10 Scary Video Game Urban Legends Everyone Believed Were True

Terrifying tales about virtual realities having real world consequences.

MAJORA S MASK Fate
Nintendo

Urban legends and video games have gone hand in hand for a long time. The creepy shadow people of Mario Galaxy; Bigfoot prowling the state of San Andreas; The death-worshipping cult of children that inhabit Azeroth... there are many stories of inexplicable in-game events creeping out players.

While unsettling in their own way, these are not the type of stories this list will be focusing on.

In this piece, we'll be discussing popular urban legends about video games that escaped their digital confines to spread terror in the real world. While the march of history has led to many of these stories being (thankfully) refuted, each tale here has managed to spread its macabre legend far and wide through newsprint, the internet and simple word of mouth.

From heart-attack inducing arcade machines to dead developers sending a letter to their publisher, and even that time Nintendo published a game that predicted the deaths of its players, let's gather round the campfire and whisper about when video games supposedly slipped through the cracks of the virtual world and began affecting ours instead.

10. Homicidal Arcade Machine Berzerk

Berzerk video game
Stern Electronics

"Homicidal Arcade Machine Berzerk" may sound like a cheesy anime series, but it's actually an early example of video games reaching the newspapers for all the wrong reasons. '80s arcade game Berzerk was blamed for not one, not two, but three deaths, all of which supposedly occurred at the same arcade centre.

As reported by Retrovolve, two gamers (Peter Burkowski and Jeff Dailey) were reported to have had fatal heart attacks shortly after playing Berzerk at Friar Tuck's Game Room in Illinois. While Jeff Dailey's death was never confirmed, the unfortunate Peter Burkowski definitely did die after playing the game. Burkowski was found to have a weakened heart in his autopsy, and the excitement induced by the game became seen as a possible cause of death.

Berzerk's legacy didn't end there, however. Years later, a fatal stabbing during a brawl occurred just outside the doors of Friar Tuck's. The rumoured cause of the fight? A quarter that had been placed inside the Berzerk machine.

While the truths behind the deaths may owe more to coincidence and hearsay than fact, Berzerk's connection to the trio of fatalities at that ill-fated arcade centre have ensured its place in videogame folklore forever.


9. The Haunted Majora's Mask Cartridge

Hard to believe this one turns 10 this year...

On 7 September 2010, Creepypasta user Jadusable published Ben Drowned, the disturbing tale of a boy whose spirit haunted a copy of N64 classic Majora's Mask.

Backing up his story with footage from the game itself, Jadusable span a tale of warped graphics, nightmarish music and a creepy Link statue that hounded the player relentlessly. Eventually, the spirit began conversing with the player himself outside the game, apparently driving him to near madness.

As Kotaku reported back in 2017, the story was a work of fiction but the effort put into embellishing the tale made it one of the biggest stories in gaming at the time. Like the best urban legends, it may not have been true but it was so well told it made Mulders of us all.


8. Twisted Metal, Twisted Note

Twisted Metal Head On: Extra Twisted Edition was a PS2 port of the PSP entry in Sony's Twisted Metal franchise. As an added incentive for returning players, the developers added a mode called Twisted Metal: Lost. Lost consisted of four levels from the cancelled Twisted Metal: Harbour City, and was a nice bonus for fans of the series to see what could have been.

Oh, the reason Harbour City was cancelled? Six of its developers supposedly died in a plane crash. That didn't stop them from wanting recognition for their work, however...

As the above video shows, the LOST levels were apparently the result of a posthumous note sent by the deceased devs. Imploring the remaining members of the development team to "show them our last earthly deeds", the note was signed by the six developers who had died in the plane crash.

Although the note itself is widely considered a hoax, it has spawned the mystery of whether or not the developers ever existed. With even the chief developer behind the series offering conflicting reports around the situation, there will always be an air of mystery surrounding Twisted Metal: Lost.


7. Saddam Hussein Used PS2s To Build WMDs

Saddam Hussein Ps2
Wikipedia/AFP-GettyImages/Sony

Taking a break from supernatural horror, this urban legend was based more on the more mundane (but no less frightening) fear of modern technology being bent towards sinister purposes.

There's something inherently unsettling about something designed for entertainment being used with homicidal intentions (it's why Chucky remains a popular character despite having starred in far more bad films than good). That sense of disquiet was present in spades when it was reported that Saddam Hussein had imported 4000 PlayStation 2s to assist the mass manufacturing of WMDs

As stated by legendsrevealed.com, WorldNetDaily reported that the former Iraqi dictator purchased the PS2s with the intent of using their CPUs to assist in the guidance of the missiles that he was definitely, absolutely manufacturing (cough, cough). As legendsrevealed goes on to state, while the initial report was alarming it wasn't exactly grounded in either science or basic knowledge of international trade law. That, plus the eventual absence of any WMDs in Iraq, would eventually put the kibosh on this particular urban legend.


6. The Vanishing Game

Going back to more traditional fare for our next myth, we come across the mystery that is Killswitch.

Killswitch was, allegedly, a limited release game made even more limited by the developer's curious decision to have the game wipe its own code upon completion. That, plus some other curious design choices (making one of the player characters invisible, thus impossible to control) and the game's supernatural themes made it a natural candidate for urban legend status.

That legend only deepened when a copy of the game was allegedly sold on eBay for $733,000 to a man named Yamamoto Ryuichi. Despite promising to livestream the entire game, the only clip that surfaced showed Yamamoto crying in despair for nearly two minutes. That video has since gone missing, and the above clip is from someone claiming to have the only existing copy of Yamamoto's stream. To recap: A game that deleted its own existence purportedly managed to erase the only livestream of it being played.

Given the lack of tangible evidence around it, Killswitch exists more as an exercise in faith than a video game. And as most of human history shows, just because you can't prove something exists doesn't mean people won't believe in it.


5. Fallout 3 - Harbinger Of Regicide

Fallout 3 Tranquility Lane
Bethesda

Tick tock, tick tock, Queen Bess hasn't got long left on the clock...

At least, that was what people believed when Fallout 3's GNR radio station began predicting the future. As GamesRadar reported at the time, in 2010 mysterious morse code transmissions were discovered to be emanating from the aforementioned station. While many of these were simply codes dictating where to find in-game loot, others were a tad more unusual.

Two of the codes in the game were discovered to be accurate predictions for the date of Gary Coleman's death, and the day of the BP oil spill. As such, people were understandably perturbed when another message read “The Queen has died today. The world mourns, as on days like these we are all Brits. 4:02 March 19, 2014". Despite Bethesda's protestations that Fallout was not designed to estimate the final days of esteemed monarchs, gamers still breathed a sigh of relief when Queen Elizabeth proved Fallout 3's predictions wrong and survived her date with destiny.

Although this spelt the end for the legend of GNR station, it still acts as a reminder of how eager people are to believe in games that can supposedly see through the cracks in the fourth wall and take a peek into our world.


4. Pokémon-Induced Suicide

Listen to the music in the above video and you'll likely agree it's pretty unpleasant. Harsh, jarring and high-pitched, it seems designed to put the player on edge. Which, given Lavender Town's status as a literal ghost town, was likely the effect Nintendo were going for. However, stories began circulating round the internet that Nintendo were a little too successful in their attempts at discomfiting the player...

Lavender Town Syndrome was the name given to a story that Lavender Town's music seriously affected the mental stability of children in Japan, to the point that it was attributed as the reason behind over two hundred juvenile suicides.

Although there has never been any real evidence to back up the story, it's easy to see why the myth remains popular. As reported in Kotaku, people will always find an illicit thrill in the subversion of childhood symbols (remember Bowsette?), and the idea that sweet, family friendly Pokémon led children to their doom is one too ghoulish to pass up on.


3. Taboo: The Sixth Sense

Taboo Nes
Rare

Although arguably the least well known myth on this list, this one was too bizarre to leave out.

In 1989 Nintendo published a game called Taboo: The Sixth Sense and it's safe to say it was a departure from the company's usual product. It is, according to Wikipedia, the only NES game to be given two separate warning labels - that it was suitable only for people aged 14 and above, and that it was to be used for entertainment only.

Presumably this was to drum up interest in what was a dud game. The entire experience was essentially a ten minute tarot reading, repeated for as long as the player's interest held. Given that the game sold terribly, it's safe to say that the interest was never really there to begin with.

However, the tale of Taboo would not end there. A relatively recent urban legend sprang up positing that Taboo had accurately predicted the deaths of several children who had played it. Although this legend hasn't quite gained the tractiton of the others on this list, it serves as a reminder that no matter how obscure a game is, there will always be the potential for it to become part of video game mythology, even if it is as a footnote.


2. The Madden Curse

Garrison Hearst Madden
EA

From the most obscure entrant on the list to arguably the most famous, it's easy to see why the Madden curse managed to transcend games journalism and enter popular culture.

Digital trends wrote a superb retrospective on the subject, and even a quick glance through it shows why so many people became believers in the curse. Freak injuries, loss of form, inexplicably poor performances in key games - from 1999-2012 the history of Madden cover stars reads like the black book of a scorned, promiscuous witch. Fortunately the curse seems to have eased up in recent years, with only a few players since 2013 suffering poor luck after starring on the box, but that doesn't change the fact that for 13 years a player appearing on the cover of a Madden game was essentially ringing the death knell for their career.

As a final note, a streak of of bad luck lasting 13 years that ended in the 2013 season? Given the importance of the number thirteen in witchcraft, maybe there is something to the curse...


1. Polybius - Gaming's Most Popular Urban Legend

polybius game
Sinneslöschen

The only urban legend on this list with its own Wikipedia page and documentary, it's safe to say that the tale of Polybius has taken in more than a few video game fans over the years.

As the story goes, in 1981 a video game called Polybius caused something of a disturbance in the town of Portland, Oregon. Players allegedly suffered from insomnia, hallucinations and amnesia and literal Men in Black came to collect information from the machine, leading to the theory that Polybius was part of a government experiment on mind control.

Like the earlier story about Berzerk, the myth has gained popularity due to its conflation of fact and fiction. As revealed by Eurogamer in 2015, the government did experiment with mind control with the MK Ultra experiments, FBI agents did raid arcades in America and games have always been capable of causing unpleasant side effects such as epileptic fits or nausea. Polybius was a lightning rod for conspiracy theorists and, given the unprecedented amount of coverage it has received, its status as gaming's most popular urban legend is assured.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Hello! My name's Iain Tayor. I write about video games, wrestling and comic books, and I apparently can't figure out how to set my profile picture correctly.