10 Things Red Dead Redemption 2 Must Learn From GTA Online

Please, Rockstar, no more Shark Cards this time, okay?

RED DEAD redemption 2 3
Rockstar

Can you actually believe it's been six years since Red Dead: Redemption dropped on consoles?

That's right. Six, dreary, Marston-less years for the series' most vociferous followers, and for those who find themselves in a fluster for all things western, the relative quiet from Rockstar must amount to some form of unconventional torture; like forcing moviegoers to watch Adam Sandler's 'The Ridiculous Six' on an infinite loop.

Granted, even Rockstar couldn't muster up a torture as sadistic as Happy Madison's assembly line of visual horrors, but let's face it, none of us know how GTA: Online continues to eek out an existence. Sure, there have been a few updates that managed to reinvigorate the game's multiplayer component, but for many, the mode continues to cast a shadow on the studio's once exemplary line of triple-A releases - a moneymaking distraction that would, it seems, appear to divert attention away from the company's hotter properties; one of which includes Red Dead Redemption 2.

Considering the nigh-monstrous success GTA: Online has brought Rockstar, it would be incredibly foolish to even ponder the suggestion that the sequel to Redemption would offer a single-player only experience. Not least of which because the last title had multiplayer too, but, given just how popular online is, the western we are all eagerly anticipating is extremely likely to place such a mode front and centre to its proceedings.

The prospect of an online-centric Red Dead may raise some eyebrows at first, but be honest with yourself, no one could possibly pass up on heists with a 19th century motif. That said, there are a number of things Rockstar need to amend from their all-singing, all microtransaction-processing behemoth, starting with...

10. Exorbitant Prices Just Wouldn't Make Sense

Red dead redemption
Rockstar

Whether or not you loathe the microtransaction-heavy nature of GTA: Online, there's no denying it's been a game changer. I mean, can you honestly recall a franchise as big as GTA actually offering what is essentially free DLC, without deviation?

I say 'free' sparingly, because, to be honest, it's not really free, is it?

GTA Online found a way to sustain itself entirely through the title's Shark Cards. When a new update rolls around, the price of admission to enjoy its delights is almost always terrifying, and certainly unattainable if your main source of virtual income stems from doing the various heists and jobs Los Santos has to offer.

If you have the hours to spare then the high entry fees of online are completely negligible, but personally, I'd much prefer a straight-up 'pay to play' model for any potential DLC in Red Dead's future. Not only would that guarantee a single-player extension - one that's been MIA from GTA for some time now - but it would eliminate the paywall that's so badly alienated so much of Rockstar's player base.

Plus, it wouldn't make a whole lot of sense to price certain steeds, ranches, and weapons at astronomical rates in the 19th century. Level the playing field and it'll make for a far better experience.


9. Make Sure There Are Actual Areas To Gamble

2010 Video Games
Rockstar/Bethesda/Bioware

Ask any GTA Online player what their most coveted feature for the title is, and chances are they'll say it's a Casino.

The Casino, located on the most easterly point of LSC, has captivated player imaginations for sometime now. Quite odd you would think, considering it's just another inaccessible building in an environment chock full of inaccessible buildings. There's one difference with this one though, and that's the big 'Coming Soon!' sign emblazoned across its parking lot.

Naturally, fans presumed that this was a direct hint from Rockstar, implying that a fully fledged gambling add on would be heading to San Andreas before Online's life cycle would come to a close. Though these predictions have, ultimately, failed to pan out, there's nothing to say that Rockstar won't have such a mode in mind for RDR's inevitable prequel/sequel/whatever.

Of course, gambling was one of the best distractions of Redemption's single player, and there's no denying the hilarious possibilities that could abound after swindling a rival in a saloon of your choosing. If you're looking to get your Doc Holliday on (minus the crippling alcohol addiction), there's no better way to do so than by pitching up in a bar and owning your table of choice.


8. Instead Of Apartments, Give Players Ranches And Hideouts

Red Dead Redemption
Rockstar

What could possibly be more synonymous with the old west than the frontier itself? I mean, if you're going to live the fantasy of being a gun slinging anti-hero, you may as well have a ranch to retire to. And, if you're up to more nefarious deeds, where better to reside than in a secret hideout with your band of crooks?

The former would most likely work like the apartments and stilt homes on offer in GTA, whereas the latter would work in a similar fashion to the offices found in the 'Finance and Felony' update that released just this June. They'd naturally be expensive, as a ranch and a piece of land where rabbits can live off the alfalfa was the dream back in the day, but again, they'd be a great place to do cowboy-esque things; like, for instance, herding cattle and all that other farming malarkey.

Things may get complicated depending on session population (no one wants to share their prize stallions with a random player they've never met before, let's be honest), but given the appropriate level of attention, they'd make for a great feature for players to strive towards.


7. Visual Customisation Is A Good Thing

red dead redemption mexico
Rockstar Games

Though it may not have started out that way, GTA: Online has an absolute bonanza of clothing items for players to deck out their characters with. It helps to personalise everyone's own experience, and the community has managed to create some truly brilliant outfits along the way.

So why stop there? Redemption's multiplayer was all well and good back in the day, but only giving players an option to choose from a few select presets just isn't going to cut it now. I mean, we need the biz this time around; an immense selection of hats, ponchos, coats and boots to dress our imagined hero up in whatever way we please.

Whether someone has their sites set on a Man With No Name getup or are looking to fit in with the Magnificent Seven shouldn't matter; all guises should be available to make Red Dead's online as immersive as possible.


6. Raise The Stakes When It Comes To Player Bounties

red dead redemption
Rockstar Games

For the vast majority of players GTA Online's bounty system is a burden. Not just because it lights you up for the whole lobby to torment, but also because the payouts for accomplishing a bounty are, shall we say, pitiful.

It would be a complete shame to do away with such a fantastic premise however, and considering just how bounty-rific the old west was, their return and eventual refinement would feel right at home in Red Dead's next instalment.

Perhaps Rockstar could implement a system where the more carnage a player wreaks on the map (PVP kills, civilian kills, robberies etc.), the more likely it is the state will issue a bounty on their head. Whether you posse up and split the dough or go it alone and reap the reward for yourself, there's no denying this would make Rockstar's western all the more absorbing.


5. Interiors Are A Good Thing, So Make Sure There Are Plenty Of Them

Red Dead Redemption Muliplayer
Rockstar

I really do wonder sometimes just why Rockstar decided GTA V should axe most of its interiors. I mean, its immediate predecessor had everything. And you don't have to look far in Online to feel their absence.

First things first: we need saloons. And I don't just mean your desolate wasteland shacks with a few barflies occupying the card tables. Throughout Red Dead's environment should be plenty of rip-roaring music-filled halls where players can kick up their heels and enjoy a bar fight or two, because let's face it, as much as we all love roaming the wild with a posse, the world still needs to feel inhabited.

If Rockstar could find away to incorporate interiors into freemode events, then they could even make for Red Dead's best feature.


4. Heists Worked Well, But Give Players More Independence This Time

Red Dead Redemption Train Robbery
Rockstar

A year on from its release Heists remain as Online's best feature, but don't we think they could've been a lot better?

I mean don't get me wrong, busting people out of prisons and ransacking city vaults are all well and good, but, apart from their grandiose nature, there was little to differentiate heists from the cookie cutter contact missions that had formed the bread and butter of Online since its release.

This was partly because of mission structure, but also because players were never really given the opportunity to carve out their own role in the semi-linear narrative they were given. Unlike in single player, everyone had to follow a predetermined approach and most roles amounted to little more than glorified context-sensitive actions. Not the most empowering of features it must be said.

So this time around, let players choose how they heist. Want to loot a train by setting dynamite to a track and derailing it? You should be allowed to. Or would you rather infiltrate it as everyday passengers and make off with the booty under the cover of darkness? Again, you should be allowed to. Independence is crucial to making something like heists work.


3. Contact Missions And Dynamic Events Are A Great Combo

Red Dead Redemption Multiplayer Gatling Gun
Rockstar

Online's aforementioned contact missions have done much to extend its life cycle over the years, occupying a niche area in the virtual economy that enables players to maintain a steady source of income in spite of the game's ever inflating costs. Of course, this is itself accompanied by a certain kind of repetitive tediousness that makes these missions wear out their welcome fairly quickly, but that by no means warrants their omission from further adventures in online mediums.

In fact, they're damn near essential for Red Dead's next outing, and here's why.

Dynamic and linear events are simply perfect for the type of open world gameplay Rockstar have been gunning for since GTA IV, since not only do they serve as fun distractions themselves, they help to add some much needed 'oomph' to the everyday business of the open world on offer. Could you imagine if armoured cars made a return in the form of armoured carriages? And again, you could even turn gang attacks into a fun little Alamo-esque distraction - charging players with holding a fort until their AI pursuers retreat.

There's lots to do with a western theme, so don't be surprised if Red Dead's online gets a boatload more of these events when it drops.


2. Give Crews A Chance To Interact Against Each Other More Often

Red Dead Redemption Multiplayer
Rockstar

Can someone please tell me just what GTA's 'Crew' system was all about?

For me at least, the experience just seemed to offer little else other than a customisable logo and a unique colour scheme. That's it. And bar that, there weren't really any ways of fostering healthy competition between competing organisations, especially when you factor in the general state of imbalance Online had with its weaponry.

Red Dead simply has to do better this time around; if not by levelling the playing field, then by facilitating rivalries directly. Oh, and can we get rid of explosives this time, Rockstar? Well, that and any other features that could potentially make PVP combat a nightmare.


1. Take Full Advantage Of The Entire Map

red dead redemption 2 map
Rockstar

If there's anything that Rockstar knows how to do well, it's how to make a truly breathtaking environment. Whether that be the sprawling landscapes of Red Dead: Redemption, or the pulpy backstreets of '40s era Los Angeles in L.A. Noire, these worlds always feel alive. GTA V's was no exception, except for some reason or another we never really got to see all of it.

Outside of LSC was a whole new world of Blaine County, complete with hicks, golf cart driving cultists, and the Sandy Shores desert. It was never really the main focus of attention though, which is a shame, considering it happened to have some of the world's most impressive vistas.

Whatever which way Red Dead 3's world turns out, its online component has to ensure that the action isn't centralised at any one point on its map. No doubt there'll be a rich array of environments to explore across Rockstar's fictionalised slice of 19th Century America, but that means diddly if players don't get the chance to explore it often.

Regardless of however Read Dead's online counterpart turns out, I think it's safe to say we're all more than ready to find out when it's heading our way. (heck, we all know it would've made PSM a heck of a lot better...) In the meantime, I guess we're just going to have to make due with cowboy Adam Sandler terrorising our Netflix accounts.

-

Are you at all intrigued by the prospect of Red Dead: Online? Or would you rather the series' next outing held itself firmly in single player? Be sure to let us know in the comments below!


Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.