 players.
Beyond the fact that anyone throwing down cash for this sort of game is likely well acquainted with its brutal difficulty, post-release Ice-Pick Lodge reluctantly released 16 difficulty sliders to aid struggling players, as reviewers obviously didn't have access to while playing.
You can bet that had the game launched with the sliders in the first place, reviews would've been considerably kinder.
5. Medievil
2019's remake of classic 1998 action-adventure game MediEvil was highly anticipated by players before release, though reviews were intensely mixed, leading to an underwhelming 67 Metascore.
The sticking point for many, as with the aforementioned Battle for Bikini Bottom remaster, is that the new MediEvil is basically faithful to a fault. The controls are still... not great, the camera is horrible, and yet its biggest sin must surely be refusing to add checkpoints to levels.
And so, despite its graphical glow-up, critics struggled to recommend MediEvil, especially to new players who would find its dated systems frustrating and cumbersome.
As a result, it makes sense that the game performed well within its nostalgic niche, racking up an 8.1 user score, with many players praising its fastidious faithfulness to the original and even insisting that fellow players shouldn't listen to the critics. Oof.
4. Left Alive
Left Alive is one of the worst-reviewed games released by a major studio in the last few years. The Square Enix-published stealth game was hyped up largely due to the involvement of legendary Metal Gear Solid artist Yoji Shinkawa, but once reviews dropped, so did jaws around the world.
On PS4, Left Alive scored a pathetic 37 on Metacritic, being panned by just about every major gaming publication for its stiff controls, brutally unforgiving stealth mechanics, inconsistent AI, bland graphics, and excess glitches.
Many complained in particular about the game's infrequent checkpointing and how even the lowest difficulty setting offered a significant challenge to those inexperienced in stealth games.
In what perhaps represents the single biggest cavern between critics and players in history, however, Left Alive rocks a strong 8.2 on PS4, and an even higher 8.5 on PC, with well over 1,000 ratings a-piece.
While some have accused Square Enix of inflating the user scores with bots, a less-nefarious explanation is that shortly after release Square Enix released a patch which introduced a new Casual difficulty level.
If nothing else this made the game basically playable without massive frustration, even if it failed to remedy Left Alive's many other failings.
Still, a cursory look at the game's subreddit confirms that it does indeed have a loyal, passionate cabal of fans, tough though that might be to believe.
3. Balan Wonderworld
Square Enix strikes again, this time with last year's platformer Balan Wonderworld. Critics similarly got their fangs out for it, with the PC version scoring a depressing 38 on Metacritic, while the PS5 version - the platform most critics played it on - topped out at a slightly better 51.
Like Left Alive, it was pilloried by most mainstream outlets for basically being a generic, tedious platformer that was low on creativity and high on repetition. Oh, and it's like 10 hours long, so doesn't even have brevity on its side.
Despite this, the user score on Xbox Series X is an impressive 7.2 and an even better 8.1 on Xbox One, with many players citing its colourful visuals and nostalgic throwback appeal to classic platformers (such as game director Yuji Naka's own Sonic the Hedgehog).
Again, players may have benefitted from not having to race through such a needlessly long experience to meet a review embargo deadline.
Played in more bite-sized chunks, it's easy to see how players might view it a lot more favourably, and seemingly love it enough to overlook or even embrace the very things that drove critics mad.
2. Terminator: Resistance
Terminator: Resistance was released shortly after the sixth movie Terminator: Dark Fate, though strangely enough wasn't a tie in-game but instead a totally standalone title based on the IP.
The PS4 version was released to a fair critical drubbing, landing a pitiable 47 Metascore, with reviewers tearing it apart for its muddy visuals, clunky combat, and all-about generic gameplay.
Most critics fobbed it off as a pretty typical video game based on a name IP, with more money spent on acquiring the license than investing in talented personnel to craft a quality game.
The PC release received a somewhat more charitable 60 Metascore, though the user scores for both versions are markedly higher. The PS4 release has a 7.4 score and the PC version 8.1, with it also receiving a "Very Positive" rating from 8,000+ Steam reviews.
"Surprisingly good" is a comment frequently discovered among the game's user reviews, perhaps implying that the brutal early reviews set them up for something far worse than formulaic, repetitive, and a bit janky - but fundamentally enjoyable.
For many long-suffering Terminator fans, it was simply a relief to play a game based on the franchise that was basically functional and competent, which surely helped boost its player esteem.
1. Remothered: Broken Porcelain
Though survival horror game Remothered: Tormented Fathers received mostly positive reviews back in 2018, its 2020 sequel Remothered: Broken Porcelain was conversely panned into the ground.
While there was some errant praise for the atmosphere and aesthetics, it was blasted across all platforms for its poor AI, frequent crashes, and fatal abundance of potentially game-breaking bugs.
The PC version scored just 39 on Metacritic, with some critics going as far as to call it unplayable on launch due to the debilitating bugs, while others simply felt it was too clunky and frustrating to recommend.
However, the player scores range from fair to great, with it scoring from 6.1 on PS4 to 8.0 on Switch.
Unsurprisingly, many of the user reviews note that the developers released patches to fix many of the pre-release bugs that plagued critics, so the discrepancy is easily accounted for.
Sadly with most critics likely not revisiting the game post-launch - either for professional or personal purposes - their experience with the game is forever tainted.