10 Stupid Early Decisions That Ruin Entire Video Games

First impressions matte- JASON?!

Heavy Rain jason
Quantic Dream

Crafting a universally loved experience is a feat that only a few developers have achieved.

It's a near impossible task to release a game that maintains its quality from start to finish, and though there are many that fail to stick the landing, offering an unsatisfying or disappointing conclusion, there are a handful that fall at a far earlier hurdle.

There are so many decisions that go into making a game, but when one doesn't go to plan in a title's opening stages it's hard to recover. Making a good first impression is vital, so when a game makes a silly move early it's so frustrating, as the rest of the experience could be tarnished as a result.

Be it a wonky narrative choice, misplaced boss battle or outdated mechanics, there's often no going back from a choice that doesn't pay off.

This puts any experience at an immediate disadvantage right out the gate, and though some releases recover from an early blunder to salvage what works, others don't, and as such fail to capture the attention of players for the long run.

10. A FOUR HOUR Tutorial - The Legend Of Zelda: Twilight Princess

Legend of zelda twilight princess
Nintendo

The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess was the first entry in the esteemed series to release on the Wii, with its motion controls setting it apart from the rest, albeit with mixed results.

There are things that are universally liked though, as its dungeon design, art style and atmosphere are all typically praised by fans of the franchise.

Yet, one of the biggest frustrations for existing players is easily its tutorial. Twilight Princess' opening is so incredibly slow in both gameplay and storytelling, and though it does this to establish the world and lore of the game, it does so in such a longwinded way.

It can take upwards of 4 hours before Link dons his iconic green tunic and the adventure truly begins. The quality of the rest of the game makes the early hours feel like more of a problem, and the decision by Nintendo to hold the hands of players through hours of gameplay is annoying as a result.

Any overly long tutorial will always be an issue to those who are familiar with a series, but in the case of Twilight Princess, it's one that spoils much of the rest of the game.


9. A Limited, Deflating Character Creator - Cyberpunk 2077

Cyberpunk 2077
CD Projekt RED

The rise, fall and rise again of CD Projekt Red's latest release feels like a tale as old as time.

Cyberpunk 2077 is a game that has had a tumultuous life since it released in the latter stages of 2020, with a botched launch being repaired somewhat as the months have rolled by.

Though the game is in decidedly better shape than it was previously, there are aspects of its design that haven't ben refined. One such example is the character creator, which is somehow both far too in depth and also not customisable enough.

Among the things that can be altered are things like eyelash colour, nails length and genital type, but players are only given two different fundamental body templates that cannot be changed at all.

Being based on a table-top RPG, Cyberpunk 2077 promised the ability to experience its story as anyone, but its character creator feels so half-hearted, only offering the choices that were in promotional material.

V's intricate features can be altered massively, but when the game only gives players two choices of their height, weight and body shape, it ruins the whole role-playing aspect.


8. The Tragic Inciting Event Is Accidentally Hilarious - Heavy Rain

Heavy Rain Jason
Quantic Dream

Released in 2010, Heavy Rain was a significant turning point for non-linear games.

It offered a butterfly effect format that made every decision feel so substantial, as just one wrong move can seal the fate of one of its four main characters.

The story it presents is harrowing, as a vicious killer is targeting small children and murdering them with rain water, leaving loved ones with unbearable tasks to complete if they want to save them. It's tone is at the centre of its story, but when one silly scene occurs in a shopping centre, it kills the entire vibe the game was going for.

After losing Jason, one of his two sons, Ethan Mars calls out for him in a scene that should have felt desperate. Instead, it's uneven voice acting and wonky gameplay ruins all tension it attempts to create.

Jason's untimely death is at the root of the game's melancholic nature, but every time he's mentioned gamers will be reminded of the scene where he wanders off, which is one of the most inadvertently amusing scenes in all of gaming, ruining much of the game's otherwise solid story.


7. Roxas' Prologue - Kingdom Hearts 2

kingdom hearts 2 roxas
Disney

Kingdom Hearts 2 was three years in the making, and upped the ante of the first game in almost every way. The story is still convoluted but its unrelenting charm carries it forward with ease, but not before an opening that takes far too long to get going.

In any Kingdom Hearts game, players have expectations. An eclectic cast of Disney characters, spiky haired heroes and, most importantly, Sora taking centre stage.

The sequel had the first two in abundance, but made players wait such a long time for the third, as the game's opening focuses on a new character, Roxas for the first few hours.

It's boring, and the story beats that it provides never do much outside of building the anticipation until Sora finally emerges. It's too long, and at a point you'd have to forgive players for thinking that the game may never reach the heights of the first.

Once Sora does awaken in the real Twilight Town, the Kingdom Hearts 2 adventure can truly begin, but the game's first impression is one that it never truly gets over.

Three years of waiting for Kingdom Hearts 2 to release, and another three hours until it actually starts to get good.


6. Solid Snake - Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty

Metal Gear Solid 2 Solid Snake
Konami

While the gameplay is better than ever and the setting is superb, Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty is known for one small narrative wrinkle.

One of the most iconic bait-and-switches in all of gaming, creator Hideo Kojima's decision to bench series hero Solid Snake in favour of someone entirely new was a decision that people still talk about to this day, 21 year after it released.

However, the game's biggest failing, and one that ruined the events of Sons of Liberty was having Solid Snake playable in the first place.

At the time of Metal Gear Solid 2's release Solid Snake had three games under his belt that solidified his heroism and made him one of gaming's best protagonists. Because of this, opening the second PS1 game in the series with the character only to introduce Raiden early on immediately put the latter at a disadvantage.

Raiden is a great character, but the game set him up to fail as fans were constantly reminded of Solid Snake because the intro, as well as promotional material implied Sons of Liberty was his adventure.

The worst decision Metal Gear Solid 2 made was showing off Solid Snake's skills, as it set unrealistic expectations for Raiden, a character who would later rival Snake in the cool department in later games.


5. Reviving A Guardian - Destiny

Destiny Ghost
Bungie

As is the way with many games that are highly anticipated, Destiny's early months on the market made it clear that it was a victim of its own success.

The Bungie-developed title is one that had years of promotional material behind it, so when it released in September 2014 with a lacklustre story and simplistic level design, there were more than a few disgruntled players.

As time passed the game received content updates that made it more worthwhile, but the decision in the game's intro to have players assume the role of a previously dead guardian made for much of the additional story feel rather pointless.

In the very beginning of Destiny, Ghost resurrects the player to continue the push back against the Darkness. The guardian has no memories of the past, so there's no narrative gain to be had from their revival. It provides the game with its most significant plot hole, and the main story does nothing to explain why Ghost chose us to bring back to life.

It felt lazy, and though the original Destiny wasn't known for its stellar storytelling, this early decision in the game made many players check out entirely.


4. Joel's Death - The Last Of Us Part II

last of us 2 joel ellie
Naughty Dog

Joel's tragic death in the opening hours of The Last of Us 2 sparked much debate in the video game sphere.

To many, it was a predictable occurrence that felt all too natural following the surprising events of the first game and how it concluded.

To others however, it was a shock the game never really recovered from.

The brutality of the act, paired with the game's attempt to humanise the culprit is something that many had an issue with, as Ellie and Joel's growing reliance on one another was the very thing that made the first game so special.

By killing its main character, The Last of Us Part II had huge shoes to fill with its main narrative, and though Ellie's quest for revenge takes up the game's first half, Abby's story is one that so many were reluctant to experience.

She was the reason that Joel and Ellie's fractured relationship became irreparable. By trying to get players to think about the consequences of their actions, those who took issue with the decision in the game's early stages found nothing in The Last of Us Part II's lengthy narrative to truly enjoy.


3. A Face Swap - Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Metal Gear Solid V The Phantom Pain
Konami

Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain is a game that feels like a seamless sequel to Peace Walker, 2010's PSP offering. The progression structure is similar, building out Mother Base, and the level design and enemies all serve the end goal of forging what would become one of the series' most iconic structures.

However, its story is one that ruffles the feathers of many Metal Gear Solid faithfuls, and it started with a subtle, yet lingering decision in the game's opening moments.

After the events of Ground Zeroes, Big Boss is in bad shape and finds himself in hospital and what would become a nine-year coma. After awakening, doctors ask players to reshape his face in an awkward, and unexplained character creator.

Following this, it's never mentioned until the end when it comes to pass that the game didn't revolve around Big Boss, but instead a medic who was injured at the same time, and was moulded to look like the character with the help of plastic surgery.

It's a decision that, when looked back at, makes the whole journey feel illegitimate. It stays in the minds of players as something that didn't make sense, and when it does, it's more frustrating than satisfying.


2. Supercars Ruin Progression - Forza Horizon 4

Forza Horizon 4
Playground Games

Carving through the Colorado landscape or rumbling around the Mexican wilderness is at the heart of what makes the Forza Horizon series great. It's a celebration of cars first and foremost, but also the freedom that they provide, as the open world always takes centre stage over the crucible of the race track in the Forza Motorsport titles.

Forza Horizon 4 is the best entry in many ways, taking the series to the quaint British countryside, but while it starts players off in a humble hatchback or hulking, slow American muscle car, it quickly gives them something more race-worthy.

In fact, it takes just a couple of hours before the garage can house any number of supercars that soar far beyond the speed limit.

This sounds like fun, but when the fastest cars in the game can be acquired so early, it breaks any sense of progression that the game should have. Instead of working their way up to the top of the Horizon Festival, players are handed what should be endgame content because it ensures the game's opening races are more thrilling.

Making supercars available so early on makes seeing Forza Horizon 4 through to the end a rather pointless task.


1. Double Kick - Pokemon Ruby

pokemon ruby
Nintendo

The third generation of Pokémon titles is one that is loved by so many. Ruby, Sapphire and Emerald are some of the franchise's best offerings to this day, and while they provide three fantastic starters, there's one that learns a move early that allows it to breeze through most early-mid game enemies.

Torchic is the fire-type Pokemon that players will start with if they decide against Treecko or Mudkip on their journey through the Hoenn Region. It's a delightfully cute character that gets meaner as it levels up with its second evolution, Combusken, wielding a move that is immensely overpowered in relation to when it can be acquired.

Torchic evolves into Combusken at level 16, and with the change in looks comes a huge upgrade in the moves department. Double Kick is a fighting type move that deals two separate hits of damage, usually arriving just in time for the Rustboro City Gym that is a Rock Type affair.

This means it's weak to Fighting Type, allowing players to easily get through the game's first true obstacle. Its usefulness doesn't end there, though, and players will lean on it for hours to come, resulting in a somewhat boring gameplay loop.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Heavy Rain
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Fan of ducks, ice tea and escapism. Spends much of his time persistently saying 'I have so much studying to do' before watching Zoey 101 for the millionth time. Thinks Uncharted 3 is the best one.