10 Spectacularly Wrong Video Game Reviews

10. IGN - Uncharted II

Mike Thomsen praises Naughty Dog's work on graphics and animations, but focuses the majority of his criticism on the game's limited freedom. What Thomsen fails to understand is that because of the game's fast-paced action, there is only so much freedom a player can have. He makes it seem that he wants more options of gameplay such as controlling a team (a la Rainbow Six) or interacting with unimportant objects (a la LA Noire). The fact of the matter is, the Uncharted series is and always will be a story-driven game. Yes, Naughty Dog wants you to be a part of the action, but more importantly they want to engage you in the story. They don't want to take away from that story with meticulous additions. You run, jump, shoot, and solve puzzles. That's essentially the premise of the game. Thomsen ignores the fact that cutscenes exist for a reason - to illustrate actions that the player themselves are unable to perform in order to progress the story. He puts fault on Naughty Dog for this - as if they are the only developers to do such a thing - and claims there is no flow. He also goes so far to criticise the entire character of Nathan Drake, seeming to be completely ignorant to the fact that Drake is supposed to be the stereotypical adventurer/hero. He uses cliche lines, predictable behaviours, and expected techniques because that's what he's supposed to do. Overall, Mike Thomsen completely misses the mark in his review of the overall gameplay in Uncharted 2. You can read the review here.

9. Commonsense Media - The Godfather: The Game

I have to give credit to Commonsense Media for existing in the first place. They tell parents about the content of games and whether they're appropriate for children, etc. It's an excellent idea, especially since stupid parents bother me. That being said, I do need to call out Commonsense Media on their overall review of The Godfather: The Game. While they briefly discuss the good - the legitimacy of characters, the use of actual dialogue, etc. - they miss the point of the game. They criticise EA for not including the character enough directly in the actual unraveling of the story - instead, they play a role in the backstory and behind-the-scenes. For EA to have stuck so true to The Godfather in the first place is a success. Had they thrown an ambiguous character (your character is never named) into the heart of The Godfather, true fans would have felt insulted. The main scenes in The Godfather that could have been playable either already had an unknown attendee that was filled with the protagonist (Luca's death; Paulie's death), or required a main character like Michael or Sonny (Michael kills Solazzo and McClusky; Sonny beats up Carlo). To keep the story true and committed, EA had to mix up the action a bit and put the protagonist in missions that didn't directly help the story unfold. Instead, the protagonist plays an equally important role in helping to lead up to those crucial scenes. Commonsense Media seemed to miss that whole idea in their review of The Godfather: The Game.

8. CVG - Battlefield: Bad Company 2

I don't think I've ever disagreed with a review as much as I did when I read Computer and Video Games' review of Battlefield: Bad Company 2. Author Rob Taylor disses the campaign mode of Bad Company 2 the entire time, making good things bad. While he credits DICE's success in the destruction department (and praises the multiplayer, obviously), he criticises nearly everything else. Taylor accuses DICE or ripping off several different games and movies, seemingly being a clear Call of Duty fanboy. This comparison of Bad Company 2 to Modern Warfare crap is unfair and unnecessary, as Taylor proves in his review. They are two completely different games with very different followings. Bad Company 2 - contrary to what Rob Taylor might say - has an excellent storyline, excellent characters, and excellent gameplay. It is solid, consistent, and exciting. Regardless, Taylor has had his say. Unfortunately, he must have had a blow to the head when playing the campaign. His review is biased and ignorant.

7. Gamespot - Resident Evil 6

There have debatably been few video game series as successful as Resident Evil. With 23 installments (all of which have received critical acclaim), 5 film adaptations, 2 CGI movies, 7 novels, and several other creations, Resident Evil not only has an enormous fan-base but has received so much success that it trumps nearly every other series. However Gamespot editor Kevin VanOrd seems to have had a bad day when he was reviewing the most recent installment, Resident Evil 6. VanOrd criticises the gameplay, accusing the developers or ripping control away from the player at inopportune times in order to show off exterior situations. In addition, VanOrd rips apart the whole 'quick-time events' by claiming they require 'super human' skills. Here's the thing, VanOrd... Resident Evil does this on purpose. They want there to be a challenge for the player. They want them to be engaged and to feel like they're actually in as much of a struggle as the character they're controlling. It's called 'involvement.' Look at Metal Gear Solid when the character is being tortured by Ocelot. I'm sure a lot of players with no super human capabilities got through that scene. Or Heavy Rain, that requires almost nothing but button-mashing and painstaking controller combinations. What perhaps strikes me most about VanOrd's review is that he gave RE6 a score of 4.5 out of 10. That is by all means a failing grade, yet the game has received so much hype and success that VanOrd can't even be given credit for what might be true. Whether Konami did have too many quick-time events or not, the game is a success. The voice acting is good, the storyline is good, and the overall gameplay is exciting. It's another Resident Evil game. All of that being said, VanOrd can perhaps play the game again on a lower difficulty and get his panties out of a bunch. You can read VanOrd's review here.

6. GameFAQs Reader Reviews - Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas

How does anybody in their right mind give Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas a 4 out of 10? Rockstar essentially broke every rule of the video game industry by creating one of the most groundbreaking, earth-shattering, mind-boggling (and of course controversial) video games of its era. However, it seems that GameFAQs contributor D'Hoost does not share this same mentality. Rather, they seem irritated with it. True GTA fans have appreciated the series since its inception as the simply designed top-down game. Back then, the controversy was in the car jackings, the shootings, and the fact that the player could make their character burp and fart with the press of a button. San Andreas broke every boundary, though. It created the largest GTA universe to date (until GTA 5 is released) full of customisation, diversity, and genuineness. The game truly captured the vibe of California with its parody cities and towns. And on top of that, the story was fresh and complete with memorable characters - CJ, Officer Tenpenny, OG Loc, Sweet - that will have their own spots reserved in GTA history. D'Hoost bashes all of this, though. He claims that the story is crap, the dialogue is worse, and that the game essentially 'just doesn't cut it.' An interesting opinion in relation to the millions of gamers that basked in the glory of GTA's amazing contents. The story is original and suited to the setting. The characters fit the story perfectly and compliment the setting. The dialogue, like everything else, just works. It's supposed to be inappropriate and brash - that's the entire point. The game focuses on gang life in Los Angeles. If Rockstar wanted appropriate, they would have told the story of a car salesman. All in all, D'Hoost seems completely oblivious of the intentions of the game. I'm still having trouble telling if he's legitimate in his review, or if he's just trying to troll. Either way, I"m sure he stirred up a ruckus in the GameFAQs discussion boards. You can read the original review here.

5. PC PowerPlay - The Sims 3: Showtime

No game will ever be able to compete with The Sims. It is one of the longest lasting, most successful series in video game history and has spanned across almost every major gaming system. The Sims Studio and EA have continuously impressed and satisfied their fans while simultaneously broadening their fan-base throughout the years with their famous expansion packs. Players don't seem to understand, however, that not every single expansion pack is intended to be an entirely new game. It's called an expansion pack for a specific reason - it expands the game. As Meghann O'Neill from PC PowerPlay proves, not everybody that plays The Sims grasps the above concept. O'Neill complains about the entire pack, calling it - essentially - a waste of money, and that it requires a lot of work for a small reward. Hmm, that sounds very similar to real life, doesn't it? Perhaps TSS/EA is just doing what they do best - giving the players more options. They begin with the basic foundation of an excellent simulation game, and then progressively provide the features that make that simulation more appealing. Sometimes this just includes a few new items and jobs/professions, but it adds to the game, does it not? From reading O'Neill's review it just seems that she is ignorant of TSS/EA's intentions. They cannot afford to recreate The Sims every single time they release an expansion pack. Instead, they do what they can to improve the gameplay value in order to continue entertaining players and bringing in more fans. You can read Meghann O'Neill's review at PC PowerPlay here.

4. Giant Bomb - Ghost Recon: Future Soldier

Ubisoft and its branches are hit-and-miss. Sometimes they release a phenomenal game like Ghost Recon; other times they release less successful games like Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood; and other times they release games that get mixed reviews and can't seem to get a solid response, like Driver: San Francisco. Regardless, they are a leading developer and publisher in the videogame industry - this is not arguable. Their most recent Ghost Recon addition, Future Soldier, was highly accepted among the war-gaming fans and critics. But, as with any excellent game, it received some backlash from reviewers such as Giant Bomb (as if their website title isn't a red flag). Giant Bomb reviewer Jeff Gerstmann was one of those forces that found Future Soldier to be a disappointment. His article stuck out to me in the fact that Gerstmann pretty much calls GRFS a failure in the aspect of it attempting to be a tactical shooter. This immediately jumped out at me, having just completed the campaign of GRFS. I found the game to be incredibly focused on tactics. Gerstmann claims that the game 'punishes run-and-gun tactics just enough to prevent fans of those sorts of games from having a great time.' Apparently Gerstmann missed the memo - the game is called Ghost Recon. Let's break this down for a moment: Ghost - a reference to the supernatural, the Ghost team is implanted in tense military situations to solve issues without making their presence known.Recon - from the word reconnaissance, recon forces gather intel on the enemy quickly and quietly without gaining attention. Now that that's out of the way, I think Gerstmann's argument can be proven invalid. The game relies heavily on not raising suspicion or alarm during missions. In the case that the enemy is alerted of your presence, they will open fire and hunt you down. This is supposed to be a challenge. Ghost Recon games are known for being realistic, and that is exactly what Ubisoft intended when they created Future Soldier - realism. In short, Gerstmann's Giant Bomb review of Ghost Recon: Future Soldier turned out to be, suitably, a giant bomb. You can read Jeff Gerstmann's review here.

3. GameCritics - New Super Mario Bros Wii

Perhaps one of my greatest childhood memories is running around colourfully imaginative worlds as Mario, punching curious yellow boxes in hopes of flowers and stomping Goombas. The sides-scrolling world of Mario is something that any true gamer can admit is simply perfect in its design, and irresistibly addictive. This trend has continued in nearly every Mario game, from the first Mario Party to Mario Kart, and Paper Mario to Mario 3D Land. Once Nintendo announced the release of their groundbreaking Wii, fans around the world knew that another Mario side-scroller was in store. Nobody could have predicted the success and pure beauty of New Super Mario Bros Wii. With the newly added multiplayer function that brings Mario, Luigi, and blue and yellow Toads together to help find the desired Princess Peach. Of course, you cannot help but stumble across a review that seems to find the negatives in an entirely positive experience. In this case, we can turn to Game Critics's reviewer Trent Fingland. Fingland essentially just calls the game a reboot. He bashes the powerups, the storyline, the development, the gameplay - everything. I think this is something that needs to be understood by anybody who calls themselves a gamer: Mario and his friends will never change. Nintendo is known for continuing franchises without changing anything. They have proven themselves successful by sticking to the same roots, but changing their presentation. The plants my look different, but the seeds are the same. That is what Nintendo does with the Mario series. It's this way with Mario Party, Mario Kart, Super Mario Bros - all of the like. Fingland, in short, appears oblivious to Nintendo's intentions - they are not trying to create a completely new, mind-boggling video game. They are simply expanding the Mario universe into a new era, a new console, and a new experience. Yes, the story is the same. Who cares? The game is fun, nonetheless. Nintendo made a bold move in branching out into a multiplayer story mode, allowing four players to progress through the universe. Were there some issues with it? Without a doubt. Was it a ballsy move and did it ultimately succeed? Absolutely. All in all, New Super Mario Bros Wii is a fantastic creation and another addicting addition to the series. Nintendo should commend themselves for their ability to continuously reanimate the same story without ever getting dull. You can read Trent Fingland's review of New Super Mario Bros Wii here.

2. Edge Magazine - Call of Duty: Black Ops

When gamers think Call of Duty, they immediately think multiplayer. This has been the case for years. Activision and Treyarch had revolutionized the multiplayer FPS industry with the Modern Warfare series, and yet they went above and beyond any human expectations with a single release of Black Ops. Personally, I never appreciated the multiplayer experience in any of the Modern Warfare games. Come to think of it, I was never a Call of Duty fan. It wasn't until I played Black Ops that I got hooked - both from the campaign and the multiplayer. Edge Magazine puts in their two cents about Black Ops - two cents that, really, don't contribute to the total amount. Let's face it - the multiplayer in Black Ops is beyond addicting. That whole idea of "let me play just one more match" diminishes once you pick up the controller. That "one more match" turns into a prestige, and then you reach level 41 and realize you're middle-aged and married. It's just that good. Edge doesn't seem to be quite as fascinated by this new development as everybody else is, though. In fact, they seem to brush it off as a simple recreation of every other CoD multiplayer experience. While they acknowledge the slight alternations, they forget the fact that Black Ops has a larger following than almost any other multiplayer FPS game - closely and viciously rivaling the Battlefield series (though they are two very different followings) - and without a doubt blowing away any possible competition from Modern Warfare expansions. Black Ops also receives criticism from Edge on its campaign mode. They give props to the visual beauty of the game, but dis its restrictive tendencies, failing to acknowledge the fact that the Black Ops campaign is story- and character-driven. There is only so much freedom a player can be given when they are - essentially - playing a movie. Overall, Edge Magazine fails in both aspects of reviewing the campaign and the multiplayer of Black Ops. They underestimate the true vastness of and the reason behind the campaign, while simultaneously blowing off the entire multiplayer experience in a way that misleads any innocent reader. Edge Magazine also claims that Black Ops is "far from a must-have" - perhaps one of the most ridiculous claims in recent video game reviews. If you'd like to read Edge Magazine's review, you can check it out here.

1. Myself - 10 Hugely Popular Games That Deserve To Be Hated

Very few reviewers and writers get their facts as wrong and as controversially ignorant as I managed to in my article titled "10 Hugely Popular Games That Deserve To Be Hated." The article, published on November 15th, received so much coverage on What Culture and started so much controversy that I even began receiving messages on Twitter criticising my literary and researching skills. Some aspects of my article were unchallenged, as they were written accurately and agreeably. However I will cover all ten games discussed very briefly and explain why they were worthy of criticism: 10) Heavy Rain - This review is, to me, completely accurate. As beautiful as the game is, the story is horrendous, the characters are poorly designed, scripted, and animated, and the gameplay is awkward and unnecessary. 9) Battlefield 3 - For this review alone I was called out as being a Call of Duty fanboy which I am not. I have been a die-hard Battlefield fan and supporter since the very first game. However there were too many aspects of the campaign of Battlefield 3 that made me so strongly against it. The multiplayer is perfect and the game is designed beautifully. The campaign story, however, is a rip-off of Black Ops and so poorly executed that it does not live up to the hype. 8) The Saboteur - My review of this game is spot-on and accurate, however it is still highly debatable as to whether this game could even remotely be considered "hugely popular." 7) Halo - There is nothing redeeming about this section. My facts are dead-wrong. I do believe that the story has dragged on for too long and has reached the point of overkill. However the enormously massive following and the immeasurable success of Halo's multiplayer is - not debatably - beyond award-winning and makes the game more than loveable. 6) Postal III - Like The Saboteur, my review and facts are all there and accurate - but its cult following does not make it even the slightest bit popular. 5) World's Scariest Police Chases - See above. 4) Assassin's Creed III - This is a controversial one. There have been such mixed reactions on Ubisoft's most recent AC addition that there will always be two sides to this argument. I still firmly stand by my opinion of this game - at first it is strikingly gorgeous, but then quickly becomes so disturbingly historically inaccurate and irredeemably glitchy that all its potential is lost. However, I wrote this section poorly and should have structured in more facts and strengthened my opinions. 3) Pokémon - I stand by this. Pokémon should never have been anything more than trading cards. 2) All Wii Games - What? What was I even thinking including this? This was a horribly poor attempt at being an internet troll. While the Wii has died down a lot in its hype and popularity - and seems to be a console sitting on a lot of shelves, untouched - it is in no way a "flop." There are very few reviews as poor as this specific one in regards to bashing the Wii. Nintendo, I love you. 1) Cabela's - Like three previously mentioned ones, this does not have nearly enough of a following to be considered hugely popular. It - like the Postal series - has a cult following that does not extend even the slightest into mainstream gaming culture. So there's my brief run-down of how wrong my review was. I openly admit that my article is inaccurate, controversial, and should be taken down and burned. However it is a necessary evil - somehow. And there you have it. Just 10 of the many spectacularly wrong video game reviews that are out there. What reviews have you stumbled across that you find plain wrong? Let us know in the comments below!

 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Sam took a four-year hiatus from writing for What Culture, but has returned ready to go. Sam created, produced, wrote, directed, and starred in the video game show Press Start during his years at university and continues to contribute material. He has self-published several books, and has written for other online magazines. Sam can be contacted via email at sam.tuchin@gmail.com, followed on Instagram @casthimnew or Twitter @antellopenguin