10 Scandals That DESTROYED Fallout 76
What exactly made Fallout 76’s launch one of the worst in video game history?
Fallout 76 came out last year with one of the worst releases on record, destroyed by a perfect storm of scandals that may well have damaged the Fallout brand for future releases - and almost all of them were entirely self inflicted.
The game appears to have been made with the attitude of a free mobile title; wanting to gouge customers as much and as quickly as possible before they inevitably move on. With triple A expectations and a price tag to boot though, that attitude simply wasn’t going to fly.
From their treatment of customers, low quality collectibles, going back on their promises and general issues with the game itself, Bethesda has had an absolute nightmare with 76. Any one of these scandals would be enough to tar a game for many players, but all of them? It’s surprising they have any left.
Those who’ve remained must only play in dungeons with electrodes strapped to their private parts; you’d have to enjoy punishment to stick around this long. Fallout as a brand could survive, as lots of people saw this as a spin off cash grab from the off. Fallout 76 on its own though? That might not be as lucky...
10. Terrible Metacritic Scores
A terrible Metacritic rating on its own isn’t an awful scandal; it’s perfectly possible to love a game that others hate, and many cult classics came out with poor critical receptions. However, it’s definitely an indication that even before anything else went wrong for Fallout 76, the game was never that great to begin with.
It wasn’t a title that anyone really seemed to want. However, if it had hit it out of the park on arrival, it might have found a home in the overcrowded marketplace. Unfortunately, it was a dud right from the start.
With the rest of the stuff still to come on this list, there weren’t many players willing to take a risk on the game anyway; the fact most people found it terrible hardly helped matters.
There were even reports of some stores giving both physical and digital copies of Fallout 76 away with new consoles, just to try and shift some more units. The PR was a disaster, but it’s important not to forget that the base game was pretty bad in any case.
9. Buying Repair Kits
This is the most recent scandal to have hit the already severely-wounded game, and it’s the one which is most clearly and obviously a lie.
When Fallout 76 was first released, Bethesda promised that only cosmetic upgrades would be available for purchase with real money. This is a rather common technique used by publishers to try and avoid any potential blowback from the game being pay to win, as well as shifting the blame for the predatory business practices onto the consumer.
After all, it doesn’t matter that a fancy new digital hat costs real money; you don’t have to buy it. You know, just like alcoholics don’t need to buy booze or drug addicts don’t need to buy heroin. Cosmetic purchases can be fun if they’re cheap and used sparingly, but honestly, all that is besides the point.
To shield themselves from criticism, Bethesda promised they’d only ever sell cosmetic items. However, they’ve since gone back on their word by selling repair kits. It was one of the few promises they’d kept, and even that’s now up in flames.
8. No NPCs
This one’s just bizarre, and it’s something that Bethesda tried to keep hidden for much all of the marketing for no real gain. It was like showing up to a birthday party with an empty box, knowing you were going to look stupid when the box was opened, but for some reason you still tried as hard as possible to delay the inevitable.
Fallout 76 has no NPCs, which would be a bizarrely hollow decision in most games, but for a triple A RPG? It’s practically unthinkable. Townspeople and the like are supposed to breathe life into games like this. How else are you supposed immerse yourself in a world if you’re the only one in it?
You can interact with other players and with Bethesda’s own bots, but it’s quite clearly not the same thing. This was a decision nobody was ever going to support; it was a lazy call to save more cash for a game that needed a lot more investment to survive.
It's an in-game failing, but it still generated a fair few headlines that soured perspective buyers even before launch.
7. Empty Content Full Of Bugs
As well as the lack of NPCs, the in-game content overall felt very hollow. Fetch quest after fetch quest after fetch quest; Fallout 76 makes Anthem looks like it’s bursting at the seams with content.
Then there’s the bugs. Normally with a Bethesda release, they’re taken in good spirits; rarely are they anything more than some wonky animation, and it’s a small price to pay for what is usually a fantastic game.
With Fallout 76 though, the patience has ran out and it’s simply getting tiresome. The small glitches are something most gamers can just crack on with if there’s a huge game to explore, but yet again Fallout 76 just doesn’t deliver.
One of the worst bugs comes in the East section of the map - The Mire - which can cause the game to crash, not reopening until the player restarts. There’s also reports of characters appearing naked or partially invisible, as well as Power Armour which can cause the game to freeze entirely. That’s without getting into loading delays, inaccessible quests, textures failing to load and a host of other issues. It’s just far too many for a game this sub-par to begin with.
6. Data Breach
1298806This is the first of the more serious scandals that have rocked Fallout 76, even though it didn’t generate the headlines the way that some other ones did.
Perhaps it’s because the data breach came as an add on to a scandal which had already generated so much press; this was a barnacle stuck to the bottom of an already diseased fish. The diseased fish in question will be discussed in more depth later on, so for now we’ll focus on the barnacle part.
To deal with the, ahem, fallout of a PR disaster, Bethesda opened a support ticket system. However, the personal information of others in this queue was exposed, and a bad turn of events became so much worse for Bethesda and their customers.
There wasn’t even any hacking or malicious software involved here, it was simply a failure at Bethesda’s end. Some customers, upon logging a ticket, were able to see the names, emails and partial credit card information of other customers who’d previously done the same. Bethesda's handling was just awful all around here.
5. Nuka Cola Dark Rum
That data breach scandal came off the back of Bethesda misleading die hard fans who’d gone the extra mile to support the company by purchasing extra merchandise. That meant that letting these fans down was particularly harmful to Fallout 76’s public reception, and it’s a trick they decided, inexplicably, to repeat.
Targeting the adult gamers that make up a sizeable chunk of Fallout’s typical fanbase, they released a Nuka Cola Dark Rum collectible. The rum was advertised as coming in a rocket shaped bottle, giving it a rather cool and unique look.
However, in a rather fitting metaphor for Fallout 76 itself, the rocket shape was just a cheap plastic shell around an entirely normal bottle. Considering the drink was $80, people were expecting a lot more from Bethesda than what they got.
Production was delayed several times, leading some to speculate that perhaps at one point the bottles were supposed to be as advertised, but the shorter timescale forced a compromise.
To add insult to injury, the plastic wrap was slightly wrongly sized, so pouring resulted in spillages. For the cost, the quality was sorely lacking in almost every department.
4. Predatory & Expensive Customisable Options
This was briefly touched on in the Repair Kits entry, but it’s worthy of its own entry for how much of a sour taste it left for players.
It’s to be expected, unfortunately, that a game like this comes with microtransactions these days. While you can debate the legitimacy of having no pay-to-win items and only selling cosmetics, the fact still remains that you’re buying a base game for full price only to immediately have content locked behind a paywall.
Gamers have made their peace with DLC, especially if it’s the quality of Horizon’s The Frozen Wilds, Witcher’s Blood & Wine or Mass Effect’s Citadel package. However, Fallout 76’s paid content was nothing of the sort, and after investing in a game that sold way below expectations and kept haemorrhaging customers, those who stuck around were probably expecting a little leeway.
You can earn currency by completing daily or weekly challenges, but to purchase enough ‘atoms’ with real money, it would cost around $240 to get everything in the game. The 500 atoms you got at preorder (equivalent to $5) wasn’t even enough to allow you to paint your PIP-Boy a different colour.
3. The Outer Worlds Twisting The Knife
You can’t really blame Obsidian for this one too much, it was just a combination of Fallout 76’s self-inflicted terrible launch and unlucky timing. Still, it didn’t help Bethesda’s press to have The Outer Worlds so publicly twist the knife.
Last year’s Game Awards saw a heap of trailers drop, and despite the press garnered by Crash Team Racing, Dragon Age and Christopher Judge’s snazzy suit, The Outer Worlds grabbed the lion’s share of the hype. A new, space-based RPG by Obsidian, the intriguing locales and slightly Rick Sanchez looking character model got everybody talking.
However, as is Obsidian’s right, they mentioned their past successes with various full-screen captions. The most controversial bragged about being ‘the original creators of Fallout’; the trailer was likely designed before Fallout 76 even dropped, but by the time it came out it seemed like maliciously kicking a game while it was down, and many fans online fully supported this mindset.
Ironically, Obsidian probably made the claim hoping to cash in on Fallout 76’s great sales. Whether or not the decision was made to keep it in there despite the increased negativity it would generate towards Bethesda, only Obsidian knows.
2. The Canvas Bag Downgrade
This is the scandal that undoubtedly generated the most ill will towards Bethesda; it’s so slimy it needs two entries in the list. Three, technically, as this was the diseased fish scandal that led to the data breach of those activating support tickets.
The canvas bag affair is another travesty which only hit the most dedicated fans, and combined with the rest could have soured the Fallout brand (and by extension, Bethesda’s PR) for a long time to come.
Pre-ordering the Power Armour Edition of the game netted you a lot of extra goodies, as these pre-order bundles often do. There were a few nice things in there, but the only one anybody was talking about was the canvas bag.
Without informing customers, changing the images online or offering refunds, Bethesda shipped the bundle with a much cheaper, thinner and less durable nylon bag instead. The canvas bag was actually useable in real life, so was worth the purchase for many people. The nylon alternative was too lightweight and flimsy.
After shelling out $200 for the bundle, customers obviously weren’t satisfied, and Bethesda’s solution only made things worse...
1. Not Enough Compensation For An In Game Canvas Bag
To make up for the lack of a canvas bag, Bethesda offered some in-game currency to soften the blow. The fact the game was hollow, glitchy and the storefront unnecessarily expensive has already been covered, but it wasn’t just those factors which made Bethesda’s compensation so ridiculous.
They offered 500 Atoms to spend in the game, something which barely counts as compensation anyway, as it requires you give that money back to them. Equivalent to $5, it hardly covers the cost of a canvas bag in real life either.
However, the worst part of this was that there was a canvas bag in the game... for 700 atoms. Their measly payout wasn’t even enough for a digital one.
Added to this, specially selected ‘influencers’ or ‘unboxers’ were sent the as-advertised canvas bag in the first place, with Bethesda claiming limited numbers forced their hand. Again, this felt like putting profit before consumers in such a money grubbing way that they may well have lost some customers for a long time.
Eventually, Bethesda did promise that everyone who preordered the expensive Power Armour Edition would get the original canvas bag, but even that had the caveat of a four to six months waiting period.