10 Smartest Horror Video Game Decisions
Put Down Those Weird Collectables.
Most of us have seen the old horror film clichés at this point, witnessing the protagonist or their friends making dumb decisions that you as the viewer know will be a mistake.
This can range from splitting up the party to investigating those strange noises and this is true of games as well. Games often do this too, often setting players down a linear path, but thanks to the interactive nature of gaming, this isn’t always the case.
Many games put the power to decide its story outcome in your hands, achieved through use of the butterfly effect and branching narratives, rewarding logical decision making and multiple endings to back these up.
Some modern games have also seen fit to break the fourth wall, bringing new horror experiences that instead target the player directly and with this comes an outside-the-box approach to decision making.
It can prove a double-edged sword though, also providing the option to make some dumb decisions to which people should honestly know better by now. Wanna explore that spooky basement? Sure, what could possibly go wrong there, player.
Smart choices don’t always equal the easy one but can often benefit players in the long-run. So for those wanting to make their lives that little bit easier, here’s a few worth taking into consideration.
10. Alien Isolation – Keep Moving, Don’t Stay Hidden
Alien has seen a mixed run of adaptations in its time. From more successful ventures like the Alien Vs Predator titles to the universally reviled Aliens: Colonial Marines, Alien Isolation was a breath of fresh air. Releasing in 2015, it took place 15 years after the original film and starred Amanda Ripley, daughter of Ellen.
Investigating her mother’s disappearance, she finds her way to space station Sevastopol looking for clues but discovers a lone Xenomorph is also aboard. Moving away from Colonial Marines’ action focus, it placed a much heavier emphasis on stealth mechanics to advance as the Xenomorph cannot be defeated in combat.
You’ll have to plot a course around it through stealth but this creature is clever, being able to hunt you through sight, investigate disturbances and even hear players directly if you plugged in a PS Camera or Kinect.
There’s plenty of hiding options within Sevastopol such as vents, lockers and underneath tables but one thing players should never do is remain in one place too long. Doing this guarantees the Xenomorph finds you, regardless of where you are.
If you want to survive against this intelligent creature, you simply have to keep moving.
9. Telltale’s The Walking Dead Season 2: Surrendering To Carver At The Lodge
Season 1 of Telltale’s The Walking Dead revitalised adventure games. Focused on Lee Everitt and Clementine, it broke new ground in its handling of player choices, ones that ultimately affected the narrative but some made little difference in the long run.
Season 2 began releasing the following year, making Clementine the playable protagonist and saw her join a new group of survivors. During Episode 2 “A House Divided”, they make their way to Moonstar Lodge, being accepted within upon her reunion with Kenny, one of season 1’s main characters.
Whilst residing at the lodge, they discovering the wind turbine is spinning out of control and realise it’s been tampered with. Discovering it’s the work of William Carver, leader of his own group within a fortified mall, it becomes clear he’s after Rebecca, a pregnant lodge survivor carrying his child.
Creating a distraction to secure entry, Carver then takes the lodge group hostage and executes one of them, Walter, after Kenny shoots one of Carver’s men. You’re given a choice in this moment, surrender or tell Carver to stop.
It can be tempting to let characters run with their emotions, but this isn’t always a sensible approach. In this case, surrendering ensures the survival of Alvin, Rebecca’s partner.
Should you try and stop Carver though, Kenny’s next shot misses and hits him in the shoulder, leading Carver to execute Alvin. It’s a false choice that sees you lose either way, but it’s one which shows the necessity of reason, helping to spare another innocent survivor, if only for a time.
8. Resident Evil – Taking The Broken Shotgun
Resident Evil established itself as king of survival horror when it launched in 1996. Receiving critical acclaim, you played as either Chris Redfield or Jill Valentine. One particular sticking point to players was the Ceiling Trap within Spencer Mansion.
Finding a working shotgun off the wall, you proceed to take it and how this plays out depends on character choice. If you’ve chosen Chris, locating the broken shotgun on the west side of Spencer Mansion is required to avoid the trap, making a swap. If you’ve not got this, you must put it back or get crushed to death.
With Jill, there’s two ways this plays out. Exploring the mansion with fellow S.T.A.R.S operative Barry Burton, you’ll split up during these investigations and if you find him again before this room, the conditions to stop the trap are identical to Chris’.
Fail to meet up with him though and he comes to Jill’s rescue, a scene which gave birth to the infamous line “You were almost a Jill sandwich”. It shows that even broken objects have their use and sometimes holding onto them is a wise call.
7. Vampire The Masquerade: Bloodlines – Keeping The Sarcophagus Closed
It might not be a horror title in the same vein as other entries but Bloodlines’ focus on the supernatural earns it a spot. Releasing in 2004 by Troika Games, Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines became a cult classic, based off the tabletop RPG game from 1991 and a sequel is scheduled for release this year.
It enters a world of Vampire politics divided by three specific groups. The Camarilla, acting as government for any place they control, Anarchs looking to break free of their control and the Sabbat, which believe vampires should openly rule over humans.
Waking up as a fledgling after being sired by one of 7 playable bloodlines, your sire is staked and you're both taken to trial for breaking the Masquerade. This is led by Sebastain LeCroix, the Ventrue clan’s prince of Los Angeles and main antagonist.
Being spared by the intervention of Anarch clan’s Nines Rodriguez, you end up in the employment of LaCroix, who decides to send you on an investigation about an Ankaran sarcophagus, one that’s believed to be housing an ancient vampire.
Depending on who you allied with, the ending varies - and few are in your favour - but one thing you absolutely shouldn’t do is open the sarcophagus.
Whether you sided with LaCroix or opened it of your own will, it contains a bomb and a farewell note from one of the Anarchs, Smiling Jack, detonating soon after opening and taking you out with it. Undeniably, this was one mystery best left unanswered.
6. Until Dawn – Avoiding The Trap Door
Until Dawn is a game designed with replayability in mind, utilising a butterfly effect system that changes the story outcome, not revealing all details within one sitting. As a result, there are many scenarios in which cast members can die - and one such instance occurs in Chapter 9 with Ashley.
Seeing Ashley gets separated from the group after descending into an underground passageway, she then hears a voice coming from a side tunnel, presenting a new choice to either investigate this or ignore it and rejoin the others.
If you choose investigate, you’ll discover a trap door and banging can be heard from this. At this point, you can either open it or head back but there’s no good result that comes from opening it, as a Wendigo emerges and decapitates Ashley.
Unsurprisingly, following the mysterious voice is a poor decision, and whilst the party is forced to split up in this instance, prioritising your friends meant Ashley lives to see another day.
5. Vampyr – Choose Who You Feed On Carefully
Dontnod Entertainment established themselves with Life Is Strange, so Vampyr was a surprising next step upon its reveal. Set during the Spanish Flu pandemic, it focused on Dr Jonathan Reid, a London-based doctor turned Vampire that struggles between his duty of care and newfound bloodthirsty nature.
How you decide to balance these urges is down to the player, allowing the story to develop in different ways, but Vampyr does its best to entice you into feeding on civilians, offering EXP boosts depending on who you killed.
If you decide to feed upon an NPC, you need to approach this carefully. The wrong person can lock you out of story segments permanently, alongside affecting the district’s health rating.
One example is Dorothy Crane and with her, you’ll be given a choice to spare. It's tempting to just take an EXP boost but on the flipside, she can also cure the sick and her absence sees more people falling ill, dropping her district’s health rating.
That’s not to say you shouldn’t kill anyone at all, if you’re not on a pacifist run that is, but it pays off to consider your target.
4. Prey – Avoid The Alien Ugrade Implants
Prey had a troubled development history before its eventual release in 2017. Initially planned as a sequel to the 2006 Prey game, it saw a reboot under Arkane Studios and Bethesda that received critical acclaim.
Set in 2035, you play as Morgan Yu, a researcher aboard space station Talos I which is designed to research the Typhon, an alien species discovered decades previously. Waking up several years after a Typhon attack leaves you knocked out, you discover they’ve taken over Talos I and how you handle this threat is up to you.
During the course of the game, you’ll unlock new abilities through different skill trees such as boosting your engineering or physician capabilities. Later on, you gain the ability to directly research Typhons and unlock new neuromod abilities, which can bestow their abilities onto you.
But of course, there’s a catch to this. Whilst Psychoshock and Mindjack are certainly useful abilities, upgrading yourself with more than two Typhon neuromods mean Turrets start detecting you as an alien and begin attacking.
Furthermore, upgrades also cause Nightmares to spawn and outside the Apex Typhon, these are some of the toughest creatures you’ll encounter. Choosing these alien neuromods will also impact the ending’s dialogue by affecting the crew’s opinion of you. So choose your upgrades wisely, every decision counts here.
3. Amnesia: The Dark Descent – The Ending
Following from their work on the Penumbra Series, Frictional Games moved onto Amnesia: The Dark Descent. Releasing back in 2010, it received praise for its sanity system, atmospheric elements, and use of audio elements to build tension.
It focused on Daniel, who awakens within the Prussian Brennenburg Castle with little memory of who he is, outside of his name. Discovering a letter from himself, it confirms he deliberately wiped his memory to forget his past and explains that you need to kill Alexander, Brennenburg’s Baron.
It also warns him of a mysterious Shadow, one you cannot fight against and urges Daniel to escape it. Heading to the Castle’s inner sanctum, you’ll eventually find Alexander in front of an Orb, surrounded by pillars providing it energy as he attempts a ritual.
Daniel is left with three options on how to stop Alexander at this stage. He can stop the ritual but curious players can also let it happen, a completely illogical decision which not only witnesses Alexander win but leaves Daniel to face the Shadow.
The more intelligent decision comes from knocking over the pillars and should players choose this, the ritual soon fails and Alexander disintegrates. At this point, it’s then assumed that the Shadow’s influence is gone and Daniel can leave Brennenburg castle with a clear conscience.
2. Doki Doki Literature Club – Watching All The Optional Scenes
Doki Doki Literature Club became highly popular amongst streamers when it launched in 2017. Disguised as a dating simulator, it’s set within a high school literature club where the protagonist is invited to join by childhood friend Sayori.
Beginning to write poems for her and fellow clubmates Natsuki and Yuri, it begins like any visual novel. Until you discover Sayori has hung herself. Doki then abruptly ends and upon being restarted, Sayori is conspicuously missing and no one remembers her, soon followed by even further deaths.
Now invited to join by Club President Monika, it becomes clear she’s not only manipulating the game but is self-aware that she’s a video game character, breaking the fourth wall and confesses her love for you, the player.
To stop her, you’ll have to delete Monika’s directory file within the system files but that alone isn’t enough for the best ending as Monika re-emerges, deleting Sayori again and corrupts the credits. Deleting Monika’s file before starting also doesn’t work, leading to a quick ending where Sayori still dies.
It may come naturally for completionists but the best ending requires you view each girl’s optional scenes in one playthrough, achieved by saving and reloading before witnessing Sayori’s suicide.
Doing this ensures Monika won’t reappear, Sayori thanks you for trying to make everyone happy and ends with a thank you letter from developer Dan Salvato. It’s the best ending you can hope for in this otherwise bleak Horror game.
1. Blair Witch (2019) – Avoid The Carved Figurines
The Blair Witch franchise has gained a new lease of life recently, seeing a surprise 3rd entry back in 2016 after production was kept secret. Produced by Lionsgate, they’ve begun branching into games developing and alongside John Wick, Blair Witch also gained a new adaptation last year from Bloober Team.
Taking place two years after Blair Witch Project, it followed former police officer Ellis Lynch and his canine companion Bullet, searching across Black Hills Forest for a missing boy, Peter Shannon.
As you progress, you’ll notice carved figurines scattered across Black Hills. They seem out of place but, being one of gaming’s oldest conventions, many would naturally grab these collectables without second thought.
But considering this takes place after Mike, Heather and Josh’s disappearance, Ellis would be smart to take caution throughout his search. How you handle this investigation determines his fate, factoring in how you approach enemies and destructible totems too.
Picking these up figurines leads to a bad ending, seeing Ellis survives but becomes imprisoned within the Witch’s cycle. If Ellis remains cautious by leaving them, he breaks free of her curse but tragically dies in the process.
It’s a case of "You either die a hero, or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain” but at the least, this ending stops you becoming her pawn.