10 Ridiculous Excuses For Failed Video Games
From Lawbreakers to Duke Nukem Forever, check out these games' feeble excuses for their failures!
The video game industry can be a harsh mistress. In recent years, developers have been increasingly inclined towards remasters and remakes, banking on gamers’ nostalgia with heavy-hitters like Final Fantasy VII Remake. Why are they doing this? Well, the allure of sweet, sweet cash aside, it’s rather less risky than taking a shot with a new IP.
As games become more and more cinematic and technically ambitious, development costs tend to skyrocket. Playing it safe, as a result, tends to be the preferred strategy. Even with that in mind, though, the surest-sounding bet can still turn out terribly at times. In that situation, the best response is for developers and/or publishers to have a darn good reason for their failure. Or, alternatively, one of these awful ones.
Not all of these games were abject failures, but they all had some major shortcomings (at least at first) that the creators tried to explain away in feeble fashion.
10. No Man's Sky: It Wasn't Supposed To Be As Popular As It Was
We all know what a disappointment No Man’s Sky proved to be on launch. This 2016 title from Hello Games was talked up to the hilt prior to its release. It had gamers salivating at the idea of a freely explorable universe of almost infinite scope; an open world consisting of more than 18 quintillion planets. What’s a quintillion? Well, a whole lot, that’s what. 18 times.
The trouble was, Hello Games talked the talked, but No Man’s Sky wasn’t ready to walk the walk when it arrived. The game had been hyped to the nth degree but was lacking in a lot of features that had been promised right out of the gate. To their credit, Hello Games have implemented a lot of these since, but the game never quite got over its bad launch press.
What did Sean Murray and the Hello Games team have to say for themselves? Well, according to Murray, the game had proven to be too popular for its own good.
“When we released No Man's Sky -- and, in fact, when we first started talking about it -- I thought we were making a pretty niche game, and I continued to think that for a long time,” he told gamesindustry.biz. “A lot of the design decisions we made were for a niche game. It turned out to be a really large niche."
9. Clang: It Was TOO Realistic
If there’s one type of video game that’s sure to be a riot of fun if done well, yet super difficult for developers to pull off, it’s a motion-controlled sword fighting title. It’s been attempted, and to some success, certainly (Ubisoft’s Wii FPS Red Steel and its sequel implemented sword-wielding sections that worked admirably well), but the controls have to be absolutely rock solid here.
In 2012, Neal Stephenson brought Clang to Kickstarter, a game that promised to present a more realistic yet fun take on video game sword fighting (which, Stephenson griped, often missed the mark and wasn’t representative of the real thing). Sadly, this commitment to realism proved to be the project’s downfall.
After raising more than $500,000, Clang’s creator announced that all the money was gone and more was needed. A year later, another announcement: Clang was cancelled. Why? Because they nailed the realism but forgot to throw in the ‘fun’ part. As Stephenson put it,
“The prototype was technically innovative, but it wasn’t very fun to play… I probably focused too much on historical accuracy and not enough on making it sufficiently fun to attract additional investment.”
As you can imagine, the whole situation was less than a PR picnic.
8. Pokémon GO: Real Pokemon Tracking Programs Ruined Its Broken One
As was the case with No Man’s Sky, Pokemon GO hasn’t ultimately ‘failed’ by any stretch of the imagination. After a long program of updates, GO is a far more involved game with many more features than it had at launch. Yes, a lot of these should have been implemented from the start (such as PvP battling and trading, crucial elements of any be-a-Pokemon-trainer adventure), but it’s better late than never.
Nevertheless, there’s no escaping the fact that GO was hit by a deluge of frustrated players at launch. Not only was the game an all you can eat glitch, crash and bug buffet, but the ability to track Pokemon (perhaps the most crucial element of all) was completely sub-par, and the Nearby function was revised many times over.
The unapologetic and less-than-communicative Niantic’s response was to remove the Nearby feature entirely for a time, while also preventing access to third-party tools, such as Pokevision, which provided players with maps that actually functioned. Their reasoning for doing so was that these third-party maps were “interfering with [our] ability to maintain quality of service.” There may be some validity to that, in terms of server strain (and there was unprecedented demand on said servers, at a time when the game was rolling out around the world), but that really wasn’t good enough.
7. Driveclub: This Socially-Connected Racer Wanted To Be Too Socially-Connected
When the PlayStation 4 and Xbox One were looming, Sony and Microsoft faced the usual dilemma: bringing consumers the familiar favorite gaming genres they love, with a dash of difference, a dash of next-generation gaming appeal. We needed an incentive to buy those expensive new consoles, after all.
As far as racing titles were concerned, the Sony-published Driveclub was PlayStation 4’s most hyped early offering. It was to be an experience all about the connectivity, offering a range of racing challenges for players to take on in ‘clubs’ of their own, earning reputation together and competing against other rival clubs from around the world.
Needless to say, robust online multiplayer was going to be key here, and that was where the team dropped the ball. The much-delayed title arrived with all manner of online issues, which (according to Sony CEO Shawn Layden back in 2014) resulted from the failure to adequately test the impact of heavy server load:
“You do a beta test, you scope against that. But now, in a connected world, you can't effectively test in your house or in your beta group what it means to have 50,000, 100,000, 200,000 users hit your service. And the guys [at the studio] are struggling with that. It's throwing up things they had not anticipated."
Again, there’s a degree of validity here, but considering the entire premise of the game and the hype it received, this really doesn’t cut the mustard. Still, that’s why Driveclub and the PlayStation Plus edition met the fate they did.
6. LawBreakers: It Was ‘Too Woke’
Now, you’d think that Cliff Bleszinski would know his way around a shooter. How to craft them, what makes them tick, all of the fundamentals. After all, he’s the man behind the critically acclaimed Gears of War series. Still, not everything Bleszinski touches turns to bullet-riddled gold, though, as we discovered with LawBreakers.
After leaving Epic Games, this team shooter was his first project. As with Hideo Kojima’s Death Stranding, this fact always puts an intense spotlight on a game, which leads to negative reactions in and of itself. Expectations are extra high in these cases, and it’s impossible to please everybody. In the case of LawBreakers, though, a lot of the negativity sprung from an unexpected source (according to Bleszinski): the game’s ‘wokeness.’
This title wasn’t exactly groundbreaking. It was a team-based shooter that pitted the Law against the Breakers, in modes based around the traditions of capture the flag, capturing points and so on. Ultimately, it was a victim of its time, launching during the early peak of Overwatch and Fortnite hype. As far as its creator was concerned, though, there was another factor.
“One big epiphany I had was that I pushed my own personal political beliefs in a world that was increasingly divided,” he wrote. “Instead of the story being ‘this game looks neat’ it became “this is the game with the ‘woke bro’ trying to push his hackey politics on us with gender neutral bathrooms.’ Instead of ‘who am I going to choose’ it became “white dude shoehorns diversity in his game and then smells his own smug farts in interviews’ instead of just letting the product … speak for itself.”
5. Tony Hawk: Ride: It Was The Controller’s Fault It Was Bad
The Tony Hawk’s titles are truly iconic. For many fans, they’re the very last word in sports titles, and it’s tough to dispute that. Whether you’re a dedicated fan of skateboarding or not, it’s just so darn fun to shred around the series’ large, open arenas and pull off absurd tricks that would probably send you off to the emergency room in forty different pieces if you attempted them in real life.
Having said that, not all the games were winners. 2009’s Tony Hawk: Ride was a bold attempt at taking the franchise in a new direction, and… well, it doesn’t often go well when you attempt to take successful franchises in new directions. Especially not when there’s a huge, ridiculous novelty skateboard controller involved.
As you’ve probably surmised, there was some impressive tech in the controller and it was a neat idea, but it just wasn’t responsive enough. Critics and players weren’t kind to the game, but the team stuck with the peripheral (revised somewhat) for the sequel, Tony Hawk: Shred.
Even so, Mike Griffith, Activision’s CEO, made it clear that it was the controller’s fault the game was bad. “Game ratings for Tony Hawk Ride weren't as high as we would have hoped last year,” he said in 2010. “In hindsight, it took longer to optimize the hardware leaving less time to develop the software.”
Generally, of course, it’s probably a better idea to ‘optimise’ both before actually releasing your game, but who has time for that nonsense?
4. Fury: The Players Were Losers And Everyone Wanted To Play World Of Warcraft Instead
As we’ve already noted, new IPs are a heck of a prospect these days. As much as developers and publishers want to bring us the Next Big Thing(tm), the industry is utterly dominated by already-existing Big Things (such as the aforementioned Fortnite and sequel-imminent Overwatch), which quite like it up there on their pedestals and aren’t about to be knocked off of them by anything other than a full-blown hurricane of gaming goodness.
Was Fury a full-blown hurricane of gaming goodness? Well, that’s probably a bit of a stretch. Auran’s MMORPG may have been, had it gone the distance, but we’ll never know now. The ambitious (and far too PvP focused) title was quickly reverted to free-to-play, before having its servers shut down just a year after release.
What went wrong? According to Auran’s CEO, Tony Hilliam, it was a mixture of players being losers “ultimately Fury didn't have 200 hours of safe haven PvE environments where players could become comfortable with their character. The result was they came and they got beaten up, without really knowing why, and blamed the game for this” and wanting to play World of Warcraft instead (which he called “the World of Warcraft factor.”
3. Duke Nukem Forever: The Reviews Weren’t Fair
Every gamer decides for themselves how much sway reviews hold over them. Some refuse to buy games that aren’t rated well by outlets they trust, while others take these opinions into consideration, but they aren’t the sole deciding factor. There’s no denying that previews and reviews can have a huge impact on a title’s early momentum, however.
One title notorious for being critically lambasted is 2011’s Duke Nukem Forever. Its visuals, performance and all-around dated and sloppy nature were the main issues, though developer Gearbox didn’t see it that way at all. Co-founder Brian Martel stated of the game’s review scores:
“There were things towards the high and things towards the low, but the middle just didn't get any traction. It's pretty obvious that people were using it in some ways to kind of use it as a soapbox or whatever." It was supposed to feel as shonky and dated as it did, he goes on: "It was what it was meant to be, which is a more old-school style game in what is today's technology". Were the reviews fair? "I think that if we were going to review the reviews fairly, no."
2. Superman 64: It’s Supposed To Look Like That, It’s The ‘Kryptonite Fog’
There are few titles in the history of gaming quite as notoriously awful as Superman 64. This was the game that turned a generation against licensed games for life; that had us flying the mighty Man of Steel throw a sad series of coloured rings like it was Baby’s First Flight Sim.
Of its many shortcomings, the visuals are an obvious problem. To an extent, we can excuse this: Nintendo 64’s 3D graphics look incredibly ropey today, after all. What we cannot excuse is the hilariously abysmal draw distance. Developer Titus Interactive did have an excuse for this, however. It’s baked right into the game’s lore itself, and it’s a doozy.
Why can’t one of the most powerful heroes in the history of comics see more than about five feet in front of himself? Why do buildings constantly pop into existence? That’s the draw distance for you, not-so-cunningly disguised by all this darn grey mist everywhere. That’s ‘Kryptonite Fog,’ we’re told, and it’s 100% supposed to be there. This is probably the funniest and feeblest way a developer has ever tried to hide their raging ineptitude.
1. Afro Samurai 2: The Revenge Of Kuma: Nobody Liked The Game, So They Had To Erase It From Existence
Over the course of this rundown, we’ve seen all kinds of elaborate and blame-deflecting excuses from developers and publishers. From Kryptonite Fog to wokeness, we’ve heard it all. As such, it’ll be refreshing to hear from a developer with the guts to simply hold up their hands and say: yep, we screwed up.
This was the case with Afro Samurai 2: The Revenge Of Kuma, which was unceremoniously taken down on the PlayStation Store and Steam in November of 2015. For no better reason than because the developers acknowledged no-one liked it.
Versus Evil’s General Manager, Steve Escalante, stated: “The game was a failure. We could not do, in good conscience, volume 2 and volume 3… if you look at the reviews, it wasn’t that the game was broken or buggy, people just didn’t like it.”
It’s a bit of a stretch to say that the game had no bugs, but to take the moral high ground, admit to this and start the long, complicated process of issues refunds to buyers is something to respect nonetheless.